Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Purna Chandra Chakrabarty v. Kalipada Roy

Calcutta High Court
Feb 18, 1942
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

This is an appeal on behalf of the Plaintiffs arising out of a suit commenced under Order 21, Rule 63 of the Code of Civil Procedure following an adverse order in claim cases. Two money decrees were obtained on June 19, 1933 against the minor defendants as heirs and legal representatives of their father, Ashutosh Roy. Those decrees were put into execution (Execution Cases Nos. 81 and 82 of 1936) and the decree-holders obtained orders for attachment of certain properties, including the properties in suit.

Two claim petitions were filed on behalf of two deities (Idol Sarat Kali and Idol Joy Kali), represented by the judgment-debtors as shebaits, seeking release of the attached properties on the ground that they were debutter (dedicated) properties and therefore not attachable in execution of personal decrees against the shebaits. Both claim petitions succeeded. The Plaintiffs (decree-holders) then commenced the present suit under Or. 21, r. 63 seeking a declaration that they were entitled to attach and sell those properties in execution of their decrees. The two deities were made Defendants Nos. 1 and 2 (represented by the shebaits), and the judgment-debtors were also made parties in their personal capacity.

Both courts below dismissed the Plaintiffs' suit. The Plaintiffs appealed to this Court; the appeal challenges the propriety of the lower courts' findings that the two relevant documents (a Will and an Arpannama) were genuine, bonâ fide deeds creating valid and absolute debutters in respect of the properties in suit.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Will executed by Ram Kishore (dated 1274 B.S.) created a valid and absolute debutter (dedication) in favour of the deity Sarat Kali in respect of the property described in Schedule 1 to the plaint.
  2. Whether the Will, even if genuine, created only a limited charge for expenses of worship and religious duties (and not an absolute debutter), making the property otherwise liable to execution.
  3. Whether the Arpannama (deed of gift) executed by Akshoy in 1323 B.S. (August 1916) effected a valid transfer/dedutter in favour of deity Joy Kali despite being unstamped at execution and being completed (stamped and registered) only after the donor's death — specifically, whether there was requisite acceptance during the donor's lifetime as required by Section 122 of the Transfer of Property Act.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments (as presented by Mr. Pakrashi)

  • Regarding the Will of Ram Kishore:
    • There was no permanent image of the deity Sarat Kali (the name is used for Goddess Durga worshipped seasonally), and hence no valid dedication could be made to such a non-permanent deity image.
    • The Will did not dedicate the property solely for Sarat Kali but directed the income to various purposes (daily worship of household deities, performance of sradh, gifts to spiritual preceptors and Brahmins), so it cannot be said the property belonged to Sarat Kali.
    • At most the Will created a charge on the property to meet worship and religious/charitable expenses rather than an absolute debutter.
  • Regarding the Arpannama of Akshoy:
    • The Arpannama was not a complete or legally valid deed when signed because it lacked the requisite stamps; since Akshoy died before the deed was completed (stamped/registered), the donee could not have accepted the gift during the donor's lifetime as required by Section 122, Transfer of Property Act, and therefore the gift failed.

Arguments / Positions Supporting Validity of the Documents (as reflected in the opinion)

  • Both Courts below found the Will and the Arpannama to be genuine, bonâ fide and creating valid dedications/debuts.
  • Evidence cited in support of the Will's effect included long-standing treatment of the property as belonging to Sarat Kali (about seventy years recorded ownership in Collectorate and zemindary papers), and the Plaintiffs themselves were co-owners who treated the property as belonging to Sarat Kali.
  • For the Arpannama, although executed on unstamped paper two days before death, it was stamped and registered after the donor's death under Collector's orders; the donee (or his agent) took steps to perfect the document and the deed had been delivered to the donee immediately after execution, indicating acceptance.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Asita Mohon Ghosh Moulik…Plaintiff, v. Nirode Mohon Ghosh Moulik…Defendant Established that absence of a permanent image of a deity (e.g., Durga Puja clay images built annually) does not preclude dedication; a permanent image is not absolutely essential for dedication to a deity. The Court relied on this decision to reject the contention that the lack of a permanent image of Sarat Kali invalidated the dedication; the decision supported upholding a debutter despite periodic images.
Bhupati Nath Smrititirtha v. Ram Lal Maitra (Full Bench) Held that the god is ever-existent irrespective of the temporal existence of a particular image; gifts for periodical pujas or to deities whose images are periodically set up and destroyed have been recognised by courts historically. The Court used the Full Bench's reasoning to reinforce that dedication to Sarat Kali (worshipped periodically) could be valid and that absence of a permanent image is immaterial to validity of a debutter.
Joymabewa v. Easin Sarkar Stated that failure to stamp a document required to be stamped under the Stamp Act does not affect the underlying validity of the transaction; it renders the document inadmissible in evidence but does not void the transaction. The Court applied this principle to hold that the unstamped Arpannama did not fail as a transaction by reason of lack of stamps at execution; subsequent stamping and admission cured the evidentiary defect and did not invalidate the gift.
Kalyana Sundaram v. Karuppa Support for the proposition that a deed may be effectual from the moment of execution subject to stamping/registration requirements under law; acceptance and delivery at the time of execution can make the gift effective. The Court relied on this case to conclude that the Arpannama, having been delivered to the donee at execution and later stamped and registered, became effectual from execution and satisfied the acceptance requirement under Section 122 of the Transfer of Property Act.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined the Appellants' contentions in turn, applying legal principles and authorities cited in the opinion.

1. On the question whether absence of a permanent image invalidates a debutter (Will of Ram Kishore):

  • The Court accepted as true that Sarat Kali is worshipped seasonally without a permanent image (earthen images prepared annually and immersed after the four-day festival), but held that a permanent image is not a necessary prerequisite for a valid dedication under Hindu law.
  • The Court relied on the Division Bench decision in Asita Mohon Ghosh and the Full Bench decision in Bhupati Nath Smrititirtha v. Ram Lal Maitra to conclude that dedications in favour of deities worshipped periodically are valid and the deity's permanence is not dependent on the continual physical existence of an image.
  • Accordingly, the first point (that lack of a permanent image invalidated the Will's dedication) was overruled.

2. On whether the Will created a dedication to Sarat Kali alone or a broader trust/charge:

  • The Court quoted paragraph 2 of the Will which fixed certain property "with the income of this property [to meet] the aforesaid rites as well as the annual gifts to the families of the spiritual preceptor and the priest as also to pious Brahmins."
  • The Court reasoned that the Will's language showed the property was directed to be used for several specific religious and charitable purposes (daily worship of household deities, sradh, gifts to priests/Brahmins), and that the Will was not drawn in an artful/legalistic manner.
  • The Court recognized an argument (attributed to Dr. Basak) that Sarat Kali was intended to hold the property subject to obligations for other religious expenses, and noted factual support that the deity was recorded as owner for about seventy years; however, the Court also acknowledged an alternative characterization was possible — that the testator created a trust for specified religious and charitable purposes rather than a gift to a particular deity.
  • Nevertheless, the Court examined paragraph 16 of the Will (penultimate paragraph) where the testator directed that his son and grandson "will as shebaits look after and arrange for the cultivation and settlement and disposal, etc., of the properties that have been made a gift of for the purpose of the performance of the worship of the deities in the manner aforesaid." The Court treated this as evidence of an actual gift/dedication and shebaitship (i.e., heirs to hold merely as custodians of the dedicated property).
  • The Court interpreted the phrase indicating income "commensurate with the expenses" as indicating the testator intended the entire income to be applied to religious purposes and did not contemplate appropriation of surplus by heirs; consequently the Court concluded that the Will did create an absolute debutter in respect of property No. 1.

3. On whether the Arpannama (Akshoy) was a valid gift despite being unstamped at execution and completed only posthumously:

  • The Courts below had found the Arpannama to be a bonâ fide document not executed to delay or defeat creditors; it was executed two days before Akshoy's death on plain demi paper because stamps could not be procured, signed by the donor, and later stamped and registered after the donor's death under Collector's orders, the registration being effected by Ashutosh, the son and heir.
  • Mr. Pakrashi argued that the unstamped state at execution meant the deed was incomplete and there could be no acceptance during the donor's lifetime as required by Section 122, Transfer of Property Act.
  • The Court rejected this contention, holding that failure to stamp a document renders it inadmissible in evidence but does not affect the validity of the transaction itself (citing Joymabewa v. Easin Sarkar). The Court noted Section 35 of the Stamp Act permits admission of unstamped/insufficiently stamped instruments upon payment of requisite stamp and penalty (subject to specified exceptions). In this case the stamps and penalties were paid under Collector's orders, and the document stood stamped at presentation for registration.
  • The Court also observed that the donee had taken all possible steps to perfect the transaction after the donor's death and that the deed had been delivered to the donee immediately after execution, which constituted sufficient acceptance under Section 122. The Court referred to Kalyana Sundaram v. Karuppa to support the proposition that the deed could be effectual from the moment of execution subject to subsequent stamping/registration requirements.
  • Therefore, the Court held the Arpannama valid and effectual as a gift/dedutter in respect of property No. 2.

4. Overall application to the Plaintiffs' suit:

  • The Court rejected the Appellants' contention that because a claim before the claim tribunal was only made on behalf of Sarat Kali, the suit under Or. 21, r. 63 could only determine that particular claimant's right; the Court explained that a suit under Or. 21, r. 63 is to establish the right the aggrieved party claims to the property in suit. If the property was trust property rather than belonging to judgment-debtors personally, the Plaintiffs' suit would fail regardless.
  • Accordingly, whether the property was an absolute debutter or trust property, the Plaintiffs could not succeed in proceedings to attach and sell the properties in execution of personal decrees against the heirs.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The appeal is dismissed with costs.

Implications and direct effect:

  • The Court affirmed the findings of the lower courts that:
    • The Will of Ram Kishore created an absolute debutter in respect of property No. 1 (the property dedicated to Sarat Kali or, alternatively, treated as trust property for specified religious purposes and held by the shebaits).
    • The Arpannama executed by Akshoy created a valid dedication/gift in respect of property No. 2; the unstamped execution did not invalidate the transfer given subsequent stamping and registration and the acceptance/delivery aspects satisfied Section 122 requirements.
  • As a consequence, the Plaintiffs' contention that the attached properties were saleable in execution of their personal decrees against the heirs was rejected; the properties could not be subjected to sale in execution of those personal decrees.
  • The opinion does not purport to lay down any sweeping new legal principle; it applied existing authorities (as cited) to the facts and disposed of the appeal on those grounds. No new precedent beyond the application of the cited authorities to these facts is stated in the opinion.

P.C. (per curiam)

Show all summary ...

The Judgment of the Court was as follows:

1. This is an appeal on behalf of the Plaintiffs and it arises out of a suit commenced by them under Or. 21, r. 63 of the Code of Civil Procedure following an adverse order in a claim case.

2. The material facts may be shortly stated as follows: There were two money decrees obtained against the minor Defendants as heirs and legal representatives of their father, Ashutosh Roy, on June 19th, 1933—one by Plaintiff No. 1 alone and the other by all the three Plaintiffs together. Both these decrees were put into execution, in execution cases Nos. 81 and 82 of 1936, and the decree-holders got an order for attachment of certain properties in the hands of the judgment-debtors, including the properties in suit. Thereupon two claim petitions were filed—one on behalf of Idol Sarat Kali and the other by Idol Joy Kali, both the deities being represented by the judgment-debtors as shebaits, for release of the properties described in Schedules 1 and 2 of the present plaint, on the allegation that they were debutter properties owned and possessed by these two deities, and hence could not be attached and sold in execution of personal decrees against the shebaits. Both the claims were allowed and the Plaintiffs decree-holders thereupon commenced this present suit for a declaration that they were entitled to attach and sell these properties in execution of their decrees. The two deities, who were made Defendants Nos. 1 and 2 in the suit, were represented by the judgment-debtors as shebaits. The judgment-debtors were also made parties in their personal capacity. Both the Courts below have dismissed the Plaintiffs' suit and they have come up on appeal to this Court.

3. For the purpose of proving that the properties in suit were debutter properties, the shebaits relied upon two documents; one was a Will executed by Ram Kishore, a maternal ancestor of Akshoy, the father of Ashutosh, 1274 B.S by which the properties described in Schedule 1 to the plaint were alleged to have been dedicated to Idol Sarat Kali; the other was an Arpannama created by Akshoy himself shortly before his death in 1323 B.S by which a debutter was made in favour of deity Joy Kali in respect to the property described in Schedule 2 to the plaint. The Courts below were of opinion that both these documents were genuine and bonâ fide deeds and that they created a valid and absolute debutter in respect of both the properties. It is the propriety of these findings that has been challenged before us in this second appeal.

4. With regard to the Will of Ram Kishore, Mr. Pakrashi, who appears for the Appellants, has contended before us that even if it was a genuine document, it did not create either a valid or an absolute debutter. It is said, in the first place, that there was no deity by the name of Sarat Kali: it was the name of Goddess Durga herself who is worshipped once every year during the Autumn months, and as there was no permanent image of the Goddess, who is only worshipped for four days in the year, no dedication of property to such deity was permissible or valid in law.

5. It is argued, in the second place, that under the Will of Ram Kishore the property was not set apart for the worship of Sarat Kali alone; it was to be used for a variety of purposes including the daily worship of the household deities, the performance of the Sradh of the ancestors, and gifts to spiritual preceptors and Brahmins, etc., and it cannot be said that the property was owned by Sarat Kali.

6. The third argument is that in any view of the case, what was created was not an absolute or complete debutter, but a mere charge for the expenses of worship of Sarat Kali and the performance of other religious and charitable duties.

7. As regards the Arpannama created by Akshoy, the learned Advocate contends that it failed as a deed of gift as defined in the Transfer of Property Act, and as it was neither stamped nor registered during the life-time of the donor, there was no acceptance of the property by the donee prior to the death of the donor as is necessary under sec. 122, Transfer of Property Act. We will deal with these points in their proper order.

8. So far as the first point is concerned it is perfectly true that the deity Sarat Kali has no permanent image, it is the Goddess Durga that is worshipped by that name in the Autumn season every year; and as is well known, an earthen image of the deity is prepared each year and after the ceremonies, which last for four days, are over, it is immersed in a river. It cannot be said, however, that a permanent image of a deity is necessary before a valid gift can be made under Hindu law. The same question was raised in the case of Asita Mohon Ghosh Moulik…Plaintiff, v. Nirode Mohon Ghosh Moulik…Defendant, .(1) and a Division Bench of this Court answered it in the following manner:

“The absence of a permanent image has also been commented upon. Such an image is not absolutely essential for dedication to a Thakur. The Durga Puja is a periodical festival in Bengal and clay images of the Thakur are built every year and thrown into a river after the Puja is over. We agree With the trial Court that Harishpur is debutter property.”

9. This is quite in accordance with what was laid down in the Full Bench case of Bhupati Nath Smrititirtha v. Ram Lal Maitra*(2). It was observed by more than one learned Judge in that case that according to Hindu scriptures the god by whatever name he is adored is ever-existent and whether a particular image did or did not exist at a particular time was not at all material. “It is immaterial” so runs the judgment of Mookerjee, J., “that the image of the deity has not been established before the death of the testator or is periodically set up and destroyed in course of the year.” One of the reasons put forward by Chatterjea, J., in that case in support of the decision of the Full Bench was that gifts of property for the purpose of periodical Pujas of Durga, Kali, etc., or for the celebration of periodical festivals were from very ancient times given effect to by our Courts.

“If a gift in favour of the deity whose image has to be prepared and destroyed periodically” thus observed the learned Judge, “is valid, I do not see any reason why a gift in favour of a deity whose image is to be prepared once and for all, except for any reason for reconstruction coming to pass, should be invalid.” The first point raised by Mr. Pakrashi must therefore be overruled.

10. To appreciate the second point raised by him, it would be necessary to refer to the relevant clause in the Will of Ram Kishore where the bequest in favour of Sarat Kali was made. The provision is contained in paragraph 2 of the Will which reads as follows:

“The great Puja of the Goddess in the Autumn season and the celebration of Syama Puja on the Mahastami day is being performed by me since 1235 B.S Further, unless immovable properties having income commensurate with the expenses of the daily worship of the deities and those of sradh, etc., are set apart it would be difficult for the ejmali heirs to perform these rites properly. Therefore I fix hereby the property mentioned in Schedule 2, and with the income of this property the aforesaid rites as well as the annual gifts to the families of the spiritual preceptor and the priest as also to pious Brahmins should toe made.”

11. It would be clear from this passage that the property mentioned in Schedule 2 of the Will, which corresponds to Schedule 1 of the present plaint, was given not merely for the worship of deity Sarat Kali, but it was to be used for several and other religious and charitable purposes expressly specified in the Will. Of course, the household gods, for whose daily worship the debutter created, were not mentioned by name, and the provision regarding gifts to pious Brahmins, priests, and spiritual preceptors, etc., was also very general. The document was certainly not drawn up artistically, and the view put forward by Dr. Basak that the named deity Sarat Kali was to hold the property subject to the obligation of meeting the expenses of the household Idols and the Sraclh of the ancestors, etc., though not altogether untenable, obviously implies an undue straining of the language used by the testator. The document, however, is an ancient one and we have this further fact in support of Dr. Basak's contention that for a period of seventy years since the execution of the document, the deity Sarat Kali was the recorded owner of this property in the Collectorate as also in the zemindary papers. The Plaintiffs themselves were co-owners in respect to this property, and to their knowledge the property was all along treated as belonging to Sarat Kali. But even if we do not accept this view, the only other conclusion that one can arrive at is that there was no gift of the property to any particular deity in the proper sense of the word, but that the testator created a trust for certain specific religious and charitable purposes. The property would in that event be regarded as a trust property in the hands of the legal representatives, and it would be equally incompetent to the Plaintiffs decree-holders to proceed against it for satisfaction of a decree obtained against the heirs personally.

12. Mr. Pakrashi argues that the claim under Or. 21, r. 58 of the Code of Civil Procedure was preferred in respect of this property on behalf of deity Sarat Kali alone and the scope of a suit under Or. 21, r. 63 is only to determine whether that particular claimant has any right or not. This contention is manifestly unsound. The person who is aggrieved by an adverse order in a claim case files the suit under Or. 21, r. 63 of the Code to establish the right he claims to the property in suit. The right which the Plaintiffs assert is that the property belonged to the judgment-debtors and was consequently saleable in execution of the decree obtained by them. If it is held that the property is trust property and does not belong to the judgment-debtors personally, then also the Plaintiffs' suit must fail. The deity Sarat Kali in that event would be regarded as one of the beneficiaries under the trust, and it is enough that one of the beneficiaries preferred a claim under Or. 21, r. 58 of the Code and disputed the alienability of the property which was attached by the decree-holder. So in any view of the case, the Plaintiffs' contention must fail.

13. The next point raised by Mr. Pakrashi is that no absolute debutter was created by the Will of Ram Kishore and at the most the expenses of the warship of the deity and the performance of other religious duties were made a charge upon the property. Mr. Pakrashi lays stress upon the fact that there were no words in the Will signifying gift or dedication of the property to any of the deities, and there was no indication also that the entire income of the property was to be spent for the particular religious purposes. In paragraph 2 of the Will quoted above, the testator has used the word which means fixed or set apart, but paragraph 16, which is the penultimate paragraph in the Will, clearly says that the testator's son and grandson “will as shebaits look after and arrange for the cultivation and settlement and disposal, etc., of the properties that have been made a gift of for the purpose of the performance of the worship of the deities in the manner aforesaid.” This proves that there was in fact a gift of the property to the deity or deities and the son and grandson of the testator were to hold it as mere shebaits of the latter. The words which mean “commensurate with the expenses” used in paragraph 2 of the Will set out above indicates, in our opinion, that the entire income of the properties is to be used for religious purposes, and the heirs should not have a right to appropriate the residue, if any, after defraying the expenses. The testator certainly did not contemplate that any surplus would be left. Our conclusion therefore is that the Will of Ram Kishore did create an absolute debutter in respect of the property No. 1.

14. We now come to property No. 2 with regard to which there is the Arpannama executed by Akshoy in August, 1916. It has been found as a fact by both the Courts below that the Arpannuma was a bonâ fide document and was not executed to delay or defeat the creditors of the grantor. The document was executed just two days before the death of Akshoy, and as no stamps could be procured at that time it was written on plain demi paper and signed by the donor. The document was stamped after the death of Akshoy under orders of the Collector of the District and was thereafter duly registered, the document being presented for registration by Ashutosh, the son and heir of Akshoy.

15. Mr. Pakrashi argues that the Arpannama was neither a complete nor a legally valid document when it was signed by Akshoy without the requisite stamps being attached to it, and as Akshoy died before the deed was completed, there could not be an acceptance by the donee during the life-time of the donor as is required under sec. 122 of the Transfer of Property Act. We do not think that we can accept this contention as sound. Failure to stamp a document which has got to be stamped under the provisions of the Stamp Act does not affect the validity of the transaction embodied in the document: it merely renders the document inadmissible in evidence—Vide the case of Joymabewa v. Easin Sarkar(3).

16. Under sec. 35 of the Stamp Act, with the exception of certain specified classes of instruments, all such unstamped or insufficiently stamped documents may be admitted in evidence on payment of the requisite stamp and penalty prescribed therein. In this case the stamps payable under the Act were actually paid by Ashutosh after the death of the donor under orders of the Collector and it was a duly stamped document when it was presented for registration. No exception can be or has been taken to the validity of the document as it now stands. The donee had done all he could possibly do to perfect the transaction, and we cannot say that the gift was incomplete at the time of the execution of the deed simply because certain fiscal requirements were not complied with. It is not disputed that the deed was delivered over to the donee immediately after execution and it would be sufficient acceptance of the transfer by the donee under sec. 122 of the Transfer of Property Act. The deed therefore became effectual from the very moment of its execution subject to its being stamped and registered as required by law— Vide in this connection the case of Kalyana Sundaram v. Karuppa(4).

17. Thus all the contentions raised by the Appellants fail and the appeal is dismissed with costs.

P.C