- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Raja Jagannath Prasad Singh Decree-Holder v. Sheonandan Sahay Judgment-Debtor .
Factual and Procedural Background
The dispute concerns execution of a mortgage decree originally passed by the Subordinate Judge, 1st Court, Gaya. Subsequently, the District Judge issued an order (under Section 13, clause (2) of the Bengal, N.W.P. and Assam Civil Courts Act (XII of 1887)) reorganising distribution of Civil business in the district so that work arising within the area where the mortgaged property was situated stood in the file of the Subordinate Judge, 3rd Court, Gaya.
The decree-holder filed an application for execution in the 1st Subordinate Judge's Court on 7 June 1919. Initial defects (insufficient court-fee; want of power of attorney) were rectified by 14 July and 22 July respectively. On 4 August the 1st Subordinate Judge recorded that the relevant pargana was beyond his territorial jurisdiction and returned the petition for re-filing in the proper Court. After an extension, the decree-holder filed the execution petition in the 3rd Subordinate Judge's Court on 13 August 1919 (registered 22 August).
The judgment-debtor objected to jurisdiction on 18 September 1919, since the decree had been passed by the 1st Subordinate Judge. The 3rd Subordinate Judge overruled the objection by order dated 17 January 1920, holding that the 1st Court had ceased to have jurisdiction over the property and therefore the 3rd Court could entertain execution. Execution proceeded in the 3rd Court: the property was sold on 24 January 1920 and the purchase-money was deposited by the auction purchaser on 11 February 1920. The judgment-debtor applied under Order XXI, rule 90 to have the sale set aside (application still pending; sale not confirmed).
The judgment-debtor appealed to the District Judge, who allowed the appeal, set aside the order of the 3rd Subordinate Judge and held that the territorial jurisdiction of the 1st Subordinate Judge extended over the whole district including the area where the mortgaged property was situated, and that this jurisdiction had not been taken away by the District Judge's distribution order. The decree-holder (appellant) brought a second appeal to the High Court impugning the District Judge's order.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the District Judge's order under Section 13, clause (2) of the Civil Courts Act transferring the distribution of civil business to the 3rd Subordinate Judge had the effect of transferring the 1st Subordinate Judge's jurisdiction over the execution of the mortgage decree (and thereby whether the execution petition was properly filed in the 3rd Subordinate Judge's Court).
- Whether, by virtue of Section 150 of the Code of Civil Procedure (Act V of 1908), a court to which business has been transferred acquires the same powers and duties as the court from which the business was transferred, thus permitting the 3rd Subordinate Judge to execute the decree.
- Whether Section 37(b) of the Code of Civil Procedure operates to deem the 3rd Subordinate Judge to be "the court which passed the decree" for purposes of execution when the 1st Court's jurisdiction has ceased.
- Whether the decree was validly sent for execution to the 3rd Subordinate Judge under Sections 38 and 39 of the Code of Civil Procedure read with Order XXI, rules 3–6 (i.e., whether procedural acts or refusals by the 1st Court produced a valid transfer of execution jurisdiction).
- Whether the mere refusal by the 1st Subordinate Judge to entertain the execution petition (on the ground of lack of territorial jurisdiction) and the subsequent filing of the petition in the 3rd Court conferred jurisdiction on the 3rd Court to execute the decree.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments (Decree-holder)
- The District Judge's order under Section 13, clause (2) of the Civil Courts Act transferred the civil business relating to the area in which the mortgaged property is situate from the Subordinate Judge, 1st Court, to the Subordinate Judge, 3rd Court; consequently, under Section 150 of the Code of Civil Procedure the 3rd Subordinate Judge acquired the same powers and duties and thus could properly entertain the execution petition.
- Under Section 37, clause (b) of the Code of Civil Procedure, because the 1st Court had ceased to have jurisdiction to execute the decree by virtue of the District Judge's distribution order, the 3rd Court should be deemed to be the court in which the suit was prosecuted and the decree obtained (and so be competent to execute).
- The decree must be considered validly sent for execution to the 3rd Subordinate Judge under Sections 38 and 39 of the Code of Civil Procedure read with Order XXI, rules 3 to 6; reliance was placed on authorities and relevant sections of the Code to support this contention.
The opinion does not contain a detailed account of any specific, separate substantive arguments advanced by the respondent beyond the initial jurisdictional objection (that the decree was passed by the 1st Court and therefore the 3rd Court lacked jurisdiction).
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Seemi Nandan Muthmamy Pillai | Held that notwithstanding that jurisdiction of the court which had passed the decree was taken away and assigned to another court, the court which passed the decree remained a proper court for execution within the meaning of clause (5) of Article 182 of the Limitation Act. | The court relied on this decision to show that transferring territorial jurisdiction does not automatically oust the executing court; the case tended to support the respondent's position that the 1st Court remained proper for execution. |
| Abbubaker Saheb v. Mohidin Saheb | Illustrates that where an application is properly entertained, certain procedural defects (omission to transmit copies or certificates under Order XXI, r.6) would not vitiate execution proceedings. | The court applied the principle narrowly: while procedural defects do not vitiate if the executing court had jurisdiction and the matter was sent properly, that authority did not support jurisdiction where the court of first instance refused to entertain and did not properly send the decree for execution. |
| Kali Pado Mukherjee v. Dino Nath Mukherjee | The opinion references this authority among those considered; the specific rule or principle cited in the opinion is not detailed. | The court listed the case as one of several authorities considered but did not extract or discuss a particular principle from it in the body of the judgment. |
| Bachu Koer v. Golab Chand | Referenced; specific rule or principle not detailed in the opinion. | Included in the list of authorities considered; no distinct application described in the opinion. |
| Kartick Nath Pandey v. Tilukdhari Lall | Referenced; specific rule or principle not detailed in the opinion. | Listed among authorities; the judgment does not explain how it was applied. |
| Panduranga Mudaliar v. Vythilinga Reddi | Referenced; specific rule or principle not detailed in the opinion. | Listed among authorities considered; no particular application recorded in the reasoning. |
| Prem Chand Dey v. Mokhoda Debi | Referenced; specific rule or principle not detailed in the opinion. | Included in the list of cases the court considered; no discrete application described. |
| Jahar v. Kamini Debi | Referenced; specific rule or principle not detailed in the opinion. | Mentioned among authorities without a detailed explanation of its application. |
| Subbiah Naicker v. Ramanathan Chettiar | Referenced; specific rule or principle not detailed in the opinion. | Listed among the authorities considered; the judgment does not set out a particular reliance upon it. |
| Kamini Sundari Chaodharni v. Kali Prossunno Ghose | Referenced; specific rule or principle not detailed in the opinion. | Included in the list of authorities considered by the court; no detailed application stated. |
| Bank of Bengal v. Sarat Chandra Mitra | Referenced; specific rule or principle not detailed in the opinion. | Listed among authorities; the judgment does not describe a direct application from this case. |
| Rameshwar Lal Bengal v. Thakur Jagadeswar Dayal Singh | Referenced; specific rule or principle not detailed in the opinion. | Included in the roster of authorities; no separate discussion of its principle is recorded in the judgment. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court proceeded by statutory and textual analysis of the relevant provisions of the Civil Courts Act and the Code of Civil Procedure and by applying established legal principles concerning jurisdiction and execution of decrees.
Key steps in the Court's reasoning:
- Interpretation of Section 37(b) CPC: Clause (b) deems "the court which passed the decree" to include the court which would have jurisdiction to try such a suit at the time the execution application is filed, although that court might not have originally passed the decree. However, the court emphasised that two conditions must be satisfied for clause (b) to operate: (1) the original court of first instance must have ceased to exist; and (2) it must have ceased to have jurisdiction to execute the decree. The Court held that neither condition was fulfilled here.
- Effect of District Judge's distribution order under Section 13, clause (2) (Civil Courts Act): The Court distinguished between (a) a notification by Government under Section 13(1) that fixes territorial jurisdiction, which can alter the territorial jurisdiction conferred on a subordinate court, and (b) an administrative arrangement by the District Judge under Section 13(2) for distribution of business among subordinate courts. The latter, the Court found, merely apportioned work arising from particular areas for convenience and did not, by itself, curtail or remove the territorial jurisdiction of the 1st Subordinate Judge.
- Applicability of Section 150 CPC: Section 150 enables a court to which business is transferred to have the same powers and duties as the court from which business was transferred, and it relieves procedural inconvenience (permitting filing directly in the court that will execute). But for Section 150 to apply it must be shown that the particular business (the suit or execution) was in fact transferred. The Court observed that the District Judge's order, as described in the record, allocated future work arising in the area to the 3rd Court but did not show a formal transfer of the already-existing decree or its file. Further, the transfer of a particular case is regulated by Section 34 CPC, and no such transfer under Section 34 was made here.
- Application of decisions and prior authorities: The Court considered authorities (including Seemi Nandan and Abbubaker Saheb) and derived two propositions: (a) transfer of territorial jurisdiction does not ipso facto deprive the court which passed the decree of its competence to execute it (Seemi Nandan); (b) procedural defects do not vitiate execution where the executing court was properly entrusted (Abbubaker Saheb), but those authorities do not help where the court of first instance refused to entertain the execution petition and did not properly send the decree for execution.
- Effect of the 1st Court's refusal to entertain: The 1st Subordinate Judge returned the petition on the understanding that the pargana was not within his jurisdiction. The Court held that such a refusal did not amount to a formal sending of the decree for execution to the 3rd Court under sections 38/39 and Order XXI. Where the original court refuses to entertain and does not properly send the decree, mere subsequent filing in another court does not vest that court with jurisdiction to execute.
- Conclusion of analysis: Because (a) the two conditions in Section 37(b) were not satisfied, (b) there was no formal transfer of the particular case under Section 34, and (c) the 1st Court's refusal did not equate to a lawful sending of the decree to the 3rd Court under the execution provisions, the 3rd Subordinate Judge lacked competence to execute the decree. Consequently, there was no substantial ground to interfere with the District Judge's order setting aside the 3rd Court's execution order.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The appeal is dismissed with costs.
Implications and direct effects:
- The High Court dismissed the decree-holder's second appeal and thereby upheld the District Judge's reversal of the Subordinate Judge, 3rd Court's execution order (i.e., the District Judge's order setting aside the 3rd Court's exercise of execution jurisdiction stands).
- The sale effected in the 3rd Subordinate Judge's Court had not been confirmed at the time of the judgment because the judgment-debtor's application under Order XXI, rule 90 remained pending; the Court's dismissal of the appeal leaves that procedural posture intact and removes the basis for the 3rd Court's execution action.
- The Court did not purport to lay down any new general rule beyond applying existing provisions (Sections 13, 34, 37, 38, 39, 150 of the Civil Courts Act and the Code of Civil Procedure and Order XXI rules). The decision's practical consequence is limited to the parties: the 3rd Subordinate Judge's execution and sale were set aside by the District Judge and that outcome is sustained by the High Court's dismissal of the appeal.
Result: Appeal dismissed; costs to respondent.
Jwala Prasad, J.:— This appeal is directed against the order of the District Judge of Gaya, dated the 5th May, 1920, reversing that of the Subordinate Judge, dated the 17th of January, 1920, and holding that the execution levied by the decree-holder in the Court of the 3rd Subordinate Judge of Gaya was incompetent and invalid.
2. The decree in question is a mortgage decree passed by the Subordinate Judge 1st Court, Gaya. Under the orders of the District Judge passed subsequent to the said decree, re the distribution of Civil business in the district, the Subordinate Judge, 3rd Court, Gaya, has now all the business in his file arising within the area in which the mortgage property in question is situate. This order was apparently passed under Section 13, clause (2) of the Bengal, N.W.P and Assam Civil Courts Act (XII of 1887). After the passing of the said order, an application for execution of the decree in question was filed in the 1st Subordinate Judge's Court, on the 7th of June, 1919. It was found that the Court-fee paid upon the application was not sufficient and consequently the deficiency was directed to be supplied, which was done by the decree-holder on the 14th of July. The power of attorney or Mukhtearnama was still wanting, and on the 22nd of July the decree-holder was directed to file it. This was also done. On the 4th of August, the Subordinate Judge recorded the following order on the back of the petition:—
“Pargana Dadar is beyond the territorial jurisdiction of this Court. Return to the filing pleader for being re-filed is the proper Court in lour days.”
3. After obtaining an extension of time, the execution petition was filed in the Court of the 3rd Subordinate Judge, on the 13th August, 1919. The petition was, however, registered on the 22nd of August. On receipt of the notice of execution, the judgment-debtor filed an application on the 18th September, 1919, objecting to the jurisdiction of the Subordinate Judge, 3rd Court, to execute the decree in question, on the ground that the decree was passed not by that Court but by the Court of the 1st Subordinate Judge. The objection was overruled by the Subordinate Judge by his order of the 17th January on the ground that
“The 1st Court which passed the decree has ceased to have jurisdiction over the property which is new situate within the jurisdiction of this Court.”
4. Hence the decree for sale was executed in the Court of the 3rd Subordinate Judge. Against this order, the judgment-debtor appealed be the District Judge. In the meantime the property was sold on the 24th of January, 1920, and the purchase money was deposited by the auction-purchaser on the 11th of February. The Judgment-debtor made an application under Order XXI, rule 90, for having the sale set aside, which is still pending. The sale has, therefore, not been confirmed yet. The learned District Judge allowed the appeal filed by the judgment-debtor and set aside the order of the Subordinate Judge, 3rd Court holding that the jurisdiction of the Subordinate Judge, 1st Court, extends over the whole district including the area in which the property in question is situate and that his jurisdiction was “not taken away by the District Judge arranging that work only from particular areas” should come to him. The decree-holder has consequently come to this Court in second appeal. He impugns the order of the learned District Judge on the following grounds:—
(1) That the order passed by the District Judge under Section 13, clause (2) of the Civil Courts Act (XII of 1887), distributing the work among his Subordinate Judges has transferred the business of the Subordinate Judge, 1st Court, be that of the Subordinate Judge, 3rd Court, with respect be Civil work, including the execution of the decree in question, relating be and arising within the area in which the mortgaged property in question is situate, and that, therefore, under the new Section 150 of the present Code of Civil Procedure (Act V of 1908) the Subordinate Judge, 3rd Court, has the same powers and performs the same duties as those which were conferred and imposed under the Code of Civil Procedure upon the Subordinate Judge, 1st Court, from which the business was transferred. He, therefore, contends that the application for execution of the decree was properly filed in the Court of the 3rd Subordinate Judge.
(2) The next ground is based upon Section 37, clause (b), of the Code of Civil Procedure and it contended that the Court of the 1st Subordinate Judge having ceased to have jurisdiction to execute the decree in question by virtue of the order of the District Judge re the distribution of Civil work, the Subordinate Judge, 3rd Court, shall be-deemed to be the court in which the suit was prosecuted and the decree was obtained.
5. Thirdly, it is contended that the decree must be considered to have been validly sent for execution by the Subordinate Judge, 1st Court, to the Subordinate Judge, 3rd Court, for execution under sections 38 and 39 of the Code of Civil Procedure read with order XXI, rules 3 to 6. We have been referred to a number of authorities as well as to the relevant sections of the Code of Civil Procedure in rapport of the aforesaid contentions. We have also fully heard the learned Vakil appearing for the respondent in this case. Under section 38 of the Code, a decree may be executed either by the court which passed it or by the court to which it was sent for execution. The decree in the present case was passed by the Subordinate Judge, 1st Court, inasmuch as be and he alone had jurisdiction to try the suit under section 16 of the Code by reason of the mortgaged property being situate within his territorial jurisdiction as prescribed and notified by the Government under section 13, clause (1) of the Civil Courts Act. Section 37 of the CPC defines the expression “Court which passed the decree” occurring in section 38. We have nothing to do with clause (a) of that section, which says that such a court will be the court of the instance when the decree is passed by another court in the exercise of its appellate jurisdiction. We at concerned, however, with clause (b) of the section. Under that clause, the court which passed the decree shall be deemed to include also the court which would have jurisdiction to try such a suit at the time when the application for execution of the decree is filed, although that court might not have originally passed the decree. But in that case, two conditions must essentially be fulfilled: (1) that the court of first instance which passed the decree must have ceased to exist, and (2) that it must have ceased to have jurisdiction to execute the decree. It cannot at all be contended that any of the aforesaid conditions has been fulfilled in the present case. The Court of the 1st Subordinate Judge has jurisdiction throughout the district. The territorial jurisdiction thus conferred upon him can only be removed by a proper order and notification by the local Government under section 13, clause (1), of the Civil Courts Act. This has not been done in the present case; and the effect of the order of the District Judge under clause (2) of section 13 of the said Act simply to make arrangements for the distribution of the Civil work in the district it cannot, and has not at all disturbed, to in any way curtailed, the territorial jurisdiction of the Subordinate Judge, 1st Court, which extends, as stated above, to the whole of the district including the area in which the mortgaged property in question is situate. This also negatives the second condition in the clause inasmuch as the jurisdiction to execute the decree rests in the Subordinate Judge, 1st Court, not only by virtue of his territorial jurisdiction but also by virtue of his having passed the decree. Execution of a decree is a continuation of the suit and is a proceeding arising out of the suit. The court which has jurisdiction to try the case, has also jurisdiction to execute its decree. This is based also upon the principle that the court must have power, to the exclusion of any other court, to execute its own decree or order, for otherwise the power to pass an order would be an empty one unless and until the authority which passes it has also power to enforce it. Therefore, in order that any other court shall “be deemed competent to execute the decree” passed by the 1st Court of the Subordinate Judge, it must have been shown that the above conditions were fulfilled. As observed above they were not at all satisfied and consequently the jurisdiction of the Subordinate Judge, 1st Court, to execute the decree in question still continues in spite of the Subordinate Judge, 3rd Court, having some portion of the business appertaining to a certain area in the district of Gaya, which formerly used to be done in the 1st Court of the Subordinate Judge.
6. There was a conflict of opinion in the Calcutta and Madras High Courts in cases arising under section 37, clause (b), as to whether an application for execution should be filed in the first instance in the court which passed the decree, or whether it should be filed in the court which is also competent to execute the decree under the aforesaid provision in section 37. That conflict was apparently set at rest by section 150 under which, when the business is transferred to another court, the said court shall have the same powers and shall perform the same duties as appertained to the court from which the business was so transferred, Section 150 is an enabling section and possibly relieves the cumbrous procedure, enunciated in the decisions of the Calcutta High Court, whereby the decree-holder was required to file an execution petition in the first court and then to obtain a transfer of the execution to another court. It enables the decree-holder to file the petition in the court which ultimately has to execute the decree. In order to apply section 150, it must be shown that the business in question was transferred from the Court of the 1st Subordinate Judge to that of the 3rd Subordinate Judge. We have not got the order of the District Judge re the distribution of Civil work, but from the purport of it given by him in his judgment, it is obvious that the works arising from the particular areas were allotted to the Subordinate Judge, 3rd Court. They obviously refer to the works arising within that area subsequent to the order of the District Judge, namely, to suits, etc., that would be instituted subsequently to that order. There is nothing to show that the decree in question or the execution thereof was transferred to the Court of the 3rd Subordinate Judge. The transfer of a particular case is regulated by section 34 of the CPC, and it is conceded that there was no transfer made by the District Judge under that section in the present case. The order of the District Judge distributing the Civil work in the district did not, as I have already observed, transfer the case to the file of the Subordinate Judge, 3rd Court. Reliance has been placed upon the case of Seemi Nandan Muthmamy Pillai(1). That case, far from helping the appellants tends to help the respondent, inasmuch as it was held that notwithstanding the fact that the jurisdiction, which the Court had at the time of the decree, was taken away from it and assigned to another Court at the time of the presentation of the application, the Court which passed the decree is still a proper Court for execution within meaning of clause (5) of Article 182 of the Limitation Act. At page 832, the learned Chief Justice observes:—
“The jurisdiction of the Court which passed the decree wet sufficiently recogniied by the decisions, as I have pointed out, and indeed had never been doubted up to that time, and there was therefore no need to re-affirm it,”
7. This passage negatives the proposition urged on behalf of the appellant.
8. He, however, relies upon the succeeding passage, which runs as follows:—
“The case of direct application to the Court to which the area had been transferred was must by the enactment of the new Section 160 which was in terms wide enough to authorise that Court to entertain in the first instance any application which might have been made to the Court which passed the decree.”
9. The words “the Court to which the area had been transferred” are important and obviously mean that the jurisdiction must have been validly and properly vested in the Court other than the Court which passed the decree by reason of the contingencies referred to in clause (2) of section 37 having arisen, namely, that the Court of first instance (1) ceased to exist, and (2) ceased to have jurisdiction to execute the decree. Therefore, these conditions must be fulfilled, for the application of section 150 also. When these are fulfilled, then the application may be made to the Court which thus receives jurisdiction, instead of its being made to the Court of first instance, as was the view of the Calcutta High Court. Nor do I think that the words of Sadashiva Iyyer, J., at page 840 of that ruling. In any way affects the case of the respondent so far as the present case is concerned. His Lordship says:— “I am still inclined to think that section 150 was enacted so as to take away both rights from the Court which ceased to have territorial jurisdiction.” It has not been shown that the Subordinate Judge, 1st Court, ceased to have territorial jurisdiction over the property sought to be sold in execution of the decree in question. Therefore, this contention must also fail.
10. Now, was the decree sent for execution in the Court of the 3rd Subordinate Judge under section 38 read with Order XXI, rules 4 to 5? No doubt the application was at first filed in the Court of the 1st Subordinate Judge who had jurisdiction to execute the decree, but be refused to entertain it on the ground that he had no jurisdiction over the parganna in which the property in question is situate. He therefore, refused to exercise jurisdiction in the matter and returned the application to be filed in the proper Court, rightly or wrongly. We have shown that he did it under a misapprehension of fact that he had ceased to exercise jurisdiction over the area in which the property is situate. When he thus refused the application, he could not possibly send it for execution to another Court. The application was then taken back by the decree-holder and filed in the Court of the 3rd Subordinate Judge. No doubt, had the application been entertained by him, then any defect in mere procedure, such as omission to transmit, to the Court to which the application is sent, a copy of the decree and a necessary certificate, etc., under Order XXI, rule 6, would not vitiate the execution proceedings or the sale held thereunder. To that extent the ruling in the case of Abbubaker Saheb v. Mohidin Saheb(2) is applicable, but where the application for execution is not at all entertained by the Court which alone had jurisdiction to entertain it, nor is it properly sent by that Court to another Court, the other Court will not derive any jurisdiction by the mere filing of the application in that Court, on the refusal of the Court of the first instance to entertain it. The respondent-judgment-debtor had raised the objection as to jurisdiction of the Subordinate Judge, 3rd Court, at the very first opportunity offered to him after he received the notice.
11. We have thus disposed of all the contentions urged by the learned Vakil on behalf of the appellant, and we do not think that any substantial ground has been made out to interfere with the order of the District Judge. We do not think it necessary to discuss in detail the authorities referred to at the Bar, but the result of our consideration of those authorities has been as set forth above. We here give only reference to those cases: Kali Pado Mukherjee v. Dino Nath Mukherjee(3), Bachu Koer v. Golab Chand(4), Kartick Nath Pandey v. Tilukdhari Lall(5), Panduranga Mudaliar v. Vythilinga Reddi(6), Prem Chand Dey v. Mokhoda Debi(7). Jahar v. Kamini Debi(8), Subbiah Naicker v. Ramanathan Chettiar(9), Kamini Sundari Chaodharni v. Kali Prossunno Ghose(10), Bank of Bengal v. Sarat Chandra Mitra(11), and Rameshwar Lal Bengal v. Thakur Jagadeswar Dayal Singh(12).
12. The result is that the appeal is dismissed with costs.
13. Adami, J.:— I agree.
14. Appeal dismissed.
Alert