Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Susil Chandra Sen And Another v. Gobind Chandra Das And Another

Patna High Court
Feb 23, 1934
Smart Summary (Beta)

Legal Opinion Summary — Dhavle, J. (with concurrence by James, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

This appeal challenges a decree which declared certain land to be debutter property appertaining to the Khairpur Math, held and enjoyed by the idol Gopal Jiu, and therefore not liable to be sold in execution of a mortgage decree. The decree also granted a permanent injunction restraining defendants 1 and 2 (the present appellants) from executing the mortgage decree against that property.

Factual chronology (as stated in the opinion): - In 1914, Baldeb Das, the Mahant of the Khairpur Math, borrowed Rs. 2,300 from the appellants' father for the purpose of purchasing some properties, creating a mortgage over the properties now in dispute. - In 1927 the appellants sued to enforce the mortgage; they obtained a preliminary decree followed by a final decree, and execution was taken out. - Gobind Chandra Das, chela of Mahant Baldeb Das, sued on behalf of the idol Gopal Jiu for declaration and injunction, alleging Baldeb Das had gone on pilgrimage about three years earlier and had not returned or been heard of since. - The defendants resisted on various grounds (including an attempt to deny the existence of an entry "Khairpur Math"), but those defences were overruled and the suit was decreed. - Defendants 1 and 2 appealed; the appeal was dismissed by the Additional Subordinate Judge of Cuttack. The present appeal is from that dismissal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the mortgaged property is debutter property appertaining to the Khairpur Math and thus not liable to be sold in execution of the mortgage decree.
  2. Whether the mortgaged property is the personal property of Baldeb Das and therefore liable to sale in execution of the mortgage.
  3. Whether entries in settlement records (e.g., Maddox's Record of Rights showing "khairat") establish that the land was absolute personal property of the individual recorded.
  4. Whether the subsequent acquisitions (Sch. Kha) by the Mahant are to be presumed to be personal property or math property (given the Mahant's celibate sanyasi status).
  5. Whether, because the mortgagor Baldeb Das had not been shown to be dead, the appellants retain rights under the mortgage during his lifetime (an argument raised on appeal but not below).

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments

  • The mortgaged property is not debutter property but is the personal property of Baldeb Das, and therefore is liable to be sold in execution of the mortgage decree.
  • As to the Ka schedule property, Maddox's Record of Rights classified that land as "khairat", and Maddox's classification of revenue-free land as "khairat" was argued to mean it was the absolute property of the individual concerned (supporting appellants' claim of personal ownership).
  • Reliance on the case Sheo Gulam Puri v. Shiam Lal Bhagat was advanced to support the proposition that devolution of property in the spiritual line does not necessarily indicate religious character (i.e., such devolution does not automatically make property non-personal).
  • The hibanama of 1892 contains provisions — described in part by the appellants' advocate — which state Baldeb will be malik and will enjoy the property himself and in succession by chelas and grand chelas; this wording was urged as supporting personal ownership or succession in personal capacity.
  • Finally, it was urged (for the first time on appeal) that because Baldeb Das had not been shown to be dead and the mortgage was executed for acquiring property, the appellants are entitled to stand on the mortgage during the lifetime of the mortgagor.

Respondent's / Plaintiff's Arguments (as described)

  • The plaint describes the plaintiff as bringing suit on behalf of the idol Gopal Jiu and refers repeatedly to the property as appertaining to the Khairpur Math; the property was alleged to be held and enjoyed by the idol and thus debutter (or at least math) property not amenable to sale in execution.
  • Reference to Maddox's Settlement Report and glossary was used to show that the term "khairat" does not necessarily indicate absolute personal ownership and may denote grants for charitable purposes or benefices, including land appertaining to religious institutions.
  • Evidence relied on by the plaintiff (and accepted by the trial court) included testimony of a landlord of Khairpur (a relative of appellants), the hibanama of 1892, and the fact that Baldeb Das was a Nihangi Baisnab and a chela of Bhagbat Das — facts supporting the conclusion that the land was debutter/math property held in trust for the institution.
  • It was argued that the character of the Mahant as a celibate sanyasi (Nihangi Baisnab) means he is unlikely to hold property in a personal capacity; rather the presumption is that land held or acquired by him is on behalf of the math.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Sheo Gulam Puri v. Shiam Lal Bhagat Cited by appellants for the proposition that devolution in the spiritual line does not necessarily indicate religious character (i.e., property passing in spiritual succession may still be personal). The court distinguished that case: it related to the Puri class of Dasnamis who often hold property for themselves, whereas in the present case the holders are Nihangi celibate sanyasis; thus Sheo Gulam Puri was not controlling on the facts here.
Rampat v. Durga Referred to as guiding the proper approach to questions of whether property is secular/personal or religious/math property. The court stated that the lower courts had rightly approached the matter from the point of view indicated in Rampat v. Durga and, on the materials, correctly concluded that the Sch. Ka property is math property.
Niladri Sahu v. Chaturbhuj Das Referenced concerning the proposition that mortgagees may obtain satisfaction by proceeding against the mortgagor personally (rather than against particularly protected institutional property). The court observed that mortgagees "may or may not" be entitled to obtain satisfaction by proceeding personally as in Niladri Sahu v. Chaturbhuj Das, but held that the question did not properly arise in the present suit and could not be decided at this stage.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's analysis proceeded along the following lines (reasoning kept to the statements and materials contained in the opinion):

  1. Examination of records: The court examined entries in Maddox's Settlement Report showing the Sch. Ka land recorded as "khairat". The court quoted Maddox to show that "khairat" could mean a benefice used for mendicants or grants for charitable purposes and that "sadabarti or pious endowments" were often recorded as "khairat or debutter." From this the court concluded that the settlement entry did not necessarily indicate absolute personal ownership by the individual named in the Record of Rights; the settlement officers were primarily concerned with revenue liability rather than the form of ownership vis-à-vis a math.
  2. Evidentiary findings: The trial court had found debutter character of the land on evidence including: - Testimony of a local landlord (who was a close relation of the appellants and who testified as their first witness); - The hibanama of 1892 under which the Ka property came to Baldeb Das; and - The fact that Baldeb Das was a Nihangi Baisnab and the chela of Bhagbat Das, who was in charge of Khairpur Math.
  3. Character of the holder: The court emphasized the special character of a Nihangi Baisnab — a celibate sanyasi without worldly attachments — and contrasted that with other classes of Mahants who may mix in business and accumulate property. Because Nihangi holders are celibate and tied to the religious institution, the court treated that fact as supporting a presumption that property held or acquired by such a holder is math property rather than personal property.
  4. Interpretation of the hibanama: The hibanama of 1892, although it contained language that could be read as making Baldeb the "malik" and providing for succession by chelas and grand chelas, had to be read as a whole. The court found that when read in context the document dealt with math property and appointed Baldeb as successor in the position of head of the institution, with restrictions on transfer (it also purported to prohibit sale, gift or mortgage). The court treated these features as supporting the non-secular / institutional character of the Ka property.
  5. Treatment of the Kha property: The Kha property (about 20 acres) was acquired later by Baldeb. The Munsif found it to have been acquired from a surplus of math income after meeting expenses; that finding was endorsed by the lower appellate court. The appellants argued it could be the personal property of the Mahant. The court reasoned that, given the Mahant's celibate sanyasi status, a presumption arises that what he holds or acquires is held on behalf of the math. The court found no error of law in the concurrent findings of the lower courts that the Kha property was also non-secular (i.e., math property).
  6. On the appellants' late-raised contention about the mortgagor's life status: The appellants' argument that they should be entitled to stand on the mortgage because Baldeb was not shown to be dead was not raised below by way of defence. The court therefore declined to decide that contention in this suit, noting that the mortgage loan was not for the legal necessities of the math. The court also noted the issue whether the mortgagees are entitled to personal satisfaction (as in Niladri Sahu) did not properly arise for decision at this stage.
  7. The court acknowledged there are textual lacunae in parts of the record (several passages in the opinion appear with "???" indicating unreadable or omitted text). The court's conclusions are based on the admissible and available parts of the record and the evidence described.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The appeal is dismissed. The decree declaring the relevant property to be debutter/math property appertaining to the Khairpur Math (held and enjoyed by the idol Gopal Jiu) and granting a permanent injunction restraining the appellants from executing the mortgage decree against that property is affirmed.

Implications:

  • The direct effect is that the appellants (defendants 1 and 2) are restrained from executing the mortgage decree against the property found to be debutter/math property; the trial and appellate courts' factual and legal conclusions on the non-secular character of both Sch. Ka and Sch. Kha properties stand.
  • The court observed but did not decide the separate point whether the mortgagees might obtain satisfaction by proceeding against the mortgagor personally; that question was held not to properly arise in the present suit at this stage.
  • No new broad legal precedent was announced beyond the application of established principles (including reliance on Maddox's descriptions and earlier authorities such as Rampat v. Durga); the decision resolves the parties' rights under the particular facts and evidence before the courts.
  • The court made no order as to costs.

Concurrence: James, J. agreed. Final statement in the opinion: "11. Appeal dismissed."

Show all summary ...

Dhavle, J.:— This is an appeal from a decree declaring that certain property is debutter property appertaining to Khairpur Math held and enjoyed by the idol Gopal Jiu and as such not liable to be sold in execution of a mortgage decree, and granting a permanant injunction restraining defendants 1 and 2, the appellants to this Court, from executing the mortgage decree against that property. In 1914 Baldeb Das, the Mahant of the math, borrowed Rupees 2,300 from the father (since deceased) of the appellants with a view to purchase some properties on a mortgage of the properties now in suit. The appellants brought a suit in 1927 to enforce this mortgage and obtained a preliminary decree. A final decree followed in due course, and when execution was taken out Gobind Chandra Das, chela of Mahant Baldeb Das, on behalf of Gopal Jiu, Thakur of the Khairpur Math, sued for the declaration and injunction already indicated, stating that he was bringing the suit because Baldeb Das had gone on pilgrimage three years previously and had neither returned nor been heard of since. The suit was resisted on various grounds, the defendants going so far as to attempt to prove that there was no such entry as Khairpur Math at all. These defences were all overruled and the suit was decreed. Defendants 1 and 2 appealed and the appeal was dismissed by the Additional Subordinate Judge of Cuttack. It has been target on their behalf that the mortgaged property is not debutter but the personal property of Baldeb Das and is therefore liable to be sold in execution of the mortgage decree.

2. The learned advocate points out that while the plaint describes the plaintiff in terms suggesting that he had brought the suit on behalf of the idol Gopal Jiu, the property is referred to at more than one place as appertaining to the Khairpur Math, and that debutter property is property that is dedicated to an idol and is not the same as property appertaining to a math. There are undoubtedly some differences between debutter property and property dedicated to a math, but the math in the present case at least has an idol installed in it and the plaintiff's allegation was that the math property was held and enjoyed by the idol, and if is clear that whether or not the property was dedicated to the idol, the property, if it appertains to the math, would not be the personal property of Baldeb Das or any other Mahant for the time being. The mortgaged property consists of two parts, one comprising an area of 11 acres odd which is described in Sch. Ka, and the other with an area of 20 acres odd described in Sch. Kha. The former came to Baldeb Das under a so called hibanama of 1892, while the latter was obtained by him by purchase in subsequent years. The learned advocate for the appellants points out that in Maddox's Record of Rights the Ka property was not shown as the property of the math or of the idol but at most as “khairat” and that Maddox's classification of revenue free land as “khairat” meant that it was the absolute property of the individual concerned. In support of this reference is made to para. 569 at p. 397 of Maddox's Settlement Report. It is however noticeable that Maddox himself says of this kind of khairat that:

“The name implies a benefice and was used of giants to mendicants and other poor Hindus.”

3. And then adds:

“Sometimes also of grants for charitable purposes.”

4. On p. 308 of the same report we find it stated against the second division of revenue free lands of the second class, that is to say, lands not the absolute property of individuals but assigned in trust for religious purpose:

“(2) Sadabarti or pious endowments is the generic name for all charitable endowments. They appear to be generally recorded as khairat or debutter.”

5. This shows that the word “khairat” used in the Record of Rights does not necessarily indicate the absolute property of the individual whose possession is recorded. The learned advocate for the respondent has referred to p. 4 of the glossary given in the beginning of Maddox's Report, where it is stated that the name “khairat” was used of grants of lands to mendicants and other poor Hindus and sometimes also of grants for charitable purposes. Such land out of Sch. Ka as was not recorded as “khairat” was recorded as lakhraj bazyafti or lakhiraj bahel and all the land in the schedule was shown as in the possession of Baldeb Das, chela of Bhagbat Das, caste Nihangi Baisnab. The entry as it stands does not show that the land belonged to the Khairpur Math. It is at the same time clear that the settlement authorities were concerned much more with the liability of the land to pay revenue or rent than with the question whether Baldeb Das held the land in his personal capacity or on behalf of the math or of the idol housed in it. The debutter character of the land, using the word to cover not only land dedicated to the idol but also land appertaining to the math as was done in the plaint, was found by the trial Court from the evidence of a landlord of Khairpur, who is a close relation of the appellants and appeared as their first witness, the hibanama of 1892 and the facts that Baldeb Das was a Nihangi Baisnab and received the land as the chela of Bhagbat Das, the Nihangi Baisnab in charge of the Khairpur Math. A Nihangi Baisnab is a celibate sanyasi without any worldly attachments, quite unlike the grihastha or house holder class of Mahants found outside the Dasnamis of Sankaracharya or unlike the Paris and other five classes and half out of the Dasnamis who mix freely in the business of the world and carry on trade and often accumulate property: see p. 245 of Jogendra Chandra Ghosh's Tagore Law Lectures on the Law of Hindu Endowments, Vol. 2, Edn. 2, 1923.

6. The learned advocate for the appellants has contended that devolution of property in the spiritual line does not necessarily indicate its religious character, and has in support of this contention cited Sheo Gulam Puri v. Shiam Lal Bhagat (1), but that was a case relating to the Puri class of Dasnamis who do often hold property for themselves. In the present case the Ka property seems utterly incapable of passing to natural heirs, for the holders are not only sanyasis but also celibates (Nihangis). The learned advocate has laid stress on the provision in the hibanama of 1892 executed by Bhagbat Das in favour of his chela Baldeb Das that Baldeb will be the malik in place of the executant and will enjoy and continue to enjoy the property himself and in succession by chelas and grand chelas. The document must be read as a whole ??? the executant in another place peaks of his math and the properties appertaining thereto being given by the hibanama to his chela who was to carry a the services of the math in the established way. In yet another place it leaks of the executant's math appertaining to another math. It also provides that Baldeb shall not be able to transfer ??? land to anyone by sale, gift or mortgage of any sort. The mere fact of the executant speaking of the math as his ??? can carry little weight; prima facie ??? math with the idol in it could not ??? the personal property of the executant. Read as a whole, the document ??? to deal with math property and ??? appoint Baldeb as the executant's successor in the position of head of the institution.

7. The learned advocate has urged that ??? has not been shown that the income ??? the property was exclusively used for ??? service of the Thakur of the math ??? the Mahant of the math is entitled ??? be maintained out of the math property, nor are we here dealing with a ??? where a worldly member of a family as made a colourable dedication of property to other than secular uses. The ??? Courts have in my opinion rightly approached the matter from the point ??? view indicated in Rampat v. Durga ??? (2), and on the materials in the ??? rightly come to the conclusion that ??? property in Sch. Ka is math property.

8. The Kha property was found by the ??? Munsif to have been “??? acquired” from the surplus left ??? the income of the math properties ??? meeting the expenses of the math, his finding was apparently endorsed by ??? lower appellate Court. The learned advocate for the appellants urges that ??? lower appellate Court was in error starting with a presumption that the ??? of a math has no property other ??? math property, and if he has any personal property, it is only the offer ??? made to him and the property inquired from those offerings, and it is ??? duty of the man who tries to prove ??? a math property is a personal property of the Mahant, to prove that it is Now there is no question that the Mahant being not only a sanyasi but also a celibate has no family of his own at all. As he is free from worldly attachments, the presumption must be that what he holds or acquires is held and acquired on behalf of the math to which his life is entirely devoted. The presumption which I have quoted from the judgment of the learned Additional Subordinate Judge was actually referred to in connexion with the Ka property where we have the hibanama of 1892 to guide us in arriving at a conclusion as regards the non-secular character of the property. But a presumption of the same kind would arise in respect of the property subsequently acquired by the celibate Mahant. In my opinion there is no error of law in the concurrent finding of the lower Courts regarding the non-secular character of the Kha property also.

9. The learned advocate for the appellants has finally urged that the mortgagor Baldeb Das not being shown to be dead, and the mortgage having been executed for acquiring property, appellants are entitled to stand on the mortgage during the lifetime of the mortgagor. This contention was not raised below by way of defence, and the suit was only intended to prevent the mortgagees from selling the property in execution of their mortgage.

10. The mortgage loan was not for the legal necessities of the math. It may or may not be that the mortgagees are entitled to obtain satisfaction by proceeding against the mortgagor personally as in Niladri Sahu v. Chaturbhuj Das (3), but that question does not properly arise in the present suit and at the present stage for the first time. The result is that this appeal fails and must be dismissed. I would make no order about costs.

James, J.:— I agree.

V.S

11. Appeal dismissed.