Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Chintam Reddi Sanyasi v. Rajasagi Appala Narasimha Raja Garu

Madras High Court
Mar 11, 1914

1. Private land is defined in Section 3, Clause 10 of the Madras Estates Land Act (1 of 1908) as the domain or home-farm land of a landholder by whatever designation known, such as kambattam, khas, sir or pannai, and S. 185 enacts rules to determine whether any particular land is private land. The presumption is that it is not, and in determining the question the Court is to have regard to local custom and to the question whether the land was before 1st July 1898 specifically let as private land, and to any other evidence that may be produced. Letting as private land after 1st July 1893 is not to be regarded because it was thought that after the introduction of the Tenancy Bill landholders might have attempted to extend unduly the area of private land. It is clear however from the section that the fact that the land has been let as private land in the years immediately preceding 1898 is some evidence that it was private land, to be considered with the evidence of local custom and all the other evidence in the case in face of these provisions we cannot accept Mr. Sarma's contention that the Act does not recognize as private land any cultivable land which was not private land at the date of the Permanent Settlement; what the Court has to find is, with regard to the clauses of evidence mentioned in the section, whether the land was private land at the passing of the Act.

2. The land in question has been found by two Courts, on evidence upon which in our opinion they might legitimately come to that conclusion, to be private land; and the learned Judge has declined to interfere.

3. We are not prepared to differ from him and we dismiss this appeal with costs.

S.N/R.K

4. Appeal dismissed.