Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Arunachella Thevan And Arunachella Thevan And Anr. v. Emperor

Madras High Court
Dec 15, 1911
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellants were tried by a jury and convicted of offences under Sections 392 and 397 of the Indian Penal Code. Each appellant was sentenced to five years' rigorous imprisonment. The learned Sessions Judge subsequently discovered, and pointed out in a letter of reference, that this sentence was less than the minimum prescribed by Section 397, I.P.C. The appellate opinion considers the correctness of the convictions and the charge as given to the jury, particularly the liability of the appellants under Section 397, I.P.C.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the direction given by the trial Judge exposing the appellants to conviction under Section 397, I.P.C. was erroneous (i.e., whether appellants could be held liable under Section 397 merely because grievous hurt was caused by some of the robbers and some robbers apparently used knives).
  2. Whether the conviction under Section 392, I.P.C. should be maintained despite the alleged misdirection regarding Section 397.
  3. What the appropriate sentence should be in light of the findings concerning the convictions.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Cr. Ap. No. 315 of 1886 (reported at p. 450, Vol. 1 of Weir's Law of Offences and Criminal Procedure) Opposition to the view that an accused can be convicted under Section 397 merely because grievous hurt was caused by some of the robbers or because some of the robbers used knives. The court cited this ruling to support the conclusion that the trial Judge's direction on liability under Section 397 was erroneous and that the resulting conviction under Section 397 should be set aside.
Emperor v. Nageshwar (Allahabad High Court) Opposed the same view: that conviction under Section 397 may be based solely on grievous hurt caused by other robbers or on the fact that some robbers used knives. The court relied on this authority to hold that the Judge's direction was not supported by the proper construction of Section 397 and to quash the conviction under that section.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded as follows:

  • It first noted the convictions under Sections 392 and 397, I.P.C., and the five-year sentences imposed on each appellant, and observed that the Sessions Judge later pointed out the sentence was less than the minimum prescribed by Section 397.
  • The court found no misdirection in the charge to the jury except in relation to the appellants' liability under Section 397. Specifically, the Judge had told the jury they might convict the appellants under Section 397 despite there being no evidence that these particular appellants caused grievous hurt or used deadly weapons; the Judge's instruction was based on the fact that grievous hurt was caused by some of the robbers and that some robbers apparently used knives.
  • The court analyzed the wording of Section 397 (and compared it with Section 394) and concluded that the Judge's approach had no support in the statutory language. The court also relied on earlier rulings (Cr. Ap. No. 315 of 1886 and Emperor v. Nageshwar) which opposed the Judge's view. The Public Prosecutor did not support the Judge's direction.
  • On that basis the court held the direction to the jury concerning Section 397 to be erroneous; the conviction under Section 397 was therefore induced by misdirection and had to be set aside.
  • Regarding the conviction under Section 392, the court found it fully supported by the evidence and determined that the jury's verdict on that offence could not have been influenced by the misdirection about Section 397. Accordingly, the conviction under Section 392 was upheld.
  • Finally, the court quashed the conviction under Section 397, upheld the conviction under Section 392, and reduced each appellant's sentence to three years' rigorous imprisonment.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The court set aside the conviction under Section 397, I.P.C., and upheld the conviction under Section 392, I.P.C.; the sentence for each appellant was reduced to three years' rigorous imprisonment.

Implications: The immediate consequence is that the appellants' convictions under Section 397 are quashed while their convictions under Section 392 stand, with a reduced sentence to three years' rigorous imprisonment each. The opinion relied on prior authorities to interpret Section 397 and did not purport to establish a new precedent beyond applying those existing rulings.

Show all summary ...

1. The appellants have been convicted by a jury of offences under Sections 392 and 397, Indian Penal Code and sentenced each to 5 years' rigorous imprisonment. This sentence, as the learned Sessions Judge himself subsequently discovered and has pointed out in a letter of reference, is less than the minimum prescribed by Section 397, I.P.C.

2. I do not find any misdirection in the charge to the jury except as regards the liability of the appellants to conviction under Section 397, I.P.C The Judge, while pointing out to the jury that there is no evidence that these appellants caused the grievous hurt or (apparently) used deadly weapons, has directed the jury that they may convict the appellant of an offence under Section 397, I.P.C., merely because grievous hurt was caused by some of the robbers and (apparently) that some of the robbers used knives. This view finds no support in the wording of the section, especially as compared with Section 394,I.P.C., and is opposed to the ruling of this court in Cr. Ap. No. 315 of 1886 reported at page 450 of Vol. 1 of Weir's Law of Offences and Criminal Procedure and of the Allahabad High Court in Emperor v. Nageshwar1. It is not supported by the Public Prosecutor, I hold it to be erroneous. It follows that the conviction under Section 397, I.P.C., was wrong and was induced by a misdirection of the Judge. It must, therefore, be set aside.

3. But I see no reason to interfere with the conviction under Section 392, I.P.C. This is fully supported by the evidence and it is impossible to see how the verdict of the jury as regards this offence could have been influenced by the misdirection above referred to. I quash the conviction under Section 397, I.P.C,, and uphold the conviction under Section 392, I.P.C. The sentence is reduced to three years' rigorous imprisonment in the case of each appellant.