Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Associates India Financial Services (P) Ltd. v. Atwal And Associates

Delhi High Court
Aug 9, 2012
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

This opinion addresses applications filed by all four defendants seeking leave to defend a suit filed under Order 37 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (CPC), for recovery of Rs. 44,83,209/-. The suit was initiated by a finance company alleging a loan granted for commercial equipment, secured by a hire purchase agreement, a demand promissory note, and guarantees by some defendants. The plaintiff claims the amount due as the balance outstanding after various repayments and defaults. The defendants challenge the maintainability of the suit under Order 37 CPC, contending that the amount claimed is a balance at the foot of the account rather than a liquidated demand arising from a written contract.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a suit claiming a balance due at the foot of an account can be maintained under Order 37 CPC, which requires a liquidated demand arising from a dishonoured negotiable instrument or a written contract.
  2. Whether invoices or bills can be considered as written contracts containing liquidated demands sufficient to sustain a suit under Order 37 CPC.
  3. Whether the plaintiff can insist on maintaining a suit under Order 37 CPC without meeting the mandatory requirements of Order 37 Rule 1 sub Rule 2 CPC.

Arguments of the Parties

Plaintiff's Arguments

  • The plaintiff relies on the hire purchase agreement, demand promissory note, and guarantees executed by the defendants as the basis for the suit under Order 37 CPC.
  • The plaintiff contends that the amount claimed is due after adjusting repayments and is recoverable as a liquidated demand.
  • The plaintiff's counsel insisted that the suit is maintainable under Order 37 CPC despite the claim being for a balance at the foot of the account.
  • Relied upon a precedent where suits based on invoices were held maintainable under Order 37 CPC.

Defendants' Arguments

  • The defendants argue that the suit is not maintainable under Order 37 CPC because the amount claimed is a balance due at the foot of the account and not a liquidated demand arising from a written contract.
  • They contend that the plaintiff cannot bypass the requirement of Order 37 Rule 1 sub Rule 2 CPC by treating running account balances as liquidated demands.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
K&K Health Care Pvt. Ltd. v. Pehachan Advertising, RFA 202/2011 (23.1.2012) Suit for recovery based on running account balances is not maintainable under Order 37 CPC as the amount claimed is not a liquidated demand arising from written contracts. The Court relied on this precedent to hold that the present suit, based on balance at the foot of the account, cannot be filed under Order 37 CPC.
Lohmann Rausher Gmbh v. Medisphere Marketing Pvt. Ltd., 2005 II AD (Delhi) 604 Suits based on invoices can be maintainable under Order 37 CPC if invoices qualify as written contracts containing liquidated demands. The Court acknowledged this precedent but distinguished it on facts, noting the present suit claims a balance after adjustments and is not solely based on invoices.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court began by reiterating the three essential grounds for maintainability of a suit under Order 37 CPC: dishonoured negotiable instruments, liquidated demands arising from written contracts, or written contracts of guarantee containing liquidated demands. The suit before the Court was initiated on the basis of a hire purchase agreement, a promissory note, and guarantees, with a claim for a sum that represents the balance after repayments rather than a liquidated amount specified in the original agreement.

The Court emphasized that claims based on balances at the foot of running accounts are not maintainable under Order 37 CPC because such balances require proof under Section 34 of the Evidence Act, 1872, and are not liquidated demands admitted in a single written instrument. The absence of a written acknowledgment or agreement specifying the liquidated demand was critical.

The Court referred to its earlier judgment in K&K Health Care Pvt. Ltd. v. Pehachan Advertising, which held that suits based on running account balances cannot be filed under Order 37 CPC. The Court also distinguished the precedent where invoices were held sufficient for Order 37 suits, noting that in the present case, the claim is not solely based on invoices but on a balance after adjustments.

The Court rejected the plaintiff's argument that a strong prima facie case on merits justifies treating the suit under Order 37 CPC, underscoring that statutory requirements must be met to maintain such a suit. It found the suit clearly not maintainable under Order 37 CPC and thus the conditional leave to defend granted by the trial court was not warranted.

Given the prolonged pendency of the suit and the plaintiff’s insistence on the incorrect procedural route, the Court granted unconditional leave to defend and imposed costs on the plaintiff for causing unnecessary litigation expenses.

Holding and Implications

The Court held that the suit is not maintainable under Order 37 CPC as the amount claimed is a balance at the foot of the account and not a liquidated demand arising from a written contract or instrument as required by Order 37 CPC.

Accordingly, the applications by the defendants for leave to defend were allowed unconditionally, with costs awarded to the defendants. The Court ordered the defendants to file their written statements within six weeks and set a date for framing issues.

The decision directly affects the parties by permitting the defendants to defend the suit on merits rather than being constrained by the procedural strictures of Order 37 CPC. The Court did not establish any new precedent but reaffirmed the strict requirements for maintainability of suits under Order 37 CPC, emphasizing that claims based on running account balances do not qualify.

Show all summary ...

VALMIKI J. MEHTA, J (ORAL)

I.A Nos. 11370/2003 (U/o 37 R 5 CPC by D-1)

I.A No. 5498/2003 (U/o 37 R 5 CPC by D-3)

I.A No. 5499/2003 (U/o 37 R 5 CPC by D-4)

I.A No. 791/2004 (U/o 37 R 5 CPC by D-2)

1. These are applications filed by all the four defendants for leave to defend in a suit filed under Order 37 of Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (CPC) for recovery of Rs. 44,83,209/-.

2. It is trite that suit under Order 37 is maintainable on three counts. One is that there is a dishonoured negotiable instrument in favour of the plaintiff. Second is that a liquidated demand arises from (i.e as specified in) a written contract with interest arising and thirdly on a written contract of guarantee and which also has to contain the liquidated demand.

3. The subject suit is a suit filed by a Finance Company. A reference to the plaint shows that the plaintiff makes averments with respect to granting of finance for a sum of Rs. 66,06,200/- for certain commercial equipment. A hire purchase agreement is referred to, which is signed by the defendants on 28.9.2000 There is a reference to a demand promissory note of the same date for Rs. 66,06,200/-. There is also a mentioning of a guarantee executed by defendant nos. 2 and 3 in favour of the plaintiff of the same date. The averments made in the plaint also admit the fact that after grant of the original loan, there were various repayments made by defendant no. 1, however, since there were defaults in payments of certain installments, the amount which is claimed in the suit, is said to have become due. The amount which is claimed in the suit even as per the plaint is not the amount which is the amount mentioned in the agreement dated 28.9.2000, but the amount is the balance due at the foot of the account. No doubt remains in this regard inasmuch as para 13 of the plaint reads as under:-

“13. That as per the accounts maintained by the plaintiff company the defendants are liable to pay a sum of Rs. 44.83.209/- (RUPEES FORTY FOUR LACS EIGHTY THREE THOUSAND TWO HUNDRED NINE ONLY) (Jointly and severally) towards principal, interest, penal interest and other charges after adjusting the payment made by the defendants as on 30.11.2002” (emphasis added)

4. Admittedly, there is no other averment in the plaint as to how the amount claimed in the suit of Rs. 44,83,209/- arises from a particular written agreement. In an Order 37 suit the amount claimed in the suit may be the principal amount plus interest arising therefrom, however, once again the plaint makes no reference to a specific particular principal amount which has been stated as a liquidated amount in a written agreement payable to the plaintiff, and the balance claimed in the suit is only interest arising thereafter.

5. The object of an Order 37 CPC suit is that on the basis of the documents specified therein the liability towards the plaintiff is admitted. Only when the liability which is admitted in the dishonoured instrument or in the written document containing a liquidated demand as payable to the plaintiff, suits can be filed under Order 37 CPC. Those suits claiming amounts which are only balances due at the foot of account cannot be treated as falling under Order 37 CPC because the suit claim is based on the account and the amount claimed is not a liquidated amount arising/payable to the plaintiff on an instrument on the limited types which are the subject matter of Order 37 CPC. Entries and statements of account have necessarily to be proved as per Section 34 of the Evidence Act, 1872 for the balance at the foot of the account to be arrived at. The present suit plaint also makes no mention of any written acknowledgment of debt, which may have amounted to a written agreement containing the liquidated demand with interest arising.

6. I have had an occasion to examine the aspect as to whether a suit such as the present can be said to be one under Order 37 CPC in the judgment of K&K Health Care Pvt. Ltd. v. Pehachan Advertising, RFA 202/2011 decided on 23.1.2012, in which, I have observed that such type of suit cannot be filed under Order 37 CPC. Paras 2 to 5 of that judgment are relevant and which read as under:-

2. The subject suit for recovery of money was filed by the respondent/plaintiff for recovery of monies on the cause of action of non-payment of bills by the appellant/defendant. The bills were raised by the respondent/plaintiff on the appellant/defendant on account of advertisements issued in newspapers by the respondent/plaintiff on behalf of the appellant/defendant. The suit which was filed under Order 37 CPC, claimed the amounts due under the bills which were stated to be ‘written contracts containing liquidated demand’, though simultaneously admitting that after the bills were raised various payments were made towards the bills. The details of bills and payments made, when first filed by the respondent/plaintiff, were as under:-

“Accounts Statement of M/s K & K Health Care Pvt. Ltd. from 01.07.2005 to 15.11.2005

Date Particulars Amount (Dr) Amount (Cr) Balance (Dr)

15.06.2005 Balance B/F 32,372.25

30.07.2005 Bill No. 07/020 290,652.00

11.08.2005 Bill No. 08/010 66,376.00

13.08.2005 Bill No. 08/019 72,127.00

18.08.2005 Bill No. 08/022 72,127.00

25.08.2005 Bill No. 08/035 288,609.00

05.09.2005 Bill No. 09/003 72,127.00

08.09.2005 Bill No. 09/005 99,418.00

08.09.2005 Bill No. 09/008 5,254.00

07.11.2005 Ch. No. 527736 87,652.00

10.11.2005 Ch. No. 527738 254,453.00

Total 999,062.25 342,105.00 6,56,957.25”

3. Subsequently, on the appellant/defendant stating and detailing other payments, a fresh statement of account was filed by the respondent/plaintiff reflecting the position of bills and payments as under:-

“M/s K & K Health Care Pvt. Ltd.

Ledger Account from 01.04.2005 to 7.11.2005

Date Particulars Debit Credit Balance

01.04.2005 Dr Opening Balance 9,54,722.81 9,54,722.81

11.04.2005 Cr Ch. No. 860348 100,000.00 2,112,065.25

30.05.2005 Cr Ch. No. 474952 200,000.00 1,912,065.25

06.06.2005 Dr Bill No. 06/015 72,126.91 1,098,976.63

09.06.2005 Cr Ch. No. 474974 100,000.00 1,812,065.25

16.06.2005 Dr Bill No. 06/018 73,199.07 1,72,175.70

23.06.2005 Dr Bill No. 06/031 72,126.91 1,026,849.72

29.06.2005 Cr Ch. No. 464018 100,000.00 1,712,065.25

30.06.2005 Cr Ch. No. 464025 100,000.00 1,612,065.25

30.06.2005 Dr Bill No. 06/059 73,199.07 1,245,374.77

22.07.2005 Cr Ch. No. 464062 100,000.00 1,512,065.25

30.07.2005 Dr Bill No. 07/020 290,651.96 1,536,026.73

05.08.2005 Cr Ch. No. 464078 64,313.00 1,447,752.25

06.08.2005 Cr Ch. No. 464079 65,183.00 1,318,256.25

08.08.2005 Dr Bill No. 08/010 66,376.25 1,674,529.89

13.08.2005 Dr Bill No. 08/019 72,126.91 1,608,153.64

18.08.2005 Dr Bill No. 08/022 72,126.91 1,746,656.80

25.08.2005 Dr Bill No. 08/035 288,609.18 2,035,265.98

26.08.2005 Cr Ch. No. 464160 64,313.00 1,383,439.25

29.08.2005 Cr Ch. No. 464161 65,268.00 1,252,988.25

09.09.2005 Cr Bill No. 09/003 72,126.91 2,107,392.89

09.09.2005 Cr Bill No. 09/005 99,418.18 2,206,811.07

09.09.2005 Dr Bill No. 09/008 5,254.18 2,212,065.25

21.10.2005 Cr Ch. No. 527737 4,632.00 1,248,356.25

24.10.2005 Cr Ch. No. 527732 58,521.00 1,189,835.25

27.10.2005 Cr Ch. No. 527734 63,591.00 1,126,244.25

27.10.2005 Cr Ch. No. 522233 63,591.00 1,062,653.25

30.10.2005 Cr Ch. No. 527735 63,591.00 999,062.25

07.11.2005 Cr Ch. No. 527736 87,652.00 911,410.25

10.11.2005 Cr Ch. No. 527738 254,453.00 656,957.25

Total Outstanding Rs. 656,957.25”

This latter statement of account is a part of the statement of account running into a total number of eight pages. This second statement of account, in addition to the two payments reflected in the first statement of account, admitted and reflected as many as five other payments. The fact that payments have been made as reflected in aforesaid two statements of account is not in dispute between the parties. The suit really therefore is a suit for the balance due at the foot of the account and is not one which is only and only on the basis of the amounts contained in the bills. The suit thus could not have been filed under Order 37 CPC as the amount claimed in the suit was not the amount as mentioned in the bills which are stated to be written contracts containing the liquidated demands of moneys payable.

4. Learned counsel for the respondent relies upon a decision of learned Single Judge of this Court in the case of Lohmann Rausher Gmbh…Plaintiff; v. Medisphere Marketing Pvt. Ltd….; 2005 II AD (Delhi) 604 to argue that the suit on the basis of invoices is maintainable under Order 37 CPC. Of course, I am bound by the decision of the learned Single Judge and therefore a suit on the basis of invoices can be said to be maintainable under Order 37 CPC, however, in the present case the suit is not based on the invoices only but the amount claimed in the suit is the balance due at the foot of a running account i.e after giving adjustment/credit for certain payments made for the invoices/bills. The suit is therefore definitely not only on the basis of invoice amounts alone for the same to be covered under Order 37 CPC. Also, in my opinion, in an appropriate case this issue will have to be examined whether a suit under Order 37 CPC can be filed on the basis of invoices alleging the same to be ‘written contracts containing a debt or liquidated demand’- the necessary requirement of Order 37 CPC. The whole purpose of the provision of Order 37 Rule 1 CPC entitling filing of the suit on a debt or liquidated demand was that there is an agreement showing that there is an admitted liability and a liquidated liability or debt which is claimed in an Order 37 suit. When an Order 37 suit is filed on bills, the bills only reflect goods supplied and therefore I feel that it cannot be said that bills should be taken as agreements containing liquidated demands or an acknowledgment or promise to pay or an admitted liability or such other factor so as to bring the claim as “claim for debt or liquidated demand arising on a written contract” as found in Order 37 CPC.

5. In view of the above, I need not go into the merits of the matter inasmuch as the plaintiff cannot arm-twist a defendant by filing a suit under Order 37 CPC, and argue in the trial Court and also before this Court, that it has a prima facie strong case on merits and therefore the impugned order granting conditional leave to defend must be sustained. Merely because a plaintiff/respondent feels it has a strong case on merits cannot mean that the suit can be filed under Order 37 unless the mandatory requirement of basing the suit on one of the four requirements of Order 37 Rule 1 sub Rule 2 is complied with. If the suit is not maintainable under Order 37, there does not arise an issue of any conditional leave to defend as was granted by the trial Court. (underlining added)

7. The present suit is pending since the year 2002 i.e 11 years. In these 11 years, in my opinion, there has been a gross wastage of judicial time on account of the plaintiff insisting that the suit be treated under Order 37 CPC. It is quite obvious that the suit is not maintainable under Order 37 CPC. Even today, I put it to the counsel for the plaintiff that how can a suit which claims the balance at the foot of the account can be a suit under Order 37 CPC because the balance which is claimed at the foot of the account is not supported by a written document admitting such liability to be payable and whereupon this liability would be a liquidated demand arising out of a written contract. Counsel for the plaintiff insisted on arguing that the suit is maintainable under Order 37 CPC.

8. Since the suit is not maintainable under Order 37 CPC, I allow these applications and grant unconditional leave to defend with payment of costs of Rs. 25,000/- to these defendants, who have been put to unnecessary expenditure with respect to filing of the applications for leave to defend in a suit which is quite clearly not maintainable under Order 37 CPC.

CS(OS) 2109/2002

Since I have allowed the applications for leave to defend, the defendants will now file the written statement within six weeks from today. Replication be filed within four weeks thereafter. Counsel for the plaintiff states that admission/denial of documents has been already done in this suit.

List for framing of issues on 19th November, 2012.