Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Brakes India Limited v. Superintendent Of Central Excise, Madras Ii Division And Others

Madras High Court
Jul 2, 1980
Smart Summary (Beta)

Concise Analytical Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioners, Brakes India Ltd., manufacture various brake equipment and supply brake assemblies as original equipment to vehicle manufacturers. For original-equipment fitments they obtain blank brake linings under the Chapter X procedure of the Central Excises and Salt Act without payment of central excise duty. Separately, the petitioners purchase brake lining blanks from Messrs Rane Brake Linings, Madras and other manufacturers after payment of central excise duty; those blanks are made to the petitioners' specifications. The petitioners then perform drilling, trimming and chamfering on those duty-paid blanks to make them fit for use, pack them in cartons and sell them under the name "B.I Girling Kit Linings."

The respondents contend that by performing these finishing processes the petitioners must be treated as manufacturers of brake linings and therefore are required to obtain an L-4 licence under the Central Excises and Salt Act and to pay excise duty on the finished brake linings. The petitioners challenge that position in a writ petition, arguing that the primary manufacture was completed by the lining manufacturers and that the finishing operations do not amount to "manufacture" within the meaning of the Act. The matter was therefore brought before the court for resolution of those questions.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether Brakes India Ltd. is bound to obtain a licence under the Central Excises and Salt Act, 1944, for marketing brake linings under the name "B.I Girling Kit Linings".
  2. Whether Brakes India Ltd. is bound to pay central excise duty on those brake linings sold after they perform drilling, trimming and chamfering on brake lining blanks purchased from other manufacturers.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The brake linings are manufactured by Messrs Rane Brake Linings, Madras, and other lining manufacturers; the petitioners only purchase finished items (referred to as blanks) that have already been manufactured.
  • The subsequent processes performed by the petitioners—drilling, trimming and chamfering—do not constitute "manufacture". Manufacture, according to petitioners' counsel, involves a complete transformation in the commercial identity of an article; processes that do not produce such a change cannot be regarded as manufacture.
  • The petitioners emphasised that the blanks are purchased after payment of excise duty, implying that further duty should not be payable on the same product to avoid double taxation.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The petitioners must be deemed to be manufacturing brake linings because the drilling, trimming and chamfering they perform are processes incidental or ancillary to completion of the manufactured product.
  • Consequently, the petitioners are required to obtain an L-4 licence for manufacture under the Central Excises and Salt Act and to pay excise duty on the finished brake linings.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Extrusion Process Ltd. v. N.R. Jadhav, 1979 ELT (J) 380 : 1974 Tax L.R. 1655 (Gujarat High Court) Interpreted Sec. 2(f) definition of "manufacture": a process incidental or ancillary to completion of a manufactured product falls within "manufacture"; on facts, printing and lacquering were examined to determine whether they were incidental or ancillary. The court noted that in Extrusion the High Court held printing and lacquering were not incidental or ancillary to completion of aluminium tubes on those facts; the present court used the decision to explain the legal test under Sec. 2(f) and to contrast factual situations.
Metro Readywear Company v. Collector of Customs, 1976 K.L.T. 642 : 1978 E.L.T. (J) 520 (Kerala High Court) Held that a finishing process (ironing) applied before packing was incidental/ancillary to completion of a stitched brassier and, carried out with power, attracted excise liability under the Act. The court relied on Metro Readywear as an example where a finishing process intended to render a product marketable was held incidental/ancillary; it applied that reasoning to the facts here and found the petitioners' finishing processes analogous.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court began by identifying and citing the statutory definition of "manufacture" in Sec. 2(f) of the Central Excises and Salt Act: "'Manufacture' includes any process incidental or ancillary to the completion of a manufactured product."

From the definition, the court extracted the legal rule that any process which is incidental or ancillary to the completion of a manufactured product, however unessential it may appear, falls within the expression "manufacture". The court reviewed prior high-court authorities to clarify how the rule is applied factually: in Extrusion Process Ltd. the printing and lacquering of already-manufactured tubes were held not to be incidental/ancillary on those facts, while in Metro Readywear the ironing of stitched brassiers was held to be incidental/ancillary because it was a finishing operation intended to render the product marketable.

Turning to the facts, the court recorded the admitted circumstances: the petitioners purchase brake lining blanks from Rane and others; those blanks are manufactured to the petitioners' specifications; the blanks cannot be used in vehicles without drilling and trimming or chamfering. The court characterized the items supplied by the lining manufacturers as "incomplete brake linings" or "brake lining blanks" and concluded that the completion of manufacture — producing brake linings fit for immediate use in vehicles — occurs only after the petitioners apply drilling, trimming and chamfering.

Applying the statutory test and the precedents, the court held that the processes performed by the petitioners are essential, incidental or ancillary to the completion of the manufactured product because, without those finishing operations, the lining blanks could not be straightaway used in vehicles. On that basis the court concluded that those finishing operations fall within the definition of "manufacture" under Sec. 2(f) and that the petitioners must therefore be deemed to be manufacturing brake linings.

Finally, the court addressed the petitioners' contention about double duty and noted the administrative position (as recorded in the respondent's order and not disputed by petitioners) that only differential duty was being called for — i.e., accounting for duty already levied on the blanks — so that the contention of double taxation had no merit.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The court held that the processes of drilling, trimming and chamferring applied by Brakes India Ltd. to brake lining blanks are incidental or ancillary to the completion of the manufactured product and therefore constitute "manufacture" within the meaning of Sec. 2(f) of the Central Excises and Salt Act. Consequently, the petitioners must be deemed to be manufacturing brake linings, must obtain the licence required under the Act and pay excise duty thereon. The writ petition fails and is dismissed (the court dismissed the petition without costs).

Immediate implications for the parties:

  • The petitioners are required to obtain the appropriate licence (L-4) as required under the Central Excises and Salt Act and applicable rules.
  • The petitioners are liable to pay excise duty on the finished brake linings; administratively they were called upon to pay only the differential duty after accounting for duty already paid on the blanks.

The opinion applies existing statutory definition and prior judicial interpretations to the facts and does not purport to state that it is creating a new legal principle beyond that application. No broader novel precedent-setting implications are identified in the text beyond the decision's direct effect on the parties in this dispute.

Show all summary ...

1. The question that falls for consideration in this writ petition is whether the Brakes India Ltd., the petitioner herein, are bound to take out a licence under the Central Excises and Salt Act, 1944, for marketing brake linings under the name of B.I Girling Kit Linings and whether they are bound to pay central excise duty on the said brake linings.

2. The petitioners are the manufacturers of brake equipment for automotive and non-automotive units comprising master cylinder, wheel cylinder, brake washers, brake hoses etc. inclusive of foundation brakes. They supply brake assemblies to vehicle manufacturers, viz., Ashok Leyland, Premier Automobiles' Telco, Hindustan Motors, Heavy Vehicles factory belonging to the Defence Establishment of the Government of India etc for fitment as original equipment. For these purposes, they obtain blank brake linings which form part of the components of the brake assembly under Chapter × procedure of the Central Excises and Salt Act from the manufacturers of brake linings without payment of central excise duty. So far as this is concerned, there is no dispute in this writ petition.

3. Apart from the above, the petitioners obtain brake, linings blanks from Messrs Rane Brakes Linings, Madras and other brake lining manufacturers made to their specifications. These brake lining blanks are removed from the factory of Messrs Rane Brake Linings, Madras only after payment of central excise duty. The petitioners then drill, trim and chamfer such duty paid brake lifting blanks to suit the requirements of the users of the various vehicles. These are then put in a carton and sold under the caption B.I Girling kit linings.

4. According to the respondents the petitioners must be deemed to be manufacturing brake linings and consequently they are bound to take out L-4 licence for the manufacture of such brake linings and also pay excise duty on the said brake linings. On the other hand, the contention of the petitioners is that the brake linings are not manufactured by therm but by Messrs Rane Brake linings, Madras and other manufacturers of brake linings. Such brake linings are purchased by the petitioners from the manufacturers after payment of excise duty at 20 per cent ad valorem. Thereafter, the brake linings are subjected to a process of drilling holes and trimming and chamferring to suit the needs of different customers depending upon the vehicles for which such brake linings are bought. Such drilling and trimming and chamferring do not constitute ‘manufacture’. Consequently, it cannot be said that the petitioners are manufacturing brake linings. Therefore, the petitioners are neither bound to take out a licence nor are they bound to pay excise duty on the brake linings sold by them.

5. It is admitted that what is purchased by the petitioners from Messrs Rane Brake Linings, Madras and other manufacturers of brake linings is brake, lining blanks. It is also admitted that such brake lining blanks cannot be used by owners of motor vehicles without drilling holes and trimming or chamferring them. It is therefore, clear that what is manufactured and supplied by Messrs Rane Brake Linings, Madras and other manufacturers of brake linings to the specific order of the petitioners are incomplete brake linings or what are called brake lining blanks. The process of completion of manufacture of brake linings which could be readily used by owners of the vehicles takes place only at the hands of the petitioners by the process of drilling and trimming or chamferring the same.

6. The learned counsel for the petitioners contended that the process of manufacture of brake linings was completed even before they left the factories of Messrs Rane Brake Linings, Madras and other manufacturers of brake linings,. The process of drilling and trimming of chamferring the brake lining blanks cannot constitute a process in the manufacture of brake linings. The Petitioners' learned counsel argued that manufacture involved a complete transformation in the commercial identity of an article and any process that did not bring about such change of identity could not be regarded as a process of manufacture. The learned counsel in this context cited various decisions dealing with the connotation of the expression ‘manufacture’. However, the meaning to be given to the word ‘manufacture’ depends upon the special-definition given to it in Sec. 2(f) of the Central Excises and Salt Act.

7. Sec 2(f) of the Central Excises and Salt Act defines ‘manufacture’ thus:—

“‘Manufacture’ includes any process incidental or ancillary to the completion of a manufactured product”

8. From the definition, it is clear that any process if it is incidental or ancillary to the completion of a manufactured product, however, unessential it may be will fall under the expression ‘manufacture’. The meaning of the word “manufacture” came up for interpretation before a Bench of the Gujarat High Court in Extrusion Process Ltd. v. N.R Jadhav, 1979 ELT (J380) : 1974 Tax. L.R 1655. The question for consideration was whether printing and lacquering of plain extruded tubes was incidental or ancillary to the manufacture of aluminium tubes. In this context, after extracting the definition of manufacture as found in Sec. 2(f) of the Act, Sheth J. observed as follows.

“The tubes which the petitioners have been printing and lacquering were already manufactured by other manufacturers. Is the process of print ing and lacquering them incidental or ancillary to the completion of manufacture of such a tube? The definition of ‘manufacture’ given in clause (f) clearly suggests that any process before it is regarded as incidental or ancillary to the completion of a manufactured product must have some relation to the manufacture of a finished product. However unessential that process may be if it is incidental or ancillary to the completion of a manufactured product then that process falls within the compass of the expression “manufacture”.

9. After stating the principle as above, the learned Judge held, on the facts of the case, that printing and lacquering could not be said to be incidental or ancillary to the completion of the manufacture of aluminium tubes.

10. A similar question arose before a Bench of the Kerala High Court in Metro Readywear Company v. Collector Of Customs, 1976 K.L.T 642 : 1978 E.L.T (J 520). There, brassiers were stitched without the aid of electric power and the finished brassiers were ironed with electric iron. Then they were packed in card board boxes and sold in the market. The question arose whether the Metro Readywear Co. which ironed finished brassiers with the aid of electric power and packed them into card board boxes and sold them, were liable to take out licence under the Central Excises and Salt Act, and were liable to pay excise duty. After noticing the definition of manufacture in Sec. 2(f) of the Act and the interpretation put on it by the Gujarat High Court in Extrusion Process Ltd. v. N.R Jadhav - 1979 ELT (J380) : 1974 T.L.R 1655, Eradi J. (as he then was,) observed as follows—

“Since the definition contained in Sec. 2(f) of the Act includes all processes that are incidental or ancillary to the completion of a manufactured product the only question to be considered by as, in the present case, is whether the process of ironing applied to the stitched brassiers can be regarded as incidental or ancillary to their completion. In our opinion, the process of ironing that was applied to the stitched brassiers prior to their packing was a process incidental to the completion of the brassiers as a manufactured product since the said process was obviously intended to give a finishing touch in order to render them marketable as ready to wear undergarments. Inasmuch as the said process was admittedly being carried out with the aid of power, liability for payment of duty under item 22D gets attracted. The contention to the contrary put forward by the petitioner cannot therefore be accepted.”

11. As already found, the petitioners purchase brake lining blanks manufactured to their specification from Rane Brake Lining Ltd. and other manufacturers. Such brake lining blanks cannot be used by the customers in their vehicles without drilling and trimming or chamferring them. Tha process of drilling and trimming or chamferring is a process which has to be essentially applied in order to render the brake lining blanks fit to be straightaway used in vehicles. Consequently, the process of drilling, and trimming or chamferring of brake lining blanks is a process essential, incidental or ancillary to the completion of the brake linings as a manufactured product as without drilling and trimming or chamferring the product could not be used in vehicles. I therefore hold that the process of drilling, trimming or chamferring which is applied to the brake lining blanks purchased by the petitioners to their specifications from Rana Brake Linings Ltd. and other manufacturers of brake linings is incidental or ancillary to manufacture and that therefore the petitioners must be deemed to be manufacturing brake linings. In this view, the respondents are right in calling upon the petitioners tp take out a licence as required by the provisions of the Central Excises and Salt Act and the rules thereof and to pay excise duty thereon under the provisions of the Act.

12. The contention that the petitioners are being called upon to pay duty twice over for the same product viz., brake linings has no merit. It is categorically stated in the order of the first respondent and that is not disputed by the petitioners that they have been called upon to pay only the differential duty after taking into account the duty already levied on the brake lining blanks as and when they are removed from the factories of the respective manufacturers. In this view, the stand taken by the respondents under the impugned orders are correct. The writ petition fails and is dismissed but without costs.