Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ
 

Vinar And Co. And Another v. Income-Tax Officer And Others.

Calcutta High Court
Aug 17, 1990
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The writ petitioners, comprising a partnership firm (petitioner No. 1) and its managing partner (petitioner No. 2), faced purported criminal proceedings initiated by respondent No. 1 for alleged failure to pay tax deducted at source (TDS) under section 194A of the Income-tax Act within the prescribed time, invoking section 276B of the Act for assessment years 1970-71 to 1976-77. The firm maintained accounts on the mercantile system, crediting interest to creditors' accounts annually and notionally deducting TDS, but due to financial stringency, payments of TDS to the government were delayed and made only when liquid funds became available.

After a significant delay ranging from 6 to 14 years, respondent No. 1 issued orders dated July 1, 1983, imposing interest under section 201(1A) for delayed TDS payments. The petitioners challenged these orders, alleging unreasonable delay, lack of opportunity to be heard, and absence of bona fide cause for delay. Appeals against these orders were dismissed, and further appeals were pending before the Income-tax Appellate Tribunal.

Subsequently, the petitioners received multiple show-cause notices dated November 20 and December 1, 1986, proposing prosecution under section 276B for failure to pay TDS within the stipulated time. The petitioners responded with requests for time to reply and challenged these notices in the present writ petition, contending that the alleged dues had been paid (albeit late), that criminal liability did not arise for delayed payment, and that the notices were issued after an unreasonable lapse of time.

The Income-tax Officer considered the petitioners’ representations and rejected their contentions by order dated February 17, 1989. The petitioners filed supplementary affidavits challenging this order, but the respondent did not file any opposition affidavit.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether delayed payment of tax deducted at source under section 194A attracts criminal liability under section 276B of the Income-tax Act.
  2. Whether a partnership firm and its partners can be prosecuted under section 276B for failure to pay TDS within time.
  3. Whether the issuance of show-cause notices and initiation of prosecution after a long delay (6 to 14 years) is valid and reasonable.
  4. Whether the petitioners were entitled to a hearing before passing the impugned orders and notices.
  5. Whether the petitioners had a bona fide and reasonable cause for delay in payment of TDS.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The firm maintained accounts on the mercantile system, crediting interest and notionally deducting TDS, but actual payment of TDS was delayed due to financial stringency and was made as soon as funds were available.
  • There was a bona fide and reasonable cause for delay in payment of TDS, arising from the difference between mercantile accounting and cash payment basis.
  • Criminal liability cannot arise merely from delayed payment; liability, if any, is limited to penalty and interest.
  • Both the firm and the partners cannot be prosecuted; prior to October 1, 1975, partners were not liable under section 276B.
  • Show-cause notices and orders were issued after an unreasonable delay of 6 to 14 years, constituting an abuse of power and denying natural justice by not providing an opportunity of hearing before issuance.
  • Relevant information regarding TDS deduction and payment was furnished to the Income-tax Officer during assessment proceedings, who was aware and did not initiate penalty or interest proceedings earlier.
  • Alternative remedies exist and the petitioners have challenged the orders before appellate authorities.

Respondent's Arguments

  • Rule 30 of the Income-tax Rules, 1962, mandates payment of TDS within two months from the date of deduction; failure to do so invokes section 276B.
  • Section 276B applies to "person" as defined in section 2(31) of the Income-tax Act, which includes a firm; hence prosecution of the firm and managing partner is valid.
  • Delay in payment of TDS is an offence under section 276B, punishable with rigorous imprisonment and fine.
  • The amended section 276B, effective from October 1, 1975, allows prosecution of partners or directors for defaults continuing after that date; thus, defaults continuing beyond that date are prosecutable.
  • Mens rea is not required for an offence under section 276B; it is an absolute liability.
  • There is no limitation period prescribed for initiating prosecution under the Income-tax Act; hence, the delay in issuing show-cause notices is not a valid ground to quash proceedings.
  • Show-cause notices were issued only against the firm and managing partner, and such notices are valid and maintainable.
  • The petitioners had the opportunity to reply to the notices and the order passed by the Income-tax Officer, and alternative remedies are available in case of conviction.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Calcutta Chromotype Pvt. Ltd. v. ITO, [1971] 80 ITR 627 (Cal) Penalty not leviable for late filing of return if filed before assessment; mens rea required for offence under section 277. Supported petitioners' contention that criminal liability requires mens rea and that penalty cannot be imposed for delayed filing if return is eventually filed.
CIT v. Anchor Pressing (P.) Ltd., [1982] 136 ITR 505 (All) Penalty provisions under Companies (Profits) Surtax Act and Income-tax Act; interpretation of "required" return and penalty applicability. Clarified that penalty is leviable only for failure to furnish return as required, not for delay; supported petitioners' argument on penalty scope.
Commissioner Of Income-Tax, Delhi-II v. Triveni Engineering Works Ltd., [1985] 154 ITR 561 (Delhi) Penalty under Companies (Profits) Surtax Act for failure to file return; late filing not penalized if return accepted before assessment. Reinforced petitioners' position on penalty for late filing and supported arguments on reasonable cause for delay.
Rishikesh Balkishandas v. I.D Manchanda, ITO, [1987] 167 ITR 49 (Delhi) Firm liable to prosecution under section 276B; mens rea not required; absolute liability for failure to deduct/pay tax. Respondent relied on this to argue firm and managing partner liable under section 276B despite absence of mens rea.
Kusum Products Ltd. v. S.K Sinha, ITO, [1980] 126 ITR 804 (Cal) Firm as juridical person cannot be imprisoned; mens rea essential for offence under section 277; prosecution of company for section 276B not maintainable. Court referred to this to distinguish liability of firms and partners, emphasizing absence of criminal liability for firms under section 276B.
Adding Machines (India) Pvt. Ltd. v. The State, [1987] 167 ITR 171 (Cal) Company cannot be prosecuted under section 276B; principal officer liable personally. Supported the view that firms (non-natural persons) cannot be prosecuted under section 276B, only individuals can be.
Parameet Singh Sawney v. Dinesh Verma & Another, [1988] 169 ITR 5 (Delhi) Partners of firm not liable to prosecution under section 276B prior to insertion of section 278B; non-application of mind and mala fide prosecution grounds. Supported petitioners' argument that partners cannot be prosecuted for defaults before October 1, 1975, and that prosecution was unreasonable.
Amin Chand and Sons v. State of Punjab, AIR 1965 Punj 441 Levy of damages after long accumulation of defaults is arbitrary and an abuse of discretion. Used to argue that delayed prosecution after many years is arbitrary and abuse of process.
Kapurchand Shrimal v. TRO, [1969] 72 ITR 623 (SC) “Person” in penalty provisions does not include firms or Hindu Undivided Families for criminal liability; mens rea required. Crucial precedent for holding that section 276B does not apply to firms or partners prior to amendment; no criminal liability without mens rea.
Jagannath Prasad Jalani v. Regional Provident Fund Commissioner, [1987] 168 ITR 341 (Delhi) Default continues till tax deducted is paid; liability extends to period of delay. Respondent relied on this to argue continuous liability for delayed payment and applicability of section 276B post amendment.
Municipal Corporation of Delhi v. J.B Bottling Co. P. Ltd., [1975] Cr. LJ. 1148 (Delhi) [FB] Proceedings under section 276B can be initiated against a firm; firm liable to fine, managing partner liable to imprisonment. Respondent cited this to support prosecution against firm and managing partner under section 276B.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court analyzed the applicability of section 276B of the Income-tax Act to the facts, particularly focusing on whether a partnership firm and its partners could be criminally prosecuted for delayed payment of TDS for the years in question.

The court observed that section 276B, as originally enacted, came into force on October 1, 1975, and did not apply retrospectively. The alleged defaults primarily occurred before that date, making section 276B inapplicable to those periods. The court relied on the Supreme Court decision in Kapurchand Shrimal v. TRO, which held that the term “person” in penal provisions does not include firms or Hindu Undivided Families, and mens rea is essential for criminal liability.

The court noted that a partnership firm is not a natural person and cannot be subjected to imprisonment, which is a compulsory punishment under section 276B. Consequently, firms cannot be prosecuted under this section for the relevant period. Similarly, partners could not be prosecuted for defaults before the insertion of section 278B, as held in Parameet Singh Sawney v. Dinesh Verma & Another.

The court found that the petitioners had furnished all relevant information regarding TDS deduction and payments during assessment proceedings and that respondent No. 1 was aware of the reasons for delay but did not initiate penalty or interest proceedings in a timely manner. The sudden issuance of multiple orders and show-cause notices after a long delay (6 to 14 years) was held to be unreasonable, arbitrary, and an abuse of process.

The court emphasized the principle that criminal proceedings must be initiated within a reasonable time to ensure availability of evidence and fair trial. The unexplained delay violated this principle and public policy. The court also underscored the absence of mens rea and the bona fide nature of delayed payments as further grounds against criminal liability.

Regarding the contention that no limitation period exists under the Income-tax Act for initiating prosecution, the court held that despite the absence of statutory limitation, delay extending over a decade is contrary to public policy and cannot be condoned.

In light of these considerations and the precedents cited, the court concluded that the show-cause notices and orders under section 276B were without jurisdiction, illegal, and unsustainable.

Holding and Implications

The court quashed and set aside the impugned show-cause notices dated November 20, 1986, and December 1, 1986, and the order dated February 17, 1989, passed by the Income-tax Officer.

The direct effect of this decision is that the petitioners are relieved from prosecution under section 276B for the alleged delayed payment of tax deducted at source for the assessment years 1970-71 to 1976-77. The court found no valid legal basis for criminal proceedings against the firm or its partners for the relevant period, emphasizing the absence of mens rea, the non-applicability of section 276B to firms pre-amendment, and the unreasonableness of the delay in initiating proceedings.

No new legal precedent was set beyond the application and reaffirmation of existing principles regarding limitation, mens rea, and the non-liability of firms and partners under section 276B for the period before October 1, 1975.

Show all summary ...

Matter No. 336 of 1987

Decided on August 17, 1990

The Judgment of the Court was delivered by

Shyamal Kumar Sen, J.:— It is the contention of the writ petitioners that, until the death of its partner, Sri H.P Nevatia, on October 15, 1977, the business and the accounts of petitioner No. 1 firm were solely looked after and maintained by and under the instructions of the said Sri H.P Nevatia. Other partners of the said firm did not at any time have any significant participation in the activities of petitioner No. 1. Petitioner No. 1, at all material times, maintained and still maintains its accounts in accordance with the mercantile system of accountancy. This application relates to purported criminal proceedings sought to be initiated by respondent No. 1 against the petitioners for alleged failure to pay the tax deducted at source under section 194A of the said Act within time, under section 276B of the said Act, for the assessment years 1970-71 to 1976-77. The previous years of petitioner No. 1 were the relevant financial years. During the course of its business, petitioner No. 1 raised and/or received loans and/or advances from different persons on interest. The accounts of the said creditors in the books of petitioner No. 1 used to be credited with the amount of accrued interest in every accounting year on the basis of the mercantile system of accountancy. On such credit for interest made in the accounts of the creditors, the petitioner-firm was required to deduct income-tax at source under section 194A of the said Act at the rate prescribed therein. In accordance with the mercantile system of accountancy, simultaneously with the crediting of interest to the accounts of the creditors, the petitioner-firm used to credit the Central Government with the amount of tax notionally deducted at source thereon every accounting year. The petitioner-firm was always in financial stringency. The balance-sheet of the petititioner-firm always showed debit balance in the capital accounts of its partners. In the premises, the petitioner-firm, as and when liquid funds were available with it, used to pay the tax deducted at source under section 194A of the said Act to the Central Government as follows:

Details of tax deducted at source on interest payable to creditors.

Assessment years Name of the creditors Amount of interest credited in the account TDS Amount Date of deduction of tax credited Tax paid on Rs. P. Rs. P. 1970-71 Hindusthan Sugar Mills Ltd. 1,76,319.00 35,264.00 31-03-70 29-01-73 1971-72 do. 91,763.84 18,352.75 31-08-70 29-01-73 Bombay Oxygen Corpn. Ltd. 39,876.79 7,975.40 30-12-70 29-01-73 1972-73 Hindusthan Sugar Mills Ltd. 61,035.85 12,207.00 31-03-72 27-08-74 Auto Centre 10,551.50 1,055.00 30-06-71 27-08-74 29,550.56 2,955.00 31-03-72 27-08-74 1973-74 Hindusthan Sugar Mills Ltd. 24,821.00 5,252.00 31-03-74 14-08-75 Arvind and Co. 46,005.90 4,601.00 31-12-73 14-08-75 do. 11,991.59 1,199.00 31-03-74 14-08-75 1975-76 Hindusthan Sugar Mills Ltd. 8,141.92 1,709.82 31-07-74 22-04-76 do. 18, 247.24 3,831.92 31-03-75 22-04-76

2. In the accounting year relevant to the assessment year 1976-77, Messrs. Hindusthan Sugar Mills Ltd., by a letter, informed the said firm that, on and from April 1, 1975, no interest is chargeable on their loan. In the premises, the said firm, although initially credited interest on the said account for the said accounting year, later on, after the receipt of the said letter, wrote back the interest credited and thus filed a revised return under the said Act and, therefore, no tax was deductible at source for the said assessment year 1976-77. The amount of tax required to be deducted at source on interest payable under section 194A of the said Act could not be deposited or paid to the credit of the Central Government within the time specified in rule 30 of the Income-tax Rules, 1962, i.e, within two months from the date of such credit due to paucity of funds. The accounts of the creditors used to be credited with accrued interest thereon under the mercantile system of accountancy whereas the tax deducted at source thereon could be paid only on the basis of cash funds available with the petitioner-firm. As and when the said cash funds were available, the petitioner-firm duly paid the said tax deducted at source. In the premises, the petitioners submitted that the delay in depositing the tax deducted at source was due to the difference in the mercantile system of accountancy and payments being made on cash basis as and when liquid funds were available. In the premises, the petitioners alleged that there was a reasonable and bona fide cause for the delay in depositing the tax deducted at source on the said interest which was credited to the accounts of the creditors in the mercantile system of accountancy. The said delay was bona fide. For the assessment years 1970-71 up to 1976-77, the petitioner-firm filed its returns on January 1, 1971, March 9, 1972, December 4, 1972, January 13, 1975, January 31, 1975, June 6, 1976 and March 30, 1977, respectively. Particulars of tax required to be deducted at source uhder section 194A of the said Act and credited to the Central Government were duly furnished by the petitioner-firm to the said Income-tax Officer, G-Ward District V(1), Calcutta, and/or respondent No. 1 herein in the course of the assessment proceedings for the relevant assessment year under the said Act. The said Income-tax Officers were also furnished with the particulars of the payments of the said tax deducted at source by the petitioner-firm for the aforesaid years under section 194A of the said Act in the course of the relevant assessment proceedings. In the premises, the petitioners alleged that the said Income-tax Officers were all along aware of the said particulars and details regarding the deduction or regarding the crediting of the accounts of the creditors with accrued interest every year and the tax required to be deducted at source thereon and the dates of payment of such tax by the petitioner-firm for the said assessment years 1970-71 to 1976-77. The petitioner-firm was assessed under the said Act by orders of assessment dated March 17, 1973, April 8, 1974, December 2, 1974, August 22, 1975, March 10, 1976, May 28, 1977, and March 31, 1979, respectively. The assessments for the assessment years 1970-71 and 1976-77 were made afresh by orders dated May 28, 1977, and July 1, 1983 respectively. It has also been alleged that respondent No. 1 was duly satisfied as regards the reason for the delay in payment of the tax required to be deducted at source on the accrued amount of interest credited to the accounts of the creditors in the mercantile system of accountancy and, therefore, respondent No. 1 did not at any time initiate any proceeding or pass any order imposing penalty under section 221 read with section 201(1) of the said Act for any of the aforesaid assessment years. In the course of the said assessment proceedings, respondent No. 1 also did not charge any interest whatsoever under section 201(1A) of the said Act. Thereafter, all of a sudden, petitioner No. 1 received on December 7, 1983, a bunch of orders all dated July 1, 1983, for the assessment years from 1968-69 to 1976-77 imposing interest under section 201(1A) of the said Act on the said firm. Petitioners further state that all the said orders were passed on one day, i.e, July 1, 1983, for several years at a time. The order for the assessment year 1968-69 has been made after 14 years and the order for the last assessment year, i.e, 1976-77, has been made after 6 years from the end of the relevant assessment year. By the said several orders under section 201(1A) of the said Act, all dated July 1, 1983, respondent No. 1, for the assessment years from 1968-69 to 1976-77, sought to levy and demand interest for delayed payment of tax deducted at source. It has been submitted that there is no reason whatsoever before respondent No. 1 for the aforesaid inordinate delay in passing the said order. All the relevant information relating to deduction of the tax at source and payment thereof were furnished by the petitioner-firm to the said respondent No. 1 in the course of the assessment proceedings and the said firm had also explained to the said respondent the reasons for the delayed payment. In the circumstances, the petitioners all along, bona fide and reasonably, believed that the said firm was not liable to pay any interest under section 201(1A) of the said Act. After a lapse of 14 years, it was not reasonably possible for the petitioners to recollect the circumstances which caused delay in payment of the tax deducted at source. No opportunity of being heard was given before passing the said orders dated July 1, 1983. In the premises, passing of the said orders all dated July 1, 1983, beyond reasonable time extending from 6 years to 14 years and exercise of such powers was not bona fide and was an abuse of power and not reasonable and could not be sustained in law. The delay in passing the said orders under section 201(1A) of the said Act could not be attributable to the petitioners and there is and could not be any explanation for the said delay on the part of the said respondent No. 1. It has been submitted that the said orders all dated July 1, 1983, made under section 201(1A) of the said Act are bad in law without and/or in excess of jurisdiction and authority of law. Being aggrieved by the said orders all dated July 1, 1983, under section 201(1A) of the said Act, the said firm preferred appeals before the Appellate Assistant Commissioner of Income-tax, Range VI, Calcutta, on the ground, inter alia that, before passing the said order, the Income-tax Officer did not give the petitioners any opportunity of being heard in the matter and exercise of power under section 201(1A) of the said Act by respondent No. 1 in the instant case had not been made within a reasonable time and the imposition of interest under section 201(1A) of the said Act for the aforesaid periods was wholly unreasonable, unjust and improper, illegal and unsustainable and there was sufficient reason for the delayed payment. The Appellate Assistant Commissioner of Income-tax, Range VI, Calcutta, by a consolidated appellate order dated September 27, 1985, dismissed all the said appeals. The said firm preferred appeals from the said appellate order dated September 27, 1985, before the Income-tax Appellate Tribunal, Calcutta, which are still pending. One of the grounds of appeal therein is that there was a reasonable cause for the delay in payment of the tax deducted at source and that no interest is leviable under section 201(1A) of the said Act. The said issue, therefore, is sub judice. On December 8, 1986, seven show cause notices all dated November 20, 1986, were received from respondent No. 1 for the assessment years 1970-71 to 1976-77 directing the said petitioner-firm to show cause why prosecution under section 276B of the said Act should not be initiated against the said petitioner-firm for failure to pay the tax deducted at source under section 194A of the said Act read with section 200 of the said Act within the stipulated time as per rule 30 of the Income-tax Rules, 1962. The petitioners thereafter by letters dated December 17, 1986, and December 22, 1986, requested the said respondent No. 1 to allow some time to the petitioners to reply in the matter. Copies of the said seven show-cause notices under section 276B of the said Act all dated November 20, 1986, and the said letter dated December 17, 1986, and December 22, 1986, have been annexed and collectively marked with the letter “A” to the writ petition. Similar notices all dated December 1, 1986, issued by respondent No. 1 for the assessment years 1970-71 to 1976-77 were also received by petitioner No. 2 to show cause why prosecution under section 276B(ii) should not be initiated. In this writ petition, the petitioners have challenged all the aforesaid show-cause notices. No affidavit in opposition has been filed disputing the aforesaid allegations and, as such, the allegations contained in the petition remain uncontroverted.

3. It has been submitted on behalf of the writ petitioners that the alleged dues have all been paid although the said payments may have been delayed. It is the contention of the petitioners that, because of delayed payment of tax, there cannot be any criminal liability for prosecution. Moreover, both the firm and the partners cannot be prosecuted. If there be any liability at all, the same is for penalty and interest. But the Tribunal has quashed the proceedings for interest initiated by the authority concerned and no penalty proceeding has yet been initiated.

4. In the instant petition, the petitioners challenged the said show-cause notices on various grounds. It was submitted that the said show-cause notices were issued under a misconceived notion of law and moreover the said notices were issued after a long lapse of 10/15 years. The learned advocate for the respondent, however, submitted that it was open to the petitioners to give reply to the show-cause notices and, in case the petitioners still give reply to the show-cause notices, they will be duly considered and disposed of in accordance with law. Accordingly, after hearing the respective submissions of the parties on December 13, 1988, an order was passed by me directing the respondents-authorities to consider the representations of the petitioners which would be submitted within a week from date. It was also provided in the said order that the authorities would give a hearing to the writ petitioners and would dispose of such representations within four weeks after the date of receipt of such representations. The authorities were further directed to pass a speaking order.

5. Pursuant to the said order dated December 13, 1988, a written representation was submitted on behalf of the petitioners on December 19, 1988. Thereafter, on February 16, 1989, the said representation was considered by the Income-tax Officer, Ward-IV (7), Calcutta, and the writ petitioners were duly given hearing. On February 17, 1989, the Income-tax Officer passed an order rejecting the contentions of the writ petitioners. Thereafter, on September 15, 1989, the following order was passed:

“Leave is granted to the writ petitioner to file supplementary affidavit challenging the order dated February 17, 1989. Such affidavit to be filed by September 27, 1989. A/O if any by November 23, 1989. Matter be treated as part heard. Liberty to mention.”

6. Accordingly, the petitioners filed a supplementary affidavit challenging the said order. No affidavit-in-opposition, however, has been filed by the respondent dealing with the said supplementary affidavit.

7. It is the contention of the writ petitioners that the said finding of the Income-tax Officer is perverse and there is an error apparent on the said finding for which the said finding should be set aside and the said show-cause notices should be quashed.

8. Mr. Murarka, learned advocate for the petitioners, submitted that there cannot be any criminal liability for delayed payment. The Income-tax Act provides for imposition of penalty and interest under section 201(1A) of the Income-tax Act. In this connection, he referred to section 271(1)(a) and section 276(c) of the Income-tax Act. He also submitted that, under section 276B, delay in payment is not an offence. In support of his contention, learned advocate relied upon the following decisions:

Calcutta Chromotype Pvt. Ltd. v. ITO, [1971] 80 ITR 627 (Cal), CIT v. Anchor Pressing (P.) Ltd., [1982] 136 ITR 505 (All) and Commissioner Of Income-Tax, Delhi-Ii v. Triveni Engineering Works Ltd., [1985] 154 ITR 561 (Delhi).

9. It was contended on behalf of the petitioners that, for the assessment years 1970-71 to 1976-77, the provisions of section 276B were not available and, therefore, a partner of the firm could not be prosecuted for a default of the firm. He also referred to the decision in the case of Parameet Singh Sawney… v. Dinesh Verma & Another…, [1988] 169 ITR 5 (Delhi). In support of his contention as to whether the firm can be prosecuted, Mr. Murarka also relied upon the following decisions:

Kusum Products Ltd. v. S.K Sinha, ITO, [1980] 126 ITR 804 (Cal), Vijaya Commercial Credit Ltd. v. Sixth ITO, [1988] 170 ITR 55 (Kar) at 60 and D.C Goel v. B.L Verma, [1974] 93 ITR 63 (Delhi).

10. He also referred to the judgment and decision in the case of S.M Badsha v. ITO, [1987] 168 ITR 332, 339 (Ker). He further submitted that the show-cause notice issued after such a long lapse of time cannot be held to be valid. In support of his contention, he relied upon a judgment in the case of Amin Chand and Sons v. State of Punjab, AIR 1965 Punj 441.

11. Learned advocate for the respondent, on the other hand, contended that rule 30 of the Income-tax Rules provides for the time limit for payment of taxes deducted which is two months from the date of deduction. In view of the fact that the tax deducted was not paid to the Income-tax Department within the said period of two months, Section 276B of the Income-tax Act, 1961, applies. Learned Advocate also referred to section 194A(4) of the Income-tax Act and the time limit mentioned therein. In this connection, learned advocate also relied upon the judgment and decision in the case of Rishikesh Balkishandas v. I.D Manchanda, ITO, [1987] 167 ITR 49, 53 (Delhi) wherein it was held that the payment of taxes has to be made during the financial year. Learned advocate also relied upon the judgment and decision in the case of Rayala Corporation (P) Ltd. v. V.M Muthuramalingam, ITO, [1981] 129 ITR 675 (Mad), wherein it was held that even in a case of delayed payment of tax already deducted and paid before initiation of proceedings, although not in time, the Department can take action under Section 276B of the Income-tax Act. Learned advocate, accordingly, submitted that the prosecution under Section 276B of the Income-tax Act is, therefore, possible and valid even in the case of delayed payments as well. Learned advocate for the respondent further submitted that the contention of the petitioners to the effect that Section 276B of the Income-tax Act, 1961, does not apply in respect of the firm and that the firm cannot be prosecuted even in case of non-payment of tax deducted at source is not correct. In this connection, learned advocate for the respondent made the following submissions:

The word ‘person’ (appearing in Section 276B of the Income-tax Act, 1961) has been defined in the Income-tax Act, 1961, in section 2(31) so as to include a firm. The first is an assessee under section 2(7) of the Income-tax Act, 1961. A partnership-firm as distinguished from a company is not a legal or juristic entity but it is an amalgam of individual partners who constitute a firm. Therefore, notices issued to a firm as well as to the managing partner of the firm to show cause as to why action under Section 276B of the Income-tax Act, 1961, should not be initiated, as in this case, are valid notices. In the instant case, show-cause notices were issued only against the firm and the managing partner thereof being writ petitioners Nos. 1 and 2 above-named. In this connection, learned advocate for the respondent referred to the decision in the case of Rishikesh Balkishandas v. T.D Manchanda, ITO, [1987] 167 ITR 49 (Delhi) and the case of Municipal Corporation of Delhi v. J.B Bottling Co. P. Ltd., [1975] Cr. LJ. 1148 (Delhi) [FB], in which it was held that proceedings under Section 276B of the Income-tax Act, 1961, can be initiated against a firm. The punishment against the firm may be by way of fine and against the managing partner by way of imprisonment.

12. According to learned advocate for the respondent, an individual partner can also be proceeded against under Section 276B of the Income-tax Act, 1961, and penalty/imprisonment can be imposed. In the instant case, show-cause notices have only been issued against the petitioner-firm (petitioner No. 1) and petitioner No. 2. V.K Nevatia, as managing partner of the firm, has verified all income-tax returns of the firm for 1970-71 and 1976-77. It has been contended that, under Section 276B of the Income-tax Act, 1961, which came into force from October 1, 1975, initiation of proceedings against the director of a company or a partner of a firm is possible but, in this case, the default has been committed prior to October 1, 1975, and as such the said amended section 276B will have no application. Such contention, it has been submitted, is not tenable. It has further been submitted that a company is a juristic entity but a firm is not. In any event, some of the offences have been committed by the petitioners after coming into force of the amended section, as the default continued until the date of payment (i.e, in case of deduction at source in March, 1975, and payment thereof being made in April, 1976, the default continued till April, 1976). Learned advocate, in this connection, referred to the judgment and decision in the case of Jagannath Prasad Jalani v. Regional Provident Fund Commissioner, [1987] 168 ITR 341 (Delhi). It has been submitted that the default continues and terminates only when the tax deducted is paid.

13. It has also been submitted that liability under section 276B is an absolute liability and a partner in charge of affairs/business of the firm is liable in law for the defaults of the firm. It has also been submitted by learned advocate for the respondent that it is settled law that, by filing a writ petition, criminal proceedings should not be stopped or prevented unless the said notices are-ipso facto mala fide or there is inherent lack of jurisdiction. According to learned advocate, in the instant case, admittedly, the petitioners have failed to pay taxes deducted at source within time as required under section 194A of the Income-tax Act read with rule 30 of the Income-tax Rules although they have paid the said sums later on and thereby an offence under section 276B has been committed. In the circumstances, it is apparent that there is no inherent lack of jurisdiction nor any mala fides in the issuance of the show-cause notices and as such the said notices should not be quashed in this writ petition. It has further been submitted that although the writ petitioners have filed a petition pursuant to the order of this court in reply to the show-cause notices and the concerned officer dealt with the same and passed an order on February 17, 1989, it is open to the petitioner in case of conviction in the said criminal proceedings, if initiated, to prefer appeal or revision to this court. It was, accordingly, urged that, in view of the alternative legal remedy available to the petitioners, the writ petition should be dismissed.

14. I have considered the respective submissions of the parties and decisions cited from the Bar.

15. In the case of Vijaya Commercial Credit Limited v. Sixth ITO, [1988] 170 ITR 55, (Kar), it was held that the expression “person” as defined under section 2(31) is wide enough to include a company or other juristic person. Having regard to the fact that a sentence of imprisonment has been made compulsory, it cannot be said that the expression “person” has been used in section 276 B. In that sense, inasmuch as it is not possible to impose a sentence of imprisonment on a company, since there is no statutory compulsion to prosecute a company alongside of the officers or persons in charge of and responsible to the company and such officers or the persons responsible to the company may be prosecuted without prosecuting the company, criminal proceedings instituted against a company under section 277 are futile and should be quashed.

16. In the case of Kusum Products Ltd. v. S.K Sinha, ITO, [1980] 126 ITR 804, 808, considering the provision, the Division Bench of the court observed as follows:

“That mens rea is an essential ingredient of an offence under section 277 of the Act is clear from the section itself and only an actual person who does any of the acts indicated therein with a specific knowledge or intent can be made liable. Although, under section 2(31) of the Apt, the definition of a person is wide enough to include a company or any juristic person, the word ‘person’ could not have been used by Parliament in section 277 of the Act in the sense given in the definition clause. That this was the intention of Parliament is clear because imprisonment has been made compulsory for an offence under section 277 of the Act. A company or a juristic person cannot possibly be sent to prison, and it is not open to a court to impose a sentence of fine or not award any punishment if the court finds a company guilty under the said section. If the court does so, it would be altering the very scheme of the Act and usurping the legislative function.”

17. The petitioner-company filed a return of income for the assessment year 1974-75 under the signature of its accountant who was also the constituted attorney of the company. The Income-tax Officer filed a petition of complaint in the court of the Chief Metropolitan Magistrate against the company and the accountant, alleging the commission of an offence punishable under section 277 on the grounds that, in the return, the company had shown a total profit from its business amounting to Rs. 66,62,114 from which a total deduction amounting to Rs. 12,89,107 was claimed. The deduction included a sum of Rs. 1,14,212 which was received by the company as interest on advance tax paid for the assessment year 1967-68. In claiming the deduction, it was stated in the return that it had already been assessed in an earlier year although there was no evidence to show that the amount had been assessed to tax in any previous year and that when this sum of Rs. 1,14,212 was added to the assessable income in the final assessment, the company did not prefer any objection to the inclusion of the amount. Therefore, the accused persons had made a false verification in the return knowing or believing it to be false or not believing it to be true. The petitioner-company filed an application before the High Court for quashing the proceedings pending against the company in the Court of the Chief Metropolitan Magistrate.

18. It was held that, as the petitioner-company could not be attributed with the requisite mens rea, its prosecution in the court of the Metropolitan Magistrate for an offence under section 277 would tantamount to an abuse of the process of the court. Therefore, the proceedings pending against the petitioner-company were quashed.

19. In the case of D.C Goel v. B.L Verma, [1974] 93 ITR 63, it was held by the Delhi High Court that section 276B of the Act provides that a person failing without reasonable cause or excuse to deduct or after deducting to pay the tax as required by the provisions mentioned therein shall be punishable with rigorous imprisonment for a term which may extend to six months, and shall also be liable to fine which shall not be less than the sum calculated at the rate of 15% per annum on the amount of such tax from the date on which such tax was deductible to the date on which such tax is actually paid. It was also held that a company or a firm being a juridical person is not liable to be prosecuted under section 276B inasmuch as it could not have been imprisoned. The provision left no discretion to the court to impose the fine contemplated by it as an alternative to imprisonment. The accused was in any case punishable with rigorous imprisonment for a term which could extend to six months. A juridical person could not have been imprisoned and could not have been prosecuted for the purpose of being prosecuted under section 276 B of the Act.

20. It was further held that where a company and its managing directors are accused of the offences under section 276D and section 276B, the court cannot impose a sentence of fine or an alternative sentence of simple imprisonment on both the accused.

21. In the case of CIT v. Anchor Pressing (P.) Ltd., [1982] 136 ITR 505, it was held by the Division Bench of the Allahabad High Court, inter alia, as under (headnote):

“The Companies (Profits) Surtax Act, 1964, envisages a levy of surtax on the excess profits of companies, other than those which have no share capital over and above a certain figure. Such a company has to file its return for purposes of assessment to income-tax under sub-section (1) or sub-section (2) of section 139 of the Income-tax Act, 1961, as the case may be. Under section 271(1)(a) of the Income-tax Act, 1961, penalty is leviable on the failure, without reasonable cause, to furnish a return of total income under sub-section (1) of section 139 or by notice given under sub-section (2) of section 139 or section 148 or within the time allowed and in the manner required by sub-section (1) of section 139 or by such notice, as the case may be. Under the Wealth-tax Act, 1957, also, for failure to furnish a return under sub-section (1) of section 14 as required or under sub-section (2) of section 14, if notice is given, penalty is provided for in section 17 of that Act. In section 9 of the Companies (Profits) Surtax Act, 1964, however, the levy of penalty has been provided only for failure to furnish a return, without reasonable cause, as required under section & of the Companies (Profits) Surtax Act, 1964. It does not include the failure to furnish the return within the time allowed and in the manner prescribed under sub-section (1) of section 5 or within the time allowed in the notice issued under sub-section (2) of section 5. It envisages a levy of penalty only for the failure to furnish a return as required under section 5. If no return has been filed as stipulated under sub-section (1) or within the time given by the notice issued under sub-section (2) of section 5 but is filed under sub-section (3) of section 5, before the assessment is made, there will be no default.

22. If an assessee filed a return under sub-section (3) of section 5 cf the Companies (Profits) Surtax Act, 1964, it would also be a return “required” by the provision. Simply because the word “required” does not occur in sub-section (3) it does not mean that it is only an enabling provision. The word “required”, therefore, does not necessarily mean an imperative or authoritative demand to file the return. It can be equated with “authorised” as well. In sub-section (3) of section 5, therefore, if a company liable to tax under the Surtax Act has not furnished a return during the time allowed under sub-section (1) or sub-section (2) of section 5, iit may furnish a return at any time before the assessment is made. Therefore, section 9 provides for a levy of penalty only on failure to furnish the return required under section 5 and not for the default in the filing of the return within the time allowed under sub-section (1) of section 5 or by notice under sub-section (2) of section 5.

23. Moreover, under section 9 of the Surtax Act, 1964, the penalty is leviable of a sum not exceeding the amount of surtax while for a default under section 271(1)(a) of the Income-tax Act, 1961, the penalty leviable is the sum equal to two per cent. of the assessed tax for every month during which the default continued. Further, Chapter XXII of the Income-tax Act, 1961, provides for offences and prosecutions. Failure to furnish returns of income is one such offence. Similarly, sections 20 to 22 of the Companies (Profits) Surtax Act, 1964, make provision for offences and prosecutions. These offences are failure to deliver returns, etc., furnishing of false statements and abatement of false returns, etc. Section 20 of the Surtax Act, 1964, which governs the case of a failure to furnish returns, etc., specifically makes the failure without reasonable cause “to furnish in due time any return under sub-section (2) of section 5”, a default. It is, therefore, evident that the Legislature intended to penalise only a default in filing the return.

24. Therefore, looking to the scheme of the Companies (Profits) Surtax Act, 1964, the purpose which it was intended to serve and the clear language used in the relevant provisions, section 9 of the Surtax Act, 1964, envisages a levy of penalty for the failure to file a return under section 5 without reasonable cause and not for the failure to file a return within the time prescribed under sub-section (1) or sub-section (2) of section 5. The Income-tax Officer is not entitled to impose penalty on the ground of failure to file a return within the time prescribed under sub-section (1) or subsection (2) of section 5 when the return is filed before the assessment is made and the Income-tax Officer accepts it and completes the assessment on the basis of such a return.”

25. In the case of Commissioner Of Income-Tax, Delhi-Ii v. Triveni Engineering Works Ltd., [1985] 154 ITR 561 (Delhi), which was relied upon by the petitioner, the facts were, inter alia, that the petitioner had to file a return, under the Companies (Profits) Surtax Act, 1964, for the relevant year by September 30, 1969, but it actually filed it on January 31, 1970. The Income-tax Officer rejected the assessee's plea that the delay was on account of the fact that there were no chargeable profits and imposed a penalty of Rs. 1,02,765. The Appellate Assistant Commissioner cancelled the penalty following the decision of this court in Calcutta Chromotype (P.) Ltd. v. ITO, [1971] 80 ITR 627 and this was upheld by the Tribunal. On an application to direct reference, it was held that under section 9 of the Companies (Profits) Surtax Act, 1964, penalty could be imposed only for the failure to file the return and not for late filing of the return.

26. In the case of Calcutta Chromotype (P.) Ltd. v. ITO, [1971] 80 ITR 627 (Cal) it was held that the Income-tax Officer is not entitled to impose a penalty on an assessee on the ground of failure to file a return under sub-section (1) of section 6 of the Super Profits Tax Act, 1963 (since superseded by the Companies (Profits) Surtax Act, 1964), within the time prescribed under that sub-section, when the return is filed before the assessment is made, as permitted by sub-section (3) of section 6. There are no specific words in section 10 imposing penalty in such cases as there are in the corresponding provisions of the Income-tax Act.

27. In the case of Amin Chand and Sons v. State of Punjab, AIR 1965 Punj 441, levy of damages were imposed up to six years upon an employer for not making payment in the scheduled time in terms of the Employees' Provident Funds Act, it was held that levy of damages not immediately after default but after allowing accumulation of defaults for years together is arbitrary exercise of discretion.

28. It may be worthwhile to consider in this connection Section 276B of the Income-tax Act, both before and after amendment. Section 276B of the Income-tax Act originally provided as follows:

“If a person, without reasonable cause or excuse, fails to deduct or after deducting, fails to pay the tax as required by or under the provisions of sub-section (9) of section 80E or Chapter XVII-B, he shall be punishable:—

(i) in a case where the amount of tax which he has failed to deduct or pay exceeds one hundred thousand rupees, with rigorous imprisonment for a term which shall not be less than six months but which may extend to seven years and with fine;

(ii) in any other case, with rigorous imprisonment for a term which shall not be less than three months but which may extend to three years and with fine.”

29. Section 276B which provides that for failure to deduct and to pay tax as required under the provision of sub-section (9) of section 80E as punishable was introduced with effect from 1st October, 1975 (sic). The relevant period for alleged default was earlier to October 1, 1975, and as such the said provisions of section 276B cannot be made applicable there to the case of the petitioner. (sic).

30. It appears to me on a proper construction of Section 276B of the Income-tax Act that the word “person” referred to in the said section does not mean to include either a partnership firm or any partner thereof and the meaning of the word “person” in section 2(31) of the said Act has no application to section 276B of the said Act. In this connection, I take note of the judgment and decision of the Supreme Court in the case of Kapurchand Shrimal v. TRO, [1969] 72 ITR 623. At page 629 of the said report, the Supreme Court observed as follows:

“Sections 276, 276A, 277 and 278 on which reliance was placed by counsel for the Revenue in support of his argument also do not assist him. These sections occur in a chapter relating to penalties, and they seek to penalise failure to carry out specific provisions mentioned therein. We are unable to hold that the expression ‘person’ in sections 276, 276A and 277 is used in the sense in which it is defined in section 2(31) of the Act. For each specific act which is deemed to be an offence under those provisions, an individual who without reasonable cause or excuse fails to do the acts prescribed by statute or acts in a manner contrary to the statute or makes a declaration on oath which he believed to be false or does not believe to be true, is made liable to be punished. Section 278 penalises the abetment or inducing any person to make and deliver an account, statement or declaration relating to any income chargeable to tax which is false and which he either knows to be false or does not believe to be true. In the context in which the expression ‘person’ occurs in sections 276, 276A, 277 and 278, there can be no doubt that it seeks to penalise only those individuals who fail to carry out the duty cast by the specific provisions of the statute, or are otherwise responsible for the acts done. For the default of the Hindu undivided family, therefore, in payment of tax, the karta cannot be arrested and detained in prison.

The High Court, we think, took a somewhat technical view in declining to allow the contention raised by the appellant in the first writ petition presented before the High Court that he was not liable to be arrested and imprisoned for non-payment of the tax arrears, since he was not an asses-see, and then in treating the judgment of the High Court in the first writ petition as operating constructively as res judicata in the second petition.”

31. Section 276B of the Income-tax Act, as originally provided, has been substituted by a subsequent amendment to the following effect:

Amended section 276B.— “If a person fails to pay to the credit of the Central Government, the tax deducted at source by him as required by or under the provisions of Chapter XVII-B, he shall be punishable with rigorous imprisonment for a term which shall not be less than three months but which may extend to seven years and with fine.”

32. It appears to me that there is no provision in the Income-tax Act imposing criminal liability for delay in deduction or for non-payment in time. Under section 276B, delay in payment of income-tax is not an offence. There is, however, provision for penalty as a consequence of failure to deduct or pay under section 201(1) of the Income-tax Act. Section 200 of the Income-tax Act provides as follows:

“Any person deducting any sum in accordance with the provisions of sections 192 to 194, section 194A, section 194B, section 194C, section 194D and section 195 shall pay within the prescribed time, the sum so deducted to the credit of the Central Government or as the Board directs.”

33. Section 201 provides as follows:

“If any such person and in the cases referred to in section 194, the principal officer and the company of which he is the principal officer does not deduct or after deducting fails to pay the tax as required by or under this Act, he or it shall, without prejudice to any other consequences which he or it may incur, be deemed to be an assessee in default in respect of the tax:

Provided that no penalty shall be charged under section 221 from such person, principal officer or company unless the Assessing Officer is satisfied that person or principal officer or company, as the case may be, has without good and sufficient reasons failed to deduct and pay the tax.”

34. Prior to the insertion of section 278B, a partner of a partnership firm could not be prosecuted under section 276B of the Act. In the case of Rishikesh Balkishandas v. I.D Manchanda, ITO, [1987] 167 ITR 49 (Delhi), it was held that a firm, though a legal entity for purposes of tax laws, is liable to be prosecuted under Section 276B of the Income-tax Act, 1961. for failure to deduct tax at source from interest paid or credited, even though the section provides a minimum punishment of imprisonment. In the case of conviction, sentence of fine only can be imposed on a firm. It was also held by the learned single judge of the Delhi High Court in the aforesaid decision that section 194A of the Income-tax Act, 1961, which requires the persons making any payment of interest to deduct the tax at the rates in force imposes an absolute liability and, for an offence under section 276B read with section 194A of deficient deduction or non-deduction which is a conscious act, mens rea is not required for constituting such an offence. The learned single judge came to the aforesaid conclusion relying upon the decision of the Supreme Court in the case of State Of Maharashtra v. Mayer Hans George ., [1965] 35 Comp Cas 557. The decision in the case of Kapurchand Shrimal v. TRO, [1969] 72 ITR 623 (SC) was not considered in the aforesaid decision by the Delhi High Court probably because the court's attention was not drawn to the said decision and as such the principles decided in that decision of the Delhi High Court cannot have binding effect. It may be noted that, subsequently, the Delhi High Court, in the case of Parameet Singh Sawney… v. Dinesh Verma & Another…, [1988] 169 ITR 5, after considering the provisions of section 276B and section 278B, held that partners of a firm could not be prosecuted. A special leave petition of the Department against the said aforesaid decision was rejected by the Supreme Court as appears from [1988] 171 ITR (St.) 257. It appears to me that the provisions of section 278B of the said Act cannot have ex post facto application and, therefore, the partner of a firm could not be prosecuted. There is no justifiable cause shown for such unreasonable delay in issuing the aforesaid show-cause notices. The order dated February 17, 1989, also does not furnish any explanation for the delay. Although the Income-tax Act did not prescribe any limitation for initiating the proceedings, it is well settled by numerous judicial decisions already noted that such proceedings have to be initiated within a reasonable time and a lapse of 10 to 16 years could not be said to be reasonable and initiation of proceedings after a lapse of such a long time would be contrary to public policy and abuse of process of law for the obvious reason that, after lapse of such a long time, the evidence, facts and other materials could not be available. Therefore, proper justice could not be rendered. Therefore, such delayed proceedings should not be allowed. It is also a well established principle of criminal law that, without mens rea, there cannot be criminal liability. The payments in this case hate all been duly made although such amounts were deducted out of time. But no mens rea could have been proved or established. It may be noted that a partnership firm is not a natural person and, therefore, cannot be prosecuted under section 276B of the Act inasmuch as punishment by way of imprisonment is compulsory thereunder during the relevant year. In the instant case the essential ingredient of an offence under section 276B of the Act is wholly absent. The judgment and decision in the case of Kusum Products Ltd. v. S.K Sinha, ITO, [1980] 126 ITR 804 (Cal) and the case of Adding Machines (India) Pvt. Ltd. v. The State, [1987] 167 ITR 171 (Cal) may be taken note of. The order dated February 17, 1989, passed by the Income-tax Officer did not consider or dispute the explanation given by the petitioner for the delay in depositing the tax.

35. In the case of Adding Machines (India) Pvt. Ltd. v. The State, [1987] 167 ITR 171 (Cal), it was held by the learned single judge of this court that though the word “person” as defined in section 2(31) of the Income-tax Act, 1961, includes a company, a company cannot be prosecuted for an offence under section 276B because a company cannot be committed to prison. However, the principal officer of a company can be prosecuted for an offence punishable under section 276B and in case he is found guilty, he has to suffer imprisonment but only for the offence committed by himself and not for any offence committed by the company.

36. In the case of Parameet Singh Sawney… v. Dinesh Verma & Another…, [1988] 169 ITR 5 (Delhi), the facts, inter alia, are that the petitioners (including a person who was a minor at the time of the alleged offence) who were partners of a firm, were charged, along with the firm, for the failure to deduct income-tax at source from interest paid by the firm to certain parties and deposit it within time. The failure related to the accounting years 1970-71 and 1973-74, when the minor was 6 and 9 years of age respectively. The prosecution was actually initiated on March 29, 1984. The petitioners, i.e, the partners, applied to the High Court under section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1898, for having the prosecution quashed. It was held by the Delhi High Court that the prosecution ought to be quashed for two reasons: firstly, because, prior to section 278B of the Income-tax Act, 1961, coming into force, i.e, on October 1, 1975, the firm alone could have been proceeded against and the partners could not be prosecuted. Secondly, it was held that there was non-application of mind because even a six-year old boy was, according to the complaint, in charge and responsible for the conduct of the firm's business. As already noted, the special leave petition against the said judgment stands dismissed.

37. In the instant case, it appears from the order dated February 17, 1989, passed by Income-tax Officer, Ward 4(7), Calcutta, that the first show-cause notice contemplating prosecution was issued on November 8, 1976, for the assessment years 1968-69 to 1974-75. Relevant portion of the said order in this connection is set out hereinbelow:

“Next issue raised by the assessee was that proceedings for launching prosecution have been initiated after more than 10 to 16 years and that there was no lawful justification for initiating such proceedings after such a long lapse of time. Firstly, in this regard, I have to state that there is no question of any limitation for launching of prosecution under the Income-tax Act. The last payment was made as late as on April 22, 1976 and the first show-cause notice contemplating prosecution was issued as far back as on November 8, 1976, for the assessment years 1968-69 to 1974-75. Hence, the assessee's contention in this regard is not accepted.”

38. It has been submitted by learned advocate for the petitioner that as no steps were taken pursuant to the aforesaid show-cause notice the proceedings relating thereto were ultimately dropped or lapsed. It appears to me that once a show-cause notice was already issued which was not given effect to ultimately, there is no reason again to issue a fresh show-cause notice on the same cause of action and the fresh show-cause notice issued for the same assessment years on the same ground after 10 years cannot have any basis whatsoever. For the reasons aforesaid, the petitioners succeed in this writ petition.

39. Accordingly, the rule issued herein should be made absolute and the impugned show-cause notices dated November 20, 1986, and December 1, 1986, and also the order dated February 17, 1989, passed by the Income-tax Officer, Ward 4(7), Calcutta, stand quashed and set aside and appropriate writ of mandamus to issue accordingly. There will be no order as to costs.