Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Delta Engineering Company (Private), Ltd., Meerut v. Industrial Tribunal V. Meerut, And Others

Allahabad High Court
Jul 29, 1997
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

Respondents 3, 4 and 5 were workmen employed by the petitioner. The petitioner states that on 7 October, 1977 the three workmen tendered resignations which the petitioner accepted and thereafter paid lawful dues (including bonus, wages in lieu of unavailed leave, gratuity, etc.). On 10 October, 1977 the three workmen made a representation alleging that their signatures and thumb impressions had been obtained on blank papers by promises of payment which were not honoured, and that they were thereby retrenched by fraud; they requested reinstatement (Annexure 4 to the writ petition).

Respondents 3 to 5, through respondent 2, raised an industrial dispute. The State Government issued a reference dated 11 June, 1978 to the Labour Court, Meerut for adjudication, asking whether termination of the three workmen with effect from 10 October, 1977 was proper and/or legal and, if not, what reliefs were due.

The parties filed written statements and rejoinders; the Tribunal framed six issues. Several opportunities were given to the petitioner to adduce evidence, but the petitioner did not lead any evidence. The respondents likewise did not adduce oral evidence, indicating they wished disposal on documentary evidence. The Labour Court, by an award dated 21 July, 1981, held that the burden of proving voluntary resignation and legality of termination lay on the petitioner; having failed to adduce evidence, the petitioner was held to have failed and the workmen were declared to have continued in employment and to be entitled to back-wages and attendant benefits.

The petitioner challenged that award on the grounds that (a) the real dispute referred was about amounts due on accepted resignations (and not termination of service) so the reference was bad, and (b) the Tribunal wrongly placed the burden of proof on the petitioner rather than on the workmen, who alleged forgery and fraud.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the State Government's reference to the Labour Court was bad in law because the real controversy (the amount due on accepted resignations) was not the dispute actually referred, i.e., whether the matter referred properly raised the question of termination/retrenchment.
  2. Whether the Labour Court erred in holding that the burden of proof of illegal termination was on the employer (petitioner) rather than on the workmen who made allegations of forgery, fraud and that resignations were not tendered voluntarily.
  3. Who bears the obligation to lead evidence in a reference made by the State Government: which party will fail if no evidence is led before the Labour Court in such proceedings?

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The real controversy was the amount payable to respondents 3 to 5 upon their resignations being accepted, not a question of termination; hence the reference was bad.
  • The Tribunal incorrectly placed the burden of proof on the petitioner; since respondents alleged forgery and false procurement of signatures, it was for the respondents to adduce evidence in support of those allegations and they did not do so.
  • Respondent 2 was not competent to espouse the cause of respondents 3 to 5, and that fact undermines the reference process.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The language of the Government's reference prima facie required the petitioner to establish that termination (if any) was legal; despite ample opportunity, the petitioner failed to adduce evidence, and the Tribunal correctly upheld the respondents' plea.
  • Annexure 4 (the representation dated 10 October, 1977) showed that thumb impressions/signatures were obtained on blank papers by fraud and that resignations were forged; therefore the dispute was properly one of retrenchment amounting to illegal termination and the reference was correct.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Airtech Private Ltd. v. State of Uttar Pradesh [1984 (49) F.L.R. 38] Holds that after considering S.5 of the Uttar Pradesh Industrial Disputes Act and rule 12 of the Rules, the burden of proving the case referred to the Labour Court by the Government lies on the workman. Cited to support the proposition that the Labour Court erred in placing the burden on the employer; the Court relied on Airtech to hold that the primary burden remains with the employee who seeks relief under the reference.
Shankar Chakravarti v. Britannia Biscuit Company Ltd. [1979 (2) L.L.N. 72] Explains that a Labour Court/Industrial Tribunal has judicial trappings and that the obligation to lead evidence to establish an allegation lies on the party making the allegation; asks who would fail if no evidence is led. Quoted to demonstrate that where the reference is made for the benefit of the workman, in absence of evidence led by the workman the reference must be answered against the workman; supports the proposition that the workman will fail if no evidence is led.
V.K. Raj Industries v. Labour Court [1981 (2) L.L.N. 498] Affirms the view concerning the obligation to lead evidence before Labour Courts/Tribunals. Cited as a supportive Division Bench authority that the party making an allegation must lead evidence; treated as consonant with the conclusions drawn about burden and onus.
Meritec India Ltd. v. State of Uttar Pradesh [1996—I L.L.J. 23] Recent decision endorsing the view that the party making the allegation must lead evidence and that failure to do so results in that party failing. Relied upon together with the other authorities to fortify the conclusion that the primary burden of proof in such references lies on the workmen who made the allegations.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined both the language of the Government's reference and the statutory/procedural framework governing Labour Court procedure. It noted that the reference's phraseology appeared to prima facie cast an onus on the petitioner to establish the legality of termination. However, the Court held that the procedural provisions and rules limit the Labour Court's discretion and define the preliminary evidential framework:

  1. The Court invoked Section 5(c)(1) of the Uttar Pradesh Industrial Disputes Act, which allows the Labour Court to follow such procedure as it thinks fit, but emphasized that this discretion is circumscribed by Rule 12, sub-rules (8) and (9) of the Uttar Pradesh Industrial Disputes Rules, 1957. The combined effect requires the workman to file an affidavit in support of his written statement; such affidavit constitutes preliminary evidence.
  2. Where a workman files the required affidavit supporting his written statement, the employer must then rebut the averments and controvert the allegations; only after such preliminary evidence is before the Tribunal does the burden shift to the employer to disprove the employee's case. Thus the Labour Court's discretion on procedure is not absolute.
  3. In the present case, the Court observed that respondents 3, 4 and 5 did not appear to have filed affidavits in support of their written statements before the Labour Court (the Tribunal's award itself does not mention any such affidavits), and therefore the Tribunal erred in treating the employer as bearing the burden of proof simply because of the reference's wording.
  4. The Court relied on a line of authority (Airtech Private Ltd.; Shankar Chakravarti; V.K. Raj Industries; Meritec India Ltd.) which distinguishes between burden of proof and onus of proof and affirms that the obligation to lead evidence to establish an allegation is on the party making it. It emphasized the pragmatic test: who would fail if no evidence is led? In a reference made by the State at the workmen's instance, the workmen would fail if they lead no evidence.
  5. The Court clarified that the primary burden of establishing allegations of forgery, thumb impressions/signatures obtained on blank papers, and false inducement will remain on the employees at whose instance the reference was made. Only after such evidence is adduced would the petitioner be called upon to prove that resignations were voluntary and were accepted on the stated date.
  6. As to the contention that the reference was bad because the real controversy was not referred, the Court held that this issue could not be resolved without examining evidence. The contents of the representation suggest allegations of false inducement, but, absent evidence proving that the resignation documents were rendered voluntarily by the employees, it cannot now be held that the matter was solely one of accepted resignations rather than retrenchment amounting to illegal termination. Accordingly, the question of the validity of the reference must be decided by the Tribunal after receipt of evidence.

Holding and Implications

HOLDING: The petition is allowed. The impugned award dated 21 July, 1981 is quashed and the matter is remanded to the Labour Court, Meerut to be disposed of afresh within six months from the date of presentation of a certified copy of this order by either party.

Implications:

  • The direct effect is that the Labour Court's award in favour of the workmen is set aside and the dispute must be re-opened for evidence and determination consistent with the Court's observations.
  • The Court clarified that, under the applicable statutory and procedural framework and supported by cited authorities, the primary burden to establish allegations of forgery and false inducement lies on the employees who invoked the reference; in the absence of prescribed preliminary affidavit/evidence by the workmen, the Labour Court erred in treating the employer as having to prove legality.
  • The question whether the reference was bad for not framing the real controversy cannot be resolved in the abstract and requires determination after the parties lead evidence before the Labour Court.
  • No order as to costs was made. The Court directed that a certified copy of the order be made available to counsel for the parties within four days on payment of usual charges.

This summary is confined to the statements and conclusions contained in the provided opinion and does not infer additional facts or expand beyond the text.

Show all summary ...

1. Heard Sri Rakesh Tewari, brief holder for Sri J.N Tiwari learned counsel for the petitioner, Sri A.K Gaur learned counsel for respondents 2 to 5 and learned Standing Counsel for respondent 1.

2. Respondents, 4 and 5 were workmen employed with the petitioner. Petitioner's case is that on 7 October, 1977 the three workmen tendered their resignations which were accepted by the petitioner. Petitioner after accepting their resignations paid lawful dues of respondents 3, 4 and 5 to them including bonus, wages, in lieu of unavailed leave and gratuity, etc. However, on 10 October, 1977 respondents 3, 4 and 5 made a representation (Annexure 4 to the writ petition) alleging that their signatures, thump impressions were obtained on blank papers on a promise that proper payment shall be made to them but the amounts agreed were not paid to them and thus the respondents were retrenched by playing fraud A request was made that the respondents may be taken back on duty. Petitioner's case is that respondents 3, 4 and 5 had resigned of their own free will but after receipt of payment and other dues they changed their stands. Respondents 3, 4 arid 5 through respondent 2 raised an industrial dispute although respondent 2 was not competent to espouse the cause of the respondents. The State Government made the following reference vide notification, dated 11 June, 1978, to the Labour Court, Meerut for adjudication:

“Kya Sewayojokon dwara apne shramik S/Sri Hakimuddin son of Nasiruddin, Karag Singh son of Nanak Singh tatha Yasin son of Abdul Rahman, Moulderki Sevaan dinank 10 October, 1977 se samapt kiya jana uchit tatha/athwa vaidhanik hai? Yadi nahin, to sambandhit shramik kalabh/chhatipurti pane ke adhikaraon se tatha anya kis vivaran sahit”?

3. It appears that the parties filed their written statements and respondents 3 to 5 also filed rejoinder statement on the basis of which the Tribunal framed six issues as mentioned in the award. Several opportunities were given to the petitioner to adduce evidence in support of their claim but the petitioner failed to adduce any evidence.

Respondents 3, 4 and 5 also did not adduce any evidence in support of their claim and expressed that the case may be disposed of on documentary evidence already tendered by them. The Tribunal held that the burden of proving that the respondents had tendered voluntary resignations and that termination of their services was legal was on petitioners and since the petitioners did not adduce any evidence, the case of the workmen that they were illegally terminated was correct. The Tribunal, therefore, by its award, dated 21 July, 1981, directed that the workmen shall be deemed to have continued in employment and will be entitled to all back-wages and other attendant benefits available to them under the rules.

4. It is this award which is being challenged on the ground that the real dispute between the parties was not referred to the Tribunal, hence the reference was bad in law. The dispute was with regard to the amount to which respondents 3 to 5 were entitled on their resignations being accepted and not termination of service and secondly that the Tribunal has wrongly held that burden of proof of illegal termination was upon the petitioner. Since the respondents claimed that the termination was illegal and that their thumb impressions and signatures were obtained on blank papers it was for them to have adduced evidence in support of their contention. Respondents 3 to 5 did not adduce any evidence and hence no finding could have been given by the Tribunal against the petitioner.

5. For respondents 3, 4 and 5 it is contended that the language of the reference shows that it was for the petitioner to prove that the termination was legal and proper and despite ample opportunity having been given they failed to adduce evidence. The Tribunal rightly upheld the plea of the respondents. It is further contended that perusal of Annexure 4 to the writ petition dearly discloses that thumb impressions/signatures of the respondent were obtained on blank papers by fraud and subsequently resignations were forged on such papers. Therefore there was a clear dispute of retrenchment amounting to illegal termination of employment. Thus the reference was correctly made.

6. The Labour Court appears to have placed burden of proof upon the employers. The claim of respondents 3, 4 and 5 was that their thumb impressions/signatures were obtained on blank papers by making false inducements and false promise and the petitioner had forged their resignation letters in order to deprive them of their legitimate dues and the sum promised by the employers. The real controversy was whether the termination of the services of respondents 3, 4 and 5 as alleged by them was illegal as also whether they had not actually tendered any resignations.

7. The reference was, however, couched in a language so as to prima facie make it incumbent upon the petitioner to establish the legality or justifiability of the termination of the service of the workmen. The phraseology employed in the reference prima facie lays the burden of proof on the employers. The question however is as to who will fail in case no evidence is led. Section 5(c)(1) of the Uttar Pradesh Industrial Disputes Act provides that subject to any rules that may be made in this behalf a Labour Court shall follow such procedure as it may think fit. Rule 12, sub-rules (8) and (9) of the Uttar Pradesh Industrial Disputes Rules, 1957, however, circumscribes the discretion of the Labour Court/Tribunal. Combined effect of S. 5(c)(1) and rule 12 is that it is imperative upon workman to file affidavit in support of his written statement. It is only when such an affidavit is filed by the employee which constitutes preliminary evidence that the employer is called upon to rebut the allegations and controvert the averments made in the affidavit and in case the employer does not do so there is no further need to prove by the workman. The discretion of the Labour Court in respect of the procedure to be followed by it is thus not absolute. If looked from this angle, it would be workmen who would suffer in case no evidence in the form of affidavit in support of the written statement is filed by him. It is true that the petitioner having taken several adjournments failed to adduce any evidence but at the same time the respondents 3, 4 and 5 do not appear to have filed any affidavit in support of their written statement. Only respondent 4 Mohd. Yaseen has filed counter-affidavit in this Court and he has nowhere stated that in support of the written statement filed before the Labour Court affidavit of any of respondents 3, 4 and 5 was filed. Even the Labour Court in its award (Annexure 9 to the petition) does not make a mention of any such affidavit having been filed by the respondents in support of their written statement.

8. There are a number of decisions fortifying the above view. In Airtech Private, Ltd. v. State of Uttar Pradesh [1984 (49) F.L.R 38], this Court after consideration of provisions of S. 5 of the Uttar Pradesh Industrial Disputes Act and rule 12 of the Uttar Pradesh Industrial Disputes Rules, held that the burden of proving the case referred to the Labour Court for adjudication by the Government lies on the workman. The distinction between a burden of proof and the onus of proof is well known. It is trite that the burden of proof never shifts. It is the onus which keeps on shifting from stage to stage. The Labour Court patently erred in holding that “keeping in view the terms of the reference made by the State Government the burden of proof lay upon the employers”.

The matter can be looked at from another angle, which party will fail if the evidence is not led before the Labour Court in proceedings in a reference made to it for adjudication by the State Government? The obvious answer is that the workman will fail. Here the reference was made by the State Government at the instance of the workmen and for the benefit of the workmen. In the absence of any evidence led by or on behalf of the workmen the reference is bound to be answered by the Court against the workmen. In such a situation it is not necessary for the employers to lead any evidence at all. This matter was d???at with by the Supreme Court in Shankar Chakravarti v. Britannia Biscuit Company, Ltd. [1979 (2) L.L.N 72]. In Para. 29, at page 86, the Court held that:

“…the Labour Court or the Industrial Tribunal has all the trappings of a Court,”

In Para. 30, at page 86, it held that:

“… any party appearing before a Labour Court or Industrial Tribunal must make a claim or demur the claim of the other side and when mere is a burden upon it to prove or establish the fact so as to invite a decision in its favour, it has to lead evidence. The obligation to lead evidence to establish an allegation made by a party is on the party making the allegation. The test would be who would fail if no evidence is led. It must seek an opportunity to lead evidence…”

Similar view has been taken by a Division Bench of this Court in the case V.K Raj Industries v. Labour Court [1981 (2) L.L.N 498], and a recent decision Meritec India Ltd. v. State of Uttar Pradesh [1996—I L.L.J 23].

9. It may be made clear here that the view taken by the Labour Court that in the absence of the evidence adduced by the employers the averments made by the employees in their written statements stood proved was erroneous. The primary burden of establishing the fact that thumb impressions/signatures of the employees were obtained by the petitioner on blank papers and such papers were subsequently used as resignation letter to the disadvantage of the employees and further that the consent for resignation was taken on false promise and inducement which was not intended to be fulfilled will always remain upon the employees at whose instance the reference was made. It is only after the evidence in support of such pleas is adduced that the petitioner is called upon to prove that the employees had voluntarily tendered their resignations and the same were accepted by the petitioners on 7 October, 1997.

10. The next question as to whether the reference was bad for the reason that the real controversy was not referred by the State Government for determination can be disposed of only in the light of the evidence that may be adduced by the parties. Although respondents 3, 4 and 5 have stated in their representation, dated 10 October, 1997 (Annexure 4 to the writ petition) that they were not paid the amount promised by the employers but at the same time what appears from reading the contents of the said documents is that consent of the employees to submit resignations was taken by making false inducements and promises which the petitioner did not intend to fulfil. Without evidence that resignations, Annexures 1, 2 and 3 to the writ petition were rendered by the employees of their own free will, at this stage it cannot be held that it was a case of resignations by the employees and not retrenchment amounting to illegal termination of the services of the employees. This question of fact has to be first disposed of on evidence of the parties by the Tribunal and only then the question whether the reference was bad as claimed by the petitioner can be disposed of.

11. In view of discussion made above the petition deserves to be allowed.

12. The petition is hereby allowed Impugned award is hereby quashed and the matter is sent back to the Labour Court, Meerut, to dispose of the matter afresh within a period of six months from the date of presentation of a certified copy of this order by either party, in the light of the observations made in the body of the judgment. No order as to costs.

13. Certified copy of this order shall be made available to the counsel for the parties within four days on payment of usual charges.

Petition allowed.