- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Vimal v. Attar Hussain And Another
Summary of Opinion — V.D. Gyani, J. (Workmen's Compensation Act appeal)
Factual and Procedural Background
This appeal under Section 30 of the Workmen's Compensation Act was preferred by a slate-pencil cutter suffering from silicosis whose compensation claim had been dismissed by the Commissioner on the technical ground of non-maintainability (the opinion refers to a Commissioner’s judgment dated 24.7.1984 and elsewhere notes an impugned order passed on 30.7.1984 in the same proceeding, recorded as case No. 23 of 1984).
The claimant had worked in the respondents' slate pencil works for over ten years immediately preceding the filing of the claim petition. The claim petition was filed on 23.12.1980; the respondents filed written statements on 23.3.1981. The case experienced extensive procedural delays: on 21.4.1981 the respondents sought better particulars under Order 6 Rule 5 C.P.C., which took about six months to decide; an amendment was made with a deadline of 15.10.1981; the Court had periods when it could not hold sittings at Mandsaur; confusion about framing an additional issue consumed several months; repeated adjournments were noted (including for non-payment of process or non-service of summons); the appellant closed his evidence on 19.3.1983; between 19.3.1983 and 3.3.1984 the respondents produced no witnesses despite many opportunities; on 24.7.1984 the Labour Court recorded the respondents' case as closed and heard arguments; the Commissioner had earlier dismissed the claim as not maintainable.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the claim petition under the Workmen's Compensation Act was maintainable in view of Section 53 of the Employees' State Insurance (E.S.I.) Act (i.e., whether the claimant was an "insured person" under the E.S.I. Act and thus barred from recovering compensation under the Workmen's Compensation Act).
- Whether, on the evidence led by the claimant and in the absence of effective rebuttal by the respondents, the claimant was entitled to compensation for silicosis and, if so, the quantum and interest payable.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments
- The appellant asserted that he was employed by the respondents for over ten years immediately before filing his claim, that he earned Rs. 400 per month, and that he had dependents (wife, father, son and daughter aged three and eight years respectively).
- The appellant presented medical evidence (including a medical board certificate and X-ray findings) establishing he suffered from pneumoconiosis/silicosis attributable to his employment in the slate pencil works (Exhibits such as P-1, P-2, P-3 were relied upon and Dr. Purnashankar Bhatt and a radiologist gave evidence).
- The appellant sought compensation of Rs. 20,000 and interest from the date of application.
Respondents' Arguments
- The respondents resisted the claim on multiple grounds and primarily raised a technical objection under Section 53 of the E.S.I. Act, contending that if the claimant was an "insured person" under the E.S.I. Act he could not recover compensation under the Workmen's Compensation Act.
- To support this contention they produced (through their witness Rameshchandra Mishra, Manager, E.S.I. at Ratlam) a declaration form (Exhibit P-4) and its counterfoil (D-1), and relied on these to assert that E.S.I. coverage applied and the Workmen's Compensation claim was thus barred.
- The respondents otherwise largely declined to adduce oral evidence to rebut the appellant's factual and medical evidence despite numerous opportunities.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court conducted a multi-part analysis focused on procedural conduct, evidentiary burdens, statutory interpretation of Section 53 of the E.S.I. Act, and the medical/compensatory elements required under the Workmen's Compensation Act:
-
Procedural conduct and delay:
The court reviewed the extensive adjournments and procedural delays, criticizing the Labour Court's failure to adhere to prescribed time-limits and emphasizing the importance of prompt disposal in labour matters because the litigants are often poor and vulnerable. The narration of dates was used to underline the duty of Labour Courts to be efficient and to avoid needless delay, especially when dealing with the labour class.
-
Evidentiary burden on respondents regarding Section 53 (E.S.I. Act):
The court analyzed Section 53 of the E.S.I. Act, which bars an "insured person" or his dependents from receiving or recovering compensation under the Workmen's Compensation Act in respect of an employment injury. The court observed that the applicability of Section 53 depends on establishing that the claimant was an "insured person" within the meaning of the E.S.I. Act (the opinion cites the statutory definition in Clause 14 of Section 2: an insured person is one in respect of whom contributions are or were payable and who is entitled to benefits under that Act).
The court held that it was incumbent upon the respondents to prove payment of contributions in respect of the claimant or at least establish on oath that contributions were payable. The respondents failed to lead such cogent evidence: the only material they produced was the declaration form (Exhibit P-4) and its counterfoil (D-1), neither of which bore signatures, endorsements, or proper authentication, and D-1 lacked endorsement or signature of any E.S.I. authority. The purported employer signature and the dates on the form were not confronted with the claimant. The court observed that Exhibit P-4 was dated 21.12.1981 — almost a year after the claim had been filed on 23.12.1980 — and was produced after the appellant's evidence was closed.
On these facts the court treated Exhibit P-4 (and D-1) as an insufficient and possibly fabricated attempt to defeat the appellant's claim; because the respondents did not place admissible material on record to attract Section 53, the objection based on that section failed.
-
Medical and factual evidence establishing entitlement:
The court reviewed the medical evidence tendered by the claimant. A medical board certificate (Exhibit P-1) and X-ray evidence (Exhibit P-2 and Exhibit P-3) showed nodular opacities and radiological findings consistent with silicosis/pneumoconiosis. Dr. Purnashankar Bhatt (a specialist) and a radiologist gave evidence; the radiologist reported bilateral chest infiltration. The court found these medical findings probative of silicosis attributable to the claimant's employment in the slate pencil works.
On factual matters (employment, salary, dependents), the court noted the respondents did not put forward sworn evidence to contradict the appellant's account that he worked for the respondents, earned Rs. 400 per month, and had the stated dependents. The respondents' failure to call witnesses despite repeated opportunities meant the claimant's factual evidence remained unrebutted.
-
Assessment of quantum:
The court accepted the appellant's evidence on age, earnings and dependents and found that the claimed compensation of Rs. 20,000 was not unreasonable on the record. Applying the Workmen's Compensation framework and the evidence, the court held the appellant entitled to Rs. 20,000 with interest at 12% per annum from the date of application.
-
Policy and interpretive approach:
The court emphasized that both the Workmen's Compensation Act, 1923 and the E.S.I. Act, 1948 are social welfare legislation and that a doctrinaire approach to interpretation should be avoided where it would defeat the objects of those Acts. The opinion also contained a policy admonition directed to employers and authorities about the occupational risk of silicosis in slate pencil manufacturing and the duty to implement safety measures and regular medical examinations.
Holding and Implications
Core Ruling: The appeal was allowed; the Commissioner's order dismissing the claim as not maintainable was set aside. The court held that the appellant was entitled to compensation of Rs. 20,000 with interest at 12% per annum from the date of the application, and that the respondents were jointly and severally liable to pay the compensation. The respondents were to bear the appellant's costs throughout; counsel's fee of Rs. 250 was awarded if certified.
Implications and direct effects:
- The immediate practical consequence is reversal of the Commissioner's decision and an award of Rs. 20,000 plus interest to the appellant, together with costs and a counsel fee as certified.
- The court rejected the respondents' maintainability objection under Section 53 of the E.S.I. Act because the respondents failed to produce admissible evidence to prove that the claimant was an insured person under the E.S.I. Act (i.e., proof of contributions or entitlement to E.S.I. benefits was not established).
- The opinion contains a strong admonition to Labour Courts to avoid procedural delay in labour cases and to apply the provisions of social welfare statutes in a manner that furthers their remedial purpose rather than adopting an overly technical or doctrinaire approach.
- The court also issued policy observations urging employers and enforcing authorities to adopt safety measures (medical examinations, ventilation, dust control) in the slate pencil industry to prevent silicosis; while these are expressed strongly, the decision principally provides relief to this claimant rather than announcing a new legal principle or precedent.
This summary is strictly confined to the material and conclusions set out in the provided opinion and does not add facts or inferences beyond that text.
V.D Gyani, J.:— This appeal under Section 30 of the Workmen's Compensation Act has been preferred by a Slate Pencil Cutter, suffering from Silicosis, whose claim for compensation has been dismissed by the Commissioner by his judgement dated 24.7.1984 passed in case No. 23 of 1984, solely on the technical ground that it was not maintainable.
2. The Appellant filed his claim for compensation against the respondents-employers, in whose Slate Pencil Works he had been working for over ten years, immediately preceding the filing of his claim, which was resisted by the employer-respondents on all conceivable grounds, tenable or untenable, permissible or impermissible, under the law.
3. The claim petition was filed on 23.12.1980 and the respondents filed their separate written statements on 23.3.1981 The case was fixed for filing of list of witnesses by the parties on 21.4.1981, when the respondents instead of filing such a list moved an application for better particular under Order 6 Rule 5 C.P.C and it took almost six months for the Labour Court, to decide the same. The necessary amendment was to be made by 15.10.1981 and what follows thereafter, is a sad commentary. For three months, the Labour Court had no room to hold its sitting at Mandsaur, as is evidenced by the order sheet dated 25.1.1982 As a necessary consequence of amendment, an additional issue was to be framed, but the Labour Court took four months from 8.3.1982 to 17.7.1982 to realise that no such additional issue was required to be framed and the case was fixed for evidence and arguments of both the parties on 11.10.1982, but that was not to be For some reason or other either non-payment of process, or non-service of summons on the witnesses, the case had to be adjourned from date after date Finally, when the Appellant closed his case and as no witness for the respondents was either summoned or kept present or produced on this day yet their prayer for adjournment was granted by the learned Judge of the Labour Court and from 19.3.1983 (when the Appellant closed his case) to 3.3.1984, no witness was produced by the employer-respondents although number of opportunities were sought and granted Finally, it was on 24.7.1984 that the Labour Court record the respondent's case as closed and heard arguments.
4. The impugned order was passed on 30.7.1984 This long arduous litigation was faught between a labourer, a patient of Silicosis, a pauper who was not even in a position to pay the required Court fee, and the owners of Slate Pencil Industry. What a battle between two unequals. This long narration of dates has become necessary, with a view to impress upon our Labour Courts that there is a purpose behind prescribing time limit for deciding such cases, which should be sincerely adhered to. Six months time prescribed for disposal of the case as such, is taken for disposal of an interim which ought to be decided then and there or at the earliest. Framing of an additional issue need not detain any Court, much less, a Labour Court where the poor and the weak throng for justice, who should not be required to wait for months and months together. Our Labour Courts have a great responsibility to share in dispensing justice to the labour class and how shocking it reads that the Labour Court should have no room available for holding its sitting at the District Head Quarters, like Mandsaur, as is evident from order-sheets dated 15.10.1981 and 25.1.1982
5. Coming now to the merits of the case, the employer-respondents have not chosen to enter the witness-box nor examined any witness to rebut the claimant-appellant's evidence, as regards his employment with the respondents, the sickness he suffered during the employment, the monthly salary of Rs. 400/- drawn by him and his dependents his wife, his father, son and daughter aged three and eight years respectively, all these facts_have been duly established. The respondents have examined one Ramesh Mishra, Manager, E.S.I at Ratlam solely with a view to prove that the appellant claim under the Workmen's Compensation Act was not maintainable thus the appellant's evidence on other aspects of the matter has not been rebutted so much so the respondents did not choose to enter the witness-box to state on oath that the claimant-appellant was not at any point of time, in their employment and that he was not drawing a salary of Rs. 400/- P.M No record has been produced. It has been proved beyond doubt by medical evidence that the appellant suffered from Pneumonconiosis, which was attributable to his employment, in Slate Pencil Works ‘Nodular Opacities’ were observed in X-Ray Exhibit P-2 which is an unfailing symptom of Silicosis. Dr. Purnashankar Bhatt, who was a specialist, posted at Government, Medical Hospital Mandsaur was cross examined at length but nothing material turned out Exhibit P-1, is the Certificate given by the Medical Board, consisting of the Eivil Surgeon, Mandsaur, Dr. Narolia, Dr. Solapur-kar and the witness Dr. Bhatt They were members of Silicosis Committee. Thus, the claimant has proved his employment as well as ailment. Except to support the technical objection, respondents have adduced no evidence in rebuttal in spite of more than a dozen of opportunities sought and granted to them for the purpose. The first date for evidence of both the parties was fixed on 11.10.1982 and the respondents had too many opportunities for adducing evidence, which they had so desired till 24.7.1984, but as the order-sheets disclose, they never sincerely meant to produce evidence, except to support their technical objection about the maintainability of the claim petition. They examined Rameshchandra Mishra Manager, E.S.I Corporation at Ratlam, who merely produced Exhibit P-4, and its counter foil Exhibit, D-I which as stated above does not bear any endorsement, seal or signature of any of the officer or authority of the Corporation, non has the witness Rameshchandra referred to any such signature, obtaining on Exhibit P-4 and D-1. It is on the basis of this evidence that the respondents support their objection that in view of Section 53 of the Insurance Act, a claim petition under Workman's Compensation Act is not maintainable,
6. So far as Section 53 of the Act is concerned, suffice it to say that the respondents have failed in placing any such material on record, which may attract Section 53 of the E.S.I Act. The section reads as follows:
“53. Bar against receiving or recovery of compersation or damages under any other law An insured person or his dependents shall not be entitled to receive or recover, whether from the employer of the insured person or from any other person, any compensation pf damages under the Workmen's Compensation Act, 1923 (8 of 1923) or any other law for the time being in force or otherwise, in respect of an employment; injury sustained by the insured person as an employee under this Act.”
7. On plain reading of this section, it is clear that the applicability of this provision depends on the respondents establishing that the claimant/appellant was “an insured person” within the meaning of this Act, ‘Insured person’ has been defined in Clause 14 of Section 2 of the E.S.I Act. The definition of insured person is “insured person” means a person who is or was employee in respect of whom contributions are or were payable under this Act and who is by reason thereof, entitled to any of the benefits provided by this Act”. It was therefore, incumbent on respondents to have proved the contributions made by them, in respect of the claimant appellant or at least stated on path that it was so payable by them. There is total lack of evidence except production of Exhibit D-1, which also does not bear any endorsement, signature, or seal of any of the authorities of the E.S.I Corporation, there is no evidence at all, D-1 is the Counter foil of Exhibit P-4 which purports to bear the appellants signature, what is surprising, is that the signature on this Form, has not been confronted to the claimant/appellant. It is also clear from the date 21.12.1981, but underneath the signature of the employer, on Form Ex. P-4 and as has been admitted by the Insurance Manager the entries therein must have been made after this date i.e 21.12.1981 This piece of evidence, Ex. P-4 concocted by the respondents as a device to defeat the appellants claim for compensation, which had already been filed on 23rd December, 1980 almost a year prior to the employer filing the declaration Form Exhibit P-4 on 21-12-1981. It was produced in the Court after the appellant's evidence was closed. It is unfortunate that the employers should have taken, recourse to such a device for defeating the claim of a poor employee, suffering from Silicosis. Such practice deserves to be deprecated in no uncertain terms. For want of evidence of material available on record, the plea raised by the respondent's counsel as regards maintainability of claim under the Workman's Compensation Act fails, as fail it must.
8. The applicant has proved his case considering the evidence on record adduced by him his age, earning, and the dependants his son and daughter, wife and father, the amount of compensation of Rs. 20,000/- as claimed by the appellant, cannot be said to be unreasonable, it is, therefore, held that the appellant is entitled to this compensation of Rs. 20,000/- with interest @ 12% P.A from the date, of application and the respondents are held jointly and severally liable to pay the compensation to the claimant/appellant as the appellants suffered from Silicosis during the course of his employment with the respondents.
9. For the foregoing reasons, this appeal deserves to be allowed and accordingly allowed, the order passed by the Commissioner is set aside, the respondents shall bear appellant's costs throughout. Counsel's fee Rs. 250.if certified.
10. Schedule III of the Workman's Compensation Act is wide enough to cover the appellant's case. Both the Workman's Compensation Act, 1923 and the E.S.I Act, 1948 are pieces of social welfare legislation. The Labour Courts while interpreting the provisions of these enactments must bear in mind that any doctrinaire approach in interpretation should be avoided lest it defeats the very object and purpose of these Acts. This appeal unfolds a human aspect of the matter, hundreds of workers who are employed in industry or manufacturing units of Slate Pencil Work, under potential risk and hazards to their lives Manufacture of slate pencil needs curring of stones with aid of circular saws, it includes processing, handling, slicing of stones, separating pencils at the grooves cut by saws and other incidental processes such as cutting, counting, packing, pointing and sorting of pencils and all these activities go on in the midst of dust which escapes into the air, which is inhaled by the workers with every breathe resulting in the deadly occupational Silicosis. The employees are required to be medically examined at intervals of six months each and the Civil Surgeon of the district has to certify physical fitness of the employees who are also required to be rediologcally examined before the fitness certificate is issued. In the appellant's case ‘nodulor capacities’ have been found in his Skiagram, as per Exhibit P-3 and as deposed to by Dr. Purshankar Bhutt, the Radiologist found bilateral infiltration of the chest has also been reported by the Radiologist who had examined the appellant, on being referred by Dr. Bhatt.
11. A person driven by poverty takes up a job in the slate pencil industry primarily in order that he may live and keep his, pot boiling so that not only he, but also his dependants live. In face of deadly hazards, involved in the job, yet as a large number of workers accepting these jobs merely points to the acute poverty, which compels them to accept such jobs no volition, no choice but sheer compulsions, of poverty drag them into the jaws of death. The Employers, Industrialists, instead of making a common cause with the employees suffering from Silicosis are too eager to contest the claims for compensation when filed on any ground that suits them, going to the extent of concocting false evidence to defeat their claims on the grounds not tenable in law (as in this case). Instead of providing necessary safe guards, installing efficient exhaust draughts localised ventilation by mechanical means so as to prevent the dust from escaping into the air, they, are too averse to doing anything; which would involve an additional burden on their purse for providing safety measures. This callous attitude of unscrupulous employers is slowly dragging hundreds of employees towards imminent death. Many have succumbed to Silicocis, a deadly occupational diseass, many more are still suffering, Elementary precautions at the work site against inhalation of dust must be taken, so as to prevent the disease as far as possible and similar other respiratory ailments, Silicosis, as it is, has no effective cure, callous disregard to the norms of safety laid down by the Government, it is the duty of officers concerned, to see that the instructions issued by the Government in this behalf are actually implemented and followed, by the owners of the slate pencil industry. Any lethargy or remissness in the matter should be sternly dealt with.
Alert