Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Md. Idris Ansari v. The State Of Bihar & Others

Patna High Court
Apr 7, 1994
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The writ application was filed on 24-8-1993 challenging the initiation of a departmental proceeding against the petitioner after his superannuation on 31st January, 1993. Although ninety percent of the pension was provisionally released to the petitioner, no gratuity payment was made. The departmental proceeding was initiated on 17th July, 1993 and was contested in the writ petition. During the pendency of the writ petition, a show cause notice dated 27-9-1993 was issued to the petitioner under Rule 139 of the Bihar Pension Rules, proposing to withhold seventy percent of his pension. This notice and a subsequent order dated 13-12-1993 withholding seventy percent of the pension were also challenged through amendments to the writ petition. The State did not support the departmental proceeding, acknowledging that disciplinary control was lost post-superannuation, but justified the show cause notice and the pension withholding order under Rule 139.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the departmental proceeding initiated against the petitioner after his superannuation was maintainable.
  2. Whether the order passed under Rule 139(a) and (b) of the Bihar Pension Rules withholding seventy percent of the petitioner’s pension was justified.
  3. Whether the State Government had the jurisdiction to reduce the pension of a retired Government servant without proof of grave misconduct or an unsatisfactory service record.

Arguments of the Parties

State's Arguments

  • The show cause notice and the final order under Rule 139 of the Bihar Pension Rules were justified.
  • The departmental proceeding could not be initiated post-superannuation as the Government lost disciplinary control, which explains why it was not supported.
  • The power under Rule 139 allows the Government to withhold pension if service was not thoroughly satisfactory or if grave misconduct is proved.

Petitioner's Position

  • The departmental proceeding was initiated after superannuation and is therefore not maintainable.
  • There was no proof of grave misconduct or unsatisfactory service record justifying withholding pension.
  • The allegations of misconduct were not established in any departmental proceeding or court of law.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court noted that the departmental proceeding initiated after the petitioner’s retirement was not maintainable as the Government loses disciplinary control post-superannuation. The State conceded that the proceeding under Rule 43(b) of the Bihar Pension Rules could not be initiated because the alleged misconduct occurred more than four years prior to the proceeding. The court examined Rule 139 of the Bihar Pension Rules, which permits reduction of pension if the service was not thoroughly satisfactory or if grave misconduct is proved. However, the State did not establish either an unsatisfactory service record or proof of grave misconduct. The allegations remained unproven in any forum. The court held that the power to reduce pension under Rule 139 cannot be exercised without such proof. Consequently, the order withholding seventy percent of the pension was unjustified and liable to be quashed.

Holding and Implications

The writ application is allowed. The departmental proceeding initiated on 17-7-1993, the show cause notice dated 27-9-1993, and the final order dated 13-12-1993 withholding pension under Rule 139(a) and (b) are quashed. The respondents are directed to grant the petitioner full pension and gratuity in accordance with the rules.

This decision directly restores the petitioner’s pension and gratuity benefits but does not establish any new legal precedent beyond the application of existing pension rules and principles regarding disciplinary control post-retirement.

Show all summary ...

1. Heard counsel for the parties. The instant writ application was filed on 24-8-1993 challenging the initiation of a departmental proceeding against the petitioner after his superannuation. It is not in dispute that the petitioner superannuated from service with effect from 31st January, 1993. After his superannuation ninety percent of the pension amount was provisionally released in his favour, but no payment was made to him by way of gratuity. The departmental proceeding was initiated on 17th July, 1993, and that was challenged in the instant writ application. During the pendency of the writ petition a show cause (Annexure-9) was issued on 27-9-1993 calling upon the petitioner to show cause why action be not taken against him under Rule 139 of the Bihar Pension Rules withholding seventy percent of his pension. The same was challenged by amending the writ application. Thereafter, an order dated 13-12-1993 (Annexure-11) was passed in exercise of power under Rules 139(a) and (b) of the Bihar Pension Rules withholding seventy percent of the pension payable to the petitioner. The aforesaid order (Annexure-11) has also been challenged by an amendment of the writ petition.

2. At the hearing of the writ petition the order initiating the departmental proceeding has not been supported, obviously because alter the petitioner had superannuated from service, the Government lost disciplinary control over the petitioner, and there was no question of proceeding against him in the departmental proceeding. However, counsel for the State submits that the show cause (Annexure-9), and the final order passed on 13-12-93 (Annexure-11) under Rule 139 of the Bihar Pension Rules are fully justified.

3. At this stage we may notice that in the show cause dated 27.9.93 (Annexure-9) it is virtually conceded by the State that the proceeding under Rule 43(b) of the Bihar Pension Rules could not be initiated against the petitioner, since the incident giving rise to the misconduct alleged against the petitioner took place more than four years before the institution of the proceeding. However, the Government exercised its power under Rule 139(a) and (b) of the Bihar Pension Rules. Rule 43(a) of the Rules provides that future good conduct is an implied condition of every grant of a pension, and the Government has the right of withholding or withdrawing a pension or any part of it for reasons mentioned in the Rule. Rule 43(b) of the Rules further provides that a pension or any part of it may be withheld permanently or for a specified period if the pensioner is found in departmental or judicial proceeding to have been guilty of grave misconduct or to have, caused pecuniary loss to the Government by misconduct or negligence during his service, including service rendered on re-employment after retirement. The proviso, however, places restriction on exercise of such power and provides that if a departmental proceeding had not been initiated before the retirement of the Government servant or during reemployment, it shall not be instituted except with the previous sanction of the State Government, and it can be instituted only in respect of an event which took place not more than four years before the institution of such proceeding.

4. In the instant case it appears that in connection with some work executed in the year 1986-1987 the Government had found some deficiencies. An order was passed to recover a sum of Rs. 93,520.70 paise from the petitioner. The same was challenged by the petitioner before this Court in C.W.J.C No. 6696 of 1992, and the writ application was allowed by an order dated 16th November, 1992, holding the order to be bad, as it was in violation of the principles of natural justice. Opportunity, however, was given to the State to initiate a fresh proceeding, if so advised, in accordance with law. It is not disputed that thereafter no further action was taken till the petitioner superannuated from service on 31st January, 1993. A departmental proceeding was ultimately sought to be instituted on 17-7-1993, which has been challenged in the instant writ petition.

5. The only question, which, therefore, survives consideration is whether the order passed under Rule 139(a) and (b) of the Bihar Pension Rules is justified. This takes us to a consideration of Rule 139 of the Bihar Pension Rules. Rule 139 to the extent it is relevant provides as follows:

“139(a) The full pension admissible under the rules is not to be given as a matter of course, or unless the service rendered has been really approved.

(b) If the service has not been thoroughly satisfactory, the authority sanctioning the pension should make such reduction in the amount as it thinks proper.

(c) The State Government reserve to themselves the powers of revising an order relating to pension passed by subordinate authorities under their control, if, they are satisfied that the service of the pensioner was not thoroughly satisfactory or that there was proof of grave misconduct on his part while in service. No such power shall, however, be exercised without giving the pensioner concerned a reasonable opportunity of showing cause against the action proposed to be taken in regard to his pension, or any such power shall be exercised after the expiry of three years from the date of the order sanctioning the pension was first passed.”

6. There is no doubt that Rule 139 provides that if the service of a Government servant, who has superannuated, has not been thoroughly satisfactory, the authority sanctioning the pension should make such reduction in the amount as it thinks proper. However, Rule 139(c) makes it clear that the State Government may revise the order relating to pension passed by subordinate authorities under their control, if, they are satisfied that the service of the pensioner was not thoroughly satisfactory or that there was proof of grave misconduct on his part while in service. In the instant case it is not the case of the State that the service record of the petitioner showed that his service was not satisfactory. In fact, the show cause notice (Annexure-9) issued to the petitioner under Rule 139 of the Bihar Pension Rules refers to specific acts of misconduct alleged against the petitioner in connection with the execution of works in the year 1986-1987. There are more than one reason to hold that in the facts of this case the proceeding under Rule 139 was not maintainable. Firstly, if the Government wished to reduce the pension payable to the petitioner on the ground that he had committed an act of misconduct, the case being squarely covered by Rule 43(b), a proceeding could have been initiated, if the incident giving rise to the proceeding had taken place within four years of the date of the institution of the proceeding. It is conceded in the show cause notice itself (Annexure-9) that the proceeding under Rule 43(b) could not be initiated in the facts of the case. Secondly, Rule 139(b) provides for the order that the sanctioning authority may pass, if the service of a Government servant is not found to have been thoroughly satisfactory. Rule 139(c) empowers the State Government to revise an order passed by subordinate authorities in regard to pension if the State Government is satisfied that the service of the petitioner was not thoroughly satisfactory, or that there was proof of grave misconduct on his part while in service. Even if the power to be exercised under Rule 139(b) is read in the light of the provision of Rule 139(c), the State Government can reduce the pension payable to a retired Government servant if (a) they are satisfied that the service of the petitioner was not thoroughly satisfactory or (b) there was proof of grave misconduct on his part while in service. So far as the first condition is concerned, the same is not fulfilled, because it is not the case of the State that the record of service of the petitioner was unsatisfactory. So far as the second condition is concerned, the same is also not fulfilled, because there is no proof of grave misconduct on the part of the petitioner while in service. Neither in a court of law nor in a departmental proceeding had any charges been proved against the petitioner. The allegations remained mere allegations and they were sought to be made use of for the purpose of exercise of power under Rule 139(a) and (b) of the Rules. In the absence of proof of grave misconduct, as distinguished from mere allegations of misconduct, the power under rule 139(a) and (b) could not be exercised by the State Government. In these circumstances, we have no doubt that even if a wider meaning is given to Rule 139(b) by reading the said rule in the light of Rule 139(e), the power conferred thereby is not wide enough to confer on the Government jurisdiction and authority to reduce the pension of a retired Government servant without proof of grave misconduct in the absence of unsatisfactory service, record. Such grave misconduct may either be proved before a court of law, or even in a departmental proceeding. That not being the case, the impugned order reducing the pension of the petitioner is wholly unjustified.

7. In the circumstances, this writ application is allowed, and the departmental proceeding initiated on 17-7-1993 as well as the show cause notice issued (Annexure-9) dated 27-9-93, and the final order dated 13-12-93 (Annexure-11) under Rule 139(a) and (b) are hereby quashed. The respondents are directed to grant to the petitioner the benefit of full pension and gratuity in accordance with the rules.