Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Madhavdas Bhagwandas Khushiramani v. State of Gujarat

Gujarat High Court
Oct 27, 1999
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner suffered cardiac problems and underwent angiography at the Gujarat Research and Medical Institution (Rajasthan Hospital) on 12 July 1996. On 22 July 1996 the petitioner consulted Dr. Rakesh Gupta (cardiologist at the Rajasthan Hospital), who advised earliest by-pass surgery. On 24 July 1996 a cardiologist at the Institute of Cardiologist and Research Centre, Civil Hospital, Ahmedabad, also advised immediate coronary by-pass surgery for triple vessel coronary artery disease.

On 26 July 1996 the petitioner applied to respondent No.2 for permission to have the by-pass surgery at Apollo Hospital, Chennai. While waiting for sanction, the petitioner suffered acute pain and was operated at Apollo Hospital, Chennai on 5 August 1996. Respondent No.2 informed the petitioner by letter dated 6 August 1996 that his application had been turned down on the ground that he had not obtained a certificate/advise from an authorised Medical Practitioner of Civil Hospital, Ahmedabad.

The petitioner paid Rs.1,19,475/- to Apollo Hospital and submitted the bill for reimbursement on 17 October 1996. Administrative attempts at post-facto sanction and reimbursement were made, including representations by the District Primary Education Officer, approaches to state health authorities, and representations to political offices, but relief was not granted. The petitioner filed the special civil application in this Court on 6 February 1998; it was admitted on 30 April 1998. The present judgment disposes of that special civil application.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the petitioner, who underwent immediate by-pass surgery at Apollo Hospital, Chennai without prior departmental sanction, was entitled to post-facto sanction and reimbursement of medical expenses where the need for surgery was supported by cardiologists' opinions and angiography reports.
  2. Whether the respondents could mechanically refuse post-facto sanction and reimbursement on the ground that the petitioner had not produced a certificate from an authorised medical practitioner of the Civil Hospital, Ahmedabad, despite other medical evidence and the emergency nature of the surgery.
  3. What monetary relief (if any) the petitioner was entitled to under the Government resolution dated 26 March 1999 (providing specified amounts for the operation and angiography) and as a consequence of the Court's earlier orders/interest awards.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • Reliance on two decisions of the Hon'ble Supreme Court (not named in the record) to support his claim; counsel contended the respondents were not disputing that the petitioner underwent the operation at Madras or disputing the hospital bill.
  • Emphasised that for life-threatening procedures like triple vessel by-pass surgery, the patient's confidence and belief in the treating institution and surgeon are paramount and a person will not risk treatment at an institution in which he has no confidence.
  • The petitioner applied for prior permission but, because of the urgency, could not wait indefinitely for departmental sanction or risk death; he proceeded in the expectation that permission would be granted or that post-facto sanction would be available.
  • Submission that post-facto sanction is routinely granted in many cases (particularly for higher officials) and should be granted here because the petitioner’s claim is bona fide and not doubted by respondents.
  • Claimed entitlement under the Government resolution to Rs.70,000 for the operation and Rs.8,000 for angiography (total Rs.78,000), and that these amounts should be paid; also noted that documentary evidence (e.g., angiography report, cardiologists’ advice) supported his case.

Respondents' Arguments

  • Respondents (through their advocate) contended that Rs.40,000 with interest had already been paid to the petitioner pursuant to court orders.
  • Argued that post-facto sanction could not be granted (submission that grant of post-facto sanction was not permissible or appropriate in the case).
  • Maintained at most the petitioner could be entitled to Rs.70,000 and that Rs.54,000 had already been paid to him (respondents did not contest the packet amounts claimed under the resolution but disputed further liability).
  • The respondents' advocate did not address or contest the petitioner's submissions on the reputation/confidence issues concerning Civil Hospital, Ahmedabad.

Table of Precedents Cited

The opinion records that counsel relied on two decisions of the Hon'ble Supreme Court, but the opinion does not identify or cite those decisions by name or provide any citation. Therefore, no specific precedents are available in the provided text for tabulation.

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined the factual record and procedural posture with the following reasoning:

  1. Evidence and admissions: The cardiologist at the Civil Hospital had also accepted that the petitioner had to undergo the by-pass surgery. The petitioner’s averments in paragraph 5 of the special civil application were not controverted in detail by the respondents and were supported by documentary evidence (annexure B (Colly)), so they were to be taken as admitted.
  2. Evidence sufficiency and practical realities: The Court acknowledged there was no specific certificate from the Civil Hospital stating that the petitioner had to go to Apollo Hospital, Madras, but found that both the Rajasthan Hospital (where angiography was done) and the Civil Hospital had diagnosed the need for surgery and angiography corroborated the need. The Court observed that a requirement of an explicit Civil Hospital certificate in every case would be impractical and could unduly impede access to urgent care.
  3. Urgency and risk of delay: Given the acute heart condition and the risk that waiting for prior sanction could have resulted in death, the petitioner’s decision to undergo immediate surgery was understandable and justified. The Court noted that governmental processes often do not act expeditiously and that rigid insistence on prior formalities in emergency situations may cause irreparable harm.
  4. Bona fides and welfare-state obligations: The Court emphasised the principle that the State is a Welfare State and its officers should adopt a justice-oriented approach rather than mechanically rejecting bona fide claims. While recognising there are instances of false medical claims, the Court held that administrative difficulty in policing false claims cannot justify arbitrary rejection of a bona fide claim without reasoned consideration.
  5. Unequal administrative practice: The Court observed (based on material from "different corners") that higher-ranked officers often receive post-facto sanction or facilitation for out-of-state treatment, suggesting inconsistency in application of rules; this inconsistency militated in favour of a sympathetic, reasoned administrative approach in the petitioner’s case.
  6. Entitlement under government resolution: The Court referred to the Government resolution dated 26 March 1999, which provided Rs.70,000 for the operation and Rs.8,000 for angiography (total Rs.78,000). The Court reconciled prior payments: Rs.40,000 had been paid towards medical expenses, and Rs.14,000 had previously been awarded as interest by the Court, yielding a total of Rs.54,000 already paid or awarded. The Court calculated that Rs.38,000 remained payable to reach the resolution entitlement of Rs.78,000.
  7. Directions and remediation: Given the admitted medical necessity, documentary corroboration, urgency, and the respondents' failure to justify denial of post-facto sanction, the Court concluded that the respondents should have considered post-facto sanction and ought not to have rejected the petitioner’s claim mechanically. The Court therefore directed payment of the outstanding amount and required respondent No.2 to reconsider the post-facto sanction application within a specified timeframe and to provide a reasoned order if sanction were refused.

Holding and Implications

PETITION SUCCEEDS; RULE MADE ABSOLUTE

The Court's specific holdings and directives are as follows:

  • The special civil application is allowed in the terms set out in the judgment.
  • The respondents are directed to pay Rs.38,000/- to the petitioner within two weeks from the date of receipt of the writ of the order. This sum represents the balance of the entitlement under the resolution dated 26 March 1999 (total entitlement Rs.78,000 less amounts already paid/awarded).
  • The respondents are directed to pay interest on the amount of Rs.38,000/- at the rate of 12% per annum from the date of the Government resolution dated 26 March 1999.
  • Respondent No.2 is specifically directed to consider the petitioner’s case for grant of post-facto sanction for undergoing the surgery at Apollo Hospital, Madras, in light of the observations in the judgment. This consideration must be completed within one month from receipt of the writ of the order. If the authority concludes that post-facto sanction should not be granted, it must pass a reasoned order and send a copy to the petitioner by registered post A.D.
  • The respondents are directed to pay Rs.2,000/- as costs of the petition to the petitioner.
  • Liberty is granted to the petitioner to revive the special civil application in case of difficulty in implementing the directions.

Implications: The decision provides direct relief to the petitioner in the form of payment of the outstanding medical amount, statutory interest, consideration for post-facto sanction, and costs. The Court emphasised welfare-state principles and bona fides of government servants in emergency medical situations. The opinion does not purport to lay down a new legal precedent beyond these directives and does not identify any binding case law in the written judgment.

Show all summary ...

JUDGMENT

S.K. Keshote, J.

1. What the Welfare State and its officers contend is that the petitioner has to undergo by-pass surgery of severe triple vessel coronary artery at Civil Hospital, Ahmedabad and not at the Hospital of his confidence and belief. It is unfortunate that the respondents have insisted to undergo for this serious operation at the Civil Hospital, Ahmedabad. But they are not appreciating that despite of the fact that the State Government invests huge amount of public money for this Civil Hospital it could not gain that much reputation, faith, belief and confidence of the ailing citizens of the city to prefer this Hospital for this type of serious operation i.e. to undergo by-pass surgery of triple vessel coronary artery. It is not a matter of going to a restaurant to have lunch or dinner or a breakfast or to go to law garden to have a chat or dabeli or hot dog etc.. It is a very serious thing and as it pertains to the life of a human being, the person concerned will not like to take any risk and at all the cost he will like to have this operation to be undertaken by a senior, experienced and reputed Doctor and at the hospital of high reputation and confidence. Though the material is not produced on the record of this special civil application and it is not possible to give any final finding, it comes from the different corners that the higher ups of the society, offices and officers of the Government do not prefer to go for all these major operations at the Civil Hospital. Even for angiography, the higher class of officers and the high dignitaries of the State Government, as what it comes from the different corners, do not prefer to go to Civil Hospital. They prefer either to go to Escort, Delhi or Apollo, Madras or Bombay Hospital, Bombay or even at Ahmedabad to the Gujarat Research and Medical Institute (Rajasthan Hospital). If for angiography this class of persons do not prefer civil hospital how it is desirable and reasonable of the officers of the Gandhinagar to expect that the petitioner had to go for this serious operation at the Civil Hospital, Ahmedabad.

2. The State Government permits its employees/ officers to go for this operation at the institution other than the Civil Hospital, Ahmedabad though on prior sanction of the concerned department. Though material is not there on the record of this special civil application, but it comes from different corners that for higher-ups in the services and the offices where they have undergone operations outside the State of Gujarat, the post-facto sanctions are being given or immediately the sanctions are being made or even advance finances are arranged or bills of hospitals are paid directly. I am constrained to observe that for the employees lower in ladder all rules and regulations are to be strictly complied with and made a rule. In the matter of engaging the services of a professional, whether it is a case of engaging an advocate in the High Court or the District courts or subordinate courts or Doctors for medical treatment or for undergoing operations, the person shall prefer to engage the best professional more so, when it is a case of life of a person concerned, as stated earlier, he will not like to take any risk or chance. It is true that the people are going to civil hospital for these operations but the people of the category who have no means and money are going there. They are the poor persons who have no means to arrange the money to pay fees of the professionals at other institutions. The State Government provides free medical facilities to its employees and officers and in case where they go outside the State for operation on prior approval of the concerned department of the State Government their bills of operations are reimbursed. In a case where employee is serious and desires to go to the hospital outside the State for operation and which he had also made it clear by making an application, if we go by the defence of the respondents, then he has to wait till the sanction has been granted before he proceeds to Chennai (Madras) and the possible result would have been in majority of the cases death of that person. In such matters, it is not unknown that the officers of the State Government do not expeditiously deal with such applications.

3. The petitioner having cardiac problem got his angiography done at the Gujarat Research and Medical Institution ( Rajasthan Hospital) on 12-7-1996. He consulted cardiologist of the Gujarat Research and Medical Institution (Rajasthan Hospital) Dr. Rakesh Gupta on 22-7-1996 who advised him to undergo earliest by-pass surgery. The petitioner has also consulted cardiologist of Institute of Cardiologist and Research Centre, Civil Hospital, Ahmedabad. On 24th July, 1996, he was examined by the cardiologist of the institution aforesaid who also advised him to undergo immediately for coronary by-pass surgery as the petitioner was found to he suffering from triple vessel coronary artery disease.

On 26th July, 1996, the petitioner made an application to the respondent No.2 praying for grant of permission to him to have his by-pass survey at Apollo Hospital, Chennai. The petitioner waited for sanction of respondent No.2 to permit him to undergo his by-pass surgery at Apollo Hospital at Madras. In the mean time he suffered acute heartache. Two options at this stage were open to him either to go for by-pass surgery at the Civil Hospital where he did not want to go for the reason that that much of reputation, confidence and faith has not been acquired by this hospital and/or was to die. Second option normally a man does not prefer and immediately he rushed to Apollo Hospital, Madras where on 5th August, 1996 he was operated for severe triple vessel coronary artery. The respondent No.2 vide his letter dated 6th August, 1996 intimated to the petitioner that his application for permission /sanction to get his operation aforesaid at Apollo Hospital, Madras has been turned down on the ground of not obtaining advise/certificate from authorised Medical Practitioner, Civil Hospital, Ahmedabad.

4. The petitioner paid Rs.1,19,475/- for his this operation and treatment to the Apollo Hospital, Madras. The petitioner submitted this bill to the respondent No.2 on 17th October, 1996 with an application and requested for reimbursement of the same. The District Primary Education Officer, District Panchayat, Junagadh requested to the Director, Health and Treatment, Gujarat State , Gandhinagar and the respondent No.3 to grant post-facto permission to the petitioner for his operation at Apollo Hospital, Madras and to sanction payment of the amount of bills. The petitioner vide letter dated 10th April, 1997, approached to the then Hon'ble Cabinet Minister, Shri Jasabhai Barad, in charge of Food and Civil Supplies who in turn by his letter dated 21st April, 1997 addressed to the Hon'ble the then Chief Minister requested to do the needful in this regard. In the meanwhile, the Section Officer of the Education Department of the Government of Gujarat, Gandhinagar vide his letter dated 10th June, 1997 informed to the petitioner that his representation has been forwarded to the respondent NO.3. The Principal of the school where the petitioner was posted informed to the petitioner on 13th June, 1997 that the Taluka Development Officer vide his letter dated 30th May,1997 informed to the Principal that his request re: treatment outside the State made in letter dated 26th March, 1997 can not be granted. The petitioner made a representation on 15th July, 1997 to the Secretary, Health and Family Planning Department and drew his attention that there is no reply to his request for reimbursement of bills of the Apollo Hospitals. It is followed by the letter on 25th October, 1997 to the said Secretary and reiterated his request to reimburse his claim amount of Rs.1,19,475/=. But when nothing has been done, the petitioner felt himself helpless in the matter and approached to this court by filing this special civil application. The special civil application is presented in the court on 6th February, 1998 and it was admitted on 30th April, 1998.

5. Learned counsel for the petitioner relying on the two decisions of the Hon'ble Supreme Court contended that it is not a case where the respondents are doubting that the petitioner has undergone the operation at Madras. They are also not doubting the bill amount of the Hospital. Carrying this contention further, he submits that in the matter of undergoing by-pass surgery for the disease aforesaid utmost confidence and belief in the professional who has to undertake this operation as well as for after care in the Hospital are very very essential. It is a case of life and death of a person and he will not like to undergo for this serious operation at the Hospital in which he has no confidence, faith and belief in the professional's and institutional efficiency. Shri Dhotre, learned counsel for the petitioner urges that only poor persons who have no means to go to other Hospitals are going to Civil Hospitals. Low paid employees are only insisted to go there otherwise the higher-ups in the services and the offices prefer only to go, earlier to U.S.A. and now in the three or four renowned institutions of this country. In his submission the petitioner applied for grant of permission to him to go outside the State for this operation but because of the seriousness in the matter he could not have indefinitely waited otherwise he would have died. He had gone to Madras with the hope and belief that permission shall be granted. Shri Dhotre refers that post-facto sanction can be granted by the Government and in a case where it believes that the petitioner had to undergo immediately this operation such post-facto sanction shall have to be granted. He next submitted that his request for grant of permission to go outside the State for this operation has been turned down on the ground that he has not produced the certificate of the Doctor of the Civil Hospital, which is wholly unjustified. Referring to pleadings made in para-5 of the special civil application he submitted that the petitioner has approached to the Civil Hospital where on 24th July, 1996 he was examined by the Doctor and he was advised to immediately go for this by-pass surgery. He submits that the respondents have not controverted these facts and the same are to be taken to have been accepted. Even as per their own circular produced on the record of this special civil application, the petitioner was entitled for Rs.70,000/= for this operation and Rs.8000/= for angiography, this amount should have been paid to the petitioner forthwith. Lastly, it is contended that the bonafide of the employees is utmost relevant and important and where it is not doubted then post-facto sanction should have been granted.

6. Shri Patel, as usual, as what the Government advocates are doing i.e. harping on technicalities, and what he did in the present case also. He urges that under the court's order, Rs.40,000/- with interest has already been paid to the petitioner. So far as grant of post facto sanction is concerned, in his submission it cannot be granted. However, he has nothing to say on what the learned counsel for the petitioner contended for the reputation, confidence and belief of the people in the Civil Hospital at Ahmedabad. Lastly, he contended that at the most, the petitioner can be given Rs.70,000/and out of which Rs.54,000/- has already been paid to him.

7. I have given my thoughtful consideration to the submissions made by the learned counsel for the parties.

8. In the facts of this case, I find that the Doctor of the Civil Hospital has also accepted that the petitioner has to undergo this operation. As usual, reply to the special civil application in detail has not been filed. The averments made by the petitioner in para-5 of the special civil application have not been controverted and the same are to be taken as admitted more so when in support of those averments, the petitioner produced the documentary evidence also as annexure `B' (Colly). It is true that there is no certificate from the Civil Hospital that the petitioner has to undergo this by-pass surgery at Apollo Hospital at Madras but that cannot be given in all the cases as it will otherwise add further to the reputation which the Civil Hospital carries. But the substance is that both the Rajasthan Hospital as well as the Civil Hospital found it to be necessary that the petitioner has to undergo this operation. Angiography has also been done, which also confirmed this opinion of Doctors. The petitioner has applied for grant of sanction i.e. he also applied for grant of permission to him to go for this operation at Apollo Hospital at Madras. There is all possibility that in the meanwhile he could have suffered acute heartache and shall have to undergo the operation immediately. In such a case, under the hope that sanction will be granted he has to wait for this sanction and there is all possibility where the Government sits over this matter and in the meanwhile he could have died of this disease. The bonafide of the Government servant has to be considered and keeping in view the overall facts of this case, i.e. the angiography report, the advise of cardiologist Dr. Gupta as well as of the cardiologist at the Civil Hospital, Ahmedabad and when the respondents accepted that the petitioner has undergone this surgery at Apollo Hospital at Madras and naturally it is known to the respondents that what is the package of that Hospital at the relevant time at Madras. It is a case where the respondents should have considered the application of the petitioner for post-facto sanction for this operation at Apollo Hospital at Madras. It is not the rigidity of the rule or regulation or resolution or standing order which is to be the only consideration. The respondent - State of Gujarat is a Welfare State and its officers are the officers of a Welfare State. Their approach should have been to see that where the Government servant puts a bonafide claim for reimbursement of his medical bill it should not be taken lightly and approach in such matters should have been justice oriented. It is true there are complaints after complaints that the employees are putting false bills of medical claims but merely because the officers of the State Government are weak or they are not in a position to stop these false claims of medical bills by the employees it is most unreasonable, unjustified and arbitrary to reject mechanically the bonafide medical claim of the employee. The package of this operation at Apollo Hospital, Madras as well as the fact that the petitioner has undergone this operation is not disputed and coupled with the other facts, in my considered opinion it is the fittest of the fit case where the State of Gujarat should have considered the matter for grant of post-facto sanction or permission to the petitioner to undergo this operation at Apollo Hospital, Madras. Whatever may be worth of the reply filed by the respondents, but nothing has been stated by them therein as to why post-facto sanction or permission to the petitioner to undergo by-pass surgery at Apollo Hospital, Madras can not be granted. This approach of the officers deserves to be deprecated. They should not have acted in a manner more so where it is not unknown in the cases of higher-ups in the services as well as the offices post-facto sanctions are being granted for these operations from time to time. As per the resolution of the Government dated 26th March, 1999 the petitioner is entitled for Rs.70,000/= for this operation. So far as angiography is concerned, he is also entitled for Rs.8000/- as what is provided in this resolution. Thus the petitioner is entitled for Rs.78,000/= out of which amount, Rs.40,000/= has been paid to the petitioner by the respondents. It is true that total amount paid to the petitioner by the respondents is of Rs.54,000/- but Rs.14,000/- has been awarded as interest by this court to the petitioner. Rs.40,000/= has only been paid to the petitioner towards his medical expenses. The respondents are directed to pay Rs.38,000/= to the petitioner within a period of two weeks from the date of receipt of writ of this order. The respondents are further directed to pay interest on this amount of Rs.38,000/- to the petitioner at the rate of 12% p.a. from the date of resolution dated 26th March, 1999. The respondent NO.2 is directed to consider the case of the petitioner for grant of post-facto sanction to him to undergo this surgery at Apollo Hospital, Madras in light of the observations made in this judgment and this exercise has to be undertaken and completed within a period of one month from the date of receipt of writ of this order. In case still the authority feels that it is not a fit case where the post-facto sanction has to be granted to the petitioner to undergo this surgery at Apollo Hospital Madras, a reasoned order be passed and copy of the same may be sent to the petitioner by registered post A.D..

9. As a result of the aforesaid discussion, this petition succeeds and the same is allowed in the aforesaid terms. Rule is made absolute accordingly. The respondents are directed to pay Rs.2000/- as costs of this petition to the petitioner. Liberty is granted to the petitioner for revival of this special civil application in case of difficulty.