Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Shrikishun v. Harihar

Patna High Court
Jan 15, 1948
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

This is the plaintiff's second appeal against the decision in the first appeal, which affirmed the Munsif's judgment dismissing the suit. The suit sought to recover possession of holding no. 231 within the municipality of Muzaffarpur town, part of survey plot 312 of khata 106 of mahal Ganipur. The land was originally recorded as part of the raiyati holding of Umesh Chandra Rai, who gifted it to his daughter's son Rakhal Das, who subsequently sold it to the plaintiff on 24th November 1934.

One Musammat Akli had taken settlement of the plot from Umesh Chandra Rai for building purposes and sold her interest to defendant no. 1 on 19th March 1942. It was found that if Akli was an under-raiyat, she had acquired occupancy status. Akli was impleaded as a defendant but did not contest the suit and has since died without heirs. The plaintiff claimed that Akli, as an under-raiyat, had no power to transfer her interest, making the defendant no. 1's claim invalid and subject to ejection.

The lower courts held that the Transfer of Property Act was applicable rather than the Tenancy Act, a position challenged by the plaintiff in this second appeal. The present appeal examines the applicability of the Tenancy Act versus the Transfer of Property Act, the nature of Akli's interest, and the validity of her transfer to defendant no. 1.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Bihar Tenancy Act or the Transfer of Property Act governs the lease and transfer of the land situated within the municipal area of Muzaffarpur.
  2. Whether the sub-lease for building purposes excludes the applicability of the Tenancy Act.
  3. Whether an under-raiyat having occupancy status can transfer his or her interest under the Tenancy Act.
  4. Whether any custom of transferability by under-raiyats exists and, if so, its legal effect.
  5. Whether the lease to Akli was valid under the Transfer of Property Act, specifically regarding the requirement of registration under section 107.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The Transfer of Property Act does not apply because the Tenancy Act governs the land despite it being within a municipal area, as there was no special notification excluding the area from the Tenancy Act.
  • The sub-lease for building purposes should still be governed by the Tenancy Act, referencing binding precedent that sub-leases inherit the governing Act of the head lease.
  • An under-raiyat with occupancy status cannot transfer interest unless section 26A applies, which does not extend to under-raiyats.
  • Even if the Transfer of Property Act applied, the oral lease to Akli was invalid under section 107 which requires registration for leases over one year, so no valid transferable interest was created.
  • There is a need to remand the case to determine if a local custom permitting transferability by under-raiyats exists, which could affect the outcome.

Respondent's Arguments

  • Conceded that if the Tenancy Act applies, there is no defense except the alleged custom of transferability by under-raiyats.
  • Abandoned the argument that the Transfer of Property Act was applicable.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Musst. Wajihunnissa Begum v. Fakira Mahton Interpretation of notification under section 1(3) of the Bihar Tenancy Act Not directly pressed or discussed in this case; cited to show lack of authoritative decision on the notification issue
Phulchand v. Mrs. Natee Mirza Whether municipal areas are excluded from the Tenancy Act by notification Held that notification constituting municipality excludes all municipal areas from the Tenancy Act (view rejected by this Court)
Kali Sahu v. Girdhari Mistri Interpretation of notification under section 1(3) of the Bihar Tenancy Act Held that notification must specifically exclude municipal areas for Tenancy Act to not apply (view adopted by this Court)
Ram Sagar Singh v. Mahabir Thakur Application of Tenancy Act to municipal areas absent special notification Held Tenancy Act applies to municipal areas unless excluded by notification (view adopted by this Court)
Jado Singh v. Bishunath Lal Kanedia Marwari Sub-lease governed by same Act as head lease irrespective of purpose Binding Division Bench decision; sub-lease for building purposes governed by Tenancy Act if head lease is
Babu Ram Roy v. Mahendra Nath Samanta Definition and applicability of under-raiyat under Tenancy Act Adopted view that under-raiyats are governed by Tenancy Act even if holding is not agricultural
Abdul Karim Patwari v. Abdul Rahaman Definition and applicability of under-raiyat under Tenancy Act Supported the applicability of Tenancy Act to under-raiyats regardless of purpose of holding
Abass Khan v. Sheikh Mohammad Hussain Transferability of occupancy holding under Tenancy Act Held under-raiyats cannot transfer interest unless section 26A applies; court agreed with this reasoning

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court first examined whether the Tenancy Act or the Transfer of Property Act governs the land within a municipal area. It analyzed section 1(3) of the Bihar Tenancy Act, focusing on the phrase “if such area is specified in a notification issued in this behalf by the Local Government.” The court reasoned that this phrase must refer to a notification specifically excluding the municipal area from the Tenancy Act, not merely the notification constituting the municipality itself. This interpretation was supported by prior judicial opinions and authoritative commentaries.

Since no notification excluding the Muzaffarpur municipality from the Tenancy Act was produced, the court held the Tenancy Act applicable despite the municipal location.

The court then considered whether the purpose of the sub-lease (building vs. agricultural) affects the applicability of the Tenancy Act. Relying on binding precedent, it held that if the head lease is governed by the Tenancy Act, sub-leases are also governed by it regardless of purpose.

Next, the court analyzed whether an under-raiyat with occupancy status can transfer their interest. It found that under the definitions and provisions of the Tenancy Act, only a raiyat can have an occupancy holding and transfer rights under section 26A. Since an under-raiyat is not a raiyat, the Act does not permit transfer by an under-raiyat, even with occupancy status.

The court acknowledged the defendant's claim of a local custom permitting transferability by under-raiyats, which the trial court found established but the lower appellate court did not consider. The court ordered a remand to determine the existence and effect of such a custom.

Finally, the court noted the appellant's alternate argument under the Transfer of Property Act concerning lease registration but found it unnecessary to decide on this point due to the holding on the Tenancy Act's applicability.

Holding and Implications

The court remanded the case to the lower appellate court for determination of whether a custom of transferability by under-raiyats exists. The lower appellate court is directed as follows:

  • If the custom is found to be established, the suit should be dismissed.
  • If the custom is not established, the suit should be decreed in favor of the plaintiff.

Costs throughout the proceedings are to abide the final result and be disposed of by the lower appellate court.

No new precedent was set beyond the court's interpretation of the notification requirement under the Bihar Tenancy Act and reaffirmation of existing principles regarding under-raiyats and transferability.

Show all summary ...

Meredith, J.:— This is a plaintiff's second appeal against the decision in the first appeal, affirming the Munsif's judgment dismissing the suit, which was to recover possession of holding no. 231 within the municipal of Muzaffarpur town, which was also a portion of survey plot 312 of khata 106 of mahal Ganipur. It was so recorded in the record-of-rights as part of the raiyati holding of one Umesh Chandra Rai, the survey having taken place before the area was included within the municipality. Umesh Chandra Rai gifted the land to his daughter's son Rakhal Das, and, on the 24th of November, 1934, Rakhal Das sold it to the plaintiff.

One Musammat Akli had taken settlement of the plot in suit from Umesh Chandra Rai, and it has been found that this lease was taken for building purposes. On the 19th of March, 1942, Akli sold her interest to the defendant no. 1. It has been found that, if Akli was an under-raiyat, she had acquired occupancy status. She was impleaded as a defendant, but did not contest the suit, this being done only by the defendant no. 1, and it is stated, and not contradicted, that Akli has since died, leaving no heir.

The plaintiff's case was that Akli, being an under-raiyat, had no power to transfer her interest, and so the defendant no. 1 acquired no interest in the land and was liable to be ejected.

The defence was that as the lease was for building, and not agricultural purposes, it was governed by the Transfer of Property Act, and not the Tenancy Act, and it was also governed by the Transfer of Property Act and not the Tenancy Act, because the land lay within the municipal area. The settlement with Akli was permanent, and she had a transferable interest.

The Court below has adopted the view that the Transfer of Property Act is applicable. It is contended before us that this is wrong, but that, whichever Act applies, the suit should succeed.

With regard to the question whether the Transfer of Property Act applies, as the land lies within the municipal area, we have to construe section 1(3) of the Bihar Tenancy Act. This sub-section was amended in 1934, and, as it now stands, reads as follows:—

“It shall extend to the districts of Patna, Gaya, Shahabad, Muzaffarpur, Saran, Champaran, Darbhanga, Bhagalpur, Monghyr and Purnea, except any area constituted, or deemed to have been instated, a municipality, under the provisions of the Bihar and Orissa Municipal Act, 1922, or part thereof, if such area is specified in a notification issued in this behalf by the Local Government.”

The wording of the original sub-section was somewhat different, but I do not think there is any significant difference as regards the particular point under consideration.

The question is what is meant by

“if such area is specified in a notification issued in this behalf by the Local Government”

Does “in this behalf” refer to the constitution of the municipality, or the exception of any area or part thereof? Upon this question there seems to be no authoritative decision in this Court. In Musst. Wajihunnissa Begum v. Fakira Mahton, which has been cited before us, the point does not seem to have been raised, or, at least, pressed. In Phulchand v. Mrs. Natee Mirza, Manohar Lall, J., adopted the view that the reference was to the notification constituting the municipal area, and so all municipal areas would be excluded from the Tenancy Act. In Kali Sahu v. Girdhari Mistri, however, Das, J. took just the opposite view, holding that the notification referred, to in section 1(3) is a notification specifically excluding a particular municipal area, and that, therefore, the Tenancy Act applies to municipal areas in the absence of a notification excluding the particular area. In neither of these cases is there any discussion of the alternative interpretations. In Ram Sagar Singh v. Mahabir Thakur, decided on the 25th of November, 1946, Ray, J., also held that the Tenancy Act applies to municipal areas unless there is a special notification excluding the area.

All three decisions are by learned Judges sitting singly. I find myself in agreement with Das, J., and Ray, J. Every area constituting a municipality must be so constituted by notification. There must be such a notification in the case of every municipal area. If the words

“if such area is specified in a notification issued in this behalf by the Local Government”

refer to the notification constituting the municipality, they would be entirely redundant. They must, I think, refer to some other notification, and, in the circumstances, can refer only to a notification creating the exception. I find that this view also has been adopted by the commentators in B.K Sen's edition of the Bihar Tenancy Act and H.C Sen's edition of the Bengal Tenancy Act.

It is not contended in the present case that there was any notification specially excluding the area from the operation of the Tenancy Act, and I would, therefore, hold that the Tenancy Act is applicable, despite the area being situated within the Muzaffarpur municipality.

The next question is whether the fact that the sub-lease was for building purposes and not for agricultural purposes, makes the Tenancy Act inapplicable. In this connection reliance has been placed upon Jado Singh v. Bishunath Lal Kanedia Marwari. This is a decision of a Division Bench and so binding upon us. What was held was that, if the head lease is governed by the Tenancy Act, so must the sub-lease, irrespective of its purpose. The original raiyat here, Umesh Chandra Rai, had an agricultural holding and was recorded as a raiyat in the record-of-rights. His lease was certainly governed by the Tenancy Act. Upon this decision, therefore, the sub-lease, even for building purposes, to the under-raiyat, will also be governed by the Tenancy Act.

The matter may be looked at from another aspect. In section 5 of the Tenancy Act “raiyat” is defined as primarily a person who has acquired a right to hold land for the purpose of cultivating it by himself or by members of his family or by hired servants, or with the and of partners; that is to say, a raiyat must be a person who holds his land for agricultural purposes. “Under-raiyat” is defined in section 4(3) as a tenant holding, whether immediately or mediately, under a raiyat. There is nothing to show he must be a person also holding for agricultural purposes. By definition, every one holding under a raiyat, for whatever purpose, will be an under-raiyat, and so governed by the Act. This was the basis of two Calcutta decisions—Babu Ram Roy v. Mahendra Nath Samanta and Abdul Karim Patwari v. Abdul Rahaman—where the same view was adopted as in Jado Singh v. Bishunath Lal Kanedia Marwari.

It follows that the applicability of the Bihar Tenancy Act is not excluded upon either of the grounds put forward, and the Court below is wrong in holding to the contrary.

Once it is held that the Tenancy Act is applicable, the next question which arises is whether Akli, the under-raiyat having an occupancy right, could transfer it to the defendant no. 1. Upon this point there is a decision of Rowland, J.—Abass Khan v. Sheikh Mohammad Hussain, and though that learned Judge was sitting singly, I find myself in complete agreement with his reasoning. There is no provision in the Tenancy Act under which an under-raiyat can transfer his interest unless section 26A is applicable. Section 26A makes an occupancy holding transferable. Does it apply to an under-raiyat?— only if an under-raiyat, having an occupancy status, has an occupancy holding within the meaning of the Act. “Holding” is defined in section 3(9) parcel or parcels of land held by a raiyat and forming the subject of a separate tenancy. Under this definition only a raiyat can have an occupancy holding, and “raiyat” does not, and cannot, include “under-raiyat”, as is clear from section 5(3), which says: “A person shall not be deemed to be a raiyat unless he holds land either immediately under a proprietor or immediately under a tenure-holder”.

It must be held that the Act does not give an under-raiyat the right to transfer his interest even if he has an occupancy status. It was, however, contended by the defendant that, if Akli should be regarded as an under-raiyat, there was a custom of transferability by under-raiyats in the locality, and he offered evidence of such custom. The trial Court held the custom established upon the evidence. The lower appellate Court did not go into this question on the ground that the Tenancy Act was not applicable. The appellant, therefore, asks us to remand this case for a finding upon this point, if it be held, as we have held, that the case is governed by the Tenancy Act.

It was alternatively argued for the appellant that if the Transfer of Property Act is applicable the plaintiff has also a good case, because it is under section 107 of that Act the lease in question could only have been made by a registered instrument. But Akli's lease was oral. She, therefore, acquired no permanent leasehold interest which she could transfer to the defendant no. 1. It is unnecessary to deal with this argument or express any opinion as we have adopted the view that the Tenancy Act applies.

For the respondent it is conceded that, if the Tenancy Act is applicable, he has no defence except that based upon the alleged custom of transferability and a, remand is necessary. After hearing the argument for the appellant he abandoned the case that the Transfer of Property Act was applicable.

In the result, I would remand this case to the lower appellate Court for a decision upon the point as to whether any custom of transferability by under raiyats had been established. If he holds that the custom has been established, then the suit should be dismissed. But if he finds there is no such custom, he should decree the suit. Costs all through should abide the final result and be disposed of by him.

Agarwala, C.J:— I agree.

K.D
Case remanded.