- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Harnarain Judgment-Debtor v. Dayabhai Hira Chand Decree-Holder .
Structured Summary of the Opinion (Chatterji, J.)
Factual and Procedural Background
The decree under execution was originally obtained on 7 November 1924 by the respondent against the firm Chunilal Madan Lal in Original Suit No. 4849 of 1922 of the Bombay High Court. On 24 September 1925 the decree-holder applied for execution in the Bombay High Court praying for the arrest of Madan Lal Srinivas, a partner in that firm; the Court made an order for arrest on 14 October 1925, but that execution proceeding proved infructuous. In 1936 the decree-holder transferred the decree to the Subordinate Judge of Motihari and filed an execution application on 23 April 1936 against Har Narayan Chuni Lal, alleged to be one of the partners; that Execution Case No. 120 of 1936 was dismissed for default on 9 February 1937. A fresh application for execution against the same judgment-debtor, Har Narayan Chuni Lal, was filed on 19 February 1937 in the same court. Har Narayan Chuni Lal opposed the application primarily on the ground that it was barred by limitation. The Subordinate Judge overruled the limitation objection and ordered the execution to proceed. The judgment-debtor appealed; this opinion concerns that appeal.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the present execution application filed on 19 February 1937 is barred by limitation under Article 183 of the Limitation Act, having regard to earlier execution proceedings and orders.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments
- The appellant (judgment-debtor), Har Narayan Chuni Lal, contended that the present execution application is time-barred under Article 183 because the decree was passed on 7 November 1924 and the present execution was filed on 19 February 1937 (beyond twelve years).
- He argued that earlier execution proceedings (notably the 1925 execution against Madan Lal) cannot operate as a "revivor" as against him because he was not a party to those proceedings; specifically, execution against one partner should not revive the decree as to other joint debtors under Article 183 (and by analogy with Article 133/182 distinctions noted in authorities).
- He pointed to the necessity of leave under O.21, R.50(2) in 1936 to execute the decree against him as evidence that he had not been bound by the 1925 proceedings.
The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the respondent's legal arguments beyond the fact of obtaining execution and taking steps in earlier years; no extended respondent submissions are recorded in the text.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| 43 Cal 903 (Full Bench) | Defines "revivor" as a decision holding that the decree is still capable of execution; requires express or implied determination that decree is capable of execution (given after notice to the judgment-debtor). | The court relied on this authority to explain the proper meaning of "revivor" and to emphasize that a revivor involves a decision after notice that the decree remains enforceable. |
| 54 Cal 500 (Privy Council) | Approval of the Full Bench decision in 43 Cal 903. | The court noted that 43 Cal 903 was approved by the Privy Council in 54 Cal 500, supporting the cited principle on revivor. |
| 41 CLJ 159 | Supports the view that mere procedural steps (e.g., issuing a notice under O.21, R.22 which is not followed by an order for execution) do not constitute a revivor. | The court invoked this authority to hold that the 1936 execution (where notice was issued but the case was dismissed for default) did not amount to a revivor. |
| 40 Mad 1127 | Holds that an order of revivor made on execution against only one of joint debtors does not keep the decree alive as against the other joint debtors. | The court followed this principle to conclude that an order of execution against one partner (Madan Lal) in 1925 would not operate as a revivor as against the appellant who was not party to that proceeding. |
| 38 Mad 1102 (Bakewell, J.) | Explains the distinction between Articles 182 and 183 of the Limitation Act regarding effect of applications against joint judgment-debtors; supports the view that Article 183 contains no provision making an application against one bind others. | The court relied on Bakewell J.'s reasoning to emphasize that Article 183 does not import the exception present in Article 182 and therefore execution against one joint debtor does not revive the decree as against others. |
| 36 Cal 543 | Describes the historical writ of scire facias as a judicial writ issued for substantiating and carrying into effect an antecedent judgment; used to explain origin of revivor practice. | The court used this decision to explain the origin of the concept of "revivor" and how historical procedure required steps (like scire facias) to revive dormant judgments. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court began by identifying Article 183 of the Limitation Act as the governing provision because the decree was obtained on the original side of the Bombay High Court. Article 183 prescribes a twelve-year period to enforce such decrees, subject to computation from any date of revivor, payment or written acknowledgment.
The decree dated 7 November 1924 and the execution application dated 19 February 1937 were more than twelve years apart. The central question therefore was whether earlier proceedings or orders operated as a "revivor" within the meaning of Article 183 and thereby restarted the limitation period.
The court examined three sets of earlier procedural acts:
- The 1936 execution in the Motihari Court: the record showed a notice under O.21, R.22 was issued but could not be served and the decree-holder did not pursue further steps, leading to dismissal for default. The court held that issuance of such a notice, without an order for execution or any determination that the decree was capable of execution, did not amount to a revivor (relying on 41 CLJ 159).
- The leave obtained before transferring the decree for execution under O.21, R.50(2) from the Prothonotary and Senior Master of the Bombay High Court in respect of Har Narayan Chuni Lal: the court held that the leave operated to make Har Narayan liable under the decree (i.e., he is to be deemed a judgment-debtor) but obtaining leave under O.21, R.50 is not itself an application for execution, nor does such leave amount to an order for execution; therefore it is not a revivor.
- The 1925 execution proceeding against Madan Lal Srinivas: an order for arrest of Madan Lal was made on 14 October 1925. The court considered whether that order amounted to a revivor. It recognized two possible positions: (a) the order for arrest could be regarded as a determination that the decree was capable of execution and thus prima facie operate as a revivor; (b) because the order was made against Madan Lal alone and the present appellant was not a party to that execution, the order could not operate as a revivor as against the appellant.
To resolve these points, the court analyzed the meaning and origin of "revivor." It traced the concept to the old requirement of issuing scire facias for judgments more than a year old and then to statutory embodiments and procedural rules (sections and then O.21 Rrs.22–23 / R.50 etc.). The court emphasized that revivor signifies a decision after notice that a decree is still capable of execution and that the decision must be given after notice to the judgment-debtor.
Applying authorities (notably 43 Cal 903 and its approval in 54 Cal 500), the court held that mere issuance of a notice or discretionary procedural acts do not amount to a revivor unless followed by a determination that the decree is enforceable. The 1936 proceedings did not show any such determination and therefore did not revive the decree.
Regarding the 1925 arrest order, the court observed that no mandatory notice under the then-applicable rules was shown to have been issued before the arrest order, and at that time the rule allowing notice before arrest was discretionary as applied by the Bombay High Court. Given these uncertainties, the court acknowledged difficulty in treating the 1925 order as a revivor for persons not party to that proceeding. The court accepted the principle from 38 Mad 1102 and 40 Mad 1127 that an order of revivor obtained on execution against one joint debtor will not, under Article 183, necessarily revive the decree as against other joint debtors who were not parties to that revivor application.
The judge therefore proceeded on the conservative assumption (solely for the purpose of decision) that the 1925 order would operate as a revivor as to Madan Lal himself but concluded that it could not be treated as a revivor vis-à-vis the present appellant who was not a party. On that basis the present execution (filed in 1937) was not within twelve years of any revivor as against Har Narayan Chuni Lal and was consequently barred by limitation.
Holding and Implications
HOLDING: The appeal is allowed and the execution case is dismissed as barred by limitation.
Implications:
- The present execution application against Har Narayan Chuni Lal, filed on 19 February 1937, is time-barred under Article 183 because no revivor sufficient to restart the twelve-year period was shown as against him.
- The court treated the earlier 1925 order for arrest as, at best, a revivor in respect of Madan Lal himself (assumed for argument), but expressly concluded that that order did not operate as a revivor as against the appellant who was not party to the 1925 proceeding.
- Because there was no appearance on behalf of the respondent, the court made no order as to costs.
- No broader precedent beyond applying the cited authorities to the facts of this execution proceeding is announced; the decision rests on existing interpretations of "revivor" and the application of Article 183 to joint debtors and proceedings in execution.
Disposition
The appeal was allowed. The two-judge bench (Chatterji, J. delivering the judgment; Dhavle, J. concurring) ordered dismissal of the execution as barred by limitation and made no order as to costs owing to absence of respondent's appearance.
Chatterji, J.:— This appeal arises out of a proceeding in execution of a money decree. The decree was obtained on 7th November 1924, by the respondent against the firm of Chunilal Madan Lal in Original Suit No. 4849 of 1922 of the Bombay High Court. On 24th September 1925, the decree, holder applied for execution in the Bombay High Court praying for arrest of Madan Lal Srinivas, one of the partners in the firm of Chunilal Madan Lal. On that petition an order was passed by the Court on 14th October 1925, for the arrest of Madan Lal Srinivas. The execution case, however, proved infructuous. In 1936, the decree-holder got the decree transferred to the Court of the Subordinate Judge of Motihari and filed an application in that Court on 23rd April 1936, for execution of the decree against Har Narayan Chuni Lal, alleged to be one of the partners of the firm Chunilal Madan Lal. The Execution Case No. 120 of 1936, which was started on that application, was dismissed for default on 9-2-1937.
2. The present application for execution was filed on 19th February 1937, in the same Court against the same judgment-debtor, namely Har Narayan Chuni Lal. The latter opposed the application mainly on the ground that it was barred by limitation. This objection has been overruled and the execution case has been ordered to proceed. Hence this appeal by the judgment-debtor. Har Narayan Chuni Lal. The only question raised in this appeal is that of limitation. The decree under execution being passed by the Bombay High Court on its original side, the case will be governed by Article 183, Limitation Act. That Article runs as follows:
Description of application. Period of limitation. Time from which period begins to run. To enforce a judgment, decree or order of any Court established by Royal Charter in the exercise of its ordinary original civil jurisdiction, or an order of His Majesty in Council. Twelve years. When a present right to enforce the judgment, decree or order accrues to some person capable of releasing the right; Provided that when the judgment, decree, or order has been revived, some part of the principal money secured thereby or some interest on such money has been paid or some acknowledgment of the right thereto has been given in writing signed by the person liable to pay such principal or interest or his agent, to the person entitled thereto or his agent, the twelve years shall be computed from the date of such revivor, payment or acknowledgment as the case may be.
3. The decree was passed on 7th November 1924, and the present execution was filed on 19th February 1937, that is to say, beyond 12 years. The learned Subordinate Judge has held that the orders passed in the previous execution proceedings in 1925, and 1936, operate as “revivor” within the meaning of Article 183. The term “revivor” has not been anywhere defined or explain, ed in the Limitation Act, but judicial decisions have laid down that to constitute a revivor of the decree there must be expressly or by implication a determination that the decree is still capable of execution and the decree-holder is entitled to enforce it. In other words, there must be an order for execution which amounts to a decision that the decree is capable of execution. It will be enough to refer here to the Full Bench decision of the Calcutta High Court in 43 Cal 9031 which was approved by the Privy Council in 54 Cal 500.2 So far as the Execution Case No. 123 of 1936 is concerned, it appears from the order sheet of that case, of which the record was called for by us, that notice under O. 21, R. 22 of the CPC, was issued, but it could not be served and as the decree-holder did not take any farther steps the case was dismissed for default. Thus, there was no order for execution passed in that case. The issue of a notice under O. 21, R. 22 must be distinguished from an order for issue of execution. It cannot be said that in that case there was any decision, express or implied, that the decree was capable of execution. The proceedings in that execution case therefore do not constitute a “revivor” within the meaning of Article 183, Limitation Act. This view is supported by the decision of the Calcutta High Court in 41 CLJ 159.3
4. It appears that before the decree was transferred for execution to the Motihari Court leave was obtained under O. 21, R. 50(2) of the CPC, from the Prothonotary and Senior Master of the Bombay High Court to execute the decree against the appellant Har Narayan Chuni Lal as a partner in the judgment-debtor firm. The effect of the leave so granted is that Har Narayan Chuni Lal is liable under the decree. In other words, he must be deemed to be a judgment-debtor. The proceeding for obtaining leave under O. 21, R. 50 is not an application for execution, nor does the leave granted amount to any order for execution. The execution case of 1925 however stands on a different footing. In that case an order was passed on 14th October 1925, for arrest of Madan Lal, one of the partners of the judgment-debtor firm. This order amounted to a determination that the decree was capable of execution. Prima facie this order would operate as a “revivor.”
5. But it is contended by Mr. B.N Mitter for the appellant that the execution of 1925 being taken out against Madan Lal and the order for execution being passed against him, it may operate as a “revivor” as against him but not against the present appellant Har Narayan Chuni Lal who was not a party to that proceeding. The fact that in 1936 leave had to be obtained under O. 21, R. 50(2) to execute the decree against Har Narayan Chuni Lal makes it obvious that he was not a party to the execution proceeding of 1925. The question then arises whether as against him the order dated 14th October 1925, passed in the execution proceeding of 1925, operates as “revivor.” The execution was taken out against Madan Lal and the order was passed for his arrest. The present appellant was not a party to the proceeding. He can not be bound by any order for execution passed in that proceeding. The order dated 14th October 1925 therefore cannot be said to operate as a “revivor” so far as he is concerned. But it may be said that the decree being against the firm, the order dated 14th October 1925, which was passed against one of the partners will operate as against the other partners as well, ??? they were named in the proceeding or not. Mr. B.N Mitter's answer to this argument is that the position of the different partners being that of joint judgment-debtors, execution against one of them will not operate as a “revivor” within the meaning of Article 133, Limitation Act. He relies on the decision in 40 Mad 11274 in which it was held that an order of revivor of a decree against two persons jointly, when made on an application for execution against only one of them, does not keep the decree alive as against the other. That is a decision upholding in appeal the judgment of Bakewell, J. in 38 Mad 1102.5 In the latter case Bake well J., pointing out the distinction between Articles 182 and 183, Limitation Act, observed as follows:
The fact that the Legislature has expressly provided for one case of joint debtors and omitted to make the same provision for another case appears to me to show an intention to place the two cases on a different footing.
6. In Article 182 there is a distinct provision that where the decree or order has been passed, jointly against more persons than one, the application, if made against any one or more of them, or against his or their representatives, shall take effect against them all.
7. But Article 183 makes no such provision. As a general rule nobody can be prejudicially affected by any judicial order to which he is not a party. The above stated provision in Article 182 is an exception to this general rule. A similar exception cannot be imported into Article 183 when it is silent about it. I agree with the view taken in 38 Mad 1102 and 40 Mad 1127 and I think the principle will equally apply where the decree is against a firm. It therefore follows that the order passed in the execution proceeding of 1925 does not operate as a “revivor” as against the present appellant. It must be observed that the execution of 1925 was taken out within one year after the passing of the decree. A notice under O. 21, R. 22 was therefore not necessary nor does it appear to have been issued. Now from the judicial decisions bearing on the interpretation of the term “revivor” it appears that it had its origin in the old practice prevailing in the Supreme Court according to which execution could not issue upon judgments more than a year old without issuing a writ of scire facias against the defendant. The idea seemed to have been that a judgment not enforced within one year became dormant and a proceeding was necessary to revive it. The procedure for revivor of judgment was to issue the writ of scire facias which as explained in 36 Cal 5436 “was a judicial writ issued for the purpose of substantiating and carrying into effect an antecedent judgment.” An analogous procedure for revivor of judgment was introduced into the original side of Chartered High Courts in India.
8. This procedure was subsequently embodied in Ss. 215 and 216 of Act 8 of 1859 which were replaced by Sections 248 and 249 of the CPC, 1882 (now O. 21, Rr. 22 and 23 of the Code of 1908). Under these provisions, whore an application for execution of a decree more than one year old is made, a notice is required to issue to the person against whom execution is applied for calling upon him to show cause why the decree should not be executed against him. If he does not appear or does not show cause to the satisfaction of the Court, the Court orders the decree to be executed. The order for execution thus made operates as a ‘revivor.” Primarily, therefore, the term “revivor” applies to a case where the order of revivor was made in a proceeding for execution of a decree more than a year old. But, upon an examination of the reported decisions, it seams to me that the procedure for “revivor” would include all cases where notice is required to be issued against the judgment-debtor before any order for execution can be made. “Revivor,” to quote the words of Woodroffe J., from the above cited case in 43 Cal 903, means “a decision holding that the decree is still capable of execution.” This implies that the decision must be given after notice to the judgment-debtor. Where therefore there is no provision for the issue of any notice before an order for execution can be made, there can hardly be a “revivor.” No such notice was necessary in the execution proceeding of 1925. No doubt O. 21, R. 37 of the CPC, as amended by the rules of this Court, provides for the issue of notice before issuing a warrant of arrest, but under the rule, as it stood in 1925 — and this was the rule under which the Bombay High Court passed the order for arrest dated 14th October 1925 — the issue of notice was discretionary. There is also nothing to show that such notice was issued in the proceeding of 1925. In the circumstances, I do not think the order for arrest passed in that proceeding can be regarded as a “revivor.” However, this is a point which is not free from difficulty and in the view which I take of the case it is unnecessary to pronounce any definite opinion on it. I have proceeded on the assumption that the order dated 14th October 1925 would operate as a “revivor” so far as Madan Lal is concerned. In my view the present execution is barred by limitation. I would accordingly allow the appeal and dismiss the execution’ case as barred by limitation. As there is no appearance on behalf of the respondent, I would make no order as to costs.
Dhavle, J.:— I agree.
D.S/R.K
9. Appeal allowed.
Alert