- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Upendra Nath Ghose v. Emperor
Summary of the Opinion (Sen, J.)
Factual and Procedural Background
Two persons, Upendra Nath Ghose (the appellant) and Sudhir Pramanik, were tried before the Sessions Judge of Khulna with a special jury on charges of murdering one Abala and of abducting her "in order that she may be murdered or put in danger of being murdered" (S. 364, IPC). The jury returned a unanimous verdict of not guilty on the murder charge for both accused. On the abduction charge the jury by a majority of 6 to 3 found Sudhir not guilty, and by a majority of 8 to 1 found Upendra guilty.
The learned trial Judge accepted the jury's verdicts, acquitted Sudhir of both charges, convicted Upendra of abduction under S. 364, IPC, and sentenced him to rigorous imprisonment for eight years. Upendra appealed from jail.
The prosecution's case, in summary, was that Sumati (mother of Abala) had refused an invitation to attend festivities at Upendra's house and agreed instead that Upendra would take her daughter Abala (then aged about 11–12) to those festivities on 10 June 1939. Abala left with Upendra on that date (wearing distinctive clothing and jewellery). She did not return the next day, and was later connected with the discovery of a female skeleton and associated clothing and articles identified by Sumati's family as Abala's. Five gold madulis that Abala had been wearing were found to have been sold by Upendra and Sudhir to a goldsmith and were identified as Abala's. On these facts the two accused were committed for trial on charges of murder and abduction with intent that the abducted person should be murdered or put in danger of being murdered.
The defence, as recorded, consisted of denials and of two alternative explanations for Abala's disappearance: that she had gone with one Charubala to Charubala's father-in-law's house and disappeared from there; and that Sumati was involved in an intrigue with Nitai, who, together with Sumati, had implicated Upendra.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether, for an offence under S. 364, IPC, the jury must be satisfied beyond reasonable doubt that the accused intended at the time of the abduction that the person abducted would be murdered or be put in danger of being murdered.
- Whether in the particular facts of this case it was permissible for the trial Judge to tell the jury that it was not essential to prove beyond doubt that the dead body was that of Abala in order to sustain a conviction under S. 364.
- Whether the framing and submission of a charge under S. 364 in the circumstances of this prosecution (where the prosecution's case was, in substance, that the abducted person had been murdered by the abductor) was proper or was a misuse of the provision.
Arguments of the Parties
Prosecution's Case (as presented at trial)
- Upendra invited Sumati to festivities; when she declined, he proposed that Abala go with him; Abala left with Upendra on 10 June 1939.
- Abala was seen that day with Upendra (and with Sudhir on at least one occasion) and did not return home the next day.
- A female skeleton and associated clothing and articles (sari, petticoat, bunch of keys, jewellery) were found and identified by Sumati's family as Abala's; the gold madulis Abala had been wearing were missing.
- Evidence that Upendra and Sudhir sold five gold madulis to a goldsmith, and that these were identified as belonging to Abala.
- Statements and inferences from witnesses, including Debendra, that connected Upendra and Sudhir to Abala's disappearance and the missing jewellery.
- On this basis, prosecution charged both accused with murder and with abduction under S. 364 (abduction with intent that the person abducted be murdered or put in danger of being murdered).
Defence's Case
- Complete denial of the prosecution's allegations.
- Suggestion that Abala had accompanied Charubala to Charubala's father-in-law's house and disappeared from there (alternative explanation for disappearance).
- Suggestion that Sumati and Nitai were engaged in an intrigue and that Upendra had been wrongly implicated by them.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court's legal analysis focuses on the essential elements of the offence under S. 364, IPC, and on material misdirections given by the learned trial Judge to the jury.
1. Essential element of S. 364 — intention at the time of abduction: The Court emphasised that to establish an offence under S. 364 it must be proved that the accused, at the time of the abduction, had the intention that the abducted person would be murdered or put in danger of being murdered. In this case the prosecution was required to prove that Upendra had that particular state of mind when he took Abala from her mother's house.
2. Failure to place the mens rea before the jury: The trial Judge failed to instruct the jury that they must be satisfied beyond reasonable doubt that Upendra had the requisite intention at the time of the abduction. The Judge did not tell the jury that conviction under S. 364 required evidence that established the accused's state of mind at the time of taking the child.
3. Absence of motive and inherent improbability: The Court noted that no motive had been proved that would lead Upendra to desire Abala's death at the time of taking her away. The facts adduced (including that the mother had refused and only then Upendra proposed taking the girl) tended to negative an intention to murder at that time. The Court found it inherently improbable that Upendra would abduct Abala from her mother's house for the specific purpose of killing her to obtain five gold madulis—particularly when he had other opportunities to obtain the jewellery without resort to abduction and murder. The trial Judge failed to emphasise this absence of motive and inherent improbability to the jury.
4. Misleading directions about proof of identity and proof of murder: The Judge instructed the jury that proof that the dead body was beyond doubt Abala was not essential for the S. 364 charge, and stated that actual proof of murder was not necessary for a conviction under S. 364 — it would suffice if the prosecution showed that the accused placed Abala in circumstances that put her in danger of being murdered. The Court held that, in the particular circumstances of this case, such directions were wrong and misleading. Given the prosecution's case that the abducted person had been murdered by the abductor, the Court explained that unless it is proved that Abala had been murdered (and identified as such), there was nothing to connect the abduction to an intent to murder. The trial Judge's statements overlooked the crucial requirement that the accused's intention at the time of abduction be established.
5. Relation between murder charge and S. 364: The Court explained that, while theoretically a conviction under S. 364 need not be premised on a proved murder, in this case the facts meant that a S. 364 charge was misconceived if the prosecution's real case was that the abductor had murdered the abducted person. If the Crown's case was that the accused had murdered Abala, the proper charge should have been murder; framing a S. 364 charge as an alternative in these circumstances was an improper device likely to mislead the jury.
6. Consequence of misdirections: The Court concluded that the misdirections and failures in the trial Judge's charge were material and had resulted in a wrong verdict being returned against Upendra on the S. 364 charge. Having found that there was really no evidence to sustain that charge against the appellant, the Court set aside the conviction and sentence and acquitted him.
Holding and Implications
CORE RULING: The conviction and sentence of Upendra Nath Ghose under S. 364, IPC, are set aside and he is acquitted; he is to be released forthwith.
Direct effect on the parties:
- Upendra's conviction under S. 364 and the sentence of eight years' rigorous imprisonment were quashed; the appellant was acquitted and ordered to be released immediately.
- Sudhir had already been acquitted by the jury and the trial Judge's acceptance of that verdict was recorded in the trial proceedings (no change to Sudhir's status arises from this appellate order).
Broader implications (as stated by the Court):
- The Court warned against the misuse of S. 364, IPC, where the prosecution's real case is that the abductor has murdered the abducted person. In such situations the proper course is to charge murder rather than prefer an alternate S. 364 charge as a fallback when the evidence of murder is weak.
- The Court expressed its determination, so far as lies within its power, to check this prosecutorial practice and held that trial judges should refuse to frame a S. 364 charge where there is no proper evidentiary basis for it in the particular circumstances of the case.
Short formal disposition in the opinion: "Conviction set aside."
Sen, J.:— Two persons Upendra Nath Ghose and Sudhir Pramanik were tried by the Sessions Judge of Khulna and a special jury charged with the offence of murdering one Abala and also with the offence of abducting her in order that she may be murdered or put in danger of being murdered. The Jury by a unanimous verdict have found both these persons not guilty of the offence of murder. By a majority of 6 to 3 they found Sudhir not guilty of the charge of abduction and by a majority of 8 to 1 they found Upendra guilty of the charge of abduction. The learned Judge accepting the verdict of the Jury has acquitted Sudhir of both the charges and has convicted Upendra of the charge of abduction under S. 364 of the IPC. He has sentenced Upendra to undergo rigorous imprisonment for a term of eight years. The case for the prosecution briefly is as follows: One Sumati is the wife of Baroda Ghose, a person of unsound mind. She had a daughter named Abala who was aged between 11-12 years. The appellant, Upendra is aged about 25 years and he is a maternal cousin of Sumati. It is alleged that Upendra came to the house of Sumati on Friday, 9th June 1939 and invited her to attend a function at his house on the next day. He told her that there would be certain festivities in connection with the puja of Satyanarayan. Sumati told Upendra that she would not be able to go on the next day as she had arranged to go to some other place. Thereupon, Upendra proposed that he would take Abala. Sumati agreed to this.
2. On Saturday, 10th June 1939 Upendra came to the house of Sumati and Abala went away with him. She was dressed in a Sari with a particular kind of border and underneath she were a rose-coloured petticoat. She also were a green blouse. At one end of the Sari there was a bunch of keys tied up. She had certain articles of jewellery on her person amongst which may be mentioned some gold madulis. Her bail was tied in a khopa and she had steel hair pins in it. After the girl left with Upendra on 10th June, they were seen on that day at two places by some of the witnesses. With Upendra and the girl Abala was Sudhir. The understanding with Sumati was that the girl would be returned next morning, that is, on Sunday. On Sunday the girl did not return home. Sumati went to Upendra'e house in search of her and found that neither Upendra nor the girl had been there. She made enquiries at different places but no trace of the girl could be found. She also got information from one Debendra that there had been no festivities in the house of Upendra. On 13th June 1939 one Nitai, who is a relation of Sumati's husband, lodged a missing information at the thana.
3. It is necessary to go back again to the consideration of certain events which had taken place on Monday afternoon. One Arapdi Gazi witness 21, Madar Molla, P.W 22 and others saw the body of a woman in a veel. They have given a description of the dress of the body and of the way in which the hair of the woman was tied and it seemed to tally with the dress of Abala, and with the way in which her hair had been tied when she left with Upendra. These persons however did nothing. On Tuesday the bones of a female skeleton were seen by a number of persons and near these bones, there were lying a sari, a petticoat, a bunch of keys, some sankhas, churls and certain other articles. Information was sent to Sumati and the members of her family and they came and identified the articles of clothing and jewellery as being those of Abala. The girl, when she left with Upendra was wearing certain gold madulis. They were missing. Upon the discovery of the skeleton and articles of clothing, Nitai again went to the thana with Sumati and there the first information was lodged. The police took up investigation. Evidence has been given that on Tuesday, Debendra, a relation of Upendra, met him and Sudhir. Debendra heard before that Abala had been taken by Upendra from her house and that she was missing. He questioned Upendra and the latter said that he had left the girl in the house of a friend of Sudhir at Basirhat. Sudhir, who was there, denied this. Evidence has also been given that Sudhir and Upendra went to the house of a goldsmith Kalidas swarnakar and there sold five gold madulis. The five madulis have been identified as belonging to Abala. On these facts Sudhir and Upendra were sent up for trial charged with murder and abduction with the intent that the person abducted should be murdered or be so disposed of as to be put in danger of being murdered. The defence taken by the accused consists of a denial of all the facts alleged against them. A suggestion was made that the girl Abala had accompanied one Charubala to the house of Charubala's father-in-law and that she disappeared from there. It was also suggested that Sumati was carrying on an intrigue with Nitai which was discovered by Upendra and that Upendra had been implicated by Nitai and Sumati because of this. As I have said before, the jury have found Upendra guilty of an offence punish, able under S. 364, Penal Code, and the learned Judge accepting that verdict has sentenced Upendra to eight years' rigorous imprisonment. Upendra has appealed from Jail. The charge of the learned Judge to the jury, which is an extremely lengthy one, contains many irrelevant details but certain vital circumstances of the case have not been placed before the jury in their proper perspective. To establish an offence punishable under S. 364, Penal Code, it must be proved that the person charged with the offence had the intention at the time of the abduction that the person abducted would be murdered or would be so disposed of as to be put in danger of being murdered. In this case the prosecution had to prove that Upendra at the time when he took away the girl Abala, bad this particular intention. Now this element of the offence was not properly placed before the jury. The learned Judge nowhere told the jury that they must be satisfied that this was the state of mind of Upendra at the time of the alleged abduction. He should have told them that they could not find Upendra guilty unless there was evidence to establish beyond all doubt that at the time he took Abala from her house he had the intention that she should be murdered or be put in danger of being murdered. Now what are the circumstances proved in this case? The evidence given on behalf of the prosecution is that on Friday, Upendra asked the girl's mother to come with him to witness the festivities at his house and that it was only after the mother had refused that Upendra suggested that the girl should come with him. This is a circumstance which negatives the case that Upendra had at that time any intention to have the girl murdered or to put her in danger of being murdered.
4. Next we cannot find any motive which may have impelled Upendra to encompass the death of Abala at the time of his taking her away. We find no reason whatsoever why be should desire her death. In a case depending on circumstantial evidence the question of motive is of great importance and it was the duty of the learned Judge to emphasise this absence of motive which was a circumstance in favour of the accused. The circumstances relied upon by the prosecution tend to show that Upendra had stolen the gold madulis from the girl. Even if that evidence be believed it was very far from establishing that Upendra must have intended to get these madulis by killing the girl. The evidence shows that the girl used to frequent Upendra's house. He had ample opportunity of securing these madulis without adopting this elaborate plan of abducting her from her mother's house. It seems to us inherently improbable that anyone placed in the position of Upendra would abduct the girl from her mother's house with the intention of killing her in order to take away five gold madulis from her person. This inherent improbability was not properly placed before the jury. We find further that there has been a serious misdirection to the jury with respect to the charge under S. 364 of the IPC. The learned Judge in explaining the charges of murder and abduction says this:
The charge under S. 302 of the IPC, is the main charge in the present case. If you find the accused persons guilty under this Section, you need not consider the other charge against them. In case however the charge under S. 302 of the IPC, is not made out in your opinion, you will consider whether the other charge has been established.
5. Then he goes on to say:
For the charge under S. 364 of the IPC, however it is not essential that the dead body should be beyond doubt proved to have that of Abala.
6. Now, in this case unless it is proved that Abala has been murdered, there is nothing whatsoever to show that the motive for abducting her was to murder her or put her in danger of being murdered; and the only evidence given to prove that she has been murdered is the evidence that the skeleton was that of Abala. The learned Judge was therefore quite wrong in telling the Jury that it was not essential to prove beyond doubt that the body was the body of Abala. The learned Judge repeats this error again towards the end of his charge. This is what he says:
As for the charge under S. 302 of the IPC, it must he definitely proved beyond reasonable doubt that Abala was murdered and that by the accused persons. As for the charge under S. 364 of the IPC, however, actual proof of murder is not necessary. It is sufficient if the prosecution makes out that the accused person or persons placed Abala under such circumstances that she was in danger of being murdered.
7. There can be no doubt that theoretically it is not necessary to prove that the person abducted has been murdered in order to establish a charge under S. 364 of the IPC. But these theoretical discussions of the elements that go to constitute an offence punishable under S. 364 of the Coda are useless and indeed in the circumstances of the present case are apt to be mischievous. As we have pointed out before, having regard to the particular facts of this case there can be no case of abduction under S. 364 of the Code unless it has been conclusively proved that Abala has been murdered. To tell the jury that even if they are not satisfied that Abala was murdered, they could still find the accused guilty of an offence punishable under S. 364 of the IPC, was to mislead them on a most vital part of the case. Again, the learned Judge was entirely wrong in telling the jury that it was sufficient if the prosecution established that the accused person or persons placed Abala in such circumstances that she was in danger of being murdered. In telling the jury this, the learned Judge seems to have overlooked the most important element necessary to establish an offence punishable under S. 364 of the IPC, namely the state of the mind of the accused person at the time of the abduotion. Even if after the abduction the accused person placed Abala in danger of being murdered that would not establish the charge of abduction punishable under S. 364 against him. It would be necessary for the Crown to establish that he intended at the time of the abduction to place Abala in a position which would put her in danger of being murdered.
8. We are of opinion that these misdirections of the learned Judge have resulted in a wrong verdict being given. If the Crown took the view that the evidence established that Upendra had murdered the girl then he should have been charged with murder and nothing else. A charge under S. 364 of the IPC, in the circumstances of the present case is entirely misconceived. We do not think, that the circumstances proved in this case can lead to the conclusion that the girl was murdered by Upendra. They are capable of many reasonable explanations which would be consistent with his innocence. We are, however, not concerned at present with the charge of murder inasmuch as the jury have found Upendra not guilty of that charge. As regards the charge under S. 364 of the IPC, it seems to us that the circumstances established are very far from establishing it. No motive has been shown as to why Upendra should want to abduct the girl in order to get her murdered; it would be ridiculous to assume that he intended to murder her in order to get possession of five gold madulis which are of not much value and which he could have secured without adopting this elaborate method. No circumstance has been proved which would indicate that Upendra wanted to murder the girl or get her murdered at or before the time that he took her away. If all the circumstances sought to be proved are accepted as having been proved it raises at most a suspicion that Upendra had taken away the girl for some improper purpose. They are certainly not sufficient to establish a charge under S. 364, Penal Code.
9. This prosecution is one of the many instances in which we have found that the provisions of S. 364, Penal Code, have been misused. When the case for the prosecution is that the person abducted has been murdered by the abductor there can be no scope for a charge under this section. The abductor should be charged with murder pure and simple. We have noticed however in such cases where the evidence to establish the charge of murder is weak or inconclusive the prosecution is prone to adopt this device of adding or preferring a charge under S. 364, Penal Code in the hope that a jury which may hesitate to find the accused guilty of murder on such slender evidence may be induced to find against him on the lesser charge.
10. We need hardly point out the unfairness and impropriety, to use no stronger term, of this procedure and we are determined so far as lies in our power to stop this abuse of the provisions of S. 364, Penal Code. It was the duty of the learned Judge in this case to refuse to frame a charge under this section. We find that there is really no evidence to bring home this charge to the appellant and we accordingly set aside the order of conviction and sentence and acquit him. He shall be released forthwith.
11. Bartley, J.:— I agree.
D.S/R.K
12. Conviction set aside.
Alert