- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Debi Saran Singh v. Rajbans Nath Dubey
Judicial Opinion — Structured Summary
Factual and Procedural Background
The suit concerns partition and possession of a 2-annas 3 dams odd share in an estate that the plaintiff purchased at a sale for arrears of revenue on 5 June 1901. The plaintiff alleges dispossession in 1912. The share purchased was an Ijmali (residuary) share remaining after creation of separate accounts under the Revenue Sales Act.
A prior partition decree dated 27 September 1893 had divided the estate into 12 separate shares (pattis). The residuary share purchased by the plaintiff fell within certain of these separated pattis. Defendants (those who contested the suit) contended the plaintiff was entitled only to have his share carved out of those pattis and that the other pattis should remain undisturbed. Defendants 17 to 22, who did not contest, were found by the Subordinate Judge to represent a 5 dams share (a finding not appealed).
The learned Subordinate Judge held that by purchasing the residuary share the plaintiff acquired an undivided share in the entire estate and was not bound by the prior partition. The defendants appealed to the Court against that judgment and decree.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether a Civil Court can re-open a partition previously made by a Civil Court decree (other than by proceedings in review), in particular whether a purchaser of a residuary share at a revenue sale can claim partition of the entire estate notwithstanding a prior Civil Court partition.
- How the concurrent jurisdiction of the Collector and Civil Courts operates in matters of partition of revenue-paying estates, including whether the Collector may re-consider allotments made by a Civil Court when a party applies for partition of land revenue.
- Whether a purchaser of a residuary or separately accounted share sold under the Revenue Sales Act obtains an undivided share in the entire estate or only entitlement to specific portions (subject to facts of each case).
Arguments of the Parties
Appellants' (Defendants') Arguments
- The defendants relied on the prior Civil Court decree of 27 September 1893 which divided the estate into 12 separate pattis and argued that the plaintiff's residuary share falls within some of those pattis.
- They contended that the plaintiff was entitled only to have his purchased share carved out of those specific pattis and that the remaining pattis should not be disturbed;
- Implicit in their stance was the position that the prior partition terminated co-tenancy and could not be re-opened in a subsequent Civil Court suit to recreate co-tenancy for a fresh partition.
Respondent's (Plaintiff's) Arguments
- The plaintiff claimed partition of the entire estate on the basis that by purchasing the residuary (Ijmali) share he had acquired an undivided share in the whole estate and therefore was not bound by the earlier partition.
- The plaintiff asked that the liability to land revenue should remain joint (as before), a point noted by the Court in its analysis of how a residuary share may be treated.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Jogodishury Debea v. Kailash Chundar Lahiry (Full Bench, Calcutta High Court) | Majority view that a Civil Court has jurisdiction to execute a decree for partition of a revenue-paying estate provided it does not assume jurisdiction to partition the liability for land revenue. | The Court relied on this authority (and noted it is confirmed by s.12 of the Estates Partition Act, 1897) to explain that Civil Courts may execute partition decrees but should not, in execution, assume jurisdiction to partition liability for the land revenue; it supports the proposition that the Collector may re-consider allotments made by a Civil Court where liability for land revenue is concerned. |
| Nalini Kanta Lakiri v. Sarnamoyi Debya (Privy Council) | Application of the principles of res judicata to a previous partition. | The Court invoked this decision to show that res judicata prevents re-opening of a partition previously determined by a Civil Court decree. |
| Gungadeen Misser v. Kheeroo Mundul (1874) | Where an account has been separated under s.10 of the Revenue Sales Act and the corresponding share is sold, what is sold may be an undivided share and not any specific portion; sale should not create uncertainty in auction sales or impair revenue security. | The Court examined and distinguished this case: it observed that Gungadeen involved separation under s.10 (not a formal Civil Court partition) and that the report did not clearly show a prior regular partition by decree. Therefore Gungadeen was held not to authorize re-opening of a partition properly made by Civil Court decree; the Court qualified the law to say extent of undivided character depends on facts. |
| Annoda Prasad Ghose v. Rajendra Kumar Ghose | Referred with approval in relation to the principles discussed in Gungadeen Misser. | The Court noted this case (and two others cited alongside it) do not carry the matter further nor provide authority that a Civil Court decree for partition does not finally terminate co-tenancy. |
| Bhawani Koer v. Mathura Prasad | Referred with approval in the context of cases about sale under the Revenue Sales Act and partition issues. | Used as supporting authority for the limited proposition that earlier cases did not displace the principle that a Civil Court partition decree finally determines co-tenancy. |
| Kumar Kolanand Singh v. Syed Sarafat Hossein | Referred with approval alongside other authorities cited. | Observed as not extending the proposition that a Civil Court decree may be re-opened by a later Civil Court suit. |
| Moonshee Buzlool Rahman v. Pran Dhun Dutt | Held that an auction-purchaser of the rights of Government in an estate sold for arrears of revenue is not bound by a decision previously obtained to which the defaulting proprietor was a party. | The Court noted this principle and that it has been extended to auction-purchasers of entire estates in several later cases; but it observed the principle has not been applied to purchasers of a share of an estate at a revenue sale. |
| Kanta Prosad Hajari v. Abdul Jamir Sadagar; Gokul Chandra Das v. Hara Sundari Dasi; Gadadhar Bose v. Radha Charan | Extensions of the principle in Moonshee Buzlool Rahman to auction-purchasers of entire estates. | The Court cited these cases as examples where the principle (that auction-purchasers of entire estates are not bound by prior decisions against the defaulting proprietor) has been extended; but stressed they do not establish the rule for purchasers of shares. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court's analysis proceeded in the following steps, adhering closely to the principles and authorities cited in the opinion:
- The Court framed the core question around the concurrent jurisdiction of the Collector and Civil Courts in partition of revenue-paying estates. It emphasized the Collector's statutory role in collection of land revenue and his jurisdiction under the Estates Partition Acts to make partitions (including partition of liability for land revenue) so as to protect the security for land revenue.
- The Court recognized Civil Courts' competence to grant partition decrees for revenue-paying estates, but noted that execution of such decrees is subject to s.54 of the Code of Civil Procedure requiring execution by the Collector. It relied on the Full Bench decision in Jogodishury Debea v. Kailash Chundar Lahiry and s.12 of the Estates Partition Act, 1897 to explain that while Civil Courts may execute partition decrees they must not assume the Collector's jurisdiction to partition liability for land revenue. From this the Court derived that the Collector may re-consider Civil Court allotments in the event a party seeks partition of land revenue before him.
- The Court then stated a limiting principle: nothing in statute or principle of law permits a Civil Court to re-open a partition properly made under a Civil Court decree other than by review proceedings. This proposition the Court grounded on res judicata as applied in Nalini Kanta Lakiri v. Sarnamoyi Debya and on the legal effect of a final Civil Court partition decree, which terminates co-tenancy and vests each party with a specific allotment or property interest.
- The learned Subordinate Judge's contrary conclusion was based on the authority of Gungadeen Misser v. Kheeroo Mundul. The Court examined that case closely, noting key factual distinctions: Gungadeen involved separation under s.10 of the Revenue Sales Act and the report did not clearly demonstrate a regular partition by decree that put an end to co-tenancy. Accordingly, the Court held Gungadeen does not support re-opening a Civil Court partition decree in a subsequent Civil suit.
- The Court qualified the legal position derived from Gungadeen: when a share for which a separate account has been opened under s.10 (or a residuary share) is sold under the Revenue Sales Act, whether the share is to be treated as undivided or as conferring rights to specific portions depends on the facts of each case. A share may remain undivided only with respect to liability for land revenue while being divided in other respects, subject to the Collector's powers.
- Applying these principles to the present facts, the Court found it would be inequitable to disturb the pattis created by the 1893 Civil Court partition which had been separately enjoyed for some 25 years and thereby re-create co-tenancy. The Court concluded the Subordinate Judge's finding that the plaintiff had acquired an undivided share in the entire estate should be set aside.
- The Court therefore directed a more limited remedy: a preliminary decree for partition of the plaintiff's share only within the pattis created by the 1893 partition in which the plaintiff's purchased share now lies. It also observed that, in order to effect an equitable division of the plaintiff's share in those pattis, it might be necessary to re-partition the defendants' shares in those same pattis.
- As to costs, the Court directed that the defendants be awarded their costs in this Court and half their costs in the Court below, and expressly disallowed a paper-book preparation allowance because of unnecessary inclusion of papers.
Holding and Implications
Holding:
APPEAL ALLOWED. The Court set aside the judgment and decree of the Subordinate Judge and directed that a preliminary decree be drawn for partition of the plaintiff's share only within the pattis created by the prior (27 September 1893) Civil Court partition in which the plaintiff's purchased residuary share lies.
Implications and direct effects:
- The plaintiff is not entitled to a partition of the entire estate; relief is limited to partition of his purchased share within the specific pattis established by the 1893 decree.
- The Subordinate Judge is directed to ascertain the relevant parties and to make the preliminary decree accordingly; a fresh partition of defendants' shares in those pattis may be necessary to effect an equitable division.
- The defendants are awarded costs in this Court and half their costs in the Court below; the Court refused an allowance for preparation of the paper-book because of unnecessary inclusions.
- On the broader legal principle, the judgment affirms that (a) the Collector retains jurisdiction related to partition of liability for land revenue and may re-consider Civil Court allotments in that narrow context, but (b) a Civil Court generally cannot re-open a partition properly made by a Civil Court decree except by review, a limitation the Court grounded on res judicata and on the finality of a partition decree which terminates co-tenancy. The Court also emphasized that whether a sold share is to be treated as undivided depends on the specific facts of each case.
Note: This summary is confined strictly to matters and statements contained in the provided judicial opinion. No information has been added beyond what appears in the text.
Chapman, J.:— This appeal arises out of a suit for partition and for possession of a 2-annas 3 dams odd share in an estate purchased at a sale for arrears of revenue on 5th June, 1901. The plaintiff alleges that he was dispossessed in 1912. The share that was purchased by the plaintiff is an Ijmali or residuary share, that is to say, the share remaining after the creation of separate accounts in respect of other shares in the estate under the Revenue Sales Act. Defendants 17 to 22 who did not contest the suit represented, according to the finding of the learned Subordinate Judge against which there has been no appeal, a share Orf 5 dams only. The plaintiff claimed a partition of the entire estate. The remainder of the share-holders who contested the suit pleaded that the plaintiff was not entitled to a partition of the entire estate, inasmuch as there had been a previous partition on 27th September, 1893 under a decree of the Civil Court. Under that decree the estate had been divided into 12 separate shares. The residuary share purchased by the plaintiff fell within certain of the separated shares or partis. The defendant's contention was that the plaintiff was entitled only to have his share carved out of these pattis. Their case was that the remaining 7 separated pattis should not be interfered with. This contention was overruled by the learned Subordinate Judge on the ground that the plaintiff by his purchase of the residuary share acquired an undivided share in the entire estate and that he was not bound by the previous partition. The defendants now appeal to this Court.
2. The question we have to determine is connected with the concurrent jurisdiction of the Collector and of the Civil, Court in the matter of partitions. The Collector is responsible for the collection of the land revenue and, with that in view, the Collector has under the various Estates Partition Acts been charged with the jurisdiction of making partition of revenue-paying estates including the partition of liability to land, revenue. This jurisdiction is given to the Collector with the object of ensuring that the security for the land revenue shall not be imperilled by the manner in which the partition is effected. The Civil Courts have jurisdiction to grant decrees for partition of revenue-paying estates, but the Code of Civil Procedure requires that the execution of the decree for the partition shall be effected by the Collector, see S. 54 of the present Code of Civil Procedure. Under the decision of the Full Bench of the Calcutta High Court in Jogodishury Debea v. Kailash Chundar Lahiry(1) however the majority of the Judges took the view that a Civil Court has jurisdiction to execute a decree for partition of a revenue-paying estate provided that it does not assume jurisdiction to partition the liability for the land revenue. This view of the matter has been confirmed by the terms of Section 12 of the Estates Partition Act, 1897. It is thus possible to say that in the event of a party applying to the Collector for a partition of the land revenue after partition has been effected by the Civil Court, it would be open to the Collector to re-consider the allotment of the shares granted in the Civil Court proceeding.
3. White however the jurisdiction of the Collector to re-open a partition made by the Civil Court may possibly have been retained, there is nothing in any of the Statutes and certainly not in any principle of law which would enable a Civil Court to re-open a partition properly made under a Civil Court decree otherwise than by proceedings by way of review. This view of the matter is based both upon the principles of res juaicata which was applied in the case of a previous partition by the Privy Council in the case of Nalini Kanta Lakiri v. Sarnamoyi Debya(2), and also upon the principle that the effect of the final decree of a Civil Court for partition is to put an end to co-tenancy and to vest in each person or group a sore ??? in a specific property or allotment. The law does not provide for a suit in the Civil Court under which these separated estates can be divested and a co-tenancy recreated for the purpose of making a fresh partition. The learned Subordinate Judge has taken a different view upon the authority of the case of Gungadeen Misser v. Kheeroo Mundul(3). That was a decision of the year 1874. The facts of that case appear from the judgment to be as follows:
A share-holder in a revenue-paying estate had been in exclusive possession of 25 bighas of land, the subject of the suit, together with other land in lieu of his undivided share in the estate. The plaintiff purchased the 25 bighas of land above referred to from this share-holder. The contesting defendants had purchased the share of certain other co-sharers at a revenue sale. The plaintiffs' contention was that these contesting defendants by their purchase at the auction sale had obtained merely a right to exclusive possession of specific portions of the estate held by the defaulting share-holders whose shares these contesting defendants had purchased. The argument was that inasmuch as the defaulting share-holders had been content to hold exclusive possession of specific portions of the revenue-paying estate in, lieu of their undivided share, the contesting defendants who purchased the defaulting shares were entitled only to get those specific portions. It appears that the defaulting share-holders had obtained a separation of accounts under Section 10 of the Revenue Sales Act and not under S. 11. The Judges held that the plaintiffs' suit must be dismissed upon the ground that under the terms of the Revenue Sales Act where an account has been separated under S. 10 and the corresponding share is sold, what is sold is an undivided share and not any specific portion of the estate, and that to enable the, plaintiff to succeed in such a suit would be to introduce uncertainty into the auction sales and the security of the land revenue. The report in the Bengal Law Reporter is imperfect. A fuller report of the judgment will be found in Gungadeen Misser v. Kheeroo Mundul. It is not clear from that report that there had in fact been a regular partition effecting the complete separation of the interests of the shareholders. Phear, J., who delivered the judgment said that the different shareholders had by some sort of private partition come to among themselves appropriated different portions of the mahal; but the Judges did not expressly find that there has been such a complete partition as to put an end to the condition of co-tenancy. In such a case no question of res judicata or of the effect of a Civil Court decree for partition arises. That case obviously would be no authority to justify us in holding that a partition effected by a Civil Court decree can be re-opened in a subsequent suit in a Civil Court. I would I also be disposed to qualify the statement of the law made in that case. It would be more correct to say that when a share in respect of which a separate account has been opened under S. 10 or a residuary share is sold under the Revenue Sales Act, the extent to which the share must be held to be undivided will depend on the facts of each case. It may be that the share remains undivided only in respect of liability for land revenue and is divided in every other respect subject to the power of the Collector to re-adjust the allotments in the event of the liability for land revenue being partitioned by him. In the present case the plaintiff asked that the liability to land revenue should remain joint as before.
4. The case of Gungadeen Misser v. Kheeroo Mandal was referred to with approval in the case of Annoda Prasad Ghose v. Rajendra Kumar Ghose(4) and in the cases of Bhawani Koer v. Mathura Prasad(5) and Kumar Kolanand Singh v. Syed Sarafat Hossein(6). These cases do not carry the matter any further and certainly provide no authority for the contention that a decree for partition effected by a civil Court does not finally terminate the condition of a co-tenancy and put an end to all further right to partition so far at any rate as the civil Courts are concerned. In the case of Moonshee Buzlool Rahman v. Pran Dhun Dutt(7) it was held that an auction-purchaser of the rights of Government in an estate sold for arrears of revenue is not bound by a decision previously obtained to which the defaulting proprietor was a party, and this principle has been extended to the case of an auction-purchaser of an entire estate at a sale under the Revenue Sales Act [Kanta Prosad Hajari v. Abdul Jamir Sadagar(8), Gokul Chandra Das v. Hara Sundari Dasi(9) and Gadadhar Bose v. Radha Charan(10)]. But the principle has never been applied to the purchaser, of the share of an estate at a revenue sale.
5. In the present case it would be obviously most inequitable that the properties, created into separate estates so far back as 1893 and separately enjoyed now for 25 years, should be again thrown into the hotchpot. We set aside the judgment and decree of the learned Subordinate Judge and, in lieu thereof, we direct that there be a preliminary decree for a partition of the plaintiff's share in the pattis created by the previous partition in which the share purchased by him now lies.
6. These parties will be ascertained by the Subordinate Judge and a preliminary decree made by him accordingly. In order to make an equitable partition of the plaintiff's share in these pattis, it may be necessary to make a fresh partition of the defendants' share also in these pattis. The defendants are entitled to their costs in this Court and to half their costs in the Court below. In assessing the costs in this Court no allowance should be given for the preparation of the paper-book having regard to the reckless manner in which numbers of unnecessary papers were included in it.
7. Atkinson, J.:— I concur.
V.S/R.K
8. Appeal allowed.
Alert