- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Subramania Ayyar v. A.L.V.R.R.M. Muthia Chettiar
Sadasiva Ayyar, J.:— Post before a Full Bench as we think that the correctness of the judgments in Palaniandi Chetti v. Appavu Chettiar(1) ought to be considered by a Full Bench on the question whether a suit ought to be brought by creditors to set aside a deed voidable as against creditors before it could be declared void and whether such a suit could be brought by a single creditor in his own interest or ought to be brought on behalf of all the creditors.
The case accordingly came on for hearing before Ayling, Seshagiri Ayyar and Bakewell, JJ.
A. Krishnaswami Ayyar for L.S Viraraghava Ayyar for the appellants. A transfer though fraudulent within section 53 of the Transfer of Property Act is good until avoided; and the way in which this could be done is by having it avoided by an action whether on behalf of all the creditors or otherwise: see form 13 of forms of decrees in Civil Procedure Code, Appendix B: Palaniandi Chetti v. Appavu Chettiar, Hakim Lal v. Mooshahar Sahu(2), Iswar Timappa v. Devar Venkappa(3), Chatterput Singh v. Maharaj Bahadur(4), Order of Bakewell, J., in Civil Suit No. 113 of 1911. Subramania Pillai v. Dakshinamoorthy Mudaliyar(5), which is the other way, is the decision of a single Judge (Sundara Ayyar, J.): see Phul Kumari v. Ghanshyam Misra(6).
V.C Seshachariar for the respondents. The matter is governed by section 53 of the Transfer of Property Act. No action need be brought to set aside the alienation; for any result that could be achieved by bringing a suit could also be achieved by a plea in defence impeaching the alienation: Abdul Kadir v. Ali Mia, a case exactly on all fours. Subramania Pillay v. Dakshinamoorthy Mudaliar shows that the settled practice of this Presidency is to attach without bringing any such suit. Reference was made to Hem Chandra Sarkar v. Lalit Mohan Kar, Sinaya Pillai v. Munisami Aiyan, Babaji v. Krishna, and Ramu Aiyar v. Palaniappa Chetty.
Ayling, J.:— In this case the appellants (plaintiffs) are purchasers of the suit property from second defendant by a sale-deed, Exhibit A, dated 20th June 1904. The first defendant, subsequent to this sale, obtained a decree against second defendant in Small Cause Suit No. 1960 of 1905, and in 1913 attached the suit properties in execution. Plaintiffs preferred a claim; on the dismissal of which they filed the present suit for declaration of their title, and for cancellation of the summary order on their claim.
The suit failed in both the lower Court?, the Subordinate Judge holding is first appeal that the sale was a fraudulent transaction intended to defeat or delay second defendant's creditors, though not a mere sham transaction.
It is now argued in second appeal that it is not open to the first defendant to set up such a defence in the present suit; and that the sale must be held good against him unless and until be obtained a decree setting it aside in proceedings suitably instituted for that purpose. Mr. A. Krishnaswami Ayyar relies on a recent ruling of this Court, Palaniandi Chetti v. Appavu Chettiar(7), and the second appeal appears to have been specially ordered to be heard by us with a view to the correctness of this ruling being considered by a Bench of three Judges.
Speaking for myself I have carefully considered the judgment in the case referred to and the arguments of Mr. Seshachariyar who has endeavoured to show us that the decision is wrong. The facts are absolutely analogous to those in the present case. It is unnecessary for us in the present case to consider whether a suit by a creditor to avoid an alienation as infringing against section 53 of the Transfer of Property Act must be brought in a representative capacity on behalf of the body of creditors, but apart from this I have no hesitation in concurring in the views expressed by Coutts Trotter and Seshagiri Ayyar, JJ., in that case. The only case quoted by Mr. Sesha Achariyar which has not been dealt with in their judgment and which appears to have any bearing on the question is a Calcutta case not reported in the regular series, Abdul Kadir v. Ali Mia. With all respect I cannot agree with the decision. I do not find in it sufficient authority for the proposition advanced by Mr. Sasha Achariyar that any thing which can be made the basis of a suit can be pleaded as a bar in action: and I agree with my learned brother Seshagiri Ayyar, J., in Palaniandi Chetti v. Appavu Chettiar that a sale such as the one we are considering must be held to continue in force until it is set aside in proceedings property instituted for the purpose.
It follows that the decree of the lower Courts in the present suit should be set aside and plaintiffs be given a decree as sued for with costs throughout.
Seshagiri Ayyar, J.:— I agree. The further arguments addressed to us by Mr. Sesha Achariyar have not convinced me that my view in Palaniandi Chetti v. Appavu Chettiar is wrong and that an attaching creditor as defendant can obtain a declaration that the sale by his judgment-debtor which he has not sued to set aside is in fraud of his and other claims against the common judgment-debtor and that on that ground the suit should be dismissed.
Bakewell, J.:— I agree.
N.R
Alert