Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Bhairab Chandra Mandal v. Jiban Krishna Mandal

Calcutta High Court
May 20, 1920
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.

Mookerjee, A.C.J:— This is an appeal by the plaintiffs in a suit for recovery of possession of land on declaration of title. The defendants resisted the claim on the ground that they had acquired a good title under an exchange.

2. The Courts below have found that an exchange was effected in the manner provided by the Transfer of Property Act; that is, as the value of the property was less than Rs. 100, the plaintiffs delivered possession of the disputed land to the defendants.

3. This is prima facie a complete answer to the claim; but the plaintiffs have established that though at the time of the exchange they were in possession of the whole of the property, they had not a complete title thereto, as they were themselves purchasers from persons who were entitled only to a half share. Their contention in substance is that the defendants acquired a good title to that half share alone and have no title to the remainder.

4. The answer of the defendants is, that subsequent to the exchange, the plaintiffs acquired the title of the co-sharers of their vendor and that as soon as their title to the whole was thereby perfected, the benefit thereof accrued to the defendants. The Courts below have held that this is a conclusive answer to the case set up by the plaintiffs. In our opinion there is no foundation for the claim.

5. Section 43 of the Transfer of Property Act provides that

“Where a person erroneously represents that he is authorized to transfer certain immoveable property, and professes to transfer such property for consideration, such transfer shall, at the option of the transferee, operate on any interest which the transferor may acquire in such property, at any time during which the contract of transfer subsists.”

6. This section in substance embodies the rule that the interest when it accrues feeds the estoppel or, in other words, that though the assignment was of a defective title, yet as the assignor afterwards acquired a good title, the Court will make that good title available to make the assignment effectual: Webb v. Austin (1); Cuthbertson v. Irving (2); Rowbothan v. Wilson (3); Holryod v. Marshall (4); Booth v. Alcock (5); Re Bridgwater (6); Gresham Life Ass. Society v. Crowthev (7); Poulton v. Moore (8); Prasanna v. Srikantha (9); Dr. Dwarka Nath Mitter has, however, contended that although Section 43 speaks of transfers in general terms, still it is not applicable to cases of exchange by reason of the special provision contained in Section 119. That section provides that “In the absence of a contract to the contrary, the party deprived of the thing or part thereof he has received in exchange, by reason of any defect in the title of the other party, is entitled at his option to compensation, or to the return of the thing transferred by him.” But this does not exclude the operation of Section 43; for a similar argument might be advanced in the case of sales, mortgages or leases, where, on proof of deficiency in the subject matter, the purchaser, mortgagee or lessee may obtain compensation or cancellation.

7. Reference has also been made to the decision in Holryod v. Marshall where Lord Westbury speaks of this principle as applicable to cases of sales and mortgages; but this does not indicate that it is not applicable to cases of exchange. It is an elementary proposition that for purposes like this an exchange stands on the same footing as a sale. We are of opinion that the claim put forward by the plaintiffs is not merely unfounded but is wholly unjust and has been rightly dismissed.

8. The appeal is dismissed with costs.

Fletcher, J.:— I agree.

9. Appeal dismissed.