- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
The Public Prosecutor . v. Sennimalai Goundan A...
We are bound by the authority of Queen-Empress v. Muppan(1) and The Public Prosecutor v. Ramaswami Konan(2), both of which place the consent and neglect of the custodian on the same footing. These rulings have been distinguished by Krishnaswami Aiyar, J. In re The Public Prosecutor(3), but with all respect we do not think the ground of distinction is sound.
We may refer to the wording of Sect. 221 of the Indian Penal Code as illustrative of the meaning to be given to the word “escape” in Sect. 225-B. Sect. 221 speaks of a public servant who “intentionally suffers such person to escape.” This strongly suggests that an escape is none the less an escape though effected with the consent of the custodian.
Under the terms of the warrant in this case, the process-server was only authorised to release the judgment-debtor on actual receipt of the decree-amount.
We must set aside the order of the Sub-Divisional Magistrate and restore the conviction, but we reduce the sentence to the term of imprisonment already undergone which is in our opinion sufficient.
S. S.Order set aside
Alert