- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Santana Ray v. The Advocate-General Of Bengal
Factual and Procedural Background
This appeal concerns the validity and operability of a provision in a deed of settlement executed on 14 March 1913 by Suprasanna Roy. Suprasanna and his brother, Upendra Narayan Roy, had been joint holders of extensive estates in Bengal. A partition decree dated 2 February 1911 had been obtained in earlier litigation, but Suprasanna failed to obtain possession of the properties awarded to him and pursued further litigation and partition claims, becoming heavily indebted and leaving his estate mismanaged.
To address his debts and provide for estate management and family maintenance, Suprasanna executed the deed of settlement. The deed appointed two trustees (each to receive Rs. 100 per month) and vested in them the estate allotted to Suprasanna (or what might be allotted later). The trustees were given broad powers, including possession, recovery of dues, borrowing and the power to sell, mortgage or otherwise dispose of the properties. Clause 7 of the deed listed the order of payments to be made from the rents, issues, profits and income of the properties, culminating (after liquidation of debts) in a provision to expend Rs. 500 per month for medical and educational charities within the settlor's zemindaries, selected by the trustees with the approval of the settlor; and related payments to the settlor's wife and then the settlor himself in defined circumstances. Clause 8 and clause 9 provided for transfers of property after liquidation of debts or after the settlor’s death subject to certain conditions.
On 1 April 1915 the trustees, with the settlor and his wife as parties to a deed, sold the settled properties to the settlor's brother for Rs. 5.5 lakhs. The sale enabled discharge of the debts and left a net balance of about Rs. 2.5 lakhs. The settlor died on 10 August 1918 leaving a widow, one son and two daughters.
On 25 November 1918 the widow (the plaintiff) instituted proceedings against the trustees seeking directions on six matters; the Advocate‑General of Bengal was joined to enable support for the validity of the alleged charitable trust. In the court below Mr. Justice Rankin upheld the charitable trust (albeit hesitantly). The plaintiff appealed to this Court; the only respondent joined in the appeal was the Advocate‑General because the question before the Court related solely to the validity of the charitable trust. The trustees and the infant children were not formally joined as respondents in the appeal (the guardian ad litem of the infants appeared and supported the attack on the charitable trust). The Court observed the trustees and infants ought to have been joined, but proceeded to decide the issue on the record before it.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the provision in the deed to expend Rs. 500 per month for medical and educational charities within the settlor's zemindaries (selected by the trustees with the approval of the settlor) became operative and is a valid charitable trust in the events that have happened.
- Whether the doctrine of cy pres can be invoked to validate the charitable provision if the specified charitable object cannot be literally carried out.
- Whether the charitable gift, if otherwise valid, is vulnerable to the rule against perpetuities or remoteness because it was subject to a condition precedent that might not vest within the period allowed by law.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant (the widow)
- The appeal challenges the validity of the alleged charitable trust provision in the deed; the core contention is that the conditions precedent for the charity were not satisfied and have become impossible to fulfil (the zemindaries were sold and the debts were not liquidated from rents, issues and profits as the deed required).
Respondent (Advocate‑General)
- The Advocate‑General was made a party to support the validity of the charitable trust (the Court below had declared the provision to be charitable).
Other parties / intervening positions
- Counsel for the guardian ad litem of the infant children supported the attack on the charitable trust (i.e., aligned with the appellant's contention that the trust is invalid).
- A "strenuous endeavour" was made (by those supporting validity) to invoke the doctrine of cy pres to save the charitable provision when its literal fulfilment became impossible.
- There was also a contention (not decided by the Court) that the charitable gift might be affected by the rule against remoteness/perpetuities because the trust did not vest immediately but was subject to a condition precedent.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| A.G. v. Earl of Powis | Court may look to surrounding circumstances when construing a deed; such circumstances must be those afforded by the instrument itself. | Supported the approach that the deed must be construed with regard to its object and whole scope and, where appropriate, by reference to surrounding circumstances evidenced by the instrument. |
| Monypenny v. Monypenny | Rule that construction must be made upon the entire deed so that one part helps to expound another; every word should, if possible, take effect. | Applied as authority for reading the deed as a whole and giving effect to its parts when determining whether a charitable trust was created. |
| N.E. Rly. v. Lord Hastings (per Lord Davey) | Deed must be read as a whole to ascertain true meaning of its clauses. | Reinforced the rule that the instrument must be read in its entirety in construing the alleged charitable provision. |
| Re Emson | Illustrates principle that a charitable gift conditioned on a precedent requirement fails if that condition is not satisfied. | Grouped with other authorities to support the proposition that a gift dependent on a condition precedent will fail where the condition is not fulfilled. |
| De Themmines v. De Bonneval | Same principle: charitable gift upon condition precedent fails if condition unmet. | Relied upon as part of established authority that conditioned charitable gifts fail when conditions precedent do not occur. |
| A.G. v. Craven | Principle that a charitable gift upon condition precedent fails if condition not satisfied. | Invoked to justify holding that the charity in the deed fails because the condition precedent was not and could not be satisfied. |
| Cherry v. Mott | Same principle regarding failure of conditioned charitable gifts. | Used with other cases to show the consistent rule against enforcing a charitable gift when a condition precedent fails. |
| Chamberlayne v. Brockett | Authorities on charitable gifts and (also cited later) on rule against perpetuities affecting later‑vesting charity. | Applied to support both (a) the principle that conditioned gifts fail when conditions aren't met, and (b) the observation that charities subject to conditions precedent may be vulnerable to remoteness rules. |
| Mills v. Farmer | Lord Eldon's formulation of three principles about the cy pres doctrine and the court's role in executing testator's charitable intentions. | Used to explain the limits and requirements of the cy pres doctrine—particularly that an absolute charitable intention is needed to invoke cy pres. |
| Moggridge v. Thackwell | Earlier authority followed by Lord Eldon in formulating cy pres principles. | Referred to as antecedent authority underpinning the threefold statement of the law about cy pres. |
| Hunter v. Attorney‑General | Referenced (cf.) in relation to the proposition that the Court cannot make a will for the testator; used in context of cy pres limits. | Cited by way of reference to support the limited role of the Court when applying cy pres (i.e., Court cannot alter the substantive gift beyond donor's intent). |
| Mayor of Lyons v. A.G. (Bengal) | Referenced (cf.) as authority that the Court may supply the place of an executor in some charitable contexts. | Used as a comparative authority in the exposition of Lord Eldon's principles concerning the Court's remedial functions for charitable dispositions. |
| In re White's Trusts | Establishes requirement of a general charitable intent overlying a particular bequest to invoke cy pres. | Applied to hold that, on the deed's terms taken as a whole, no such overlying general charitable intent appeared and so cy pres could not be applied. |
| Biscoe v. Jackson | Also cited for the proposition that an over‑riding charitable intention is necessary for cy pres. | Used together with In re White's Trusts to demonstrate the absence of a general charitable intent in the deed. |
| Yates v. University College | Distinguishes between "foundation" and "regulation" and holds incomplete bequests requiring future supplement are inoperative if supplement is not provided. | Employed to illustrate that this case involves initial failure (incompleteness) rather than breakdown of administrative machinery; applied to show the bequest remained incomplete and inoperative. |
| Grimond v. Grimond | Authorities illustrating the principle in Yates concerning incomplete charitable dispositions. | Referred to in support of the distinction between needing supplementation (and failing) and mere administrative inability. |
| Houston v. Burns | Another authority in the line of cases about incompleteness of charitable dispositions requiring supplementation. | Cited to bolster the conclusion that where a bequest is incomplete because a necessary supplement was never made, it is inoperative. |
| Re Bowen | Referenced in relation to the rule against remoteness as affecting charities that do not vest immediately. | Used to note the considerable force in the contention that a charity subject to a condition precedent might be affected by the rule against remoteness, though the Court did not decide this point fully. |
| Brundenell v. Elwes | Authority for the proposition that the doctrine of cy pres has been applied to wills but not to deeds. | Relied upon to support the view—backed by other authorities—that cy pres is confined to testamentary dispositions and does not extend to deeds, a distinction that, if maintained, leads to failure of the charitable gift here. |
| Pitt v. Jackson | Earlier leading case on cy pres in wills; contrasted with deed cases. | Cited as the type of will cases to which the cy pres doctrine had been applied; the Court contrasted such cases with deeds where cy pres had not been applied. |
| Adams v. Adams | By implication supports the view that cy pres was not applied to deeds (as opposed to wills). | Noted by the Court as persuasive that cy pres has historically been confined to testamentary cases and not applied to inter vivos appointments by deed. |
| Slackpoole v. Stackpoole | Conceded that cy pres could not be applied to deeds (authority from Irish chancery practice). | Used to illustrate historical acceptance of the limitation of cy pres to wills rather than deeds. |
| Hunter v. Attorney‑General (Lord Halsbury) | Referenced regarding the appropriate treatment of the Advocate‑General and his costs when appearing in a public capacity for a supposed charitable fund. | Applied to justify payment of the Advocate‑General's costs out of the estate because he was sued in a public capacity and had properly appeared to defend the trial court's view that the gift was charitable. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court undertook a textual and contextual construction of the deed, applying the established rules that a deed must be read as a whole and that parts of the instrument should be construed so as to give effect to each other. The Court looked back from clause 9 to clause 7 (where the charitable provision is first expressed) to determine the settlor's intention and the conditions upon which the charity was to operate.
Clause 7 unambiguously provided that the settlor intended the rents, issues, profits and income of the properties to be applied in a specific order: debts and charges first; allowances to the settlor and his wife; liquidation of debts; and only after liquidation of debts would Rs. 500 per month be expended for medical and educational charities within the settlor's zemindaries, selected by the trustees with the approval of the settlor. These provisions established that the charity was dependent on conditions precedent: (1) liquidation of debts out of the income of the estate, (2) that the charities be within the zemindaries, and (3) selection by trustees with settlor’s approval.
The Court found that the subsequent events made satisfaction of those conditions impossible in the manner contemplated by the deed: the trustees had sold the zemindaries (with the settlor's concurrence) and the debts were discharged by the sale proceeds rather than by the rents, issues and profits of the properties. Because the zemindaries no longer existed in the required form and the debts were not liquidated out of income as the settlor intended, the conditions precedent for the charity were not satisfied and became impossible to perform.
On this basis the Court applied the well‑established principle (from authorities such as Re Emson, De Themmines v. De Bonneval, A.G. v. Craven and others) that a charitable gift made upon a condition precedent fails if that condition is not fulfilled. The Court rejected the attempt to revive the charity by invoking the cy pres doctrine because, on a reading of the deed as a whole, the Court did not find an absolute or over‑riding general charitable intention which would allow cy pres to operate to substitute a near equivalent object. The Court explained the cy pres doctrine and its limits (drawing on Mills v. Farmer and associated authority) and concluded that the essential test for cy pres—an absolute general charitable intent over and above the particular gift—was not met within the four corners of the deed.
The Court also observed an additional and independent reason which rendered cy pres inapplicable: considerable authority suggests the doctrine of cy pres has been applied to wills but not to inter vivos deeds, and if that distinction is maintained the charitable gift in a deed such as this must fail. The Court therefore held that the charitable provision could not be saved by cy pres.
The Court noted, but did not decide, that there was force in the contention that even if the charity had otherwise been valid, the fact that it did not vest immediately but was subject to a condition precedent might have exposed it to objection under the rule against remoteness (perpetuities). The Court deemed it unnecessary to examine that point in detail in view of its primary conclusion.
Holding and Implications
HOLDING: The appeal is allowed insofar as it concerns the provision for medical and educational charities; the decree of the Court below insofar as it sustained that charitable trust is set aside and the trust for the sum of Rs. 500 per month for those charities is declared invalid and inoperative in the events that have happened.
Implications:
- The charitable gift failed because the conditions precedent for its operation were not satisfied and became impossible to perform.
- The Court held cy pres inapplicable because the deed did not disclose an over‑riding general charitable intention; the Court also noted significant authority that cy pres traditionally applies to wills rather than deeds, which, if accepted, independently defeats the attempt to save the gift.
- The Court did not definitively decide the remoteness/perpetuities point but observed there was considerable force in the contention that the gift would be affected by the rule against remoteness if it had not vested immediately.
- All questions involving any conflict of interest between the widow and the children are to be left open for future determination, as there was no present dispute between them on those points.
- Costs: The costs of all parties to the appeal (including the Advocate‑General) are to be paid out of the estate; the Advocate‑General’s costs were allowed because he appeared in a public capacity to defend what was supposed to be a charitable fund.
- No broader authoritative rule beyond the application of existing authorities was laid down; the decision applies the established principles of construction, conditional gifts to charity and the limits of the cy pres doctrine to the facts of this deed.
Attorneys recorded in the opinion: For the appellant: Jones & Co.; For the respondent (Advocate‑General): Kesteven.
Mookerjee, J.:— This appeal is directed against the decree in a suit on an originating summons which was taken out for the determination of questions arising under a deed of settlement. On the 14th March, 1913, the deed was executed by one Suprasanna Roy who, along with his brother, Upendra Narayan Roy, jointly held and possessed extensive estates in different districts of Bengal. Disputes had arisen between the two brothers and a suit for partition of the joint properties had resulted in a decree on the 2nd February, 1911. Suprasanna, however, failed to obtain possession of the properties awarded to him, and instituted a second suit for recovery of his allotment or for a fresh partition of the entire estate. The result was that Suprasanna became heavily indebted, and the affairs of his estate were in a state of great mismanagement. In these circumstances, he executed the trust deed under consideration, with a view to pay off his debts, and to make arrangements for the proper management of his properties, for the support and maintenance of himself and his family, and for the payment of charities which had been observed and paid by him and his father. Two trustees, who were to receive a remuneration of Rs. 100 a month each, were appointed, and the estate allotted to him in the first partition suit or what might be allotted on the second partition, was vested in them. The trustees were empowered, amongst other things, to take possession, to recover all dues, and, from time to time, if and when they thought fit, to borrow money and to sell, exchange, surrender, give up, mortgage, charge, pledge or dispose off the properties conveyed to them or any of them or any portion thereof. These are inaccurately described “trusts”, but are really “powers” conferred on the trustees to enable them to carry out the trusts effectively. In the seventh clause the trusts which were to be performed “out of the rents, issues, profits and income of the properties” were enumerated in the following order:
(i) To pay the litigation expenses;
(ii) To pay the management charges;
(iii) To pay the interests on secured debts;
(iv) To pay the interest on unsecured debts;
(v) To pay Rs. 200 a month to the settlor for personal expenses and Rs. 350 a month to his wife for household expenses, these sums to be raised to Rs. 250 and 500 respectively, after half the debts had been discharged;
(vi) To apply the balance, if any, to the liquidation of debts specified in one of the schedules or proved to the satisfaction of the trustees;
(vii)(a) To expend, after the liquidation of all the debts, “the sum of Rs. 500 per month for such “medical and educational charities within the” zemindari of the settlor as shall, with the approval “of the settlor, appear just to the trustees;” (b) to pay Rs. 500 per month to the wife of the settlor for household expenses; and (c) to pay the balance to the settlor.
The seventh clause further contained a provision that, on the death of the wife of the settlor during his lifetime, the amount made payable to her would become payable to the settlor himself until he remarried, when it would become payable to the newly married wife.
The eighth clause laid down that, after the liquidation of the debts, properties yielding an income of Rs. 1,000 a mouth would be transferred to the settlor absolutely, subject to the condition that if any of the properties were sold, the income of the properties to be so conveyed would be reduced proportionately.
The ninth clause provided that, after liquidation of debts, or, after the death of the settlor, whichever event might happen last, the trustees would transfer the residue of the properties to the wife absolutely “subject nevertheless to the payment of Rs. 500 per month for the charities hereinbefore mentioned and also subject to the transfer to the settlor and his heirs contemplated in clause 8.”
On the 1st April, 1915, the trustees by a deed to which the settlor and his wife were parties, sold the whole of the settled properties to his brother and coparcener for a consideration of five and a half lacs of rupees. The debts were discharged and the net value of the balance left was about two and a half lacs of rupees. The settlor died on the 10th August, 1918, leaving his widow, one son and two daughters. On the 25th November, 1918, the widow instituted the present proceedings against the trustees with a view to obtain the directions of the Court upon six matters. The two trustees as also the children (who were infants) and the Advocate-General of Bengal were joined as parties defendants. The chief question in controversy was whether the provision for payment of Rs. 500 a month to, charities was operative, and the Advocate-General was made a party with a view to enable him to support the validity of the charity. Mr. Justice Rankin has pronounced in favour of the charity, though not without considerable hesitation. The plaintiff has appealed to this Court and the only person joined as respondent is the Advocate-General, inasmuch as the only question raised by her in the appeal relates to the validity of the charitable trust. The trustees have not been joined, as respondents, apparently for the reason that, with their concurrence and at the request of the plaintiff, they have been relieved of their duties. The children also were not joined as parties to the appeal, but at the hearing counsel appeared for their guardian ad litem and supported the attack on the charitable trust made by their mother. In our opinion the trustees as also the infants should have been joined as parties to the appeal but in the view we take, it is possible for us to decide the question in issue, though the trustees are not represented before us.
To determine the true construction of the deed of settlement, it is useful to remember that regard must he had to the object and whole scope of the instrument, judged, if necessary, by reference to the surrounding circumstances; as was remarked by Page Wood, V.C in A.G v. Earl of Powis , in construing a deed, the Court has a right to look to all the circumstances which the donor had before him at the time, such circumstances to be proved not by extrinsic evidence but by evidence afforded by the instrument itself. Again as Lord Chelmsford, L.C observed in Monypenny v. Monypenny , referring to Sheppard's Touchstone, in the construction of all parts of all kinds of deeds, amongst the rules to be universally observed is “one that the construction be made upon the entire deed and that one part of it doth help to expound another, and that every word, if it may be, may take effect and none be rejected”. Lord Watson indicated the same view when he said that the deed must be read as a whole in order to ascertain the true meaning of its several clauses [per Lord Davey in N.E Rly. v. Lord Hastings ]. If we bear these principles in mind, we cannot hold in favour of the alleged charitable trust, merely upon the contents of the ninth clause which contemplates a transfer of the residue, after the liquidation of the debts, to the wife of the settlor, subject to the payment of Rs. 500 per month for the charities. Indeed, the clause refers to the charities as “hereinbefore mentioned.” Consequently, we must refer back to the seventh clause, where provision is first made for the charitable trust in these terms;
“after the liquidation and payment of the said debts, to spend the sum of Rs. 500 per month for such medical and educational charities within the zemindaries of the settlor as shall, with the approval of the settlor, appear just to the trustees”.
This clause leaves no room for doubt that the settlor intended that his debts should be discharged out of the income, and after they had been liquidated in that manner, the charitable trust would come into operation, the expenditure in that behalf to be incurred from the income of the estate. The trust was further subject to two conditions, namely, first, that the charities were to be carried out within the zemindaries of the settlor, and, secondly, that the charities were to be selected by the trustees and approved by the settlor himself. The events which have happened have rendered impossible the fulfilment of each and every one of these conditions. The zemindaries have all been sold by the trustees with the concurrence “of the settlor, the debts have not been discharged out of “the rents, issues, profits and income “of the zemindaries as intended by the settlor. On this account, the charities cannot be carried out within the zemindaries of the settlor, and possibly for this very reason, the charities were not selected by the trustees and approved by the settlor. In these circumstances, the case, in our opinion, falls within the principle that where a charitable gift is made upon a condition precedent, the gift fails if the condition is not satisfied, a principle of fundamental importance which has been repeatedly recognised by the Courts: Re Emson , De Themmines v. De Bonneval , A.G v. Craven , Cherry v. Mott , Chamberlayne v. Brockett . A strenuous endeavour however, has been made to validate the charity by invoking the and of the cy pres doctrine, namely, that when a general intention of charity is manifest, but the particular object of the bounty of the founder cannot be carried out literally, it must be carried into effect as nearly as possible, a doctrine which has been not only applied to protect charitable trusts at their birth but also to save them from an untimely end. Reference has been made in this connection to the judgment of Lord Eldon in Mills v. Farmer , where he followed his earlier decision in Moggridge v. Thackwell which had been meanwhile approved by the House of Lords; In that case Lord Eldon formulated three principles, namely, first, that the Court has not the power to make a will for the testator, but only to carry into execution that which he has made himself [cf. Hunter v. A.G ]; secondly, to give effect to a bequest in favour of charity, the Court will, if no executor has been appointed or if the executor named has died in the lifetime of the testator, supply the place of an executor and carry into effect that which in the case of individuals, must have failed altogether [cf. Mayor of Lyons v. A.G, Bengal) ]; and, thirdly, in all cases in which the testator has expressed an intention to give to charitable purposes, if that intention is declared absolutely, and nothing is left uncertain but the mode in which it is to be carried into effect, the intention will be carried into execution by the Court which will then supply the mode which also was left deficient. The true position, then, is that to attract the application of the cy pres doctrine, an absolute declaration of intention to give to charity must be established. The case before us fails to satisfy this essential test; we do not find, within the four corners of the deed taken in its entirety, what is called “a general charitable intent overlying the particular charitable bequest” or “an over-riding charitable intention,” [In re White's Trusts , Biscoe v. Jackson ]; the settlor has not manifested a desire to devote in any event a fund to charity so as to entitle the Court to hold that though his charitable intention cannot be literally carried out it will be carried into effect as nearly as possible. Here we have in substance a case, not of breakdown of the machinery required to carry out a validly created charitable trust, but rather of initial failure of the conditions essential to bring the trust into existence. This distinction is well illustrated by the decision of the House of Lords in Yates v. University College , where there was a bequest to the College to found a Professorship of Archaeology, with a statement of intention on the part of the testator, which he did not carry out, to make rules for the regulation of the Professorship. Lord Selborne, L.C, in the Court of Appeal, [Yates v. University College ], observed that “regulation in the case of a charity, is one thing, foundation is another,” and held that the words of immediate gift could not be narrowed by declaration of intention to do something in future. Lord Cairns, L.C, adopted the same view in the House of Lords, and held that if it could be found in the original bequest that there was something which required to be supplemented, so that one could not predicate of it that it was a complete bequest without the supplement, and if that supplement had not been applied or added, the bequest would have remained incomplete and consequently inoperative: cf. Grimond v. Grimond , Houston v. Burns . We hold, accordingly, that in the events which have happened in this case, the gift of Rs. 500 a month for medical and educational charities has not taken effect, as the conditions precedent have not been satisfied and have now become impossible. This conclusion renders unnecessary a detailed examination of the interesting question, whether or not the charitable gift, if otherwise valid, is vitiated by the rule against perpetuities; we need only say that there is considerable force in the contention that as the trust in favour of the charity did not vest immediately, but was subject to a condition, namely, liquidation of the debts from the income, which might not be fulfilled within the period prescribed by the law, the gift though charitable, would be affected by the rule against remoteness: Chamberlayne v. Brockett , Re White's Trusts , Re Bowen . We desire in conclusion to refer to an important aspect of the question in controversy, which does not appear to have been noticed up to this stage of the litigation. The case was argued in the Court below, as also in this Court, on the assumption that the doctrine of cy pres was applicable. There is, however, weighty authority for the proposition that the doctrine of cy pres is applied only in wills and not in deeds In Brundenell v. Elwes , Lord Kenyon, C.J, who as Master of the Rolls had carried the doctrine of cy pres to its farthest limits in Pitt v. Jackson observed as follows:
“The doctrine of cy pres goes to “the utmost verge of the taw, even in the construction of wills; and we must take care that it does not run wild. But it has never been applied to the construction of deeds. The cases cited were questions upon wills.” In the same case, when before Lord Eldon [Brundenell v. Elwes ], the Lord Chancellor said, “This case does not come near Pitt v. Jackson and “the other cases upon wills: first, as they are cases upon “wills, not deeds, to which this doctrine has not been applied; secondly, those cases have at least gone, as Lord Keynon observes, to the utmost verge of the law.”
The same view had been adopted by Lord Mansfield, by implication at least, in the case of Adams v. Adams . There under a power to appoint to children, the parent appointed by deed to the children for life, remainder to their sous in tail, remainder to their daughters in tail; the grand children were not objects of the power; but as the appointment was by deed, the doctrine of cy pres was not discussed (3 Property Lawyer 219, where opinions of Sir John Scott, Sir John Mitford and Sir Samuel Romily on this case are set out). In a case before Sir Edward Sugden, when Lord Chancellor of Ireland, [Slackpoole v. Stackpoole ], it was conceded that the doctrine of cy pres could not be applied to deeds, and in his Treatise on Powers (1861 p. 502) he adopted the view that the doctrine of cy pres is confined to wills, and does not extend to limitations by deed only, of either real or personal estate. Lewis in his Treatise on Perpetuity (1843, p. 440) enunciates the same principle and points out that Preston (Essay on Abstracts of Title, 1824, Vol. 2, 166, 167) seemed inclined to the opinion that the doctrine of cy pres was admissible in the construction of limitations by way of trust, in deeds, although not of similar limitations of legal estates; but no authority was adduced for this opinion which was hesitatingly expressed and was not confirmed by that of any other author or by any decided case. Lewis observes that the doctrine of “cy pres is in fact an offshoot of that general system of indulgence and laxity of construction as respects wills, which has long obtained in our Courts both of law and equity, but which has not been suffered to have place, in regard to the interpretation of and giving effect to instruments inter vivos.” The preponderance of authority is thus in favour of the view that the doctrine of cy pres is applicable only in wills and not in deeds. If this distinction between the construction of deeds and of wills is maintained, there can be no doubt that the charitable gift in the present instance must fail.
The result is that this appeal is allowed and the decree of the Court below set aside with regard to the trust in favour of medical and educational charities, which will be declared invalid and inoperative in the events that have happened. We further direct that all questions which involve a conflict of interest between the widow of the settlor and their children be left open, as there is no dispute amongst them at the present moment.
The costs of all the parties to this appeal including the costs of the Advocate-General will be paid out of the estate. If we apply to this case, the language of Lord Halsbuvy, L.C in Hunter v. Attorney-General , we may say that considering the fact that the Advocate-General was made a defendant, in a public capacity, as the guardian of a charitable fund, as this was supposed to be, and that he had the judgment of the Primary Court which asserted that it was a charity, it would have been contrary to his duty as Advocate-General if he had not appeared in support of the judgment of the Trial Court, which pronounced this to be a charity. In such circumstances, he ought to have his costs paid out of the estate. The costs of all the parties will be as between party and party, with liberty to them to apply, if necessary.
Fletcheb, J.:— I agree.
Attorney for the appellant: Jones & Co.
Attorney for the respondent: Kesteven.
Appeal allowed.
S.K.R
Alert