Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Municipal Council Of Kumbakonam v. Veeraperumal Padayachi

Madras High Court
Dec 22, 1914
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The plaintiff initiated a suit against the Municipality of Kumbakonam and a contractor, claiming an interest in a contract made by the contractor (the plaintiff's brother) with the Municipality. The plaintiff sought an injunction to prevent interference with work being performed under that contract and asked for a small amount of damages for past interference. The contractor (the person with whom the contract was made) was initially made a defendant because he was alleged to be in jail and unable to sue. The District Munsif later permitted an amendment of the plaint to make the contractor a plaintiff and added an alternative claim for damages (Rs. 312-8-0) in case an injunction could not be granted. The District Munsif decreed the amount against the Municipality and dismissed the suit as against the other parties. The Municipality appealed on grounds that notice required by Section 261 had not been given and that the suit was barred by limitation on the merits. The subordinate Judge dismissed the appeal, and this appeal followed.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the notice required by Section 261 was necessary in this suit and, if so, whether proper notice had been given.
  2. Whether the District Munsif erred in law by permitting the plaint to be amended (including substituting/adding parties).
  3. Whether the original plaintiff (a non-contracting family member) had locus standi to file the suit.
  4. Whether the suit was barred by limitation (including the effect of substitution/addition of parties on the starting point for limitation, and the applicability of Article 2 of the Limitation Act).

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • No proper notice under Section 261 of the relevant Municipal Act had been given prior to instituting the suit.
  • The District Munsif erred in permitting amendment of the plaint (implicitly challenging procedural regularity of substitution/addition of parties).
  • The first plaintiff (a person not party to the original contract) lacked locus standi to bring the suit.
  • The suit was barred by limitation on the merits (reliance on Article 2 of the Limitation Act and timing of amendments/substitutions).

Respondent's Arguments

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the respondent's legal arguments beyond the factual and procedural matters described and the Court's responses to the appellant's points.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Ranchordas Moorarji v. Municipal Commissioners of the City of Bombay Held that a suit on a specific contract is not within the scope of the statutory notice provision (i.e., not within the section requiring prior notice). The Court treated this decision as authoritative (the "25 Bombay" decision) and followed its ratio: breaches of specific contracts are distinct from acts done in execution of the municipal Act, so no notice under S.261 was necessary for such contractual claims.
Garton v. G.W. Railway Determined that an action for money had and received or on accounts stated was not within a statutory notice provision phrased "in pursuance of the Act or in execution of powers"; thus such actions did not require the notice. Cited as supporting authority (through English decisions) for excluding contractual or money-recovery actions from the notice requirement; used to illustrate the narrower reach of analogous words in statutory provisions.
Municipality of Faizpur v. Manak Dulab Shet Section in the Bombay Municipal Act in similar terms did not apply to suits for damages in respect of specific contracts (including claims for specific performance and damages). Used to support the proposition that S.261 (or its equivalents) does not extend to damages claims arising from specific contracts.
Mayandi v. McQuhae A suit for money due on a timber contract was held not to be within Section 168 of the Town Improvements Act, but that section used narrower language. Cited but the Court noted the narrower wording of that Act, and therefore treated it as of limited persuasive value for construing the broader wording of S.261.
Muthya Chettiar v. Secretary of State for India Interpreted a Salt Act provision ("for anything done or ordered to be done under this Act")—an example of narrower statutory wording. Referred to as another instance where narrower language made the case of limited relevance to the broader S.261 language; not relied on as a direct precedent for the present construction.
President of the Taluk Board of Sivaganga v. Narayanan Held that a suit for declaration of title and injunction was not within the scope of the notice section; used language that "the cases contemplated ... are suits for compensation and for damages" to justify giving public bodies time to tender amends. The Court observed that while the cited language is broad, the case did not decide that a suit for breach of a specific contract fell within the section; therefore it was not authority for the appellant's broader proposition.
Srinivasa v. Ratanasabapathi Case involved recovery from a Municipality of money deposited under a contract and was decided (without detailed reasons in report) not to be within S.261. The Court treated this decision as not being an authority against applying S.261 to certain contract claims, and noted its limited applicability to the present question.
Chunder Sikhur Bundopadhya v. Obhoy Churn Bagchi Garth, C.J., stated that the section is applicable only where the plaintiff claims damages or compensation for wrongful acts committed by the Commissioners or their officers in the exercise of statutory powers. The Court cited this language and observed that it cannot reasonably include suits for damages for breach of a specific contract; used as textual support for excluding contractual breaches from S.261.
Municipal Council of Kurnool v. Subanna Ghetty Addressed a challenge to a decree on the ground that a notice to the Council was defective; the report references Eales v. Municipal Commissioners of Madras (a tort case). The Court concluded this case did not support the appellant since it either concerned tortious claims or did not decide the contractual point; it was thus not persuasive authority for extending S.261 to the present contractual damages claim.
Eales v. Municipal Commissioners of Madras Was a suit in tort (referenced in other cases). Cited by other reported cases; treated as an example of a tortious action to which notice provisions were applicable, distinguishing it from contractual claims.
Syed Ameer Saheb v. Venkatarama Construction of Section 156 of the Local Boards Act (similar to S.261) adopting the language that the section applies only to suits for compensation for wrongful acts committed under colour of the Act. The Court relied on this Court's language to support the view that S.261-type provisions apply to wrongful acts under statutory authority and not to ordinary breaches of contract; it reinforced the conclusion that no notice was necessary here.
Iswaram Pillai v. Taregan Held that a stranger to a contract, even if entitled to a benefit under it, is not entitled to sue on the contract. The Court considered this authority in assessing locus standi but found, on the facts found by the lower court, that the original plaintiff was effectively the person who carried out the contract and that the actual contracting family member had been made a party; hence the objection failed.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court first analysed the language and purpose of Section 261. Although the statutory phrases "done or purporting to be done in pursuance or execution or intended execution of this Act" and "in respect of any alleged neglect or default in the execution of this Act" are wide, the Court rejected an expansive reading that would bring ordinary contractual breaches within the section's scope. The Court considered the following lines of reasoning and authority:

  • Textual indicator: Sub-section (2) speaks of the Council or persons having "tendered sufficient amends" which the Court observed is more naturally associated with tortious wrongs (e.g., trespass) than with breaches of contract where the natural phrase is "compensation" or "damages." This suggested the section was intended to govern tortious/statutory-wrong situations rather than private contract disputes.
  • Precedent: The Court reviewed and relied on decisions from Bombay, England, and this Court which, taken together, supported excluding suits upon specific contracts from the notice requirement. In particular, the Court followed Ranchordas Moorarji v. Municipal Commissioners (the "25 Bombay" decision) and considered English precedents such as Garton v. G.W. Railway to be analogous and persuasive on the construction of similar words.
  • Distinguishing narrower enactments: Decisions based on statutes with narrower wording were noted but not followed for construing the broader words of S.261. Thus cases founded on narrower statutory formulations were of limited persuasive value.
  • Consistency with this Court: The Court cited Syed Ameer Saheb v. Venkatarama where a provision similar to S.261 was construed to apply only to compensation for wrongful acts done under colour of the Act; the present construction was held consistent with that approach.

On these bases the Court concluded that the impugned interference that gave rise to the damages claim was a breach of a specific contract (or a wrongful act in relation to the contract) and not an act done in the execution of the statutory municipal powers or a neglect in executing the Act; therefore Section 261 did not require prior notice and the appellant's notice objection failed.

Concerning the amendment of the plaint and substitution/addition of parties, the Court held that under the procedural rules (Order 6) the District Munsif had full power to allow the amendments made, and there was no error in permitting the contractor-defendant to be made a plaintiff.

On limitation, the appellant argued Article 2 of the Limitation Act applied ("suit for compensation for doing an act alleged to be in pursuance of any enactment"). The Court found the same construction adopted for S.261 applied to Article 2: the present suit was not one "for an act done in pursuance or execution of this Act." The Court therefore did not need to resolve the technical point whether limitation should run from the date the 3rd defendant became the 2nd plaintiff or from the original filing date, observing that Section 22 of the Limitation Act (as amended) governed substitutions and had particular application to cases where a defendant is made a plaintiff; the Court considered the limitation objection to fail on the construction point.

Finally, on locus standi, the Court considered Iswaram Pillai v. Taregan (that a stranger to the contract may not sue) but accepted the findings of the lower appellate court that the original plaintiff was the undivided brother of the contractor and the person who actually carried out the contract. Because the actual contracting family member was made a party in the original plaint, the original plaintiff was entitled to bring the suit; after substitution (making the contractor a plaintiff) there was no need to join other family members. Thus the locus standi objection failed.

Holding and Implications

DISMISSED — The appeal is dismissed with costs.

Direct consequences and holdings:

  • The Court held that Section 261 (the statutory notice provision under consideration) does not require prior notice in respect of a suit for damages arising from breach of a specific contract of the kind before the Court; consequently, the appellant's objection based on defective or absent notice failed.
  • The District Munsif did not err in permitting amendment of the plaint under the procedural rules (Order 6), and substitution/addition of the contractor as a plaintiff was permissible.
  • The limitation objection based on Article 2 of the Limitation Act failed on the construction adopted for S.261/Article 2; the Court did not need to decide finely whether limitation ran from the later substitution date because Section 22 of the Limitation Act governed substituted parties in the manner described.
  • The objection as to the original plaintiff's locus standi was rejected on the factual finding that he was the undivided brother who carried out the contract and that the contracting party was properly joined; after substitution the necessary parties were before the Court.

The opinion applies existing authorities and statutory interpretation to the facts and dismisses the appeal; it does not purport to establish a novel legal principle beyond applying and following prior decisions construing comparable statutory provisions.

Additional procedural note: Spencer, J. concurred in the result and reasons; the appeal was dismissed (order recorded).

Show all summary ...

The Judgment of the Court was delivered by

Napier, J.:— In this case the plaintiff brought a suit originally against the Municipality of Kumbakonam and another, a contractor, claiming to be interested in a contract made by his brother with the defendant Municipality, which contract was still in force, asking for an injunction against the defendants to restrain them from interfering with the work being done under the contract, and for a small amount of damages for extra expense to which the contractor had been put owing to past interference, the person with whom the contract was made not being-joined as plaintiff but being made a defendant on the ground that he was at the time in jail and unable to bring the suit himself. Subsequently, leave was granted by the District Munsif to amend the plaint and to make the contractor-defendant a plaintiff. This was done and a claim, alternative to that for an injunction, in the form of a claim for damages for Rs. 312-8-0 was added in the view that possibly the conditions had changed in such a manner that an injunction would not or could not be granted. The District Munsif decreed the amount against the Municipality and dismissed the suit against the other parties, holding that they were in no way responsible for the damage. The Municipality appealed on the ground that notice required by S. 261 had not been given and that the suit was barred by limitation on the merits. The subordinate Judge dismissed the appeal.

2. The points taken in this appeal are that no proper notice under S; 261 had been given, that the District Munsif erred in law in permitting the plaint to be amended, that the first plaintiff had no locus standi to file the suit and that the suit is barred by limitation. On the question of notice, various points were raised which are only important if notice is necessary; but, I am satisfied that S. 261 does not require notice in a suit of this nature. It provides that no action shall be brought against the Council or any Councillor or any servant or any person acting under the directions of the Council, Councillor or servant, on account of any act done or purporting to be done in pursuance or execution or intended execution of this Act or in respect of any alleged neglect or default in the execution of this Act, until the expiration of one month after notice in writing has been delivered at the office of the Council or at the place of the abode of the Councillor or such person, explicitly stating the cause of action, the nature of the relief sought, the amount of compensation claimed and other particulars. Sub-S. (2) provides that if such Council or person to whom notice has been given has before action commenced tendered sufficient amends to the plaintiff, such plaintiff shall not recover more than the amount so tendered; sub-S. (3) provides that except in the case of a suit for recovery of immoveable property or declaration of title thereto, the action shall be commenced within six-months after the accrual of the cause of action; and sub-S. (4) provides that no action shall be brought against the Chairman on account of any act done in pursuance or execution or intended execution of this Act or in respect of any alleged default on his part in the execution of this Act, if such act was done or if such default was made in good faith, but that such actions shall be brought against the Council.

3. The suit in this case was one for damages in respect of a contract entered into between the Municipal Council and the contractor for the removal of the rubbish. The act alleged to have been done was interference by the Council through its servants with the contractor, which interference prevented his collecting and disposing of at a profit the rubbish, the subject of the contract. The damages are estimated at the value of the manure which he was unable to collect and so dispose of. The contract is not of such a character as must necessarily arise out of the statutory powers given to a Municipal body although, of course, apart from the Act, the Municipality would have no existence and would, therefore, be unable to enter into such a contract.

4. The question now is, whether the interference by the Municipality giving rise to the breach is “done or purports to be done in pursuance or execution of this Act” or whether the action is brought in respect of “alleged neglect or default in the execution of this Act.”

5. The words used are wide and it may be said are also vague, for, in one sense if a statutory body does any act or makes any contract it may be said that act was done or contract made in execution of the act. But in my opinion this reading of the words is not what is contemplated by the Legislature. Some slight indication of the meaning may be gathered from sub-S. (2) which speaks of the Councillor or servant having tendered sufficient amends to the plaintiff. It would be a natural use of the word “amends” to apply it to any tortious act injuring a person or his property, such as for instance, trespass. But the word seems inapplicable to breaches of contract where the natural and legal phrase is compensation or damages. This point alone would not be sufficient to decide the case, but there appears to be fairly uniform authority both in England and in India for exclusion of contracts of this nature from the purview of the section.

6. In Ranchordas Moorarji v. Municipal Commissioners of the City of Bombay(1), this point was considered and it was held as settled law that a suit on a specific contract was not within the section. Reference is made to the case of Garton v. G.W Railway(2). The action was on a contract, the plaintiff suing for money had and received and on accounts settled. Earle, J., held that the notice given under the section was bad. In the Court of Exchequer Chamber the point was taken that no notice was required and it was held by the Court that an action for money had and received or upon accounts stated was not within the section which provided for notice for anything “done or omitted in pursuance of the Act or in execution of powers or authorities made, given or directed in, by or under the Act.” It has to be noted that the section does not contain the words “in respect of any alleged neglect or default in the execution of the Act”, but the words considered by the Court were “in pursuance of the Act or in execution of the powers under the Act”, which words govern the additional words in S. 261 “alleged neglect or default.” The ratio of the decision in Ranchordas Moorarji v. Municipal Commissioners for the City of Bombay is stated by the Chief Justice as follows: “Conduct leading to the action is a wrongful act or omission under the contract, as distinct from one in the execution of the Act, and it is the breach of a specific contract that is the occasion of the right to sue.”

7. Municipality of Faizpur v. Manak Dulab Shet(3) was a suit for specific performance of an alleged contract by the Municipality under which the plaintiff permitted the Municipality to pull down some constructions, they undertaking to rebuild them; there was a breach by the Municipality and damage was sought in addition to the suit for specific performance. It was held that Section 48 of the Bombay Municipal Act of 1884, which was in the same terms as Section 527 of the Bombay Municipal Act of 1888 considered by the Chief Justice, did not apply to suits for damages in respect of specific contracts.

8. Reliance is also placed on Mayandi v. McQuhae(4), a suit for money due on a timber contract. It was held that the suit was not within Section 168 of the Town Improvements Act of 1871; but that section is in much narrower words—a suit against the Commissioners, etc., for anything done under the Act—and it would hardly be safe to rely on the construction of such words as an authority for the construction of S. 261. The same objection applies to another case relied on, Muthya Chettiar v. Secretary of State for India(5). The Act considered there was the Salt Act IV of 1889, the words of S. 87 being “for anything done or ordered to be done under this Act.” Two cases relied on by the appellant were President of the Taluk Board of Sivaganga v. Narayanan(6) and Srinivasa v. Ratanasabapathi(7). The first was a suit for an injunction restraining the Taluq Board from interfering with a wall built by the plaintiff. The Court held that a suit for declaration of title and for an injunction was not within the scope of the section, but used the following words: “the cases contemplated in that section are suits for compensation and for damages and the principle is to allow public bodies time for tender of amends to parties to avoid litigation.” The words “compensation and damages” are certainly wide enough to cover suits for breach of contract, but they can be applied to the narrower limits laid down in the 25 Bombay case and certainly it did not decide that a suit will lie for breach of a specific contract. The case at page 474 was a suit to recover from a Municipality money deposited for the due performance of a contract. The Court decided without giving reasons that the suit was not within S. 261, quoting the words “the cases contemplated in that section are suits for compensation and damages.” It has to be noted that this was a suit on a contract but for money had and received under the contract. It is, therefore, not an authority against the application of the section to a suit for damages for breach, but at the same time the words cannot be held necessarily applicable to such suits. These cases, therefore, are no authority for the appellant's proposition. The case of Chunder Sikhur Bundopadhya v. Obhoy Churn Bagchi(8), quoted by the learned Judges, is one in which Garth, C.J, decided that “the section…is applicable only in those cases where the plaintiff claims damages or compensation for some wrongful act committed by the Commissioners or their officers, in the exercise…of their statutory powers.” These words can hardly include a suit for damages for breach of a contract.

9. The last case that is relied on is Municipal Council of Kurnool v. Subanna Ghetty(9). In that case the point was taken in a petition under S. 25 of the Act IX of 1887, that a certain notice sent to the Council was defective, and the High Court was asked to set aside the decree obtained by the plaintiff. It does not appear from the report on what basis the loss or damage that was sustained was ascertained. But reference was made to the case of Eales v. Municipal Commissioners of Madras(10), which was a suit in tort. So far as it appears, therefore, this case is no authority in favour of the appellant. Even if the case was one on contract, the point was not decided as the Court declined to interfere in revision when the objection to the notice was then raised for the first time.

10. As against the inference sought to be made from the language of the Court in the above cases, there is the language used by this Court in Syed Ameer Saheb v. Venkatarama(11) where in construing Section 156 of the Local Hoards Act of 1884, which is on similar terms to S. 261 under construction, the Court adopts the language of Garth, C.J, in Chunder Sikhur Bundopadhya v. Obhoy Churn Bagchi above referred to, that the section is only applicable to suits for compensation claimed for wrongful acts committed under colour of the Act. It can hardly be claimed that this language is applicable to suits for damages for breach of contract. On a careful consideration of the authorities I have come to the conclusion that there is no conflict between the view taken by this Court and that held in Bombay and on the words of the section and on the view taken in England on analogous words, I am satisfied that the decision in 25 Bombay is correct and should be followed by me. I, therefore, hold that no notice was necessary.

11. On the second point it is clear that under the rules of O. 6, the District Munsif had full power to allow the amendments. The point as to limitation is that the amendment of the plaint was made more than 90 days after the alleged breach by the defendants and that, therefore, the suit is barred by Article 2 of the Limitation Act, the language of which is “suit for compensation for doing an act alleged to be in pursuance of any enactment.” The reasons above given for holding that this suit is not one for an act done in pursuance or execution of this Act or in respect of any alleged neglect or default in the execution of this act apply equally to the construction, of this Article. It is, therefore, unnecessary to decide whether the date when the 3rd defendant became the 2nd plaintiff should be the starting point of limitation or the date on which the plaint was originally filed, but it would appear that Section 22 of the Limitation Act is conclusive on the point. The old Act which makes the date from which the limitation runs, where a new plaintiff is substituted or added, the date when he was so made a party, has been amended and the section has no application where a defendant is made a plaintiff, as has been done in this case. The last question is whether the original plaintiff had any cause of action. Reliance is placed on Iswaram Pillai v. Taregan(12), where it was held that a stranger to the contract, although entitled to a benefit under it, is not entitled to sue. The lower Appellate Court has found that the first plaintiff was the undivided brother of the second plaintiff, the actual party to the contract and that he was the person who actually carried out the contract. He was as such entitled to bring the suit, provided that the actual contracting member of the family was made a party. This was done in the plaint as originally framed. After the 3rd defendant had become the 2nd plaintiff there was no necessity to join the other members of the family as the party in whose name the contract was made was entitled to bring the suit. This objection, therefore, fails. This second appeal is dismissed with costs.

Spencer, J.:— I concur.

S.N.R.K

12. Appeal dismissed.