- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Johabaj Khan v. Srikrishna Dey
Factual and Procedural Background
The appeal concerns whether a landlord (described as a Lakhiraj bajiaftidar in a temporarily settled estate in Balasore) is entitled to eject persons recorded as chandnadars after service of notices to quit. The plaintiffs' title as landlords was challenged by the defendants, but both the trial Court and the District Judge found for the plaintiffs on title and on the question of service of the notices; those findings were no longer disputed. The defendants were recorded in successive Records of Rights as chandnadars, and for the current settlement their rent had been raised from Re. 1 to Re. 1-4-0.
The trial Court decreed the suit in favour of the landlords on the grounds that (i) the landlord prima facie had a right to all lands within his mahal or tenancy; (ii) the defendants failed to show any custom or usage entitling them to remain against the landlord's will; (iii) the defendants were tenants at will whose rights had been terminated by notices served on them.
The District Judge on appeal similarly found no reliable evidence of any local custom or usage conferring permanence or occupancy rights on the defendants and upheld the trial Court's decree. The case was then placed before a larger Bench of this Court because earlier decisions (notably by Das, J.) holding that the onus lay entirely on the chandnadar to establish a right to remain required reconsideration in the light of the Orissa Tenancy Act.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the landlord is entitled to eject a chandnadar after service of a notice to quit.
- Who bears the onus of proving the local custom or usage that regulates the ejectment of a chandnadar under the Orissa Tenancy Act — the landlord (plaintiff) or the chandnadar (defendant)?
Arguments of the Parties
Appellants' (Defendants') Arguments
- The defendants (appellants) challenged the landlords' title and denied the service of the notices to quit (both matters were found against them by the lower courts and were no longer disputed on appeal).
- They advanced contentions of permanency and of a right of occupancy, relying before the District Judge on authorities referred to in the text (for example, a citation rendered in the opinion as 17 Cal 144 and S.6, Act 10 of 1859).
Respondents' (Landlords') Arguments
- Mr. Manohar Lal, for the landlords-respondents, relied on authorities (including a Privy Council decision reported as 47 Mad 337) supporting the general proposition that when a tenant claims permanent tenancy in a suit by his landlord to eject him, the onus of proving permanence lies on the tenant.
- He also argued that Section 74 of the Orissa Tenancy Act (protecting chandnadars from ejectment for arrears of rent) does not prevent the landlord from ejecting the chandnadar on other grounds in the absence of proof of local custom or usage.
- He pointed out textual and historical aspects of the Act and of prior settlement practice (for example, that the term “chandnadar” does not occur in the first clause of a certain section) and cited instances where such tenancies had been dealt with in earlier decisions (e.g., Rowland, J. in 14 PLT 688).
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| 3 Cal 696 (Garth, C.J.) | Terms of a holding are a matter of contract; absent express agreement, a tenant let into possession and paying rent is a tenant at will or from year to year and liable to be ejected by reasonable notice unless local custom is proved. | The Court cited this passage to support the general proposition that, in absence of an express agreement or proved custom, a tenant (including a chandnadar, if nothing more were known) would be liable to ejectment on notice. |
| 43 Mad 567 (Judicial Committee; Sir Lawrence Jenkins) | Permanence is not a universal incident of an under-ryot's holding; when claimed it must be established by proof (by custom, contract or title). | The Court used the principle to show that claims of permanence must be proved and cannot be assumed; applied in considering what a chandnadar must prove if resisting ejectment. |
| 16 Cal 223 (Lordi Hobhouse) | When possession is proved, it is for the defendant to show that such possession leads to inference of a perpetual tenancy. | Quoted to explain the general rule that once the landlord proves his title, the onus shifts to the defendant to prove a non-precarious tenancy, in ordinary cases. |
| 47 Mad 337 (Privy Council) | Where a tenant sets up a defence of permanent tenancy in a suit by his landlord to eject him, the onus of proving such right is upon the tenant. | Relied on by the landlords' counsel and discussed by the Court as part of the body of authorities that generally place the onus on the tenant when permanence is claimed. |
| 1 Cuttack LT 5 and 1 Cuttack LT 8 (Das, J. — 1925) | Expressed the view that the whole onus lies upon the chandnadar who resists ejectment to establish a right to remain on the land either under contract or under custom. | These decisions were identified as requiring reconsideration by a larger Bench; the Court declined to accept Das, J.'s treatment of chandnadars under the Orissa Tenancy Act and held the onus shifts to the landlord in ejectment proceedings concerning chandnadars. |
| 149 IC 805 (James, J.) | Discussed the classification of two classes of chandnadars corresponding to Clauses 1 and 2 of Section 236 of the Orissa Tenancy Act; noted inconsistency of viewing chandnadars as mere tenants-at-will with certain statutory protections. | Cited to support the proposition that the Act confers some measure of permanence on chandnadars and that the view of them as mere tenants-at-will is inconsistent with provisions like Section 74. |
| 1 Cal LJ 138 and 33 Cal 630 (decisions under Section 181 of the Bengal Tenancy Act) | Examples where general expressions like “incidents of a holding” led to difficulties; these decisions were disapproved by the Privy Council. | Referred to when discussing interpretive caution about broad statutory phrases such as “incidents of the tenancy”; the Court used this to support careful reading of the Orissa Tenancy Act. |
| 13 Pat 254 (Privy Council) | Disapproved the earlier decisions (1 Cal LJ 138 and 33 Cal 630) that misapplied broad statutory language. | Referenced to show that courts must be cautious in interpreting phrases like “incidents of the tenancy”; supported the Court's interpretive approach. |
| 14 PLT 688 (Rowland, J.) | Dealt with an actual instance of a chandnadar tenancy. | Noted by the Court as an instance where the term “chandnadar” was considered in earlier jurisprudence. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court proceeded with a structured analysis rooted in established principles and the specific provisions of the Orissa Tenancy Act:
- Burden on title and ordinary burden-shifting: The Court reiterated the settled rule that in an ejectment action where the defendant is in possession the plaintiff must first prove his title; once the landlord proves his title, the burden ordinarily shifts to the defendant to establish that his tenancy is not precarious but entitles him to continue in occupation (citing authorities such as 3 Cal 696 and 16 Cal 223).
- Nature of chandna tenancy: The Court examined the historical understanding of chandnadar tenancies (including Maddox's and Dalziel's settlement reports) and the statutory treatment under the Orissa Tenancy Act of 1913. The Act expressly includes chandnadars as tenants for its purposes and defines them (Section 3(3)), but Clause 2 of Section 236 states that, save as otherwise provided, the incidents of a chandnadar's tenancy shall be regulated by local custom or usage and the rent is liable to reassessment on revenue revisions.
- Statutory indicators of permanence and protection: The Court highlighted that Section 74 explicitly protects chandnadars from ejectment for arrears of rent (their tenure is liable to sale in execution but not ejectment for arrears). The Act elsewhere treats incidents of tenancy and ejectment for other tenant classes by prescribing specified grounds for ejectment. These statutory features indicate that chandnadars enjoy a degree of permanence and protection that cannot be disregarded.
- Interpretation of Clause 2, Section 236 and the allocation of onus: Given that the Act (a) includes chandnadars among tenants, (b) expressly protects them from ejectment for arrears (S.74), and (c) leaves other incidents to local custom or usage, the Court concluded that the legislature intended that ejectment of chandnadars be governed by local custom or usage. Because of that statutory context, the ordinary evidential shift (from plaintiff proving title to defendant proving permanence) must be adjusted: the onus of proving the local custom or usage that would permit ejectment of a chandnadar lies on the landlord where the landlord seeks ejectment.
- Rejection of prior, narrower approach: The Court expressly disagreed with the view taken by Das, J. in earlier Cuttack decisions that the entire onus always lies on the chandnadar to establish a right to remain. The present Bench held that, under the Orissa Tenancy Act, a landlord cannot eject a chandnadar merely by proving title and serving notice; he must also prove the local custom or usage permitting such ejectment.
- Application to the facts: As to the evidence in the present case, the only material on the question of local custom was a statement from one defendant who said he could not say if chandna tenants could be ejected at the landlord's will. The lower courts had found no reliable evidence of a custom allowing eviction. Since the Court held the onus of proving such a custom lay on the landlord and the landlord had not proved it, the landlord's claim failed.
Holding and Implications
Holding: APPEAL ALLOWED; SUIT DISMISSED WITH COSTS.
The Court held that a landlord is not entitled to eject a chandnadar except when the landlord proves the local custom or usage that permits such ejectment. While the ordinary evidential rule places an initial burden on the plaintiff to prove title and then shifts to the defendant to show permanence, the statutory scheme of the Orissa Tenancy Act (notably Section 74 and the inclusion of chandnadars among tenants) requires that, in ejectment proceedings against chandnadars, the landlord must establish the relevant local custom or usage supporting ejectment.
Direct consequences for the parties in this case: because the landlord failed to prove any local custom or usage authorising ejectment, the suit for ejectment was dismissed and the appeal by the defendants was allowed with costs in all Courts.
Note: The Court expressly disagreed with prior Cuttack decisions (Das, J.) that placed the whole evidential burden on the chandnadar to prove permanence; instead it treated the proof of local custom permitting ejectment as a matter for the landlord to establish in the circumstances governed by the Orissa Tenancy Act.
Dhavle, J.:— The question in this appeal is whether the landlord, a Lakhiraj bajiaftidar in a temporarily settled estate in Balasore, is entitled to eject a chandnadar after service of a notice to quit. The plaintiffs' title as landlords was challenged by the defence, but has been concurrently found against by the trial Court and the District Judge on appeal, and there is no further dispute about it. The defence also denied service of notice, but this too has been concurrently found against the defendants appellants, and there is no further dispute about it. The defendants have been recorded in successive Record of Rights (commencing with the Provincial Settlement) as chandnadars, and for the current settlement their rent has been raised from Re. 1 to Re. 1-4-0 (apparently in accordance with para. 126 of Mr. Dalziel's Final Report on the Revision Settlement of Orissa, 1922–1932). The trial Court decreed the suit on the ground that the landlord prima facie has a right to all the lands included in his mahal or tenancy, that the defendants have totally failed to show that by custom or usage they are entitled to remain on the land against the will of the landlord, that they are tenants at will, and that their rights have been terminated by the notices served on them.
2. The District Judge on appeal found that there was absolutely no reliable evidence of any local custom or usage by which the defendants, who had appealed to him, could acquire any permanent right, and after negativing the contentions of parmanency and of a right of occupancy that were urged before him on the authority of 17 Cal 144(1), and S. 6, Act 10 of 1859, upheld the decree of the trial Court. There was then a second appeal to this Court, and James, J., before whom it was first placed, considered, doubtless in view of the general importance of the question raised, that the matter should be heard by a larger Bench. The appeal thus came before Fazal Ali and Varma, JJ., who were of opinion that the view taken in 1925 by Das J., (sitting with Poster J.,) in 1 Cuttack LT 5(2), and in 1 Cuttack LT 8(3), that the whole onus lies upon the chandnadar who resists the landlord's action for ejectment to establish a right to remain on the land either under contract or under custom requires consideration by a larger Bench in view of the intention and scheme of the Orissa Tenancy Act, and of certain observations in later decisions. The case has accordingly been placed before us for decision. Now, there can be no doubt or controversy that in an action of ejectment, when the defendant is admittedly in possession of the land in dispute, the onus is initially upon the plaintiff to prove his title thereto. It is also clear that when the plaintiff has proved his title as landlord the burden shifts to the defendant, if he claims to be a tenant to prove that the tenancy is not precarious but entitles him to continue in occupation. A chandna tenancy, as will be seen presently, is an essentially non-agricultural tenancy, and if nothing further were known about it, the tenant will have to be considered as holding from year to year, and liable to be ejected by a proper notice to quit. In an action of ejectment from homestead land decided before the passing of the Bengal Tenancy Act, in 3 Cal 696(4), Garth, C.J, said at p. 699:
The truth is, that the terms of a holding, as between landlord and tenant, must always be matter of contract, either expressed or implied. If they enter into an express agreement of tenancy, either written or verbal, such agreement generally defines the terms of the holding. If, on the other hand, a tenant is let into possession without any express agreement, and pay rent, he becomes a tenant at will, or from year to year, or, in other words, holds by the landlord's permission upon what may be the usual terms of such a holding by the general law, or by local custom, aud in such a case, he is of course liable to be ejected by a reasonable notice to quit. Occasionally there are local customs by which special terms and incidents are engrafted upon the contract of tenancy; but the existence of the custom in such cases must be a matter of proof and no Judge has a right to act upon such customs unless their existence is duly established. In this case no such custom is even suggested, and as there was no express agreement of tenancy and no evidence of its origin, the defendants must be considered as holding from year to year, and liable to be ejected by a proper notice to quit.
3. In such circumstances the chandnadar, without an express agreement, could only resist the ejectment by proving a custom entitling him to continue in occupation. As Sir Lawrence Jenkins observed in, delivering the opinion of the Judicial Committee in 43 Mad 567(5) in an action of ejectment from ryoti land brought by a Government pattadar permanence is not a universal and integral-incident on an under-ryot's holding; if claimed it must be established. This may be done by proving a custom, a contract or a title, and possibly by other means.
4. It was also pointed out in that decision that if this is not established, the defendant who does not any longer dispute the plaintiffs's title or the notice by which he purported to terminate the defendant's tenancy and who, according, to the Record of Rights holds under if not from, the plaintiff must fail, unless, as required by Section 101 of the Evidence Act, he proves the existence of a right to continue in occupation of the land. In actions of this kind it is for the tenant-defendant to show why the landlord may not recover his property, and as Lordi Hobhouse said in 16 Cal 223(6),
It is not the business of the plaintiff to explain, the possession; it is the business of the defendants to show that it leads to the inference of a perpetual tenancy,
or it may be added of a tenancy that cannot be terminated by a notice to quit at the will of the landlord. Mr. Manohar Lal who appears for the landlords-respondents has also brought to our notice another Privy Council decision, 47 Mad 337(7), which was further referred to by Das, J., in the decisions of 1925 and in which the same view was thus expressed.
It cannot now be doubted that when a tenant of lands in India, in a suit by his landlord to eject him from them, sets up a defence that he has a right of permanent tenancy in the lands, the onus of proving that he has such right is upon the tenant.
5. It is therefore beyond question that the onus at this stage would lie upon the tenant, but this is by no means an end of the matter. For clearly the position must be further examined in the light of the status of the chandnadar under the Orissa Tenancy Act. As to the origin and nature of the chandna tenancy, there is an oft-quoted passage from Maddox's Report on the Settlement of Orissa (para. 327) which says:
Tenants other than the khushbash or respectable thani and resident raiyats have always paid rent for their homestead lands. In the case of the cultivating classes such lands were generally part of the pahi holding, but the shopkeepers, artisans, and labouring classes, who having no arable land in the village, pay rent for homestead lands only, are called chandnadars' and their tenure chandna pahi raiyats also, who having their home in one village hold also house or homestead in other, are sometimes known as chandnadars of the latter village…. At the last settlement chandnadars were given leases securing to them fixity of rent for the term of settlement, and the incidents of the tenure do not materially differ from those of thani raiyats (which are found in para. 320 of the Report) except that they are governed by the Contract Act and not by Act 10 of 1859.
6. This points to two classes of chandnadars corresponding to Cls. 1 and 2, Section 236 of the Orissa Tenancy Act, as was said by James, J., in 149 IC 805(8), a decision to which I was a party. Incidentally, Mr. Manohar Lal points out that the term “chandnadar” does not occur in the first clause of the section; but an actual instance of such a tenancy was dealt with by Rowland, J., in 14 PLT 688(9). The second class of chandnadars, shop-keepers, artisans, and labouring classes who, having no arable lands in the village pay rent for their homestead lands only, now falling within Cl. 2 of the section, were essentially non-agricultural tenants, and were therefore at first excluded from the protection given to agricultural tenants by the Rent Act of 1859 and its modifications which were in force in Orissa down to 1913. The assets (as they are commonly called in revenue and other settlements) of such tenancies were however as they still are, included in the amounts which the proprietors have to collect and on which their revenue is assessed. For the first time the Orissa Tenancy Act of 1913 includes chandnadars in an agricultural Tenancy Act by providing in S. 4 that there shall be for the purposes of this Act, the following classes of tenants, namely,
(1) tenure holders,… (2) raiyats, (3) under raiyats….(4) chanadars,….and
the term ‘chandnadar’ itself being defined in Section 3(3) of the Act as meaning a person holding land which has been recorded as chandna in the course of a settlement of land revenue and for which a rent has been fixed for the term of that settlement; and also the successors in interest of such person.
7. Though the chandnadar is thus a tenant for the purpose of the Act, Cl. 2, S. 236, lays down that:
Save as otherwise expressly provided in this Act, the incidents of the tenancy of a chandnadar shall be regulated by local custom or usage and his rent shall be liable to re-assessment on each revision of a land revenue settlement.
8. General expressions, like “the incidents of a tenancy,” sometimes lead to difficulties, as actually happened under Section 181 of the Ben. Ten. Act, in 1 Cal LJ 138(10) and 33 Cal 630(11), decisions which were disapproved by the Privy Council in 13 Pat 254(12). At the same time it would be surprising if the landlord's right to eject the tenant or the corresponding liability of the tenant to ejectment—if it is to arise in any circumstances at all—should in an agricultural tract be excluded from the incidents of the tenancy; and the Orissa Tenancy Act shows clearly enough that this right or liability was regarded as one of the incidents of tenancies. For the three classes of tenants that are mentioned along with chandnadars in Section 4 of the Act as tenants for the purposes of the Act are all governed by specific provisions in the Act as regards ejectment, and in more than one instance the matter is expressly dealt with as an incident of the tenancy. Thus, section 11 which occurs in the chapter relating to tenure-holders and provides that a holder of a permanent tenure shall not be ejected by his landlord, except on the ground…. is the first section in a bundle of sections headed “Other incidents of tenures”. S. 21 which provides that a raiyat holding at a rent or rate of rent fixed in perpetuity shall not be ejected by his landlord except on the ground…. is described in the margin as “incidents of holding at fixed rates”. S. 29 which gives “protection from eviction, except on specified grounds” by providing that “an occupaincy raiyat shall not be ejected by his landlord from his holding, except in execution of a decree for ejectment passed on the ground……” occurs in a bundle of sections headed. “Incidents of Occupancy Right”. Other sections governing and restricting the ejectment of tenants are 8, 52 which provides that a non-occupancy raiyat shall, subject to the provisions of this Act, be liable to ejectment on one or more of the following grounds; and not otherwise……
and S. 57 which impose “Restrictions on ejectment, of under-raiyats” by providing that “an under-raiyat shall not be ejected by his landlord except…”. For the ejectment of chandnadars, regarded as an incident of the tenancy, we have first to look to express provision in the Act and then to local custom or usage. The only express provision to which our attention has been drawn is found in S. 74, which provides that:
When a tenant is a parmanent tenure-holder, a bajiaftidar, a raiyat holding at fixed rates, a chandnadar or an occupancy raiyat, he shall not be liable to ejectment for arrears of rent, but his tenure or holding shall be liable to sale in execution of a decree for the rent thereof and the rent shall be a first charge thereon.
9. This is only a negative provision and saves the chandnadar, along with tenants possessing substantial interests and ranging from permanent tenure-holders to occupancy-raiyats, from ejectment for, arrears of rent, unlike the other tenants dealt within S. 75 as regards ejectment or this ground, and in Ss. 52 and 57 as regards ejectment generally. The landlord's right to eject a chandnadar is thus, unlike his right to eject other classes of tenants, not fully dealt within the Act, but has been left, subject to S. 74, to “be regulated by local custom or usage”. At the same time we do know from the Act that a chandnadar has his rent fixed for the term of the current Land Revenue Settlement, that this rent is liable to reassessment on each revision of such a settlement, that the term chandnadar includes “the successors-in-interest of such person”, and that the interest of a Chandnadar is not extinguished by a suit, decree and execution for arrears of rent, but passes to the auction-purchaser in execution, like the interests of tenants down to occupancy raiyats. These are clear indications of some degree of permanence attached to a chandna tenancy yinder the Act; indeed the settlement authorities who investigated the permanent or precarious character of these tenancies at the last settlement came to the conclusion that the mere fact that the word ‘istamrari’ is not found in the entry of a chandnadar's status should be taken to imply that he is a mere tenant-at-will (see para. 63 of Mr. Dalziel's Report). As was pointed out by James, J., in 149 IC 805, the view that a chandnadar is a mere tenant-at-will is inconsistent with Ss. 74 and 232(1)(c) of the Act. Mr. Manohar Lal has urged that though under S. 74 the chandnadar may not be ejected for arrears for rent, there is nothing in the Act to save him from ejectment on other grounds or to prevent the landlord, in the absence of proof of local custom or usage to the contrary from ejecting him without giving any reason at all. To allow the latter however would render S. 74 nugatory; and as to the former, it must be borne in mind that it was one of the objects of the Tenancy legislation in these parts to give adequate security to the tenants in the enjoyment of their existing rights, both statutory and customary. As the Orissa Tenancy Act makes chandnadars tenants for the purposes of the Act and leaves the incidents of their tenancies generally to be regulated by local custom or usage, while expressly providing for the grounds on which tenants of all other classes may be ejected, it would seem to have been the intention of the legislature to allow the ejectment of chandnadars in those cases only in which the landlord is supported by local custom or usage. This is the view that Fazl Ali and Varma, JJ., were inclined to take. The scheme of the Act suggests, as the learned Judges observed, that it could never have been contemplated by the legislature that a chandnadar should be in a worse position than even a non-occupancy raiyat as regards his liability to ejectment. Cl. 2, S. 236 does not itself indicate whether the local custom or usage regulating the ejectment of a chandnadards to be proved by the landlord or by the tenant; but having regard to the status of the chandnadar as gathered from the definition and his express inclusion in Ss. 4 and 74, and to the fact that all other tenants under the Act are projected from eviction except on specified grounds, the clause ought, in my opinion to be taken to provide in effect that while the landlord is not entitled to eject the chandnadar for arrears of rent, his right to eject him on other grounds shall be regulated by local custom or usage and will only be available so far as is permitted by local custom or usage. The onus that shifts in ordinary cases to the tenant when the landlord suing for ejectment proves his title as such thus shifts again to the landlord in view not only of the way in which the Act has dealt with his right to eject by confining it to specified grounds in the case of all other tenants but also of the protection which the Act was designed to give to the chandnadar together with the measure of permanence expressly conferred on him, especially by Section 74 of the Act. This aspect of the matter was not considered by Das, J., when in concurrence with Foster, J. he remanded 1 Cuttack LT 8 and 1 Cuttack LT 8, for a reconsideration of the evidence after throwing the onus of proving local custom or usage on the defendant in accordance merely with the general proposition repeatedly laid down by the Privy Council. For these reasons I am unable to accept the view of Das, J. as a correct treatment of the chandnadar in the matter of ejectment under the Orissa Tenancy Act. In my opinion the land-lord is not entitled to eject the chandnadar except when he proves local usage or custom in support.
10. It is curious to note that in para. 4 of the plaint the landlords stated that the defendants were in possession of the disputed property as chandnadars tenants-at-will and from year to year and had no permanent right “according to law and local usages” over it and were bad tenants, where for the plaintiffs gave them notice to quit.
11. The decision of the case must however rest not on whether the plaintiffs undertook to discharge the burden of proving local usage in support of the ejectment—as a matter of fact the only evidence that was given on the point was (as the lower Courts have said) a statement obtained from one of the tenants defendants that he cannot say if chandna tenants can be ejected at the will of the landlord—but on whether it was for the landlords to prove a local custom or usage in support of the ejectment claimed or for the chandnadars to prove a local custom or usage to defeat the suit. In my opinion the former is the true position.
12. I would accordingly allow the appeal and dismiss the suit with costs in all Courts.
13. Courtney-Terrell, C.J:— I agree.
14. Agarwala, J.:— I agree.
15. Appeal allowed.
Alert