Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ
 

Manian Patter And Others (S) v. The Madras Railway Company By Its Agent And Manager (Petitioner) .

Madras High Court
Aug 29, 1905
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.

One Syed Ismal entered into a contract with the respondent, the Madras Railway Company, to supply for a term of 12 months 2,400 tons of fuel at 200 tons per month at Rs. 4 per ton. If was also agreed between the parties that even after the expiry of the year all the terms of the contract were to hold good for an indefinite further period of time and quantity of fuel, subject to three months' notice from either side of an intention to withdraw from the engagement. The written contract contained; various stipulations as to the proper performance of the contract and provided that the contract should be liable to be considered at an end and the sum of Rs. 350 deposited with the Company for the due fulfilment of the contract should be liable to be forfeited for the benefit of the Company, if the contractor failed to make ??? delivery in accordance with the terms of the contract and specification thereto annexed.

The contractor having failed to supply duly, the Company in June 1901 cancelled the contract and forfeited the sum of Rs. 350 deposited with them. Subsequently in execution of a decree against the contractor his right title and interest, if any, in the said deposit amount was sold and was purchased by the appellant. The question is whether he is entitled to recover the amount from the Company as held by the Subordinate Judge, or not, as held by the learned Judge in revision.

Neither section 74 of the Indian Contract Act nor the expositions of law in decisions English or Indian which were referred to in the argument, as to promises to pay specified sums in case of breach of contract are really in point, for the rule as to penalties dealt with them has been uniformly held not to be applicable to cases of ??? of deposits for the breach of stipulations even where some them are but trifling while others are not such (Wallis v. ???(1)). In these cases the bargain of the parties is carried out ??? when the forfeiture is relieved against on terms which the ??? imposes to meet the justice of the case where the circumstances ??? the grant of such equitable relief. In other words the rule ??? the class of cases under consideration is that, where the ??? refers to a sum deposited as security for performance, ??? will not he interfered with, if reasonable, in amount ??? on ‘Damages’, VII edition, vol. I, section 414, p. ??? It was apparently with reference to this principle of reasonless that Kelly, C.B, and Hawkins, J., in Cooper v. London ??? and South Coast Railway Company(2) upheld the forfeiture ??? by a season ticket-holder for his failure to deliver up ??? the very day next after its expiry. Unless therefore ??? of the deposit in the present case be found to be reasonable it must be treated as valid. With reference to this aspect of the question no argument founded on the facts of the case were put forward on behalf of the appellant and having regard to all the circumstances of the transaction there is no ground whatsoever for saying that it is otherwise than perfectly reasonable. As to Srinivasa v. Rathnasabapathi(3) the attention of the learned Judges who decided the case was not drawn to the inapplicability of the presumptions and doctrines as to penalties therein relied of ??? to cases of forfeiture of deposits, and their decision if it proceed solely on those doctrines cannot, as inconsistent with the ??? established view of the law on the point, be followed.

The appeal is dismissed with, costs.

Messrs Orr, David & Brightwell—Attorneys for respondent.