- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
A.T. Vasudevan, In Re
Judgment Summary — A.S. Thiruvengada Mudaliar (Application under Clause 17, Letters Patent)
Factual and Procedural Background
This is an application by A.S. Thiruvengada Mudaliar under Clause 17, Letters Patent of 1866 requesting:
- Appointment as guardian of the joint family property in respect of the interests of his five minor sons; and
- Sanction for sale of specified ancestral immovable properties (about 52 acres) in the villages of Sembiam and Paravallur, now within Madras Municipal limits.
Family composition and property context given in the petition: the petitioner is the Karta and father; besides five minor sons there are two adult sons, a wife and an unmarried minor daughter entitled to maintenance. The lands are ancestral, dry lands without irrigation; they were valued at Rs. 15,000 at partition in 1942 (when a mortgage of Rs. 11,000 existed and was since discharged by the petitioner). Income sources included a lease for toddy extraction (ending 30 Sept. 1948 because of approaching prohibition) and casuarina plantations under a 9-year arrangement. A purchaser, Mr. M.V. Venkataraman, offered Rs. 1,95,000 and required prior Court sanction. The petitioner proposed arrangements to pay off lessees and to invest net proceeds for minors' benefit.
Procedurally the Court considered (1) whether it had jurisdiction under Clause 17 to entertain the application; (2) whether the proposed sale was beneficial to the minors; (3) safeguards for the minors' shares; and finally made orders appointing the petitioner guardian of the joint family property, sanctioning the sale for Rs. 1,95,000, prescribing investments and deposits, appointing a guardian ad litem, and directing payment of costs from the estate. The application was allowed.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the High Court has jurisdiction under Clause 17, Letters Patent to appoint a guardian in respect of a minor's undivided interest in a Mitakshara joint family (i.e., whether this inherent jurisdiction survives and is available despite the Guardians and Wards Act).
- Whether the proposed sale of ancestral joint family property by the family manager (karta/father) can be sanctioned where the sale is alleged to be beneficial to the estate and minors (even if no strict legal necessity is shown).
- What safeguards and mode of custody of the minors' shares of sale proceeds should be provided if the sale is sanctioned.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Case and Submissions
- The petitioner (father and karta) sought appointment as guardian under Clause 17 and sanction for sale on grounds that the sale is highly beneficial to the family and to the minor coparceners.
- Factual evidences advanced: partition history (1942 valuation Rs. 15,000), prior mortgage discharged by petitioner, lack of irrigation and limited agricultural income, cessation of toddy-lease income from 1 Oct. 1948 due to prohibition, casuarina plantations still immature under lease arrangements, and a current offer of Rs. 1,95,000 from Mr. M.V. Venkataraman to build a factory.
- Practical considerations highlighted: an adjoining 35-acre plot had been sold a year earlier for Rs. 34,000; the present offer was therefore a substantial and time-sensitive opportunity which might not recur.
- Proposed safeguards: purchase of National Savings Certificates of Rs. 15,000 in the name of each minor son and in the names of the petitioner and his wife; investment of a further Rs. 50,000 in Government securities to be deposited with the Registrar; deposit of the certificates and securities in Court (custodia legis).
- Counsel relied on the practice and decisions of chartered High Courts (Bombay, Calcutta, Allahabad) and an obiter statement in this Court (Venkataramana Rao, J.) to support the availability of the High Court's inherent jurisdiction under the Letters Patent.
The opinion does not present adversarial or detailed counter-arguments by any opposing party in the text provided.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Gharibullah v. Kalaksingh, 25 ALL. 407 : (30 I.A. 165 P.C.) | Established that under the Guardians and Wards Act no guardian will be appointed where the minor is a member of an undivided Mitakshara family because the minor's interest is not individual property. | Used to explain the limitation of the Guardians and Wards Act and to frame the issue of whether Clause 17 (Letters Patent) supplies an alternative inherent jurisdiction. |
| Raja of Visianagaram v. Secretary of State for India, I.L.R (1937) Mad. 383 : (A.I.R (24) 1937 Mad. 51) | Contains an obiter indicating that the High Court has jurisdiction to appoint a guardian apart from the Guardians and Wards Act and that the practice of the Court was consistent with other High Courts. | Cited for the dictum of Venkataramana Rao, J. that practice in this Court has been aligned with Bombay/Calcutta decisions; relied upon to support existence of jurisdiction under Clause 17. |
| Ryots of Garbandho v. Zamindar of Parlakimidi, I.L.R (1944) Mad. 457 : (A.I.R (30) 1943 P.C. 164) | Privy Council decision referenced; its effect on previous rulings noted as not directly arising for decision in this case. | Mentioned as a potentially relevant authority but the Court stated that its effect upon the Madras ruling was not a matter for the present case. |
| In re Jairam Luxman, 16 Bom. 634 | Illustrates instances where the question of guardian appointment for minors in joint family estates arose; guardians appointed but alienation responsibility left to guardians. | Surveyed to show historical practice in Bombay Court and to contrast with cases where alienation was not directly sanctioned by the Court. |
| In re Jagannath Ramji, 19 Bom. 96 | Similar to Jairam Luxman—appointment of guardians and direction of responsibility regarding alienation. | Included in survey of Bombay decisions indicating practice in that Court. |
| In re Manilal Hurgoven (Murgovan), 25 Bom. 353 : (3 Bom. L.R. 411) | Held that proposed alienation by manager was sanctionable where beneficial; affirmed High Court power to appoint guardian apart from Guardians and Wards Act. | Seen as closely similar to present facts; relied on as precedent permitting sanction of alienation where beneficial to estate. |
| Narsi Tokersey v. Sachindranath Gajanan, 84 Bom. 75 : (A.I.R (16) 1929 Bom. 475) | Followed the principle in In re Manilal Hurgoven that alienation by manager may be sanctioned for benefit of estate. | Cited as an affirming Bombay decision in support of sanctioning beneficial sale by manager. |
| In re Dattatraya Govinda Haldankar, 56 Bom. 519 : (A.I.R (19) 1932 Bom. 537) | Doubts expressed (by Kania, J.) on certain aspects: why purchaser should seek sanction and whether purchaser is absolved from independent enquiries even if court sanctions sale. | Cited by the Court as recording important reservations that were subsequently answered by other Bombay decisions. |
| Mahadev Krishna In re, I.L.R (1937) Bom. 432 : (A.I.R (24) 1937 Bom. 98) | Reaffirmed the principle that alienation for benefit is sanctionable and answered the doubts raised in Haldankar regarding purchaser's role/security. | Used to show subsequent Bombay authority endorsing the view that purchasers may seek Court sanction and that the burden on purchasers is manageable. |
| Ratanji Ramaji In re, I.L.R 1942 Bom. 39 : (A.I.R (28) 1941 Bom. 397 (F.B.)) | Full Bench review affirming the High Court's jurisdiction to appoint guardian under Letters Patent and confirming the principle in Bombay decisions. | Relied upon by the Court (and followed procedurally) for appointing a guardian ad litem and for the proposition that Bombay practice supports inherent jurisdiction. |
| Mari Narain Das In re, 50 Cal. 141 : (A.I.R (10) 1923 Cal. 409) | Calcutta High Court decision adopting the view that the High Court can appoint a guardian in respect of minors' undivided interest under Letters Patent. | Included in the cross-jurisdictional survey to show consensus among chartered High Courts. |
| In re Bijaykumar Singh Budar, 69 Cal. 570 : (A.I.R (19) 1932 Cal. 502) | Another Calcutta decision adopting the jurisdictional position and practice. | Surveyed as part of supporting authorities from Calcutta. |
| In the matter of Govinda Prasad, 50 ALL. 709 : (A.I.R (15) 1928 ALL. 709) | Allahabad High Court case recognizing jurisdiction under its Letters Patent (Cl.12) but in one instance refusing to exercise it on grounds of inexpediency and want of precedent. | Cited to show comparative approaches in other chartered High Courts and that some discretionary refusals occurred in specific circumstances. |
| Sellappa v. Suppan, I.L.R (1937) Mad. 906 : (A.I.R (24) 1937 Mad. 496) | Madras decision holding that a manager's power to alienate can be exercised not only out of necessity but also for the benefit of the estate. | Relied upon as Madras authority supporting the proposition that alienation for benefit (not strictly legal necessity) is permissible. |
| Hunoomanpershad Panday v. Mt. Babooee Mtmraj, 6 M.I.A. 393 : (1 Sar. 552 P.C.) | Privy Council observations previously thought to require 'pressure and danger' as examples of benefit; cited historically. | Cited to explain prior narrower readings and then to show that later decisions interpreted those observations as illustrative rather than exhaustive. |
| Palaniappa Chetti v. Sreemath Devasikamony Pandarasannadhi, 40 Mad. 709 : (A.I.R (4) 1917 P.C. 33) | Privy Council observations cited historically regarding examples of benefit (pressure/danger). | Cited to show the historical context of the 'benefit' test and how later Madras decisions interpreted it more broadly. |
| App. No. 206 of 1942; App. No. 101 of 1945 (A.I.R (36) 1949 Mad. 67); Appeals Nos. 261 and 418 of 1945 | Unreported/recent Madras appellate decisions cited as adopting the broader view that alienation for benefit is sanctionable and consistent practice in Madras. | Referred to as indicating a uniform recent practice in Madras courts consistent with the broader principle of sanctioning beneficial alienations. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court's analysis proceeded in distinct steps (summarised strictly as contained in the opinion):
-
Jurisdiction under Clause 17:
- The Court began by distinguishing the operation of the Guardians and Wards Act (which, following Gharibullah v. Kalaksingh, does not permit appointment of guardians for minors' undivided coparcenary interests) from the inherent jurisdiction preserved by Clause 17 of the Letters Patent.
- Clause 17 was traced to earlier Letters Patent and the Madras Charter of 1800, which referred to the Supreme Court's power "to appoint Guardians and Keepers for infants, and their estates, according to the order and course observed in ... England."
- The historical English foundation (Chancery/parens patriae jurisdiction of the Crown) was examined; the Court noted differences between English law (distinction between realty and personalty) and Hindu law (no analogous distinction), concluding that the reference to English "order and course" is primarily jurisdictional, not an adoption of all English substantive law rules.
- The Court surveyed decisions of other chartered High Courts (Bombay, Calcutta, Allahabad) and earlier statements by a Madras judge (Venkataramana Rao, J.) to conclude that the High Court's inherent jurisdiction under Clause 17 survives and may be exercised in respect of minors' undivided interests; the Letters Patent jurisdiction is saved by Section 3 of the Guardians and Wards Act.
-
Benefit of proposed transfer:
- The Court analysed the petitioner's factual case: the land's nature (dry lands, limited cultivation), historical valuation (partition value Rs. 15,000), discharge of mortgage by petitioner, reliance on leases (tapping/palmyra lease and casuarina plantations), imminent loss of toddy-lease revenue due to prohibition, and the substantial offer of Rs. 1,95,000 from a purchaser proposing industrial use.
- Comparative market data was noted (an adjoining 35-acre plot sold earlier for Rs. 34,000) to highlight the exceptional nature of the present offer.
- After evaluating those facts and the arrangements to compensate lessees and secure the transaction, the Court found the transaction to be "highly advantageous and beneficial to the interest of the entire family including the minor coparceners."
-
Power of manager to sell for benefit (even absent strict legal necessity):
- The Court reviewed authorities (including Sellappa v. Suppan and multiple Bombay decisions) showing a trend to allow alienation by the manager where it is clearly for the benefit of the estate, and to treat examples like "pressure and danger" as illustrative rather than exhaustive.
- It considered and addressed earlier doubts (e.g., in Haldankar) about purchasers seeking sanction and their duty to make independent enquiries, relying on subsequent decisions (Mahadev Krishna and Ratanji Ramaji Full Bench) that answered those doubts and affirmed the practice.
- On this basis the Court concluded that the proposed sale could be sanctioned as it was beneficial to the estate and the minors.
-
Safeguards and custody of proceeds:
- The Court required specific safeguards: purchase of National Savings Certificates of Rs. 15,000 in the name of each minor son (and also in the names of the petitioner and his wife), deposit of these certificates in Court immediately upon receipt of consideration, and investment of an additional Rs. 50,000 in Government securities to be deposited with the Registrar to the credit of the petition.
- The certificates and securities were to remain in custodia legis and under Court control.
- Because the minors' shares would be in custodia legis, the Court dispensed with the requirement for the guardian to furnish security.
- The guardian was ordered to give an undertaking under Order 82, Rule 8 (Original Side Rules) to keep full and correct accounts and to file and prove them in Court when required; the undertaking was to be furnished within three days.
-
Ancillary and administrative orders:
- The petitioner was appointed guardian of the joint family property for the five minors and empowered to convey their interests subject to the specified conditions.
- A guardian ad litem (Mr. A.V. Viswanatha Sastri, Advocate) was appointed (to represent the infants) and to be paid Rs. 600 by the petitioner within two days; costs of the petition (including that remuneration) were ordered to come out of the estate.
Holding and Implications
Core Ruling: Application allowed. The Court appointed the petitioner guardian of the joint family property in respect of the five minor sons and sanctioned the sale of the two scheduled properties to Mr. M.V. Venkataraman (or his nominee) for Rs. 1,95,000, subject to the safeguards and conditions set out in the order.
Direct implications for the parties
- The petitioner is appointed guardian of the joint family property for the five minor sons and is empowered to complete the sale subject to Court-imposed conditions.
- On receipt of sale proceeds, National Savings Certificates (Rs. 15,000 each) are to be purchased in each minor's name and deposited in Court; Rs. 50,000 is to be invested in Government securities and deposited with the Registrar to the credit of the petition.
- The minors' shares will be in custodia legis; consequently, no security from the guardian is required.
- The petitioner must give the undertaking under O.82, R.8 (Original Side Rules) and keep and file full accounts; undertaking to be furnished within three days.
- Mr. A.V. Viswanatha Sastri is appointed guardian ad litem and is to be paid Rs. 600 by the petitioner; costs to be paid from the estate.
Broader implications and precedent
The opinion primarily applies existing principles and surveyed decisions from other chartered High Courts and a line of Bombay authorities to reach its conclusion. It affirms the Court's exercise of inherent jurisdiction under Clause 17 to appoint a guardian and sanction beneficial alienations of joint family property. The judgment does not purport to create a novel legal doctrine beyond that surveyed consensus; it applies the established "benefit of the estate" test and prescribes protective measures for minors' shares.
Prepared from the text of the provided judgment. No information has been invented or inferred beyond what is contained in the opinion.
JUDGMENT
1. This is an application under Cl. 17, Letters Patent of 1866 by A.S Thiruvengada Mudaliar for being appointed guardian of the joint family property belonging inter alia to his five minor sons the respondents and for sanction of the sale of that property as being beneficial to the interests of the minor sons. The petitioner as the father is the karta of the family and he has besides the five minor sons two adult sons, and there are also his wife and an unmarried minor daughter who have rights of maintenance. The properties admittedly are ancestral immovable properties consisting of lands in the villages of Sembiam and Paravallur measuring in the aggregate about 52 acres. Those villages were recently brought within the Municipal limits of Madras City and the lands therein have consequently risen in value. I shall deal with the facts bearing upon the beneficial nature of the proposed transaction at a later stage.
2. The first question is whether this Court has jurisdiction to entertain this application. It is not denied that under the Guardians and Wards Act no guardian of the property of an infant will be appointed where the minor is a member of an undivided family governed by the Mitakshara law, the reason being as laid down by the Judicial Committee in Gharibullah v. Kalaksingh, 25 ALL. 407 : (30 I.A 165 P.C), that the infant's interest is not individual property. As observed by their Lordships, it has been well settled by a long series of decisions in India that a guardian cannot be appointed in respect of the infant's interest in the property of an undivided Mitakshara family. This was pointed out to be clearly right, “on the plain ground that the interest of a member; of such a family is not individual property at all and that therefore a guardian, if appointed, would have nothing to do with the family property.” This view has been acted upon in a series of cases collected in foot-note (n) to para. 230 of Mayne's Hindu law. It is, however, mentioned by the same learned author that the High Court has inherent jurisdiction to appoint a guardian of the property of the minor who is a member of the joint family even where the minor's interest in the property is an undivided share in the family property unlike under the Guardians and Wards Act. This jurisdiction is conferred by cl. 17, Letters Patent which is in these terms:
“And we do further ordain that the said High Court of Judicature at Madras shall have the like power and authority with respect to persons and estates of infants, idiots and lunatics within the Presidency of Madras, as that which is now vested in the said High Court immediately before the publication of these presents.”
3. This is substantially a reproduction of cl. 16, Letters Patent of 1862 in which it was stated that this Court would have the jurisdiction which was then vested in the Supreme Court. The jurisdiction of the Supreme Court was laid down in cl. 32, Madras Charter of 1800 which is as follows:
“And we do hereby authorise the said Supreme Court of Judicature at Madras to appoint Guardians and Keepers for infants, and their estates, according to the order and course observed in that part of Great Britain called England.”
4. That jurisdiction was exercised in England by the Chancellor in the Court of Chancery as a part of the general delegation of the authority of the Crown virtute officii. As it has been laid down in a series of cases in England, the Chancellor's jurisdiction has its foundation in the prerogative of the Crown flowing from its general power and duty as parens patrics. Now the Court of Chancery in exercise of this jurisdiction does not permit the conversion of real property belonging to a minor into personal property: but that is because under the English law a distinction obtains between realty and personalty both with regard to the infant's power of disposal thereof by will and with regard to the line of succession. No such distinction applies to a Hindu family in India as it is now well settled. The reference in the Charter of 1800 to the order and course followed in England is primarily with regard to matters of jurisdiction and not to the entire body of the law applicable such as the distinction with regard to conversion of real property belonging to the minor into personal property. There is no direct case decided by this Court on the question of inherent jurisdiction of the High Court under cl. 17, Letters Patent in a matter like this except for an obiter reference contained in the judgment of Venkataramana Rao, J. in Raja of Visianagaram v. Secretary of State for India, I.L.R (1937) Mad. 383 : (A.I.R (24) 1937 Mad. 51). There the question was whether under this clause the High Court had jurisdiction with regard to minors outside the limits of the Presidency Town and whether its jurisdiction to act under that clause was not affected by the Guardians and Wards Act. Venkatasubba Rao and Venkataramana Rao, JJ. held that the jurisdiction of the Supreme Court was not limited to the City of Madras, that jurisdiction was not in the exercise of its ordinary original jurisdiction and that it is saved by Section 3 of the Guardians and Wards Act. What is the effect of the decision of the Privy Council in Ryots of Garbandho v. Zamindar of Parlakimidi, I.L.R (1944) Mad. 457 : (A.I.R (30) 1943 P.C 164) will be upon that ruling is a matter which does not arise here, but the only material portion of the judgment in the Madras case that is relevant for the purpose of this case is the dictum of Venkataramana Rao, J. at page 459 of the report. After referring to a number of Bombay, Calcutta and Allahabad decisions, the learned Judge concluded that the High Court has jurisdiction to appoint a guardian for a minor apart from the Guardians and Wards Act and then observed: “The practice in this Court, so far as my experience goes, has been consistent with the view taken by the other High Courts.” This observation is relied on by Mr. Panchapakesa Sastri to show that although there are no reported cases bearing upon the question at issue there has been an invariable practice here following the line of the various decisions of the Bombay, Calcutta and Allahabad High Courts. I shall refer to a few of those cages. In in re Jairam Luxman, 16 Bom. 634 and In re Jagannath Ramji, 19 Bom. 96, this question had arisen, but in those cases no directions for alienation of the property were given. Guardians were appointed and the responsibility with regard to the alienation was thrown upon them. In In re Manilal Hurgoven, 25 Bom. 353 : (3 Bom. L.R 411), the proposed alienation by the guardian was duly sanctioned by the Court after considering the various objections raised against it. The facts of that case were very similar to those of the present case. Jenkins, C.J raised the question whether the manager of the family, the father, had not the right to deal with the family property and whether by granting sanction the Court would not be depriving the minor of the right to object to the alienation after attaining majority if he thought proper to do so. Eventually sanction was given holding that the High Court had power in such cases to appoint a guardian of the property of the minor apart from the Guardians and Wards Act. This case was followed by the same Court in Narsi Tokersey v. Sachindranath Gajanan, 84 Bom. 75 : (A.I.R (16) 1929 Bom. 475). The correctness of this view was, however, doubted by Kania, J., as he then was, in In re Dattatraya Govinda Haldankar, 56 Bom. 519 : (A.I.R (19) 1932 Bom. 537). The learned Judge raised two important doubts; (1) Why should the purchaser demand an order of sanction from the Court before purchasing the property? (2) In spite of the Court passing the order of sanction, the purchaser would not be absolved from the duty of making the necessary enquiries and, in the event of the minor challenging the transaction, the purchaser would still have to prove that he made independent enquiries and satisfied himself as to the power of the manager of the joint family to enter into that transaction. In Mahadev Krishna In re, I.L.R (1937) Bom. 432 : (A.I.R (24) 1937 Bom. 98), the question again arose for consideration and Sir John Beaumont, C.J and Bangnekar, J. reaffirmed the principle of the earlier decisions in In re Manilal Murgovan, 25 Bom. 353 : (3 Bom. L.R 411) and in Narsi Tokersey v. Sachindranath Gajanan, 54 Bom. 75 : (A.I.R (16) 1929 Bom. 475) and referring to Kania J's decision in In re Dattatraya Haldankar, 56 Bom. 519 : (A.I.R (19) 1932 Bom. 537) dissented from it and answered both of his doubts. With regard to the first of his doubts it was said that the purchaser does not seek to cast any burden on the Court. He merely says that he is not going on with the transaction unless he gets good title. It was pointed out that it was difficult for a purchaser to satisfy himself as to the existence of legal necessity or benefit to the estate and that the evidence with regard to legal necessity might not be available when the transaction may be attacked in years to come by a minor son of the manager. The youngest minor in the present case, it may be noted here, is one year old and the transaction may be questioned 20 years later. With regard to the second doubt Bangnekar, J. further pointed out that although the legal position is correct that the purchaser should satisfy himself that a legal necessity exists or that moneys are required for the benefit of the estate many transactions take place which are not challenged and the burden placed upon the purchaser or the mortgagee in such cases is completely discharged without the parties coming to the Court. The latest pronouncement of the Bombay High Court is contained in a Full Bench decision in Ratanji Ramaji In re, I.L.R 1942 Bom. 39 : (A.I.R (28) 1941 Bom. 397 (F.B)). The entire case law was fully reviewed and the jurisdiction of the Court to appoint a guardian of the minor was affirmed both on the ground of the power conferred under cl. 17, Letters Patent and by virtue of the long standing practice in that Court. This view has been acted upon by the Calcutta High Court in Mari Narain Das In re, 50 Cal. 141 : (A.I.R (10) 1923 Cal. 409) and In re Bijaykumar Singh Budar, 69 Cal. 570 : (A.I.R (19) 1932 Cal. 502) and by the Allahabad High Court in In the matter of Govinda Prasad, 50 ALL. 709; (A.I.R (15) 1928 ALL. 709). The Allahabad High Court has jurisdiction by virtue of Cl. 12, Letters Patent in respect of the persons and property of the minors. That Court, however, refused to exercise that jurisdiction in that particular case on the ground of inexpediency and want of precedent. The result of this foregoing survey is that in the other chartered High Courts the consensus of opinion has been that in the exercise of its inherent jurisdiction vested in it under the Letters Patent, which jurisdiction is preserved by Section 3 of the Guardians and Wards Act, the High Court has power to appoint a guardian in respect of the person and property of the minors covering even their undivided interest. Although there is no direct decision of this Court with regard to this matter there is the statement of Venkataramana Rao, J. that the practice in this Court has been on the same lines as indicated in the Bombay and Calcutta decisions. That practice is warranted by cl. 17, Letters Patent. The next question is whether, the Court having the power, the proposed transfer is beneficial to the interests of the five minor sons of the petitioner. The facts set out in the application and-the supporting affidavit are these. Both the pieces of land are dry lands. This property fell in the partition which took place in 1942 between she petitioner and his brother to the petitioner's share. It was in that year valued in the deed of partition as being worth Rs. 15,000. On the date of partition there was a mortgage subsisting over Jhis property for Rs. 11,000. The petitioner from his own earnings discharged the entire debt. The land has no irrigation facilities for the purpose of cultivation and hence no wet crops were ever raised except in a small area. The petitioner was therefore constrained to lease out the palmyra trees in both the pieces of land for the purpose of today extraction. He entered into an arrangement on 12th April, 1947 whereby the lessee was to take a lease of the property for one year which will expire on 30th September, 1948, the rent reserved for that period being Rs. 1600. On that date, this source of revenue will completely disappear owing to the introduction of prohibition in the city from 1st October 1948. With regard to the rest of the land, the petitioner arranged for raising casuarina plantations with two persons who were to raise plantations at their expense ever a period of nine years commencing from 3rd July, 1943. At the expiry of the period after the plantation is cut it would be sold and half the sale proceeds would be paid over to the petitioners. The plantation is very tender still and the lease has to run its course. In the meantime by reason of the general rise in prices and also the special rise occasioned by the inclusion of those villages within the limits of the City of Madras, the petitioner has been in a position to secure an offer of Rs. 1,95,000 for both the plots of land measuring 52 acres from one Mr. M.V Venkataraman who proposes to build a factory on the land. An agreement was entered into with him embodying the terms; but since the purchaser is offering such a high price he has stipulated that the sanction of the Court should be previously obtained. It would appear that an ad-Joining plot of land with similar facilities measuring 35 acres was Bold a little over a year ago for a sum of Rs. 34,000. It is perfectly clear that the offer of Rs. 1,95,000 is a very handsome offer which, if not accepted and implemented, might be withdrawn and no similar offer may be forthcoming for along time to come. In order to effectuate this transaction the petitioner has entered into an arrangement with the lessees of the casuarina plantation by which they have agreed to relinquish all their rights under the lease on being paid a sum of Rs. 9001 on or before 14th April, 1948. The net amount available by the sale of the property would then be Rs. 1,86,000 which undoubtedly is an exceedingly good price for the land, almost in the nature of a windfall. There can be no doubt in these circumstances that the proposed sale of these lands is highly advantageous and beneficial to the interest of the entire family including the minor coparceners.
5. The next question is whether a sale by the manager of a joint family property is competent when it is only for the benefit of the estate, since there is no case of there being any legal necessity. Whatever the ancient texts might have said about this matter, the trend of decisions for a long time has been definitely to hold that a joint family property can be sold by a manager if it is shown that it is clearly beneficial to the interests of the family even though there is no legal necessity justifying the transaction. It will be sufficient to refer to some of the most recent cases reported and un-reported. In Sellappa v. Suppan, I.L.R (1937) Mad. 906 : (A.I.R (24) 1937 Mad. 496) Venkatasubba Rao and Cornish JJ. held that the power of the manager of a joint Hindu family to alienate property can be exercised not only in a case of need but for the benefit of the estate. At one time in view of certain observations of the Judicial Committee in Hunoomanpershad Panday v. Mt. Babooee Mtmraj, 6 M.I.A 393 : (1 Sar. 552 P.C) and Palaniappa Chetti v. Sreemath Devasikamony Pandarasannadhi, 40 Mad. 709 : (A.I.R (4) 1917 P.C 33), it was thought that there should be actual pressure on the estate; but in Sellappa v. Suppan, I.L.R (1937) Mad. 906 : (A.I.R (24) 1937 Mad. 496), it was pointed out that “pressure and danger” in those two cases were referred to by their Lordships as examples of benefit and that the pronouncement of the Judicial Committee did not justify a narrower view being taken of the expression “for the benefit of the estate”. In a number of recent unreported cases this view has been uniformly adopted, (vide App. No. 206 of 1942, decided by King and Shahabuddin, JJ. on 3rd March, 1944, App. no. 101 of 1945, decided by Wadsworth and Govindarajachari JJ. on 15th April, 1947: (A.I.R (36) 1949 Mad. 67) and Appeals Nos. 261 and 418 of 1945, decided on 5th February, 1948 by Rajamannar, O.C.J and Satyanarayana Rao, J). I find that the proposed transaction is clearly beneficial to the estate and to the interests of the minors and I have no hesitation in sanctioning it.
6. The only other question is as to the safeguards that should be provided in the interests of the minors as to the disposal of their shares of the net proceeds of the sale. The petitioner undertakes to purchase National Savings Certificates for the maximum amount permissible, viz., Rs. 15,000 in the names of each of his minor sons and also in the names of himself and his wife. As the family is now composed, the five minor sons will be entitled to 5.sths of the consideration which comes to Rs. 1,16,250. Nobody can predicate the precise share of an undivided coparcener but proceeding upon the existing basis it is essential that a sum equal to the share of the minors with some further margin is put in their names. National Savings Certificates of the value of Rs. 15,000 may be purchased in the name of each of the minor sons and deposited in Court immediately on receipt of consideration. A further sum of Rs. 50,000 should be invested in Government securities. The petitioner is em-powered to purchase them out of the consideration of the proposed transaction and deposit the securities with the Registrar to the credit of this original petition. The certificates and the securities will remain in the custody of the Court subject to such orders as may from time to time be passed.
7. The result is that the petitioner is appointed guardian of the joint family property belonging to the five minor sons and that the sale of the two items of property mentioned in the schedule attached to the petition is sanctioned in favour of Mr. M.V Venkataraman or his nominee for a sum of Rs. 1,95,000. The guardian is empowered to convey the minor sons interest in the said property to the purchaser subject to the conditions enumerated above. As the entire share of the minor sons will be under custodia legis, there is no further necessity to ask the guardian to furnish security.
8. It is sufficient if under O. 82, R. 8, Original Side Rules he gives an undertaking to furnish the statement mentioned in that rule and to keep full and correct account of all moneys and properties of the minors received and expended by the guardian on their behalf and file and prove the same in Court whenever so required. The undertaking should be furnished in three days.
9. As the father of the five minors is himself the petitioner, following the course of action adopted in Ratanji Ramji In re, I.L.R (1942) Bom. 39 : (A.I.R (28) 1941 Bom. 397 F.B), I appointed Mr. A.V Viswanatha Sastri Advocate, as guardian ad item of these five minors in this case. I have received very valuable assistance from him. He will get a remuneration of Rs. 600. The petitioner will pay that amount to Mr. A.V Viswanatha Sastri within two days.
10. The costs of this petition including the remuneration to be paid to Mr. A.V Viswanatha Sastri will come out of the estate.
C.R.K/G.B
11. Application allowed.
Alert