Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Umesh Chandra Pramanick v. Mathur Mohan Haldar

Calcutta High Court
Jan 15, 1901
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

This appeal arises from a suit filed by the Plaintiffs-Appellants seeking recovery of money due under a mortgage deed executed by the Defendants in favour of the Plaintiffs' predecessor in title. The Plaintiffs also claimed damages on the basis that the mortgage security was impaired due to a decree obtained by Bhagoban Chandra Naskar against the Plaintiffs, which forced them to incur litigation expenses.

The Defendants denied liability, contending that no money was borrowed under the mortgage deed, that the Plaintiffs' prayer for foreclosure and sale was illegal, and that the mortgage security was not impaired by any wrongful act of the Defendants.

The trial court held that although the Plaintiffs were not entitled to a decree for sale of the mortgaged property, they were entitled to a personal decree against the Defendants for the amount claimed due to impairment of the mortgage security caused by the Defendants' wrongful conduct.

The Defendants appealed, and the Appellate Court allowed them to raise an objection not previously taken: that the Plaintiffs had not obtained a certificate under the Succession Certificate Act, 1889. The Appellate Court dismissed the suit under Section 4 of the Succession Certificate Act on this ground.

The Plaintiffs have now appealed against the Appellate Court's decision, contending that the lower Appellate Court erred in holding that Section 4 of the Succession Certificate Act barred the suit and in permitting the objection to be raised at the appellate stage without allowing the Plaintiffs to produce a succession certificate.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether Section 4 of the Succession Certificate Act bars the Plaintiffs from maintaining the suit for recovery of money due under the mortgage deed and damages for impairment of mortgage security.
  2. Whether the objection under Section 4 of the Succession Certificate Act could be raised for the first time at the appellate stage without giving the Plaintiffs an opportunity to produce a succession certificate.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments

  • The Court of Appeal was wrong in holding that Section 4 of the Succession Certificate Act barred the suit.
  • The objection under Section 4 was improperly allowed to be raised at the appellate stage without permitting the Plaintiffs to produce a succession certificate.

Defendants' Arguments

  • Denial of liability on the ground that no money was borrowed under the mortgage deed.
  • The Plaintiffs' prayer for foreclosure and sale was illegal.
  • The mortgage security was not impaired by any wrongful act of the Defendants.
  • The suit was barred because the Plaintiffs did not obtain a certificate under the Succession Certificate Act.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court analyzed the applicability of Section 4, sub-section 1, clause (a) of the Succession Certificate Act to the facts. It observed that the mortgage was a usufructuary mortgage and that the Plaintiffs' right to obtain a personal decree arose only after the mortgage security was impaired due to a decree obtained by Bhagoban Chandra Naskar against the Plaintiffs themselves, not against the original mortgagee.

The Court reasoned that this right to demand payment did not accrue to the estate of the deceased mortgagee but to the Plaintiffs upon the occurrence of a contingency (the impairment of the mortgage security). Therefore, Section 4 of the Succession Certificate Act did not bar the Plaintiffs from maintaining the suit.

Regarding the procedural issue, the Court expressed doubt about the correctness of allowing the objection under Section 4 to be raised for the first time at the appellate stage without giving the Plaintiffs an opportunity to produce a succession certificate, but it did not decide this point as it found the first issue determinative.

Consequently, the Court set aside the decree of the lower Appellate Court and remanded the case for disposal of other points raised in the appeal before it.

Holding and Implications

The appeal is allowed, the decree of the lower Appellate Court is set aside, and the case is remanded for further consideration.

The decision means the Plaintiffs are not barred by Section 4 of the Succession Certificate Act from maintaining the suit for recovery of money and damages related to the mortgage security impairment. The case returns to the Appellate Court for further examination of other issues. No new precedent was established beyond the decision on the applicability of the Succession Certificate Act in these circumstances.

Show all summary ...

This appeal arises out of a suit brought by the Plaintiffs-Appellants to recover money due under a mortgage deed executed by the Defendants in favour of the predecessor in title of the Plaintiffs, and for certain other sums of money claimed as damages, on the allegation that the mortgage security has been impaired by reason of a decree obtained by one Bhagoban Chandra Naskar against the Plaintiffs, and that the Plaintiffs had to incur expense in the litigation with Bhagoban Chandra Naskar.

The defence, so far as it is necessary to refer to it for the purposes of this appeal, was a denial of liability, on the ground of no money having been borrowed on the mortgage deed, and also on the ground that the Plaintiffs' prayer for foreclosure and sale was illegal, and on the further ground that the mortgage security was not impaired by any wrougful act on the part of the Defendants.

The first Court held that the Plaintiffs were not entitled to any decree for sale of the mortgaged property, but that they were entitled to a decree making the Defendants personally liable for the amount claimed by reason of the mortgage security having been impaired through the wrongful conduct of the Defendants.

Against that decree the Defendants preferred an appeal; and they were allowed by the Appellate Court to take the objection, not raised by them either in the first Court or in their memorandum of appeal, that the Plaintiffs were not entitled to any decree by reason of their not having taken out a certificate under the Succession Certificate Act, VII of 1889; and the lower Appellate Court has given effect to that objection and dismissed the suit under sec. 4 of the Succession Certificate Act.

From that decision of the lower Appellate Court the Plaintiffs have preferred this appeal: and it is contended on their behalf that the Court of Appeal below was wrong in holding that sec. 4 of the Succession Certificate Act was a bar to the maintenance of this suit, and that the Court of Appeal below was further wrong in allowing the objection under that section to be raised in the appellate stage of the case, without giving the Plaintiffs an opportunity of producing a certificate under the Succession Certificate Act.

If the first branch of the Appellants' contention is right, it will be unnecessary to go into the second. We are of opinion that the first branch of the Appellants' contention is correct. The mortgage in this case was a usufructuary mortgage, and one of the objections successfully urged by the Defendants in the first Court was that the Plaintiffs were precluded by the terms of the mortgage deed from suing for the money, the ground upon which the Plaintiffs were held by that Court to be entitled to a decree was that by reason of events that subsequently happened their mortgage security was impaired, and they acquired the right to obtain a personal decree against the mortgagors. If that was so, can it be said that the money for which this suit has been brought was a debt due to the estate of the deceased mortgagee within the meaning of sec. 4, sub-sec. 1, cl. (a) of the Succession Certificate Act 1. We are of opinion that the question must be answered in the negative. The case before us is not like a case in which the money was due to the deceased person upon the expiry of a certain time when it fell due. The case before us is one in which, if the security had remained unimpaired, the right to demand payment of the money would never have accrued to the mortgagee or his legal representatives, and the right to obtain a personal decree against the mortgagors arose only upon the happening of a contingency which might never have happened, namely, the obtaining of a decree by Bhagoban Chunder Naskar which deprived the mortgagee's heirs, the Plaintiffs, of a part of the mortgaged property. That decree was obtained not against the original mortgagee but against the Plaintiffs themselves. That being so, we think the right to demand payment of the money accrued for the first time to the Plaintiffs, and sec. 4 of the Succession Certificate Act was therefore no bar to the Plaintiffs obtaining a decree in this suit.

In this view of the case it becomes unnecessary to consider the second branch of the Appellants' contention; but we may observe that it is open to doubt whether the District Judge was right in allowing the objection under sec. 4 of the Succession Certificate Act to be taken in the appellate stage of the case, when the objection was not raised before the first Court, without giving the Plaintiffs an opportunity of meeting it by producing a succession certificate.

The result is that the decree of the lower Appellate Court will be set aside, and the case sent back to that Court in order that it may dispose of the other points raised in the appeal before it.

The Appellants are entitled to the costs of this appeal. All other costs will abide the result.

J.B
Appeal allowed: Case remanded.