Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Shib Charan Das v. Muqaddam

Allahabad High Court
Aug 12, 1935
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

This appeal arises from a suit for sale on a mortgage dated 8th March 1919. The dispute concerns whether defendants 8 to 10 acquired the rights of a prior mortgagee from 1919 and could use that mortgage as a defense against the plaintiff-appellant's claim. The property was originally mortgaged in 1913 by Muqaddam to Murlidhar via a simple mortgage deed. In 1919, Muqaddam mortgaged the same property again to the plaintiff-appellant, with Muqaddam's brother Pir Baksh also joining in the 1919 mortgage execution (though Pir Baksh's share is not relevant here).

Murlidhar initiated suit on his mortgage and obtained a preliminary decree in 1925 and a final decree in 1926 for Rs. 539-4-6 plus future interest at six percent per annum. Following this, Muqaddam's equity of redemption in the property was sold in execution of a simple money decree and purchased by Babu Ram, the predecessor-in-title of defendants 8 to 10. Babu Ram paid Rs. 539-4-0 to Murlidhar on 22nd January 1928 in satisfaction of the final decree held by Murlidhar.

Babu Ram died before the suit leading to this appeal was filed. The plaintiff impleaded defendants 8 to 10, successors-in-interest of Babu Ram, alleging they were subsequent transferees of the mortgaged property. The defendants contested the suit claiming that by paying the decretal amount to Murlidhar, they had acquired his rights as prior mortgagee and thus could prevent the plaintiff from selling the property without first paying them the amount due on their prior mortgage of 1919. This contention was accepted by the lower courts.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether defendants 8 to 10, by paying off the amount due on Murlidhar's final decree, acquired the rights of Murlidhar as prior mortgagee by subrogation.
  2. Whether the mortgage held by Murlidhar was redeemed in full by Babu Ram’s payment, thereby conferring the right of subrogation under Section 92 of the Transfer of Property Act.
  3. Whether the plaintiff-appellant was entitled to proceed with the sale of the property notwithstanding the defendants’ claim to prior mortgage rights.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The amount paid by Babu Ram in 1928 (Rs. 539-4-0) exceeded the sum due under Murlidhar’s mortgage, which was only Rs. 9-4-0, thus the mortgage was redeemed in full.
  • Reliance on the last paragraph of Section 92 of the Transfer of Property Act, which states that no right of subrogation arises unless the mortgage has been redeemed in full.
  • The appellant argued that since the mortgage was fully redeemed, Babu Ram did not acquire the prior mortgagee’s rights and therefore defendants 8 to 10 could not hold the mortgage as a shield against the plaintiff’s claim.

Respondents' Arguments

  • By paying the decretal amount to Murlidhar, Babu Ram acquired Murlidhar’s rights as prior mortgagee by subrogation.
  • Therefore, defendants 8 to 10, as successors-in-interest, were entitled to prevent the plaintiff from selling the property without first satisfying their prior mortgage claim.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined the applicability of Section 92 of the Transfer of Property Act, which confers a right of subrogation only when the mortgage in question has been redeemed in full. The appellant’s contention that Babu Ram had to pay the entire amount mentioned in the final decree, including interest, to acquire the right of subrogation was rejected. The court clarified that it is sufficient if the mortgage has been redeemed in full, and it is not necessary that the entire amount due under the mortgage be paid if the mortgagee consents to accept a lesser sum as full satisfaction.

In this case, there was no evidence that Murlidhar did not consent to the payment of Rs. 539-4-0 as full satisfaction of his decree. Moreover, testimony from Murlidhar’s son confirmed that the decree had been discharged. Consequently, the mortgage was deemed redeemed in full, conferring the right of subrogation to defendants 8 to 10 as successors of Babu Ram. The court found no error in the lower courts’ acceptance of this position and dismissed the appeal with costs.

Holding and Implications

DISMISSED WITH COSTS

The court upheld the lower courts’ rulings that defendants 8 to 10 acquired the rights of the prior mortgagee by subrogation upon payment of the decretal amount. As a result, the defendants were entitled to assert the mortgage as a defense against the plaintiff’s claim. This decision directly affects the parties by confirming the defendants’ priority rights but does not establish any new legal precedent beyond the application of established principles under Section 92 of the Transfer of Property Act.

Show all summary ...

1. This appeal arises out of a suit for sale on a mortgage dated 8th March 1919, and the sole question for consideration in the appeal is whether or not the Courts below were right in holding that defendants 8 to 10 had acquired the rights of a prior mortgagee of the year 1919 and were entitled to hold up that mortgage as a shield against the claim of the plaintiff-appellant. The facts are as follows:

One Muqaddam mortgaged his property in the year 1913 by means of a deed of simple mortgage to one Murlidbar. He again mortgaged the same property in the year 1919 to the plaintiff-appellant. Muqaddam's brother Pir Baksh also joined in the execution of the mortgage of 1919, but I am not concerned in the present appeal with the share mortgaged by Pir Baksh. Murlidhar put his mortgage into suit and obtained a preliminary decree in the year 1925 and a final decree in the year 1926. The final decree was for a sum of Rs. 539-4-6 with future interest at six per cent, per annum. After Murlidhar obtained the final decree for sale Muqaddam's equity of redemption in the mortgaged property was sold in execution of a simple money decree and purchased by Babu Ram, the predecessor-in-title of defendants 8 to 10. Babu Ram paid a sum of Rs. 539-4-0 to Murlidhar on 22nd January 1928, in satisfaction of ??? final decree held by him (Murlidhar). ??? had not impleaded the ??? plaintiff in the suit for sale brought ??? him and the present plaintiff there ??? was not debarred from putting his ??? into suit.

2. Babu Ram died before the suit giving ??? to the present appeal was filed and ??? plaintiff impleaded amongst other defendants 8 to 10, the successors-interest of Babu Ram, on the allegation at they were subsequent transferees of ??? mortgaged property. These defendants contested the suit on the allegation at by paying up the decretal amount Murlidhar they had acquired the ??? of Murlidhar as prior mortgagee, ??? as such, the plaintiff was not ??? to sell the property for the ??? of the amount due to him with ??? first paying to them the amount ??? on the basis of the prior ??? of 1919. This contention of the ??? has been accepted by both the ??? below.

3. It is contended by the ??? counsel for the plaintiff-appellant that as the amount due on the basis the final decree in the year 1928, ??? the payment was made by Babu ??? far exceeded the sum of Rupees 9-4-0 the mortgage of Murlidhar was ??? redeemed in full by Babu Ram. It therefore argued that the right of ??? was not acquired by Babu Ram. In support of this contention ??? placed on the last paragraph of 92 of the Transfer of Property Act which provides that:

Nothing in this section shall be deemed to ??? a right of subrogation on any person unless ??? mortgage in respect of which the right is ??? has been redeemed in full.

4. The argument is that in order to ??? the right of subrogation conferred ??? S. 92 Babu Ram should have paid to ??? the entire amount mentioned the final decree together with interest ??? by that decree. This ??? in my opinion, is untenable. All ??? is necessary to confer the right of ??? is that the mortgage in respect of which the right is claimed should have been redeemed in full. It is not necessary that the entire amount due on ??? basis of the mortgage should be paid the mortgagee agrees to let the mortgage be redeemed on payment of a ??? amount. In the present case there ??? nothing to show that Murlidhar did ??? consent to let his decree stand satisfied on payment of sum of Rs. 539-4-0 only. This point was not raised in either of the Courts below and therefore the matter was not decided by those Courts. There is however the fact that the son of Murlidhar came in the witness-box and testified to the fact that his decree had been discharged. The mortgage of Murlidhar was therefore redeemed in full and defendants 8 to 10 were subrogated to the right that Murlidhar had on the basis of the mortgage of 1913. The decrees of the Courts below are therefore perfectly correct and accordingly I dismiss this appeal with costs.

B.D

5. Appeal dismissed.