Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Abdul Kasim v. Thambusami Pillai

Madras High Court
Sep 15, 1916
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Concise Analytical Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The proceedings arise from execution of a decree passed in a Small Cause suit. The second defendant was a party to that suit. At first instance the District Munsif gave a judgment allowing the second defendant's claim to the attached property; on appeal the Subordinate Judge dismissed that claim. The matter reached this Court by an appeal (described as a second appeal against an appellate order) and a separate revision petition filed by the same person who sought revision.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a second appeal to this Court lies in respect of the appellate order, having regard to Section 102 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
  2. Whether the conditions for interference under Section 115 of the Code of Civil Procedure are satisfied—specifically, whether the second defendant was a party throughout the suit so that the enquiry into his claim was held under Section 47 and an appeal lay.

Arguments of the Parties

Argument Pressed in Support of Revision

  • The single argument pressed (as recorded in the opinion) was that the second defendant was not a party throughout the suit in which the decree under execution was passed, and therefore the enquiry into his claim was not held under Section 47; consequently, no appeal lay from that enquiry.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Aithala v. Subbana, 12 M. 116 : 4 Ind. Dec. (N.S.) 430 Referenced in relation to Section 102 of the Code of Civil Procedure to support the conclusion that the second appeal to this Court does not lie. The Court relied on this authority (in connection with Section 102) to hold that the appeal to this Court does not lie and accordingly dismissed the second appeal against the appellate order.
Gadicherla China Seetayya v. Gadicherla Seetayya, 21 M. 45 : 7 Ind. Dec. (N.S.) 388 Example of a case where a party's name was removed from the suit (an exoneration that resulted in removal of the party's name from proceedings). The Court observed that nothing before it showed that the exoneration recorded in the decree had the effect of removing the second defendant's name from the suit as occurred in this precedent; this supported the conclusion that the second defendant did not cease to be a party.
Ramaswami Sastrulu v. Kameswaramma, 23 M. 361 : 10 M.L.J. 126 : 8 Ind. Dec. (N.S.) 653 Cited similarly in support of the proposition concerning removal/exoneration and continuity of party status in the suit. Used by the Court as additional authority for the conclusion that the recorded exoneration did not demonstrate that the second defendant had ceased to be a party; consequently, subsequent proceedings were under Section 47 and were appealable.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded in two analytical stages corresponding to the two procedural remedies invoked.

  1. On the question whether the appeal to this Court lay, the Court considered Section 102 of the Code of Civil Procedure and referred to Aithala v. Subbana. On that basis the Court held that the appeal did not lie and therefore dismissed the second appeal (the appeal against the appellate order).
  2. On the revision petition under Section 115, the Court considered whether the Subordinate Judge had acted without jurisdiction—which would justify interference—because the second defendant allegedly was not a party throughout and therefore the enquiry into his claim had not been held under Section 47 (making any appeal invalid).
    • The Court noted the sole argument pressed on revision: that the second defendant ceased to be a party during the suit, so that proceedings were not properly conducted under Section 47.
    • The Court examined the decree and observed that, although it recorded that the second defendant was "exonerated" by the plaintiff, there was nothing before the Court to show that this exoneration had the operative effect of removing the second defendant's name from the suit in the manner shown in Gadicherla China Seetayya v. Gadicherla Seetayya (and as elucidated by Ramaswami Sastrulu v. Kameswaramma).
    • Because there was no evidence that the exoneration effected such a removal, the Court concluded that the second defendant did not cease to be a party to the suit. Accordingly, the subsequent enquiry between him and the plaintiff was governed by Section 47 and the resulting order was appealable.
    • Given this conclusion, the Court found no ground to hold that the Subordinate Judge had acted without jurisdiction; thus interference under Section 115 was not justified.

Holding and Implications

Final Disposition:

The second appeal (appeal against the appellate order) is dismissed. This dismissal rests on the Court's conclusion under Section 102 of the Code of Civil Procedure (as supported by Aithala v. Subbana).

The civil revision petition under Section 115 is dismissed with costs. The Court held that the second defendant did not cease to be a party to the suit despite the recital of exoneration in the decree; therefore the proceedings were under Section 47 and the appellate order was properly appealable, leaving no ground for revision.

Implications: The decision disposes of the two remedies sought by the petitioner by upholding the appellate order and dismissing the revision. The opinion does not set out any broader precedent beyond the application of the cited authorities to the facts; its immediate effect is confined to dismissal of the second appeal and dismissal of the civil revision petition with costs.

Show all summary ...

1. The second defendant was a party to the Small Cause suit in which the decree under execution was passed; and the lower Court's judgments were given, the District Munsif's allowing and the Subordinate Judge's dismissing his claim to the attached property.

2. The first question is whether this appeal to this Court lies. We must hold that it does not with reference to Section 102 of the Code of Civil Procedure. Vide Aithala v. Subbana 12 M. 116 : 4 Ind. Dec. (N.S.) 430. The second appeal (Appeal against Appellate Order), therefore, must be dismissed.

3. Next he has also filed a revision petition and we have to consider whether the conditions postulated by Section 115 of the Code of Civil Procedure are fulfilled. We have been pressed only by one argument, which calls for notice, that the second defendant was not a party throughout the suit in which the decree under execution was passed and that, therefore, the enquiry into his claim was not held under Section 47 and no appeal lay. If the lower Appellate Court heard an appeal which did not lie, it would no doubt have acted with, out Jurisdiction and interference under Section 115 would be justified. We, however, are not satisfied that the second defendant was not a party throughout. The second defendant, as the decree states, was exonerated, by the plaintiff. But there is nothing before us to show that this exoneration resulted in anything except the dismissal of the suit against him of that there was any such removal of his name from the suit as appears to have taken place in Gadicherla China Seetayya v. Gadicherla Seetayya 21 M. 45 : 7 Ind. Dec. (N.S.) 388. Vide also Ramaswa ni Sastrulu v. Kameswaramma 23 M. 361 : 10 M. L.J. 126 : 8 Ind. Dec, (N.S.) 653. In these circumstances the 2nd defendant did not cease to be a party to the suit. The subsequent proceedings between him and the plaintiff were, therefore, under Section 47 and the order in them was appealable. There is, therefore, no ground for interfering with the Subordinate Judge's order in revision. The civil revision petition is, therefore, dismissed with costs.