Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Secy. Of State v. Dhokalmal Mahadeb Lal .

Calcutta High Court
May 25, 1931
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion (Mitter, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

This appeal is brought by the Secretary of State for India in Council, arising from an action by a respondent firm (the consignor/plaintiff) for compensation against the East Indian Railway Company (the railway administration) after goods consigned from Burdwan to Barakar were partly not delivered. On 27 December 1924 twenty-one casks of mustard oil were despatched; the consignor paid reduced freight and a risk-note in form B was executed. The plaintiffs alleged that six out of the 21 casks were not delivered because of misconduct by the railway administration or their servants and claimed Rs. 1,206.

The East Indian Railway Company had been taken over by the Government and the Secretary of State was made defendant 2. The defendants relied on the new risk-note form B to limit liability, arguing the company was exonerated except where loss arose from misconduct of the railway administration's servants. The Subordinate Judge dismissed the plaintiffs' action on that basis. The District Judge of Burdwan reversed the Subordinate Judge and allowed a substantial part of the plaintiffs' claim. The Secretary of State appealed to the court whose opinion is summarized here.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. What is the proper legal interpretation and scope of the word “misconduct” in the new risk-note form B (effective 1 October 1924), in particular whether it requires proof of breach of company rules by railway servants or whether it can include misconduct of the railway administration itself or other mismanagement or wilful neglect?
  2. Whether, on the specific facts found by the District Judge (wagon doors fastened with rivetted tin shackles instead of being padlocked, ease of removal of shackles, unexplained two-day transit for 72–76 miles), an inference of misconduct on the part of the railway administration or its servants is raised so as to discharge the consignor's burden and render the railway liable for loss of part of the consignment.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant (Secretary of State for India in Council / Railway administration)

  • The railway administration contended that under the new risk-note form B its liability is limited and it is not liable except upon proof that the loss is due to the misconduct of the railway company's servants.
  • It was argued the word “misconduct” in the risk-note implies that a railway servant has committed an act inconsistent with the conduct required of him by the company's rules — i.e., an actual breach of duty or rules — and in the absence of proof of such breach no fair inference of misconduct could arise.
  • The appellant relied on the decision in B.B. & C.I. Ry. Co. Ltd. v. Rajnagar Spinning, Weaving and Manufacturing Co. Ltd. (A.I.R. 1930 Bom. 129) to support the narrower interpretation of “misconduct.”

Respondent (Consignor / Plaintiffs)

  • The consignor's pleaded case was that six casks out of twenty-one were not delivered and the loss could not be delivered owing to misconduct of the railway administration or their servants.
  • The plaintiffs claimed Rs. 1,206 as compensation for the loss of the six casks.
  • The District Judge's findings emphasised facts said to show misconduct or wilful neglect: the wagon doors arrived open, the casks were missing, doors had rivetted tin shackles (not padlocks) which could be hammered away quickly, and the unexplained delay of two days for the short journey.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
B.B. & C.I. Ry. Co. Ltd. v. Rajnagar Spinning, Weaving and Manufacturing Co. Ltd., A.I.R. 1930 Bom. 129 Supported a narrow interpretation of “misconduct” in the new risk-note — requiring proof that a railway servant breached company rules. The court considered this decision but rejected its restrictive approach in cases falling under the proviso of the new risk-note, holding the Bombay view to be too limited.
Bengal Nagpur Railway Company v. Hukum Chand Hurdutt Roy, A.I.R. 1930 Pat. 559 Criticised the restrictive Bombay interpretation and supported a broader view of “misconduct.” The opinion relies on this Patna decision as correctly criticising the Bombay view and supports the broader construction adopted by the court.
B.N. Ry. Co. Ltd. v. Moolji Sicka & Co., A.I.R. 1929 Cal. 654 Held that in certain circumstances negligence was good evidence of misconduct; treated “misconduct” as covering mismanagement such as using an improper wagon in contravention of company rules. The court referred to this case as precedent for treating negligence or mismanagement as evidence of “misconduct” under the new risk-note.
B.N. Ry. Co. Ltd. v. Moolji Sicka & Co., A.I.R. 1930 Cal. 815 Expressed a wide meaning of “misconduct” to include wrongful commission or omission, intentional or unintentional. The court cited this wider interpretation (Suhrawardy, J., with Patterson, J. concurring) to support the conclusion that omission deliberately not to padlock can constitute misconduct.
Karali Prosad Dutta v. E.I. Ry. Co., A.I.R. 1928 Cal. 498 Found that deliberate omission (e.g., not padlocking) could amount to misconduct/wilful neglect by the railway administration. The court relied on this case to support the conclusion that deliberate omission to padlock is misconduct or wilful neglect and thus falls within the new risk-note's liability.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court began by setting out the operative language of the new risk-note form B (effective 1 October 1924), emphasising the proviso that applies where there is nondelivery of whole packages or pilferage. Under that proviso the railway administration must disclose in detail how the consignment was dealt with while in its possession and, if necessary, give evidence before the consignor is called upon to prove misconduct. If the circumstances disclosed permit a fair inference of misconduct by the railway administration or its servants, the consignor's burden of proof as to misconduct is discharged.

The appellant's argument (and the Bombay decision it relied on) treated “misconduct” narrowly — as requiring proof that a railway servant violated company rules. The court examined that approach and concluded it was too restrictive. In particular, the court reasoned that where the proviso applies the disclosure requirement is intended to enable an inference of misconduct to be drawn from the company's own account of the handling of the goods; that inference may concern misconduct of the railway administration itself as distinct from only misconduct of individual servants.

The court reviewed relevant precedents. It observed that in B.N. Ry. Co. Ltd. v. Moolji Sicka & Co. negligence or mismanagement had been treated as evidence of misconduct and that other judges (Suhrawardy, J. and Patterson, J.) had given a wide meaning to “misconduct” to include wrongful commission or omission. The court held it was unnecessary to resolve whether unintentional omission would always amount to misconduct because on the facts found in the present case the omission to padlock the wagon was deliberate — the usual practice was not to padlock — and that deliberate omission sufficed to constitute misconduct under the new risk-note.

Applying these principles to the District Judge's factual findings (wagon doors fastened only with rivetted tin shackles, shackles could be hammered away in a minute, train stopped at many stations and took two days to cover a short distance without explanation, and the wagon reached Barakar with doors open and casks missing), the court concluded these circumstances raised the inference of misconduct or wilful neglect by the railway administration. The consignor had therefore discharged the onus of proof required by the proviso and entitlement to compensation followed.

The court further explained the policy background: the old risk-note had placed a burdensome initial proof requirement on traders (to prove wilful neglect or theft by the railway or its servants), and the new risk-note (form B) was intended, in cases covered by the proviso, to ease that burden by requiring the railway to disclose handling and thereby permit inferences of misconduct when warranted.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The appeal is DISMISSED.

Implications and direct effects:

  • The District Judge's decree in favour of the plaintiffs (a substantial part of their claim) is upheld by reason of the dismissal of the appeal.
  • The court held that the new risk-note form B imposes a larger measure of responsibility on the railway administration in cases covered by the proviso: where the railway's own disclosure of handling permits an inference of misconduct by the administration or its servants, the consignor's burden to prove misconduct is discharged.
  • On the facts found (deliberate omission to padlock, easy tampering with shackles, unexplained lengthy transit), the court found wilful neglect/misconduct of the railway administration and therefore liability for the loss of part of the consignment.
  • The court ordered dismissal of the appeal with costs (i.e., costs to the respondents as indicated by "I would dismiss the appeal with costs" and the statement "Appeal dismissed").

Note: This summary is strictly confined to matters stated in the provided opinion. No additional facts or inferences beyond the opinion's text have been introduced.

Show all summary ...

Mitter, J.:— This is an appeal by the Secretary of State for India in Council and arises out of an action which was brought by the respondent firm as owner of the goods consigned for compensation against the East Indian Railway Company to whom the goods were delivered for carriage from Burdwan to Barakar Station of the said railway. It appears that 21 casks of mustard oil were despatched from Burdwan on 27th December 1924 for delivery to the plaintiffs at Barakar. The goods were despatched on a reduced freight and a risk-note in form B was executed. Plaintiffs' case is that the railway company did not deliver six out of 21 casks of oil consigned to them and these casks could not be delivered owing to the misconduct of the railway administration or their servants. The plaintiffs claimed Rs. 1,206 as compensation for the loss they sustained.

2. The Secretary of State was made defendant 2 to the action as the railway administration of the East Indian Railway Company was taken over by the Government. The defence, which is material for the purpose of this appeal, is that the defendants are protected from liability under the terms of the new risk-note form B which limits the liability of the railway administration and exonerates them from all liability for any loss, destruction or deterioration of or damage to the consignment from any cause whatever except upon proof that such destruction, deterioration or damage arose from the misconduct of the railway administration's servants. This defence prevailed with the Sub-ordinate Judge who dismissed plaintiffs' action. An appeal was taken to the District Judge of Burdwan who has reversed the decision of the Sub-ordinate Judge and has decreed a substantial part of the plaintiffs' claim.

3. Against this decree of the District Judge the present appeal has been brought and it is contended for the Secretary of State that the decision of the lower appellate Court is vitiated by an erroneous view of the measure of the railway company's liability as limited by the new risk-note form B and it is said that the learned Judge has relied on decisions which were based on the old risk-note form B. In support of this contention reliance has been placed on the case of B.B & C.I Ry. Co. Ltd. v. Rajnagar Spinning, Weaving and Manufacturing Co. Ltd. . A.I.R 1930 Bom. 129. In order to consider the soundness or otherwise of this contention it is necessary to state the precise findings of fact arrived at by the learned District Judge. They can best be stated in his own words:

“(i) The railway company's case is that the casks were loaded in a wagon the doors of which were fastened with rivetted tin shackles from Burdwan on 28th December 1924. The wagon reached Barakar late at night on 30th December 1924 with the doors open and the casks missing. The police were informed of the theft but they failed to trace either the goods or the thieves.

(ii). In the present case the misconduct that the plaintiff alleges to hive been proved lies in the fact that the doors of the wagon were not locked, but were only fastened on the tin shackles which according to the witnesses examined for the defendant could be hammered away in a minute.

(iii). The fact that there were tin shackles and not locks facilitated the theft.

(iv). Another fact which seems to have facilitated the theft was that the wagon took two whole days and more to go to the short distance of 76 miles between Burdwan and Barakar. Why it took such a long time has not been explained.”

4. On these findings the District Judge was of opinion that the plaintiffs are entitled to compensation.

5. It is argued for the appellant that under the new risk-note form B the Railway company is not liable except upon proof that the loss is due to the misconduct of the railway company's servants, in other words, except upon proof that the railway company's servants did violate some rules of the company. It is argued on the authority of the Bombay case previously referred to that the word “misconduct” in the risk-note suggests that a Railway servant has been guilty of doing something which was inconsistent with the conduct required of him by the rules of the company. In the absence of proof; it is argued, that there was any breach of duty in the railway servants or any infringement of the rules which regulate their terms of employment no fair inference of misconduct on the part of the railway administration's servants could properly arise.

6. This contention receives support from the decision of Sir Norman Kemp, C.J, and Murphy, J., in the case of B.B & C. 1. Ry. Co. Ltd. v. Rajnagar Spinning, Weaving and Manufacturing Co. Ltd.. It is therefore necessary to consider carefully the terms of the new risk-note which came in force from 1st October 1924 and which is supposed to have imposed a further measure of responsibility on the part of the railway administration than was entailed by the previous risk-note form, and to see if the view of the learned Chief Justice of Bombay is the right one.

7. The new risk-note form, in so far as is material, runs as follows:

“Whereas the consignment of—tendered by me “Forwading Order” No.—of this date, for despatch by the East Indian Railway Administration to — Station, and for which have received Railway Receipt No.—of same date, is charged at a special reduced rate instead of at the ordinary tariff rate chargeable for such consignment the undersigned do in consideration of such lower charge agree and undertake to hold the said railway administration harmless and free from all responsibility for any loss, destruction or deterioration of or damage to, the said consignment from any cause whatever except upon proof that such loss, destruction, deterioration or damage arose from the misconduct of the railway administration's servants; provided that in the following cases:”

“(a) Nondelivery of the whole of the said consignment or of the whole of one or more packages forming part of the said consignment packed in accordance with the instructions laid down in the tariff or, when there are no such instructions, protected otherwise than by paper or other packing readily removable by hand and fully addressed, where such nondelivery is not due to accidents to trains or to fire; (b) pilferage from a package or packages forming part of the said consignment properly packed and in (a), when such pilferage is pointed out to the servants of the railway administration on or before delivery, the railway administration shall be bound to disclose to the consignor how the consignment was dealt with throughout the time it was in its possession, control and, if necessary, to give evidence thereof before the consignor is called upon to prove misconduct but if misconduct on the part of the railway administration or its servants cannot be fairly inferred from such evidence, the burden of proving such misconduct shall lie upon the consignor.”

8. In the present case there being loss of a part of the consignment the proviso would govern the case and by the proviso it is incumbent on the railway administration to disclose how the consignment was dealt with throughout the time it was in the possession and control of the railway company and to give evidence thereof before the consignor is called upon to prove misconduct, but if misconduct on the part of the railway administration or its servants, cannot be fairly inferred from such evidence the burden of proof of such misconduct shall lie upon the consignor.

9. In the case covered by the proviso, as the present case is, it is obligatory on the railway company to disclose in detail how the consignment was dealt with throughout the transit and if the circumstances so disclosed raise an inference of misconduct on the part of either the railway administration or its servants the burden of proving misconduct on the part of the railway company's servants as in the original clause of the risk-note must be taken to have been discharged by the consignor.

10. The learned Judges of the Bombay High Court overlook this that in cases covered by the proviso inference of misconduct even on the part of railway administration as distinguished from those of its servants is sufficient to discharge the burden which lies on the consignor of proving the misconduct of the railway administration's servants. The view taken in the Bombay case is that the liability of the railway company must be limited to those cases where the servants of the railway administration have been guilty of the breach of the company but this view seems to me to be inconsistent with the rule that even misconduct of the railway administration where the facts disclosed by the company raise the inference of misconduct of the railway administration as distinguished from the misconduct of its servants would discharge the consignor of the burden which lay on him of showing the misconduct of the servants and seems to be too restricted a view of the company's liability. I do not say that the consignor is not to prove that the loss was due to the misconduct of the company's servants, but the proviso makes it clear that the burden of proving the same is discharged by showing misconduct either of the railway administration or of its servants:

“The contract which we have to interpret is a contract between the railway administration and the consignor of the goods, and the misconduct referred to in the risk-note is not such misconduct of the railway servants as may amount to a failure of duty towards their employers but such misconduct on the part of the railway servants or the railway administration itself as amounts to failure of duty towards the consignor.”

11. This is the criticizm to which the Bombay view has been subjected, and in my opinion rightly subjected, by James, J., in a recent Patna case: see Bengal Nagpur Railway Company v. Hukum Chand Hurdutt Roy, A.I.R 1930 Pat. 559.

12. For these reasons lam unable to agree with the learned Judges of the Bombay High Court. If the view of the learned Judges of the Bombay High Court is to be adopted then however lax may have been the rules of the railway administration regarding the care to be taken by them regarding goods on transit they escape liability for there is no misconduct on the part of the servants of the railway in the sense that there has been no breach of any rules or orders of the railway. In the old risk-note form the company was liable if the loss was due to the wilful neglect of the railway administration or its servants. By the new form it was not intended to restrict the liability but to enlarge the measure of the responsibility of the administration in cases that fall within the proviso.

13. We have now to consider whether the facts found by the District Judge raise an inference of misconduct on the part of railway administration. In the case of B.N Ry. Co. Ltd. v. Moolji Sicka & Co. . A.I.R 1929 Cal. 654, I held that in certain circumstances negligence was good evidence of misconduct. In that case it is true biris were damaged by being carried in a wooden-topped wagon through which rain-water filtered, and the use of the wooden-topped wagon was contrary to the rules of the company. I said in that case that the word “misconduct” covered mismanagement of that kind. A wider meaning has been given to the word “misconduct” by my learned brother Suhrawardy, J., with whom my learned brother Patterson, J. concurred. In that case Suhrawardy, J. said this:

“I am inclined to hold that the word “misconduct” as used in the new risk-note B is wide enough to include wrongful commission and omission, intentional or unintentional; any act which it wrongfully did or wrongfully neglected to do, or, to put it in another way, did what it should not have done and did not do what it should have done: see B.N Ry. Co. Ltd. v. Moolji Sicka & Co. . A.I.R 1930 Cal. 815.”

and the learned Judge was of opinion that this was the view which I took in the case of B.N Ry. Co. Ltd. v. Moolji Sicka & Co.. The appellant has argued that Suhrawardy and Patterson, JJ. put a wider meaning on the word “misconduct.” It is not necessary to consider whether an unintentional omission will amount to “misconduct” seeing that on the facts found in the present case there was clearly deliberate omission to padlock the wagon and this is sufficient to constitute misconduct on the part of the railway administration. The consignment was loaded in a wagon which was not padlocked and the omission was not accidental but the usual practice was not to padlock and therefore there was deliberate and intentional omission which made the railway company responsible under the old risk-note form: see Karali Prosad Dutta v. E.I Ry. Co. . A.I.R 1928 Cal. 498, on the ground that this was misconduct on the part of the railway administration. The word “misconduct” has been substituted for the words “wilful neglect or theft” used in the superseded risk-note B but the term covers both.

14. I do not see any reason why this deliberate omission to padlock should not be regarded as misconduct on the part of the railway administration. The findings show that the rivet and the seal could be hammered away in a minute, the train was to stop at every station and some time for hours and the seal could be tampered with. Then again the learned Judge points out that it has not been explained by the railway company why it took two whole days and more to go the short distance of 72 miles. Under these circumstances I think there was wilful neglect on the part of the railway administration and they cannot escape liability for “misconduct,” the new form covers a case of wilful neglect. The view that there would be wilful neglect on the part of the railway administration in circumstances resembling the present has been held in the case of Karali Prosad Dutta v. E.I Ry. Co., already referred to. The consignor having proved misconduct on the part of the administration has discharged the onus of showing misconduct on the part of the railway administration's servants. It seems to me that the risk-note form B imposes a larger measure of responsibility on the railway administration than the old risk-note form. Under the old risk-note form before the trader could recover for any of the goods the burden of proving in the first instance that the loss sustained arose from the wilful neglect or theft of the railway administration or its servants lay on him.

15. And it appeared that the apparent protection afforded to the trader was rather illusory; it practically gave him no protection at all for it was often impossible for a trader to know what it is that has caused loss of the goods between the time when he delivered the goods in the hands of the railway company's servants and the time when they ought to have been delivered at the other end of the journey. The explanation of the loss was often within the exclusive knowledge of the railway company and for the trader to be compelled to prove that it was due to the wilful neglect or theft of the railway company's servants was to call upon him to establish something which it was almost impossible for him to prove. None the less that was the burden which the trader undertook under the old risk-note form B. Representations were made for the revision of the old risk-note and as a result of the representation the Governor-General in Council approved the new risk-note form in 1924 and it has, in cases covered by the proviso viz., where there is loss of the entire packages, made it easier for the trader to discharge the initial burden if on the facts disclosed by the railway company misconduct either on the part of the railway administration or its servants could be inferred. For these reasons I would dismiss the appeal with costs.

Patterson, J.:— I agree.

K.N/R.K

16. Appeal dismissed.