Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Syed Amir Nawab v. Musammat Wajda Begum

Patna High Court
Feb 16, 1927

Kulwant Sahay and Allanson, JJ.:— (After stating the facts set out above, proceeded as follows:)

Under section 8 of the Suits Valuation Act where in suits other than those referred, to in section 7, paragraphs V, VI and IX, and paragraph X, clause (d), of the Court-fees Act, court-fees are payable advalorein, the value as determinable for the computation of court-fees and the value for purposes of jurisdiction shall be the same. In the present case court-fee is payable under Schedule II, Article 17 of the Court-fees Act. The fee payable on the plaint as well as on the memorandum of appeal is & fixed sum of Rs. 15 and not advalorem. Therefore, the value of the subject-matter of the suit must be the market value thereof. Having regard to the circumstances of the present case, there can be no doubt that the market value of the subject-matter of suit exceeds the sum of Rs. 5,000, and under section 21(1) of Act XII of 1887 the appeal would lie to the High Court.

It has, however, been contended on behalf of the defendant-respondent that the plaintiff having valued the properties in suit in his plain at a sum below Rs. 5,000, he is not now entitled to alter the valuation, and that the value of the subject-matter of the suit must be taken to be the valuation as stated in the plaint, and that, therefore, the appeal would lie to the District Judge. Learned Advocate for the defendant-respondent referred to Order VII, rule 1, of the Code of Civil Procedure where it is provided that the plaint shall; among other matters, contain a statement of the value of the subject-matter of the suit for the purposes of jurisdiction and of court-fees so far as the case admits. He next refers to section 96 of the Code and contends that the appeal would lie to the Court authorised to hear the appeal, and that the Court authorised to hear this appeal under section 21 of Act XII of 1887 is the Court of the District Judge. These provisions, however, in my opinion, do not help us in determining the question now before use Order VII, rule 1, merely directs that the value of the subject-matter of the suit should be stated in the plaint, and section 96 directs that the appeal would lie to the Court authorised to hear the appeal. The real question is, what is the value of the subject-matter of the suit. The value of the subject-matter of the suit unquestionably exceeds the sum of Rs. 5,000, and, therefore, the Court authorised to hear the appeal would be the High Court.

It is however, contended that the plaintiff having valued the subject-matter of the suit in the plaint at a certain sum cannot now turn round and say that the valuation is higher than that sum. In my opinion there is nothing in the law to prevent the plaintiff-appellant from showing what the real value of the subject-matter of the suit is Cases have frequently come up to this Court where objection has been taken that the valuation given in the plaint did not represent the true value of the subject-matter of the suit, and this Court has on several occasions enquired into the real value of the subject-matter of the suit inspite of the fact that the plaintiff had stated the value at a certain figure in the plaint.

In Mohini Mohan Misser v. Gour Chandra Rai the suit was valued in the plaint at Rs. 1,400. An appeal against the decree passed by the trial Court was filed in the Court of the District Judge, and on the case coming up in Second Appeal to the High Court against the decree of the District Judge in appeal, it was found that the proper valuation of the subject-matter of the suit was Rs. 16,275. It was held that the appeal to the District Judge was incompetent and that his decree was without jurisdiction. No doubt, objection as regards valuation in that suit was taken in the trial Court as well as in the District Judge's Court, but this circumstance does not affect the question now for determination.

In Mahanth Rukmin Das v. Deva Singh* it was held under similar circumstances that the appeal to the District Judge was incompetent, and his decree was without jurisdiction.

In Shah Radha Kishun v. Mahadeo Lal the Second Appeal was heard by a Division Bench of this Court and judgment delivered. But before judgment was signed, a question was raised as regards the value of the subject-matter of the suit. An inquiry was ordered, and it was found that the value exceeded the sum of Rs. 5,000. It was held that the District Judge had no jurisdiction to hear the appeal and his decree was set aside on this ground, and the memorandum of appeal presented in the Court of the District Judge was directed to be returned in order to be presented to this Court.

It is contended, that; having regard to the valuation put by the plaintiff in his plaint, the memorandum of appeal must be presented before the District Judge, and the question as regards valuation determined by him, and if he found that the value exceeded the sum of Rs. 5,000, it was for him to return the memorandum of appeal to be presented to this Court, and that the plaintiff-appellant could not come up directly to this Court without first going to the Court of the District Judge. In my opinion this is not the proper procedure. If the District Judge had no jurisdiction to entertain the appeal, the plaintiff-appellant cannot be compelled to present his memorandum before the District Judge with the object of its being returned.

The question whether the plaintiff can be allowed to show that the valuation given by him in the plaint is below the real value has been frequently raised in applications for leave to appeal to the Privy Council. Under section 110, paragraph 1, of the Code of Civil Procedure the amount or value of the subject-matter of the suit in the court of first instance must be Rs. 10,000 or upwards, and plaintiffs desiring to appeal to His Majesty in Council have frequently been allowed to show that although the valuation put by them in the plaint was below the sum of Rs. 10,000, yet the real value was above Rs. 10,000.

On a consideration of all the circumstances we are of opinion that this Court has jurisdiction to entertain this appeal, and the memorandum of appeal was properly presented to this Court. We, therefore, direct that the appeal be admitted and proceeded with in the ordinary course.

Appeal admitted.