- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
A.P. Bagchi v. F. Morgan
Structured Summary of the Opinion
Factual and Procedural Background
This appeal arises from a suit for ejectment and arrears of rent relating to a house at No. 10 Albert Road. The material facts as recorded in the opinion are:
- The monthly rent for the house was agreed at Rs. 75.
- The plaintiff claimed the defendant remained in occupation despite repeated notices to vacate and did not deliver possession.
- The defendant's principal defences were: (a) an alleged contract of tenancy that he could remain so long as he paid rent regularly and complied with conditions (i.e., landlord could not give notice to quit), and (b) that 15 days' notice given on the 15th of a month by either party was essential.
- The trial Court decreed the plaintiff's claim, but the lower appellate Court dismissed the claim, finding that the plaintiff never accepted the defendant's proposed condition barring her right to give notice to quit.
- Relevant correspondence: plaintiff offered to let the house on 12 May 1930 at Rs. 75/month; defendant replied on 13 May 1930 with conditions; on 14 May 1930 plaintiff stated among other things a 15-days' notice rule; defendant replied with a counter-offer including nine additional conditions (one being the alleged perpetual tenancy so long as rent paid); plaintiff did not reply; defendant took possession on 18 May 1930 and paid Rs. 75 monthly.
- The defendant raised additional points later in the litigation about municipal taxes and repairs and relied on several statutory and common-law concepts in support of his case.
Procedurally, the case comes to this Court as a defendant's appeal from the lower appellate Court's dismissal of the plaintiff's claim; this Court examined the correspondence and evidence and dismissed the appeal with costs.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether there was a binding contract of tenancy (lease) by which the plaintiff agreed that so long as the defendant paid rent regularly and complied with conditions the plaintiff would not be entitled to give notice to quit.
- Whether 15 days' notice given on the 15th of a month (or, alternatively, any particular mode of computing the notice period) was an essential term binding the parties.
- Whether, in absence of a written instrument signed by the lessor, Section 53-A (and related doctrines of part performance) or other equitable principles could validate the defendant's asserted permanent tenancy or prevent ejectment.
- Whether the decision in AIR 1932 PC 279 (Privy Council) and Section 110 of the Transfer of Property Act (relating to computation of time where the lease commences from a particular day) applied to the notice computation in this case, or whether Section 106 governed monthly tenancies.
- Whether the defendant could claim credit for municipal taxes and repairs at this stage, and whether the Court below ought to have passed a preliminary decree under Order XX, Rule 12 CPC to allow ascertainment of amounts due.
Arguments of the Parties
Defendant's (Appellant's) Arguments
- There existed a contract of tenancy under which the defendant could remain so long as he paid rent regularly and complied with other conditions; hence he could not be lawfully ejected.
- Alternatively, the parties agreed that tenancy could be terminated only by a 15-days' notice given on the 15th of a month.
- Section 53-A of the Transfer of Property Act (and doctrines of part performance) would protect the defendant where there is a completed contract, enabling him to remain in possession.
- The plaintiff's notice was invalidly computed and should have expired on 1 August rather than 31 July (relying in part on the Privy Council decision, AIR 1932 PC 279, and the analogy to Section 110).
- The defendant had paid municipal taxes and spent money on repairs and should be credited for those amounts against amounts claimed by the plaintiff.
- The Court below should have passed a preliminary decree under Order XX, Rule 12 CPC to permit ascertainment of sums due and allow the defendant to set off taxes and repair expenses.
Plaintiff's (Respondent's) Arguments
- The plaintiff did not accept the defendant's proposed condition that barred her right to give notice to quit; her offer included ordinary monthly tenancy terms (15 days' notice expiring at the end of a month) and the defendant's reply was a counter-offer.
- The plaintiff never signed any writing accepting the defendant's terms; she did not reply to his letter proposing new conditions.
- The plaintiff limited her relief at trial to recovery of fixed rents and did not press claims for damages; thus the amount due was ascertained and a preliminary decree (Order XX, Rule 12) was unnecessary.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| AIR 1932 PC 279 (Privy Council) | Interpreted under Section 110 of the Transfer of Property Act regarding exclusion of the day when a lease is expressed to commence from a particular day in computation of time. | The Court held this precedent inapplicable because the present case involved no writing expressing a particular commencement date from which to compute the lease period; thus Section 110 (and the Privy Council authority) did not help the defendant's contention about notice computation. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court's analysis proceeded in stages, closely tied to findings of fact and statutory requirements recorded in the opinion:
- Factual finding upheld: The lower appellate Court's finding that the plaintiff never accepted the defendant's alleged term (that she would not be entitled to give notice so long as rent was paid) was treated as a finding of fact and was not open to rehearing on appeal. The correspondence showed the plaintiff made an offer (letter of 12 May 1930 and 14 May 1930), the defendant replied with a counter-offer containing additional conditions, and the plaintiff did not accept or sign any writing accepting those new terms.
- Counter-offer and lack of acceptance: Because the defendant's reply introduced a large number of new conditions, it amounted to a counter-offer rather than acceptance of the plaintiff's offer. The plaintiff's silence and lack of signed acceptance meant there was no concluded contract on the defendant's terms.
- Credibility and conduct: The lower appellate Court reasonably rejected the defendant's oral evidence as interested and improbable—particularly given that the defendant was a trained lawyer and the plaintiff an elderly lay person. The Court found it unlikely the defendant would rely solely on oral assurances for what would be an effectively perpetual lease without obtaining a written, signed instrument.
- Requirement of writing and registration: The Court relied on the established rule that a lease of immovable property which is to be valid and, in particular, one which purported to be permanent or for more than one year would require writing signed by the lessor and registration. The alleged contract — a perpetual lease enforceable from generation to generation so long as rent was paid — lacked any writing signed by the plaintiff and so could not be given effect.
- On Section 53-A and part performance: Section 53-A of the Transfer of Property Act was held inapplicable because it requires a written contract signed by the person or his agent containing terms from which a transfer can be ascertained with reasonable certainty. There was no such writing here. Part performance could not transform the defendant's possession into a perpetual registered lease; at most it could have borne on possession and rent, but not create indefeasible rights of perpetual tenancy in absence of the required written and registered instrument.
- Computation of notice: The defendant's reliance on AIR 1932 PC 279 and Section 110 was rejected because there was no writing fixing a particular commencement date of the lease. Instead, the tenancy in this factual setting fell under Section 106 (monthly tenancy) so that the tenancy would terminate by 15 days' notice expiring with the end of a month. The plaintiff's notice dated 24 June 1931 requiring vacation by midnight 31 July was valid; there was no requirement that the plaintiff must have sent the notice on 15 July or that the notice must expire on 1 August.
- Taxes and repairs, and Order XX, Rule 12 CPC: The defendant's claim for municipal taxes and repair expenses was not pleaded in the written statement nor raised in the lower appellate Court by written application. The trial Court (this Court) therefore did not permit introduction of those late points. Regarding the request for a preliminary decree under Order XX, Rule 12 CPC, the Court found that when the plaintiff confined her claim to fixed rents the amount was ascertained, so there was no need for a preliminary decree to permit further ascertainment by additional evidence; preliminary decrees are appropriate when exact amounts must be ascertained after examination of further evidence, which was not the situation here.
- Conclusion of analysis: On the combination of factual findings (no acceptance by the plaintiff), evidentiary considerations (rejection of interested oral testimony), statutory requirements (writing and registration for leases of indefinite/long duration), and the inapplicability of Section 53-A and the cited Privy Council authority, the defendant's case was found to be wholly without merit.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The appeal is dismissed. The Court affirmed that the plaintiff had not accepted the defendant's asserted term forbidding notice to quit and that the notice served by the plaintiff was valid. The Court dismissed the appeal with costs.
Implications and consequences:
- Direct effect on the parties: The defendant's attempt to establish a perpetual or indefeasible tenancy without a written, signed, and (where required) registered instrument failed; the plaintiff's right to recover possession and fixed rents as claimed was upheld. The defendant's late contentions about municipal taxes and repair expenditures were not entertained.
- No broader new precedent announced: The opinion applies established principles regarding the necessity of written and registered instruments for long leases, the inapplicability of Section 53-A without an appropriate writing, and the rules for computation of notice for monthly tenancies under Section 106. The Court treated the matter primarily as one of fact and application of settled legal rules rather than as laying down a novel rule of law.
P.R/A.L
Disposition: Appeal dismissed.
1. This is a defendant's appeal arising out of a suit for ejectment and arrears of rent from the defendant who occupied the plaintiff's house at No. 10 Albert Road. Admittedly the monthly rent fixed was Rs. 75. The plaintiff's case was that the defendant in spite of repeated notices to vacate the premises stuck to the place and did not deliver possession to the plaintiff. The main defence consisted of two pleas, namely: (1) That there was a contract of tenancy between the parties under which it was agreed that so long as the defendant continued to pay rent regularly and complied with the other conditions, the plaintiff would not be entitled to give him notice to quit; and (2) that 15 days' notice given on the 15th of a month by either party was essential. The trial Court decreed the claim, but on appeal the lower appellate Court has dismissed the claim. The findings of the lower appellate Court are that the plaintiff had never accepted the condition set up by the defendant regarding his continuance so long as he paid rent regularly, and there is again a further finding that she never accepted the term not to eject the defendant if rents were paid. The learned Judge says: “it seems to me that it is clear that she did not accept that condition.” The defendant relied on certain correspondence which passed between the parties prior to the occupation of the house by the defendant.
2. The lower Court has rightly pointed out that the defendant was a trained lawyer familiar with the work of Courts, whereas the plaintiff was an old lady, a lay person, who could not be expected to be acquainted with the technicalities of the law.
3. She had offered to let out the house on rent to the defendant on Rs. 75 a month and she had written a letter to that effect to the defendant on the 12th May 1930 that he was to take the house on a monthly rental of Rs. 75. The defendant offered some conditions in his letter of the 13th May. On 14th May 1930, the plaintiff sent a letter in which, among other matters, she said that 15 days' notice of removal to be given on the fifteenth of a month by either party, that is the landlord and tenant, should be a condition. The defendant in reply never accepted all the conditions put forward by the plaintiff in her letter of 14th May 1930. On the other hand, he accepted some of them and put forward no less than nine more conditions, including the one in which it was said that so long as he paid the rent regularly and complied with the conditions the landlady should not be entitled to give him notice to quit. As the offer made by the plaintiff was not accepted in full, but a large number of new conditions were proposed, it became a counter-offer and by no means an acceptance. It is an admitted fact that the plaintiff never replied to this letter.
4. The defendant, although he was a lawyer and was dealing with a lay person, never took care to obtain any writing from the plaintiff clearly indicating that she agreed to the condition that she would not be entitled to serve notice upon the defendant to vacate the premises so long as rents were paid regularly. It would indeed be a strange condition, unless there were some consideration, like premium for a permanent lease, actually paid. On 18th May 1930, without having received any letter from the plaintiff accepting his terms, and without taking any writing from her as to exact conditions agreed upon, the defendant occupied the house and began to live in it as a tenant and continued to pay Rs. 75 a month as rent for the house. It is therefore not surprising that the lower appellate Court has come to the conclusion that there was never any contract as put forward by the defendant and that the plaintiff had never in fact accepted the condition depriving her of her right to get the premises vacated and restricting such right to the case only when rents were not paid regularly. Such a lease would obviously be a permanent lease which would enure almost for ever, at least from generation to generation so long as rents were paid regularly and no other conditions were expressly broken. The lower appellate Court has further found it most difficult to believe that the defendant would have on a mere oral assurance or acceptance of his terms by the plaintiff taken possession of the house without getting something in a more indelible form from her, and accordingly its categorical finding is that the term was never accepted either expressly or tacitly by the plaintiff, and that this condition in dispute which is the fundamental and sole deciding factor in the defendant's case has not been established to have been agreed upon. He has further remarked that as without taking any writing from the plaintiff to enter into the possession of the house, the defendant took possession, it may be inferred that he agreed to the terms which had been offered by her, which are the ordinary terms on which houses are let out on monthly tenancies terminable at 15 days' notice. The oral evidence in a matter of this kind was of course interested and was rejected by the lower appellate Court.
5. The learned Judge of this Court has again taken pains to examine the entire correspondence carefully and after a consideration of the entire correspondence has come to the same conclusion that there was no contract in fact between the parties that the defendant would not be liable to ejectment so long as he paid rents regularly. We think it was wholly unnecessary for the learned Judge to go into this matter as the finding really was one of fact. It was not a case of any interpretation of a title deed which was the foundation of the defendant's title, but an inference to be drawn from a number of documents as well as evidence and circumstances which cannot be questioned in second appeal. Quite apart from this, we are satisfied that the defendant's case has not a leg to stand upon. The contract of lease as alleged by the defendant would become no doubt one of a permanent lease or lease in perpetuity which would hold good from generation to generation so long as rents were paid regularly. There was no writing obtained from the plaintiff for such a lease and we have only the condition contained in the letter written by the defendant, the alleged lessee. According to the rulings of this Court, before a lease can be validly executed and registered, there ought to be a writing signed by the lessor when immoveable property is leased out, and a mere kabuliyat by the defendant is of no avail. The lease being for more than a year and continuing in perpetuity would require registration. Without a registered document such a lease could not be given effect to. The mere fact that the defendant obtained possession would not entitle him to force upon the plaintiff terms which would amount to a grant in perpetuity.
6. On behalf of the defendant it is urged that Section 53-A of the Transfer of Property Act, would help the defendant when there is a completed contract. That section is obviously inapplicable because it refers to cases where there is a contract to transfer for consideration any immoveable property by writing signed by a person or on his behalf from which the terms necessary to constitute the transfer can be ascertained with reasonable certainty. Admittedly there is no writing signed by the plaintiff containing any such condition, much less any writing from which such a condition could be deduced with reasonable certainty. Again the part performance of the contract would entitle the defendant to remain in possession until evicted on notice and would entitle the plaintiff to claim rent from the defendant, but in the absence of a written contract signed by her would not grant to the defendant permanent rights as rights of a perpetual lessee. The next point urged on behalf of the defendant is that the notice served by the plaintiff was invalid inasmuch as this notice should have expired on the 1st August and not on the 31st July. The defendant in one breath pleads that there was a contract under which he was not liable to ejectment at all, and in the same breath pleads that there was a contract between the parties that the tenancy could be terminated on 15 days' notice. The fact is that the letter which contained the condition of 15 days' notice was never accepted by the defendant. We have already pointed out that his reply was in the form of a counter-offer which had imposed fresh conditions. There is therefore nothing to show that this condition was expressly accepted by the defendant. Indeed if his case had any semblance to reality he would not have accepted the condition of being compelled to vacate the premises on receipt of 15 days' notice. The contention is based on the decision of their Lordships of the Privy Council in AIR 1932 PC 279.1 That was, however, a case under Section 110 of the Transfer of Property Act, which provides that where the time limited by a lease of immoveable property is expressed as commencing from a particular day, in computing that time such day shall be excluded. Admittedly there was no writing in the present case where any particular date was expressed as the date from which the lease would commence. The case in the absence of a contract to the contrary would be governed by Section 106 of the Transfer of Property Act, and monthly rent being payable, the lease would terminate by 15 days' notice, expiring with the end of a month of the tenancy. The plaintiff had given notice on 24th June 1931 calling upon the defendant to vacate the premises by the midnight of the 31st July following. It is impossible to accept the contention that the plaintiff was bound to send the notice on the 15th July and could not have sent it earlier, or that she ought to have asked the defendant to vacate the premises on the expiry of the 1st August and not at the end of the 31st July.
7. The last point urged is that the defendant has paid some municipal taxes and has also spent some money on repairs for which credit should have been given. The points were not taken in the written statement nor was the matter brought to the notice of the lower appellate Court by means of any written application. There is accordingly no reference to these points in the judgment of the lower appellate Court. The point was therefore not allowed to be raised by the learned Judge of this Court at this late stage. The contention urged by the defendant is that under O. 20, R. 12 of the CPC, it was the duty of the Court below to pass a preliminary decree in the first instance and then order the amount due to the plaintiff to be ascertained so as to give the defendant an opportunity to show the payment of taxes and the amount spent by him on repairs. When the plaintiff made it clear that she would not press her claim for damages and confined her relief to the recovery of the fixed rents which had been agreed upon between the parties, the amount was definitely ascertained and there was no occasion for framing a preliminary decree so that there may be another ascertainment of the amount due to the plaintiff. ??? preliminary decree becomes necessary where the exact amount has to be ascertained after an examination of fresh evidence. There was no such thing in this case and we do not think that the Court below was bound to pass a preliminary decree in the first instance.
8. The case of the defendant has completely broken down, and at is not surprising that he should have failed. When a lawyer deals with a lay person, especially ??? stranger, in respect of a contract of lease regarding immoveable property, it is expected that he would have a written and unambiguous document executed by the lady. If he relies merely on her implied consent by her not objecting to the defendant's occupation, he has himself to thank for if the Courts refuse to accept is story. It is difficult to believe that if here had been a clear and agreed contact between the parties, no writing could have been taken from the plaintiff under her own signature so that she light not have any longer any loophole or escape. We accordingly dismiss this appeal with costs.
P.R/A.L
9. Appeal dismissed.
Alert