- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Raj Chandra Bhowmick v. Nawab K. Habibulla And Ors.
Structured Summary of the Opinion
Factual and Procedural Background
The plaintiffs are zamindars of mauza Islampur (Tauzi No. 446, Tipperah Collectorate). The plaintiffs asserted that the mauza was held in defined patni shares: two taluks of six annas each, one taluk of three annas and one taluk of one anna. The one-anna share originally belonged to Ramdhone Nath. After his death his heirs and successors were in possession of that one-anna patni share and paid an annual rental of Rs. 82-15-0.
In 1918 arrears of rent were owed in respect of the one-anna share. The plaintiffs sued for recovery of arrears, obtained a decree, and in execution purchased the patni interest in the one-anna share; the sale was confirmed in or about 1920 and delivery of possession was obtained in 1921. After purchase the plaintiffs discovered settlement records indicating defendants recorded in mirash right; the Record-of-Rights, however, recorded the mirash as held under both the one-anna patni and another patni (a 2 1/2 annas share), while the plaint confined its allegation to the plaintiffs' one-anna patni.
Plaintiffs alleged that the mirash recorded against their one-anna share was an incumbrance; they served notices under Section 167, Bengal Tenancy Act, seeking cancellation and then filed suits in 1926 seeking (inter alia) (a) a declaration that the defendants had no mirash right in the plaintiffs' patni lands and that the plaintiffs were entitled to assessment of rent at local rates; and (b) assessment of fair and equitable rent and recovery thereof. Tenants occupying specific lands were recorded in khatians 317, 318, 319, 321, 323 and 324, which required the plaintiffs to bring separate suits.
Procedural history of the litigation:
- The learned Munsif of Gomilla tried the suits, framed issues (including defect of parties, bar under Section 188 Bengal Tenancy Act, and whether lands belonged to one-anna or 2 1/2-anna hisya) and dismissed the suits on findings including that owners of the 2 1/2 annas hisyas were necessary parties, that notices under Section 167 were not served within statutory time, and that the settlement record presumption had not been rebutted.
- The plaintiffs appealed to the Subordinate Judge of Tipperah, who allowed the appeals: he held the one-anna share had in fact passed to the plaintiffs by sale in execution, that the plaintiffs were not bound to recognize the alleged transfer of half-anna to Bashi Nath, that the mirashes relied upon by defendants did not exist, and that there was no defect of parties.
- The defendants appealed to the High Court and the second appeals were dismissed by Mukerji, J., on 30 January 1929.
- The present proceedings are Letters Patent appeals from that decision; they were heard by C.C. Ghose, J., (whose opinion is summarized here) and another judge who agreed.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the suits were bad for defect of parties (i.e., whether the owners of the 2 1/2 annas hisya were necessary parties).
- Whether the suits were barred by Section 188 of the Bengal Tenancy Act.
- Whether the suit lands appertained to the one-anna hisya (plaintiffs' share) or to the 2 1/2 annas hisya (the other share), i.e., the question of which patni share the lands belonged to.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellants (the defendant tenants)
- Claimed that the lands in suit were held by them in mirash right under the patnidars of a 2 1/2 annas share (derived through family transfers) and not under the one-anna share which originally belonged to Ramdhone Nath.
- Alleged that there had been a transfer (sale) of half an anna from Ramdhone's one-anna share to Bashi Nath, making the latter owner of a 2 1/2 annas share; therefore the present plaintiffs had no cause of action in respect of lands under the 2 1/2 annas share.
- Argued that if some lands belonged to the 2 1/2 annas share and others to the one-anna share, the suits were bad for non-joinder because the owners of the 2 1/2 annas share had not been made parties.
- Contended that the entries in the khatians/settlement records had not been rebutted by admissible evidence and that the lower appellate court had not made a clear finding to the contrary.
- Relied on the decision in Partap Mahton v. Wazirunnissa (A.I.R. 1925 Pat. 559) to support the contention that assessment and declaration affecting cosharers should not be made in their absence; also sought to distinguish or render inapplicable the court's reliance on Dhanunjoy v. Upendra ([1918] 46 I.C. 428).
Respondents (the plaintiffs and supporting judges' findings)
- Asserted that plaintiffs acquired the one-anna patni by purchase in execution of a rent decree, obtained possession, and were entitled to cancel any incumbrance (mirash) affecting that patni.
- Maintained that the mirashes recorded by defendants were either non-existent or did not affect solely the plaintiffs' one-anna patni (the Record-of-Rights recorded mirash under both patnis) and that on the evidence the presumption of correctness in the settlement entries had been rebutted.
- Argued that where the plaintiff proves that particular lands are held under himself alone, he may clear his title against defendants in a suit against them alone; thus plaintiffs should obtain assessment of rent and declarations in respect of lands exclusively within their one-anna patni.
- Respondent counsel (Dr. Basak) argued that there was neither evidence nor finding that defendants were tenure-holders (i.e., that mirash rights existed), and that it would be an improbable factual inference that the joint lands were let as an indivisible tenure from different patnidars without kabuliyats or rent assessments.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Partap Mahton v. Wazirunnissa, A.I.R. 1925 Pat. 559 | Cited for the proposition that, in suits for assessment/declaration affecting co-sharer landlords, other co-sharers should normally be made parties so that any assessment or declaration binds all interested persons. | The court observed that Partap's decision was upon a special case and noted that Partap supported the proposition that co-sharers should ordinarily be made parties; the court treated Partap as authority emphasising practical inconvenience and anomaly that may result if co-sharers are not parties. |
| Dhanunjoy v. Upendra, [1918] 46 I.C. 428 | Used to show that an action for assessment of rent can be upheld in circumstances where co-sharer landlords were made parties (the case involved co-sharers as defendants). | The court noted that Dhanunjoy was relied upon by earlier judges to justify assessment in certain circumstances, but also emphasised that in Dhanunjoy the co-sharers had been made parties — a fact relevant to the case at hand. |
| Govind Chandra Pal v. Hamidulla Bhuiyan, [1903] 7 C.W.N. 670 | Cited as an instance differing from other authorities in the treatment of co-sharers (the opinion notes that this case was an exception in the survey of prior decisions). | The court recorded that, unlike most cases reviewed, Govind Chandra Pal was different in its treatment of parties — the reference was used to illustrate that authorities varied and to support the cautionary approach to making declarations or assessments in the absence of interested co-sharers. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court proceeded in stages, applying the factual findings made by the Subordinate Judge and considering the legal consequences.
- Findings of fact accepted: The court accepted the lower appellate court's fact-findings that the plaintiffs had acquired title to the one-anna share by sale in execution and that some of the lands in dispute were exclusively held under that one-anna share while other lands were held jointly under the one-anna and the 2 1/2 annas shares. The court also accepted that the mirash rights claimed by defendants had been negatived on the evidence.
- Effect of negation of mirash rights: Given the finding that defendants had no mirash rights, the court held there was no valid reason to deny the plaintiffs an assessment of rent in respect of those lands shown to be held exclusively under the plaintiffs' one-anna patni. The court observed there was nothing in the record to indicate that tenants' holdings in those exclusive plots formed an indivisible or "entire rent" tenure which would preclude separate assessment.
- Necessity of co-sharer parties for joint lands: For plots held jointly by the one-anna and the 2 1/2 annas patnis, the court analysed whether plaintiffs could obtain (a) a declaratory judgment that defendants had no mirash rights, and (b) assessment of rent, in the absence of the owners of the other co-sharer (2 1/2 annas) from the record of these suits. The court examined prior authorities (including Partap Mahton and Dhanunjoy) and accepted the principle — as articulated by Adami, J., in Partap — that in suits affecting interests common to co-sharers, the other co-sharers ought generally to be made parties so that any assessment or declaration binds all interested persons and to avoid multiplicity of inconsistent proceedings.
- Distinction between exclusive and joint plots: The court emphasised the practical distinction: where the plaintiff proves a defendant's holding is exclusively under the plaintiff's patni, the plaintiff may obtain relief against that defendant alone. By contrast, where a plot is recorded or shown to be held under two patnis as joint landlords, a declaration or assessment of rent in a suit involving only one co-sharer would prima facie affect the absent co-sharer and therefore should not be granted in their absence.
- On pleadings and scope of relief: The court noted that although some judges below had considered that the plaintiffs confined their prayer to their own share (and one judge thought that this made the other co-sharers unnecessary parties), the present court adopted a cautious approach: declarations (whether substantive under the Specific Relief Act or ancillary) affecting a third party's rights should not be granted unless that party is before the court.
- Remedial consequence and procedural disposition: The court concluded that plaintiffs were entitled to assessment and declaratory relief only in respect of plots exclusively belonging to the one-anna patni (where the mirash claim had been negatived), but could not obtain a decree for assessment or declaration in respect of jointly held plots without the presence of the other co-sharer. The court adjourned for a fortnight to enable the parties to agree on the consequences in each suit; otherwise the case would be remanded so that decrees could be settled or worked out consistent with the decision.
Holding and Implications
Core Ruling: The Court held that the appeals "fail in respect of so much of the lands as are held exclusively under the 1 anna share and must be allowed in respect of the lands held jointly under the 1 anna and 2 1/2 annas shares."
Immediate consequences for the parties
- For plots held exclusively under the plaintiffs' one-anna patni: plaintiffs are entitled to assessment of rent and declaratory relief as to the absence of mirash rights vis-à-vis the defendants in those exclusive plots. The appeals (by defendants) fail insofar as these exclusive plots are concerned.
- For plots held jointly under the one-anna and the 2 1/2 annas patnis: plaintiffs cannot, in these suits, obtain a declaration that defendants have no mirash right or a decree for assessment of rent in the absence of the owners of the 2 1/2 annas share. Accordingly, the appeals are allowed in respect of those lands (i.e., the plaintiffs' claims are defeated on this point).
- The court adjourned the matter for a fortnight to enable counsel to agree on the exact consequences in each suit and, if necessary, remanded the cases for decree-drafting consistent with the decision.
Costs
The court directed the following allocation of costs (as stated in the opinion):
- In each suit where there are separate lands for which plaintiffs are entitled to relief, plaintiffs should get their costs according to their success in the trial Court and in the lower appellate Court.
- Defendants should have their costs of the second appeal and of the present proceedings before the court.
- If in any suit the plaintiffs wholly fail, the defendants must have their costs of that suit throughout.
Precedential impact
This decision clarifies (within the facts of these cases) the limits of a single co-sharer seeking declarations or assessments in respect of lands that are jointly held by more than one patnidar: relief affecting interests of absent co-sharers should not ordinarily be granted in their absence. The opinion does not indicate that it establishes a new general rule beyond the reasoning it applies to the facts before the court.
Judges: The opinion is delivered by C.C. Ghose, J., and another judge agreed ("I agree.").
1. The facts involved in these appeals shortly stated, are a9 follows :.The plaintiffs are the zamindars of mauza Islampur, bearing Tauzi No. 446 of the Tipperah Colleotorate. The mauza, according to the plaintiffs, was held under them in patni in certain defined shares, i.e., two taluks of six annas each, one taluk of three annas and one taluk of one anna. This last mentioned one anna share was held by one Ramdhone Nath. He died some time ago, and on or about the dates hereinafter preferred to, his heirs and successors were in possession of the said patni taluk of one anna share under the plaintiffs on payment of a um of Rs. 82-15-0 as annual rental. In 1918 there were arrears of rent due on account of the said one anna share. A suit was instituted by the plaintiffs for the recovery of the arrears; a decree was obtained and in execution of the decree for arrears of rent the plaintiffs purchased the patni interest in the said one anna share. The sale was confirmed some time in 1920. The plaintiffs obtained delivery of possession in 1921. Their case is that the lands of the one a one had been separated from the lands of the other shares and their one anna patni taluk comprised certain plots exclusively belonging to it and certain undivided but defined shares of other plots held by it jointly with another of these patnia, apparently a patni of three or two and a half annas. That this is really the position is not now disputed. Nor is it disputed that the defendants in these suits are in fact in possession of the whole of both sets of plots, viz. those exclusively belonging to the plaintiffs' patni and those belonging jointly to the plaintiffs' patni and the other patni. The plaintiffs further say that after their purchase of the one anna patni they came to know that in the settlement records (the settlement having taken place before the purchase of the said one anna share by the plaintiffs) the defendants had been recorded as being in possession in mirash right. In point of fact the Record-of-Bights does not record the defendants as holding solely under the one anna patni. It records the mirash as being held under both the patnis, but the plaint confines its allegation to the plaintiffs' patni. According to the plaintiffs the mirash right, or whatever it was, was in the nature of an incumbrance and accordingly, as they allege, a notice under Section 167, Ben. Ten. Act, was served by the plaintiffs on tie defendants with a view to cancel the incumbrance. The plaintiffs thereafter instituted the present suits in 1926 against the defendants' praying (inter alia) (a) for a declaration that the defendants had no mirash right in the plaintiff's patni lands and that the plaintiffs were entitled to get the said lands assessed to rent at the rate prevalent in the locality; and (b) for assessment of fair and equitable rent and for recovery of the same. The tenants who were in possession of specific lands alleged to belong to the said one anna share were different, and the khatians in which their mirash right was recorded were numbered 317, 318, 319, 321, 323 and 324. This fact accounts for the circumstance that the plaintiffs had to bring separate suits.
2. The defendants raised various contentions in their written statements. I do not propose to set out in detail the contentions of the defendants except one. The defendants alleged that the lands in suit were held by them in mirash right under the patnidars of a certain 2 1/2 annas share in mauza Islampur and not under the one anna share which originally belonged to Ramdhone Nath. According, to them there were two brothers of the name of Earn Mohan and Basi Nath and each of them owned a 2 annas share in patni in the said mouza. Earn Mohan had two 3ons named Eamdhone and Kristo Mangal. Ramdhone had a one anna share and Kristo Mangal had a one anna share. It is alleged that Ramdhone sold anna out of his 1 anna share to Bashi Nath and that the latter thereby became owner of 2 1/2 annas share in patni. The contention of the defendants was, to repeat that they held the lands under this last-mentioned 2 1/2 annas share and not under the 1 anna share. They therefore argued that the present plaintiffs had no cause of action and further that should it be found that some of the lands held by them did belong to the share which originally belonged to Ramdhone Nath and that some belonged to the said 2 1/2 annas share, the present suits were bad inasmuch as the owners of the 2 1/2 annas share had not been made parties thereto.
3. All these suits came on for hearing before the learned Munsif of Gomilla and the following specific issues were raised on the pleadings in the said suits:
(a) Ate the suits bid for defect of parties?
(b) Are the suits barred by Section 188, Ben. Ten. Act and
(c) Do the suit lands appertain to one annas hisya (share) or do those lands appertain to ij annas hisya?
4. The learned Munsif held that Section 188, Ben. Ten. Act, did not operate as a bar but, having regard to the prayers, of the plaintiffs in their plaints, the? owners of the 2 1/2 annas hisyas were : necessary parties. The learned Munsif further held that the purchase of the said one anna share by the plaintiffs in execution of their rent decree was-under the bengal tenancy act and: not under the Patni Regulation, that the notices under Section 167 were not served within the time limited by statute, that therefore the mirashes, mention of which is to be found in the settlement record, had not been annulled, that on the evidence adduced on behalf of the plaintiffs it was clear that some of the lands in suit were held1 exclusively under the said one anna share and that some were held jointly under the said one anna and 2 1/2 annas shares, that the presumption about the correctness of the entries in the settlement records had not been rebutted and that therefore the plaintiffs were not-entitled to any reliefs fn these suits. The Munsif thereupon dismissed these-suits. The matter of these suits was carried on appeal to the learned Subordinate Judge of Tipperah and his findings were as follows. He found thai Regn. 8 of 1819 applied to the share in which the mouza had been let' out in patni and that the one anna share which originally belonged to Eamdhone had passed to the plaintiffs under the sale in execution of the rent decree-referred to above, that the plaintiffs were not bound to recognize the transfer of the anna share out of the said one anna share and that the plaintiffs were entitled to annul incumbrances if any really existed, that the mirashea relied upon by the several defendante did not exist and that there was no evidence in support of the entries is the settlement records, that the defendant's mirashes being non-existent, no question of any notice under Section 167, arose, and lastly that the fact that some plots of the said one anna share were joined with the lands of the two and half annas share did not preclude the plaintiffs from obtaining the reliefs, prayed for by them and that there was no defect of parties. He accordingly allowed the appeals pending before him with costs. The defendants thereupon preferred appeals to this Court. These appeals were heard by my learned brother Mukerji, J., and by his judgment dated 30th January 1929, the second appeals in question were dismissed. Thereafter the present appeals have been brought under the Letters Patent.
5. Before my learned brother several points were urged on behalf of the defendants tenants. Mukerji, J., accepting the findings of fact by the learned Subordinate Judge, negatived the contentions that the plaintiffs had not acquired title to the 1 anna share which originally belonged to Ramdhone that the presumption of correctness in respect of the entries in the settlement records had not been rebutted and that the plaintiff3 had recognized the transfer of the said half anna share to Bashi Nath. Mukerji, J., referred to the finding of the Munsif concurred in by the learned Subordinate Judge, that some of the lands in suit were held exclusively under the one anna share and that some were held jointly under the one anna and 2 1/2 annas shares and proceeded to observe as follows:
Then it has been urged that if the finding on Issue 6 be as above, than the owners of the 2 1/2 annas hisya are necessary parties to the suit, as the learned Munsif had held. It has been contended that the declaration which the plaintiff has asked for as regards the non-existence of the incumbrances will affect the said owners and such a declaration cannot be obtained in their absence. But on reading the schedule to the plaint I find that the plaintiffs have confined their prayers for relief to such share in the lands as they themselves have. However much it may be said to have been convenient if the plaintiffs had made those owners parties, it cannot be held that the said owners were necessary parties in the sense that the suit could not proceed in their absence.
Lastly, it has been contended that the prayer for assessment of rent in the ab3enoe of the said owners of the 2 1/2 annas hisya was not maintainable, and in support of this contention a decision of the Patna High Court in Partap Mahton v. Wazirunnissa A.I.R. 1925 Pat. 559, has been cited. That decision was upon a very special case, and in any case, the decision of this Court in the case of Dhanunjoy v. Upendra [1918] 46 I.C. 428 is against the appellants' contention.
6. Mr. Gupta who appeared for the appellants (the defendants tenants) argued that there was no evidence sufficient in law to rebut the entries ire the khatians and that the Subordinate' Judge had given no clear finding that they had been rebutted. On this point however I agree with the learned Judge-in this Court in thinking that the finding of the lower appellate Court is clear enough and that it was open to him on the evidence to negative the existence of the mirash rights claimed by the defendants. Mr. Gupta further contended that the suit as framed were not maintainable in the absence of the owners of the two and half annas share and. that the learned Judge in this Court was in error in thinking that Dhanunjoy's case [1918] 46 I.C. 428, was against; the appellant's contention. He pointed out that although Section 188, Beng. Ten. Act, did not come into play, no case had gone to the1 length of holding that in the absence of the cosharer landlords, a decree for assessment of rent could be made and that in Dhanunjoy's case [1918] 46 I.C. 428, the other cosharer landlords had been made parties. He argued that the present cases were indistinguishable from Pratap's case A.I.R. 1925 Pat. 559 and were covered by it.
7. Before I deal with Mr. Gupta's contentions, I desire to clear the ground as regards one matter. The finding of fact-being that the defendants have no mirash right and that some lands are held exclusively under the anna share there is no valid reason why the plaintiffs should not get assessment of rent in respect of those lands. There is nothing to show that the tenancy of the defendants or any set of them in the separate and joint lands is held as a single unit. No rent having ever been assessed before there is no question of their holdings being at an entire rent. In these circumstances it seems to me that there should be a decree for assessment of rent in respect of these lands; I can see nothing in the records before me which can disentitle the plaintiffs to this modicum of relief.
8. Now it appears from an examination of the khatians that each set of defendants has set up one mirash in respect of the lands held by them. In view of the findings of fact arrived at by the learned Subordinate Judge to the effect that the defendant's lands comprise land held jointly under the one anna and 2 1/2 annas share, we have to see whether the plaintiffs can get the declaration which they seek and can get the joint lands assessed to rent in the absence from the records of these suits of the owners of the said 2 1/2 annas share? On the latter question the learned Judge in this Court has relied on Dhanunjoy's case [1918] 46 I.C. 428, but in that case the cosharer landlords had been made parties. They were not indeed in the category of plaintiffs but they were in the category of defendants. The case seems to be quite consistent with the decision in Partap's case A.I.R. 1925 Pat. 559, which really followed it Adami, J., who delivered the judgment of the Court went at length into the various authorities and observed as follows:
The question next arises whether, under the general law, a suit by a cosharer landlord for an assessment of the rent of a tenant's holding is maintainable where the other co-sharers have not been made parties either as plaintiffs or defendants. It is to be noticed that in the various oases noted above, except in the case of Govind Chandra Pal v. Hamidulla Bhuiyan [1903] 7 C.W.N. 670, the other cosharers were made parties defendants to the suit for assessment; in the present case the plaintiffs have not made their cosharers parties to the suit at all and the plaint tells us that the cosharers refused to take any action: they are apparently satisfied with the rent now paid to them in accordance with the Record-of-Rights. Two of the cosharers come forward and ask for an assessment of the rent of the 22 bighas and for their proportionate shaie; the other cosharers are vitally interested. It may be that it was unnecessary to join the other cosharers as plaintiffs as Section 188 does not apply, but surely they should have been made parties defendants, so that the assessment when made might bind all equally. As pointed out by the learned Munsif, great hardship will be caused to the tenants defendants if each of the other cosharer landlords is left free to bring a separate suit for assessment; not only may there ensue a multiplicity of suits but also the tenant, if different assessments are made in the separated suits, will be uncertain as to what is really the assessed rental. No really effective decree can be made in the absence of the interested cosharers and there can be no finality as to what is really the fair and equitable rent as in a partition suit so in a suit for asesssment all the interested persons should be made parties.
9. These observations appear to me to be sound in principle and in my judgment any departure from the rule laid down must be in practice inconvenient and liable to produce anomaly and difficulty.
10. The Sub-Judge dealt with this matter by saying:
It is true that some plots of one anna hisya are joint with land of the two annas hisya, but a tenure may consist of undivided shares of lands and that fact does not afford any ground for adding the owners of the other shares as parties.
11. Dr. Basak for the respondents before us argued on the same lines. The question however is not what a tenure may consist of, but what in fact the tenancies of these defendants are. Their mirash right having been negatived there is neither evidence nor finding that they are tenure-holders at all. It may not legally be absolutely impossible, even if these tenancies are only ryotis that the joint lands have been let to them for cultivation as to one undivided share by one patnidar and as to another such share by another patnidar; c.f. Govind's case [1903] 7 C.W.N. 670. It would however be a very improbable inference of fact in the present case where no kabuliyats have been produced and there has not been an assessment of rent. The claim to mirash right was laid on very different lines and the Record-of-Rights was also to the contrary.
12. Hence in my judgment the plaintiffs cannot in these suits get a decree for assessment of rent of the plots which have the two patnis as joint landlords.
13. As to the prayer for a declaration "that the defendants have got not mirash or permanent right in the disputed lands": It is quite true as the learned Judge observes that the plaint has been so framed as to confine this prayer "to such share in the lands a3 they themselves have". As regards those plots which are entirely within the plaintiff's patni the declaration may stand, but if A and B are joint landlords of a plot held by G and C has been recorded in the Record-of-Rights as holding a tenure under both of them as joint landlords, a declaration that C has riot the right he claims should prima facie be refused to A unless B has been impleaded. The fact that A and B hold their interest in defined shares is not of itself any reason for proceeding in the absence of B. The greatest caution must be exercised in granting declarations whether these be granted as substantive relief under the Specific Relief Act or are merely ancillary to or explanatory of other relief. The absence of a party whose presence is necessary to quiet the real dispute (in this case to settle the nature and terms of the defandants' tenancies vender their joint landlords) is a good reason for refusing this form of relief. On the other hand if, as here, the plaintiff proves that the defendants hold certain lands under himself alone then, though they may set up title in fifty other people the plaintiff may clear his title as against the defendants in a suit against them alone.
14. The plaints contained a prayer for back rents or compensation for use and occupation. This does not appear to have been canvassed in any of the Courts, and I do not understand that it as persisted in.
15. The result is in my judgment that these appeals fail in respect of so much of the lands as are held exclusively under the 1 anna, share and must be allowed in respect of the lands held jointly under the 1 anna and 2 1/2 annas shares. It may be that the learned advocates on either side will be able to agree or to satisfy us as to the consequences of this decision in each of these suits so as to enable a decree to be finally drawn up here: We will adjourned the case for a fortnight for this purpose. Otherwise we will have to remand the case in order that a decree may be settled or worked out in accordance with our decision. As to costs assuming that in each suit there are some separate lands in respect of which the plaintiffs are entitled to relief, we think that the plaintiffs should get their co3ts according to their success in the trial Court and in the lower appellate Court, but that the defendants should have their costs of the second appeal and before us. If in any suit the plaintiffs wholly fail the defendants must have their costs of that suit throughout.
C.C. Ghose, J.
16. I agree.
Alert