Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Kalikumar Pal v. Rajkumar Pal

Calcutta High Court
Feb 24, 1931
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

This appeal arises from a suit for recovery of money due on a simple mortgage bond executed by defendant 1. The plaintiff claimed the amount due, which defendant 1 resisted by pleading a payment of Rs. 150 made on 20th Chaitra 1326 B.S. The trial court examined whether this plea of payment was true. Evidence was presented, notably by two defense witnesses, including a pleader, Harikrishna Bhatta, who testified that the plaintiff admitted receipt of Rs. 150. The trial court rejected the plea of payment and decreed in favor of the plaintiff.

Defendant 1 appealed, and the appellate Court reversed the trial court’s decision in part, reducing the plaintiff’s claim by Rs. 150 based on the payment. The appellate Court relied on the testimony of the two witnesses, accepting that the payment was made and admitted by the plaintiff.

The present appeal by the plaintiff challenges the appellate Court's reliance on the pleader’s testimony, alleging it was inadmissible under Section 126 of the Evidence Act.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the deposition of the pleader witness, Harikrishna Bhatta (D.W. 4), was admissible in evidence under Section 126 of the Evidence Act.
  2. Whether the plea of payment made by defendant 1 could be proved by the admission allegedly made by the plaintiff during negotiations for compromise.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The appellate Court erred in relying on the pleader Harikrishna Bhatta’s statement, which was inadmissible under Section 126 of the Evidence Act, as it constituted privileged communication.
  • The admission of payment was made during negotiations for compromise and thus should not be admissible as evidence since the compromise failed.

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the respondent’s arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Shore v. Bedford [1843] 5 Man. & G. 271 Communications made to a pleader who is not exclusively employed by the party are not privileged and are admissible. The Court held that since the plaintiff’s admission was made in the presence of the defendant and not exclusively to his pleader, the communication was admissible.
Perry v. Smith [1842] 9 M. & W. 631 Only communications made to a pleader in the course of and for the purpose of his employment are privileged. The Court applied this principle to determine that the admission was not privileged as the pleader was not acting as the plaintiff’s exclusive legal adviser.
Memon Hajee Haroon Mahomed v. Abdul Karim [1878] 3 Bom. 91 For a communication to be privileged under Section 126, it must be confidential and made to the pleader in his capacity as legal adviser. The Court found the communication was made in the presence of the defendant and thus was not confidential or privileged.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined whether the pleader’s deposition was inadmissible under Section 126 of the Evidence Act, which protects confidential communications between a client and his legal adviser. The Court found no indication that the plaintiff had employed the pleader as his exclusive legal adviser or that the communication was made confidentially in the course of such employment. Since the admission was made in the presence of the defendant and not solely to the pleader, the communication was not privileged.

Regarding the argument that the admission was made during failed compromise negotiations and thus inadmissible, the Court held that it was unnecessary for the defendant to prove the terms of any compromise. The key question was whether the plaintiff admitted receipt of Rs. 150, which was established. Therefore, the plea of payment was valid and reduced the plaintiff’s claim accordingly.

Consequently, the Court upheld the appellate Court's acceptance of the payment admission and dismissed the plaintiff’s appeal.

Holding and Implications

The appeal is dismissed with costs.

The direct effect of this decision is that the plaintiff's claim is reduced by the amount of Rs. 150 admitted as paid by defendant 1. No new legal precedent was established; the ruling confirms the applicability of Section 126 of the Evidence Act only to confidential communications made in the course of legal employment, and that admissions made in the presence of the opposing party are admissible evidence.

Show all summary ...

1. This is an appeal by the plaintiff in a suit for recovery of money due on a simple mortgage bond, dated 11th Agrahayan 1319 B.S, executed by defendant 1. The claim of the plaintiff in the suit was resisted by defendant 1 and it was pleaded by the defendant that there was a payment made of Rs. 150 to the plaintiff on 20th Chaitra 1326 B.S On the pleadings before the Court, the first issue and the material question arising for consideration in the case was whether the plea of payment of Rs. 150, as alleged by the defendant, was true or not. The plea of payment as raised in the suit, based on an alleged admission of the plaintiff himself, was sought to be substantiated by the defendant by evidence adduced by him; and the material witnesses examined in this behalf were two in number, D.Ws 3 and 4. With reference to the first of these witnesses, witness 3, his deposition was to the effect that the plaintiff had on a previous occasion admitted the receipt of Rs. 150 from the defendant, in part payment of the mortgage debt. The most important evidence in the case in respect of this payment by defendant 1 was that afforded by the deposition of D.W 4, Babu Harikrishna Bhatta, a pleader; and the statement that this pleader witness made before the Court in his deposition was this:

“The plaintiff and the defendant admitted to have received and paid respectively the same amount of money, Rs. 125 or Rs. 150, in connexion with payment due to the mortgage bond.”

2. The witness added that the plaintiff and the defendant were present, but did not remember who else was present when the plaintiff admitted to have received the amount of Rs. 150. The witness further stated in his deposition before the Court, that the defendant approached him, and had informed him that the settlement of the debt due on the mortgage bond had not been effected.

3. Upon this state of the evidence before the Court, the trial Court passed a decree in favour of the plaintiff, holding that the plea of payment of Rs. 150 had not been made out.

4. On appeal by defendant 1, the decision of the trial Court and the decree passed by that Court in favour of the plaintiff were reversed. The learned Subordinate Judge in the Court of appeal below allowed the appeal by defendant 1 in part. The decree of the Court of first instance was modified. The plaintiff's claim was reduced on the footing of the payment of Rs. 150, on 25th Chaitra 1326, as alleged by defendant 1; and the decree made by the Court below was for the sum found due with interest upon calculation as indicated in the judgment of the lower Court. The lower appellate Court has entirely relied upon the testimony of the two witnesses referred to above. According to the learned Subordinate Judge, the testimony of the witnesses could not be lightly discarded. It was held that the deposition of the two witnesses mentioned above supported the other evidence given by defendant 1, relating to the actual payment of Rs. 150 to the plaintiff; and the Court below has expressed the definite opinion that it could not but believe that the plaintiff did actually get Rs. 150 from defendant 1 in Chaitra 1326.

5. The present appeal is directed against the decision and the decree of the Sub-ordinate Judge in the Court of appeal below. The main question that has been raised in support of the appeal by the plaintiff is this that the Court of appeal below has erred in law in relying upon the statement of the pleader, Harikrishna Bhatta, which was inadmissible in evidence by reason of Section 126 of the Evidence Act.

6. It is necessary therefore to examine whether the deposition of D.W 4, Harikrishna Bhatta, was or was not admissible in evidence by reason of Section 126 of the Evidence Act. The witness has stated in his deposition that the admission was made by the plaintiff in the presence of the defendant and it was not suggested, neither was it indicated by anything contained in the deposition of the witnesses before the Court, that the communication was made to him as a pleader, much less as a pleader who was employed by the plaintiff; nor was there any indication that the communication was made to the witness in the course, and for the purpose of his employment as a pleader. On general principles, and under Section 126 of the Evidence Act, there is no privilege to communications made before the creation of relationship of pleader and client. Further, where two persons have a dispute about a claim made by one of them upon the other, and both seek the help of a pleader, and one of them makes a statement to the pleader, the statement so made to the pleader by one of the parties is certainly admissible: see Shore v. Bedford . [1843] 5 Man. & G. 271. The question being, was the communication or admission made by the plaintiff to the witness in the character of his own exclusive pleader or legal adviser? If it was so, the bond of secrecy is upon the witness; and if it was not, the communication was not privileged: see Perry v. Smith . [1842] 9 M. & W. 631. It may be mentioned further that to be privileged under Section 126 of the Evidence Act, a communication by a party to his pleader must be of a confidential nature: see Memon Hajee Haroon Mahomed v. Abdul Karim . [1878] 3 Bom. 91.. The communication to the pleader in this case was made in the presence of the defendant. As indicated above, regard being bad to the principles which underlie Section 126 of the Evidence Act, to which reference has already been made, it is impossible to hold that the deposition of the pleader witness, D.W 4 in this case, was inadmissible in view of the provisions contained in Section 126 of the Evidence Act.

7. A further point was argued in support of the appeal by the plaintiff, that the plea of payment, as raised by defendant 1 in the suit, could not be allowed to be proved by him, by reason of the fact that the admission as to payment made by the plaintiff was in the course of a negotiation for arriving at a compromise. That compromise having fallen through, the terms could not be proved. There is no substance in this contention. It is hardly necessary to mention that it was not necessary for defendant 1 to prove the terms of any compromise, which ultimately failed, and which had no direct bearing on the plea of payment raised in this case, the question for consideration in this case being whether the plaintiff had made an admission as to the receipt of the amount of Rs. 150 from defendant 1. The admission by the plaintiff has been proved, and the plaintiff's claim in suit has therefore been reduced to the extent of the payment already made by defendant 1.

8. In the result, the appeal fails and is dismissed with costs.

R.M/R.K

9. Appeal dismissed.