- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Ram Sahai Singh And Others 1St Party v. Dwarka Singh And Others 2Nd Party Opposite Parties.
1. This is an application against the order of the Deputy Magistrate of Monghyr, dated 31st May 1920, passed in favour of the second party in a proceeding under Section 145 of the Cr PC.
2. The first party is the applicant before us. The proceeding under S. 145 was an outcome of a previous order under S. 144 of the Code issued on 15th December, 1919. During the course of the proceeding under S. 144, it was thought desirable to inquire into the possession of the parties under S. 145 and the police was directed to make inquiry and report. The report of the police was received on 20th February and the present proceedings under S. 145 were directed to be drawn up on 1st March, fixing 15th March for filing written statements and examination of witnesses.
3. In the meantime, on 4th March the Magistrate held a surprise local inquiry, at, the instance of the second party, without giving any notice to the petitioners first party. During the course of the inquiry, the petitioners came to know of the local inspection by the Magistrate and moved the District Magistrate for a transfer of the case from, the file of the Deputy Magistrate, who was holding inquiry in the present case under S. 145. The application was refused on 6th May but the District Magistrate, while refusing it observed as follows:
βI consider that his (Deputy Magistrate's) conduct was judicially improper and he will, no doubt, be careful to guard against any bias that may be introduced into his mind by a proceeding which was decidedly unfair.β
4. The petitioners then came to this Court, but their application was returned to them by the Criminal Bench on the ground that it was premature.
5. In spite of the wholesome advice given by the District Magistrate, the Deputy Magistrate has mainly used his impression of the local inspection in deciding this case, and this has, to my mind vitiated the trial of the case as well as take final order passed by the Magistrate. Reading the judgment one cannot help thinking that all his findings appear to be more or less influenced by his local inspection.
6. The danger of holding local inspections is so great, that it has been repeatedly pointed out that it must be held sparingly and only for the purpose of elucidating and understanding the evidence in the case and it should never be substituted for evidence in the case. I need hardly discuss here the reasonableness of this view, for the party against whom the result of the local inspection is used is greatly prejudiced and is put to an irreparable disadvantage in not being able to remove the wrong impression from the mind of the Magistrate by cross-examining him. The danger is intensified by the Magistrate holding the local inquiry ex parte. When the first party were not present at the time of the local, inspection, we cannot be sure that the right field was shown to the Magistrate from which the first party were alleged to have cut the unripe and green crops. The course adopted by the Deputy Magistrate might have been commendable in the good old days of Har-un-ul-Rashid, but it is certainly repugnant to the present age of deciding matters upon legal evidence.
7. The local enquiry was certainly not under S. 148 of the Code. It was not during the course of the trial of S. 145 proceedings, for till then the Magistrate was not in possession of the respective claims of the parties, their written statements not having been filed.
8. There are other irregularities in the judgment in the case. The Magistrate has made illegal presumptions against the first party and has taken a prejudicial view of their case. He has suspected the police to be in collusion with them without any just ground. He has also deprived the first party of the presumptions which they were entitled to as purchasers at the revenue sale of the property in dispute and of the recent possession having been delivered to them on 26th February, 1919 by the Revenue Court. The lands in dispute are admittedly the kamat or zerait lands of the outgoing proprietors second party Nos. 1 and 2, and presumably the new purchasers, the first party, would be entitled to the possession of the same. The second party Nos. 3 to 16 claim possession on the ground of their having taken settlement of the ??? kamat land from the second party Nos. 1 and 2, the ex-proprietors by means of unregistered hukumnamas in the year 1321. The police reported in favour of the possession of the first party and against that of the second party, and notice under S. 144 was accordingly issued upon the second party. The police held that the opposite party Nos. 3 to 16 were set up by the old proprietors Nos. 1 and 2 and that their unregistered hukumnamas were not reliable. The criminal Court had to maintain the possession delivered by the Revenue Court, but the Magistrate went mainly upon the local inspection and judged the evidence in the light of the information gained by him at such inspection and decided the case against the first party. He has not given due weight to the oral evidence in the case as is clear from the passage in his judgment:
βIn the face of the above I think I need not further discuss the oral evidence that each party has adduced.β
9. Thus the illegal procedure adopted by the Magistrate in holding the local inquiry ex parte has vitiated the trial and is sufficient to set aside his final order under S. 145. Loath as we are to disturb the jurisdiction of the Magistrate under S. 145, we cannot help setting aside his order when he acted illegally or with material irregularity in the exercise of his jurisdiction.
10. The order passed by the Magistrate declaring the possession of the second party is set aside.
11. If in the opinion of the Magistrate there be still danger of a breach of the peace, which probably is, on account of the nature of the dispute between the parties and the old proprietors and the new purchaser, the Magistrate will hold an inquiry under S. 145 and decide it upon legal evidence, and if it is not possible to decide the possession of either party, he will attach the property in dispute under S. 146 of the Code. Should further inquiry be necessary the District Magistrate will arrange to have it done by a Magistrate other than the Magistrate, who tried this case.
V.S/R.K
12. Order set aside.
Alert