Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Mokshadayini Dassi v. Karnadhar Mandal

Calcutta High Court
Jul 28, 1914
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The Respondent, Karnadhar Mandal, applied for probate of a Will allegedly executed on 1 March 1886 by Gobinda Chandra Mandal. The Will purportedly gave a life-interest to the testator's daughter Brojeswari, with the residue to vest in Karnadhar Mandal and his paternal uncle Dukhiram Mandal after the life-interest ended. Brojeswari died in 1907. Notice of the probate application (filed 21 September 1912) was served on Lukshmi Narain Mandal and Dukhiram Mandal; there was no opposition and probate was granted by the District Delegate on 27 November 1912. On 21 December 1912 the Appellants applied for revocation of the probate, alleging they had acquired an interest in the property by purchase from Lukshmi Narain Mandal on 14 September 1912 (a week before the probate application). The District Judge dismissed the revocation application on the ground that the Applicants' evidence was insufficient to throw doubt on the genuineness of the Will. This appeal challenges that dismissal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the question of the genuineness of the Will is to be considered at the stage of an application for revocation of probate, or only after the court has decided that revocation should be granted on one or more grounds in section 50 of the Probate and Administration Act.
  2. Whether persons who have acquired an interest in the deceased's estate by assignment or subsequent purchase (after death) may apply for revocation of a probate granted in a manner adverse to their acquired interest (i.e., whether such acquisition constitutes "just cause" within the meaning of section 50).
  3. Whether probate granted without notice to persons who claim an interest by recent acquisition may be revoked for want of notice and/or by reason of fraudulent or material concealment in the grant process.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments

  • The Appellants alleged they purchased an interest in the properties left by Gobinda Chandra Mandal from Lukshmi Narain Mandal on 14 September 1912, prior to the probate application of 21 September 1912.
  • They contended that probate was granted without notice to them and that this furnished a just cause for revocation under section 50 of the Probate and Administration Act.

Respondent's / Other Relevant Positions

  • The Respondent obtained probate on 27 November 1912 after notice had been served on Lukshmi Narain Mandal and Dukhiram Mandal and there was no opposition in the probate proceedings.
  • The District Judge treated the Appellants' evidence as insufficient to cast doubt on the genuineness of the Will and dismissed the revocation application on that basis.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Bridaban v. Sureshwar(1) Used in context that the only matter at the revocation stage is whether appellants have made out a just cause for revocation. The court relied on this proposition to hold that genuineness need not be examined until just cause for revocation is established.
Durgagati v. ???(2) "The question of genuineness cannot be considered till a case for revocation is made out." Quoted to support that genuineness is not to be considered at the initial revocation-stage.
Komol Lochan Dutt v. Nilruttan Mundal(3) That a person interested by assignment in the estate of the deceased may apply for revocation of the probate where a Will has been set up and proved at variance with his interests. Applied as authority that a purchaser/assignee of an interest may seek revocation of probate.
Muddun Mohan Sircar v. Kali Charan Dey(4) Followed the view that an assignee or purchaser with an interest may apply for revocation. Noted as a subsequent case adopting the same principle.
Lalit Mohan v. Nabadwip(5) Followed the same view regarding an assignee's right to apply for revocation. Recorded as consistent authority.
Sheikh Azim v. Chandra Nath(6) Followed the same principle regarding assignment/purchase giving standing to apply for revocation. Applied as corroborative precedent.
Digambar v. Narayan(7) Followed the same principle regarding standing to apply for revocation. Noted by the court as following the same view.
Ram Chandra v. Ramrao(8) Followed the same principle regarding assignment/purchase and revocation applications. Recorded as consistent authority.
Lindsay v. Lindsay(9) Held that a person entitled to intervene in revocation need not show interest at the time of death; an interest acquired subsequently by purchase may suffice. Relied upon to support that a subsequent purchaser's acquisition can constitute just cause to intervene in probate/revocation proceedings.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court determined that the District Judge erred in dismissing the revocation application on the sole ground that the evidence did not cast doubt on the genuineness of the Will. The court reasoned that the issue of genuineness arises only after the court has decided that the probate must be revoked on one or more grounds specified in section 50 of the Probate and Administration Act. At the revocation stage the proper inquiry is whether the Appellants have made out a "just cause" for revocation of a probate that was granted without notice to them. The court applied precedent (including Komol Lochan Dutt v. Nilruttan Mundal and Lindsay v. Lindsay) establishing that a person who acquires an interest by assignment or purchase may apply for revocation even if the interest was acquired after the testator's death. The Court observed that notice had been served on Lukshmi Narain Mandal, who should have informed the Court that he had transferred what he claimed as his share to the Appellants, and that the applicant for probate likewise should have disclosed the transfer; had this been done, notices would have been issued to the Appellants. On this basis the appeal was allowed and the District Judge's order set aside, with a remand to decide whether the Appellants in fact acquired the alleged interest.

Holding and Implications

APPEAL ALLOWED

Direct effect: The order of the District Judge dismissing the application for revocation is set aside and the matter is remanded to the District Judge to determine whether the Appellants acquired the interest they allege by purchase. If the Appellants establish their purchase, the court indicated consequent procedural steps (including calling upon the respondent for probate to proceed appropriately); if the Appellants fail to establish the purchase, they will be deemed not entitled to intervene and their application will be dismissed. There will be no order for costs in the appeal. The opinion does not state that it establishes any new legal precedent beyond applying and following existing authorities.

Show all summary ...

This appeal is directed against an Order of dismissal of an application for revocation of probate. The Respondent Karnadhar Mandal applied for probate of a Will alleged to have been executed, on the 1st March 1886, by Gobinda Chandra Mandal, a cousin of his father Lukshmi Narain Mandal. The effect of the Will is to give a life-interest to the daughter of the testator, Brojeswari, who was a childless widow when her father died in 1886. After the termination of the life-interest in favour of the daughter, the estate was to vest in Karnadhar. Mandal and his paternal uncle Dukhiram Mandal. Brojeswari died in 1907. Notice of the present application for probate, which was not made till the 21st September 1912 was served upon Lukshmi Narain Mandal and Dukhiram Mandal. There was no opposition and the District Delegate granted probate on the 27th November 1912. On the 21st December 1912 the Appellants applied for revocation of the probate on the allegation that they had acquired an interest in the property left by the deceased by purchase from Lukshmi Narain Mandal on the 14th September 1912, that is, a week before the application for probate. The District Judge has dismissed the application on the ground that the evidence adduced by the Applicants for revocation is not sufficient to throw doubt upon the genuineness of the Will. It is plain that this order cannot be sustained. No question of the genuineness of the Will arises for consideration till the Court has decided that the probate must be revoked on one or more of the grounds specified in sec. 50 of the Probate and Administration Act. The only matter for consideration at this stage is, whether the Appellants have, made out a just cause for revocation of the probate which was granted without notice to them: [Bridaban v. Sureshwar(1)]. The question of genuineness cannot be/considered till a case for revocation is made out: [Durgagati v. ???(2)].

It was ruled by this Court in the case of Komol Lochan Dutt v. Nilruttan Mundal(3) that a person interested by assignment in the estate of the deceased may where a Will has been set up and proved at variance with his interests apply for revocation of the probate of the Will so set up. This view was followed in the cases of Muddun Mohan Sircar v. Kali Charan Dey(4), Lalit Mohan v. Nabadwip(5), Sheikh Azim v. Chandra Nath(6), Digambar v. Narayan(7) and Ram Chandra v. Ramrao(8). This is in accord with the principle adopted in the case of Lindsay v. Lindsay(9) where it was ruled that the person entitled to intervene in a proceeding for revocation of letters of administration or probate need not show that he had an interest in the estate of the deceased at the time of his death; an interest acquired subsequently by purchase of a part of the estate is ??? Consequently, if it is established ??? have acquired by ??? in the properties left by ??? they were entitled to be ??? proceedings for grant of ??? is thus “just cause” for ??? location of the probate within the meaning of sec. 50 of the Probate and Administration Act. If the case is not covered by the first cause in the definition of the expression “just cause,” namely, that the proceedings ??? the grant were defective in substance it ??? undoubtedly covered by the second clause namely, that the grant was obtained fraudulently by making a false suggestion or by concealing from the Court something material to the case. Notice was served in the probate proceedings upon Lukshmi Narain Mandal. It was his duty to apprise the Court that he had no subsisting interest in the estate so as to justify an opposition on his part to the grant of probate; he should have intimated to the Court that he had transferred what he claimed as his share of the estate left by Gobindo Mandal to the present Appellants. It is further difficult to imagine that the Applicant for probate was unaware that his father had, a week before, conveyed away to the Appellants what he claimed as his share of the estate; it was thus equally his duty to intimate this fact to the Court. If this had been done, the Court would undoubtedly have issued notices upon the present Appellants.

The result is that this appeal is allowed and the order of the District Judge set aside. The case will be remanded to him in order that he may ??? gate whether the Appellants ??? the interest which they ??? estate left by Gobinda Chandra ??? If their purchase is proved ??? will stand cancelled and the ??? for probate will be called upon to ??? the Will in solemn form. If, on the other band, the Appellants fail to establish their alleged purchase, they must be deemed persons not entitled ??? intervene in the probate proceeding and their application for ??? will stand dismissed. There will be no order for costs in this appeal.

Appeal allowed.