- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Muthayyan Swaminatha Sastrial And Others v. S. Narayanaswami Sastrial And Others Opposite Parties.
Summary of Legal Opinion
Factual and Procedural Background
This is an application to revise the order of the Principal Subordinate Judge of Kumbakonam dated 24 January 1935 in C.M.A. No. 15 of 34, which set aside an order of the District Munsif of Valangiman that had returned the plaint in O.S. No. 6 of 34 for presentation to the proper Court.
The original suit sought an injunction restraining defendants 1 to 9 from interfering with the plaintiffs' possession and enjoyment of the plaint properties. The plaintiffs alleged the properties were Samudayam properties owned by the mirasdares of the village, that plaintiffs 1 to 4 and defendant 10 were appointed as managers of those properties, and that the other plaintiffs were lessees under those managers; they alleged interference by certain defendants. The defendants denied appointment of the managers.
The District Munsif held that the suit was effectively to have the managerial rights of plaintiffs 1–4 and defendant 10 declared, directed amendment of the plaint to add a prayer for declaration and ordered payment of additional court-fee. The plaint was amended but no additional court-fee was paid. The District Munsif found the amended plaint beyond his pecuniary jurisdiction and returned it for presentation to the proper Court.
On appeal, the Subordinate Judge reversed that order, holding it was unnecessary to add a prayer for declaration and that the suit as originally framed was maintainable; the trial Court was directed to re-entertain the suit. The present petition seeks revision of that appellate order.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the District Munsif was correct in treating the suit as a declaratory suit and directing amendment of the plaint to add a prayer for declaration (and consequent payment of additional court-fee).
- Whether a party who has amended the plaint in compliance with a trial Court's direction is precluded from challenging the correctness of that direction in revision.
- Whether the Subordinate Judge had jurisdiction in appeal to question the correctness of the trial Court's order requiring amendment of the plaint.
- Whether the provisions of Section 105 of the Civil Procedure Code (which on its face refers to decrees) apply to appeals against orders as well.
Arguments of the Parties
Defendants' Contentions (as pleaded)
- The defendants denied the plaintiffs' allegation that plaintiffs 1 to 4 and defendant 10 were appointed managers of the plaint properties.
Mr. Raja Ayyar's Contentions
- First, because the plaintiff obtained the amendment of the plaint in accordance with the District Munsif's direction, the plaintiff is precluded from questioning the validity of that order.
- Second, the learned Subordinate Judge was not entitled, on appeal, to go into the correctness of the District Munsif's order requiring the plaintiff to amend the plaint.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| 4 MLW 4111 | Support for the proposition that the provisions of Section 105 CPC (though referring to decrees) apply to appeals against orders as well. | The Court relied on the authority to hold that the Subordinate Judge could question the correctness of the trial Court's order in the appeal; this supported the view that the appellate court had jurisdiction to reverse the District Munsif's direction. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court agreed with the Subordinate Judge that the suit, as originally framed, was maintainable as an action for injunction. The reasoning proceeded as follows:
- The Court observed that although plaintiffs will need to prove that plaintiffs 1–4 and defendant 10 were properly appointed managers and that the other plaintiffs were lessees in order to obtain an injunction, that does not transform the suit into a declaratory suit. The plaintiffs' pleaded cause of action was that they were in lawful possession and that their possession was threatened, which entitled them to sue merely for an injunction.
- Therefore, the District Munsif was wrong in ordering amendment of the plaint to add a prayer for declaration and in ordering additional court-fee on that basis.
- On the contention that the plaintiff was estopped from challenging the trial Court's order because the plaint had been amended: the Court rejected this. It noted the order directing amendment was not appealable; the proper remedy would have been a revision petition in this Court. Failure to take that extraordinary step did not preclude the plaintiff from later challenging the correctness of the trial Court's order. Moreover, the plaintiff had not fully complied—he amended the plaint but did not pay the additional court-fee—so it was not a case of accepting benefits and thereafter challenging the order.
- On the jurisdictional contention that the Subordinate Judge could not question the correctness of the trial Court's order on appeal: the Court held that an appeal against the order returning the plaint was the proper channel to challenge that return. The Court further held that, although Section 105 CPC refers only to decrees, its provisions apply to appeals against orders as well, and it cited the authority of 4 MLW 4111 to support this position.
- On these bases the Court concluded the Subordinate Judge's order reversing the District Munsif and directing re-entertainment of the suit was correct.
Holding and Implications
HOLDING: The petition to revise the Subordinate Judge's order is dismissed. The Court held that the Subordinate Judge was correct in reversing the District Munsif's direction to amend the plaint and in holding that the suit as originally framed was maintainable; the trial Court's order was erroneous.
Implications:
- The direct effect is that the Subordinate Judge's order stands and the trial Court was correctly directed to re-entertain the suit as originally framed.
- The Court accepted the view that the provisions of Section 105 CPC can apply to appeals against orders (citing 4 MLW 4111) and relied on that principle to uphold the appellate court's jurisdiction to review the trial Court's order. The opinion does not announce a novel precedent beyond applying that principle in the case at hand.
- The petition was dismissed with costs.
Order date as recorded in the opinion: 24 January 1935 (Subordinate Judge's order reversed); petition dismissed.
1. This is an application to revise the order of the Principal Subordinate Judge of Kumbakonam, dated 24th January 1935, in C.M.A No. 15 of 34, setting aside an order of the District Munsif of Valangiman, returning the plaint in O.S No. 6 of 34 for presentation to the proper Court.
2. The suit was for an injunction restraining defendants 1 to 9 from interfering with the plaintiff's possession and enjoyment of the plaint properties. It was alleged that the properties were Samudayam properties owned by the mirasdares of the village, that plaintiffs 1 to 4 and defendant 10 were appointed as managers for the properties, that the other plaintiffs were lessees under those managers and that defendants 2 to 2 were interfering with the possession of the plaintiffs. The defendants denied those allegations and contended that plaintiffs 1 to 4 and defendant 10 were not appointed managers in respect of those properties. The learned District Munsif, holding that the suit was is effect to have the right of plaintiffs 1 to 4 and defendant 10 as managers in respect of these properties declared, directed the plaintiffs to amend the plaint by adding a, prayer for a declaration to that effect and to pay additional court-fee. The plaint was accordingly amended, but no additional court-fee was paid. As the learned District Munsif found that the plaint as amended was beyond his pecaniary jurisdiction, he returned it for presentation to the proper Court.
3. On appeal to the Subordinate Judge that order was, as already observed, reversed, the Subordinate Judge holding that it was not necessary for the plaintiff to add a prayer for declaration and that the suit as originally framed was maintainable. The trial Court was, therefore, directed to re-entertain the suit; hence this petition.
4. On the merits, I have no doubt that the learned Subordinate Judge was right in holding that the suit as originally framed was maintainable. It is true that in establishing their right to have an injunction against the defendants, the plaintiffs will have to prove that plaintiffs 1 to 4 and defendant 10 were properly appointed managers in respect of the properties and that the other plaintiffs are the lessees under them. But it does not follow from this that the plaintiffs are suing for a declaration of the title of plaintiffs 1 to 4 and defendant 10 as managers. Their allegation is that they are in lawful possession of the properties and that their possession is threatened to be interfered with by the defendants. On these allegations, they were perfectly entitled to sue for a mere injunction. The learned District Munsif was, therefore, wrong in ordering the amendment of the plaint.
5. But Mr. Raja Ayyar contends, firstly, that as the plaintiff actually got the plaint amended in accordance with the direction of the trial Court, he is precluded from questioning the validity of that order, and secondly, that the learned Subordinate Judge was not entitled to go into the question of the correctness of that order of the trial Court in the appeal before him. I am unable to accept either of these contentions. The order of the trial Court directing the plaintiff to amend the plaint was not appealable. All that the plaintiff could I have done was to file a petition in this Court to revise that order. It cannot be said that because he did not take that extraordinary step, he is estopped or precluded from questioning the correctness of that order. Further it is seen that he did not fully comply with the directions of the District Munsif, for he did not pay the requisite court-fee, but only got the plaint amended. It is not as if a person, having obtained the benefits conferred by an order and stood by it, subsequently challenges its correctness. There is therefore, no substance in the first contention.
6. The second contention that the learned Subordinate Judge bad no jurisdiction to question the correctness of the order of the trial Court requiring the plaintiff to amend the plaint has also no force. It was only in appeal against the order returning the plaint that the plaintiff could challenge the correctness of it. Though Section 105 of the CPC, refers only to decrees, I think the provisions of that section apply to appeals against orders as well. This Court has so held at least in one case, vide, 4 MLW 4111. In these circumstances, there is no substance in this contention either. The order of the learned Subordinate Judge is correct and there is no reason to interfere with it in revision. The petition is, therefore, dismissed with costs.
C.R.K/B.D
7. Petition dismissed.
Alert