Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Bishambhar Nath v. Achal Singh

Allahabad High Court
May 23, 1932
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

This opinion addresses an application for revision of an order passed by the District Magistrate of Agra in exercise of appellate powers under section 318 of the Municipalities Act, Act II of 1916. The applicant filed an application under section 115 of the Code of Civil Procedure seeking revision of that order before the High Court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the District Magistrate's court, when hearing appeals under section 318 of the Municipalities Act, is a court subordinate to the High Court within the meaning of section 115 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
  2. Whether the High Court has jurisdiction to entertain a revision application under section 115 of the Code of Civil Procedure against orders passed by the District Magistrate under section 318 of the Municipalities Act.

Arguments of the Parties

Applicant's Arguments

  • The court hearing an appeal under section 318 of the Municipalities Act must be deemed subordinate to the High Court because section 319 allows the appellate court to make references to the High Court, which then must decide the referred matter.
  • Reliance was placed on the case of Sadeck Abdulla v. Mahomed Abdulla Hasanalli, which supported the contention that the appellate court is subordinate to the High Court.

Opposite Party's Arguments

  • The District Magistrate's court, when exercising appellate jurisdiction under section 318, is not subordinate to the High Court within the meaning of section 115 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
  • Therefore, the High Court has no jurisdiction under section 115 to revise orders passed by the District Magistrate under section 318 of the Municipalities Act.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Sadeck Abdulla v. Mahomed Abdulla Hasanalli Support for the contention that a court making references to the High Court is subordinate to it under section 115 of the Code of Civil Procedure. The court rejected the application of this precedent to the present case, distinguishing the statutory framework.
Case regarding the Resident at Aden and High Court of Bombay under Aden Courts Act (II of 1864) Held that the Resident's court was subordinate to the High Court of Bombay due to specific statutory provisions granting superintendence and rule-making powers. The court found this precedent inapplicable as analogous provisions were absent in the Municipalities Act.
John Thomson (referenced in Bombay case) Reference described as a "modified form of appeal", suggesting subordination of the referring court to the court deciding the reference. The court disagreed with this view, emphasizing the lack of statutory provision making the referring court subordinate.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court began by examining the nature of the District Magistrate's role under section 318 of the Municipalities Act, confirming that the District Magistrate acts as a court under section 320 of the Act. The pivotal question was whether this court is subordinate to the High Court within the meaning of section 115 of the Code of Civil Procedure, which limits the High Court’s revisional jurisdiction to subordinate courts.

The court clarified that subordination requires the existence of appellate, revisional, or supervisory powers conferred by statute on the higher court over the lower court. The mere power to decide references from the lower court does not establish subordination. Furthermore, section 115 contemplates judicial, not merely administrative, subordination.

The court noted that the Municipalities Act does not confer appellate or revisional powers on the High Court over the District Magistrate's appellate court, and section 321(2) declares the appellate court's order as final. There is no statutory provision granting the High Court supervisory powers over the District Magistrate’s appellate court.

The court distinguished the Bombay case concerning the Aden Courts Act, where the High Court had explicit statutory superintendence and rule-making powers, which are absent in the Municipalities Act. It rejected the analogy drawn by the applicant’s counsel.

The court further rejected the notion that the power to make references equates to subordination, emphasizing that references differ fundamentally from appeals. A reference is made by a court, not a party, and the appellate court is not bound to decide in accordance with the High Court’s opinion on the reference. Consequently, the High Court cannot enforce compliance with its decision on a reference.

On these grounds, the court held that the District Magistrate’s appellate court under section 318 is not subordinate to the High Court, and therefore, no revision lies under section 115 of the Code of Civil Procedure.

Holding and Implications

The application for revision under section 115 of the Code of Civil Procedure against the order of the District Magistrate passed under section 318 of the Municipalities Act is dismissed as incompetent.

The direct effect of this decision is that the High Court lacks revisional jurisdiction over orders passed by the District Magistrate exercising appellate powers under the Municipalities Act. No new precedent regarding the subordination of courts beyond this determination was established.

Show all summary ...

Iqbal Ahmad, J.:— A preliminary objection has been taken to the hearing of this application in revision. The order sought to be revised is an order of the District Magistrate of Agra purporting to have been passed by him in exercise of the appellate powers conferred on him by section 318 of the Municipalities Act, Act II of 1916. The application before me purports to be an application under section 115 of the Code of Civil Procedure.

The revisional jurisdiction conferred on the High Court by that section is limited to cases decided by “any court Sub-ordinate to such High Court” and it is argued by the learned counsel for the opposite party that, as the court of the District Magistrate when dealing with appeals under section 318 of the Municipalities Act is not Sub-ordinate to the High Court, this Court has no jurisdiction under section 115 of the Code of Civil Procedure to revise the orders passed by the District Magistrate under section 318 of the Municipalities Act.

The learned counsel for the applicant contends that, in view of the fact that by section 319 of the Municipalities Act the court hearing an appeal under section 318 can make a reference only to the High Court and that on such reference the High Court has not only to express its opinion but to decide the matter referred to it, the court hearing an appeal under section 318 must be deemed to be Sub-ordinate to the High Court, and in support of this contention he has placed reliance on the case of Sadeck Abdulla…Applicant; v. Mahomed Abdulla Hasanalli…Opponent. (1).

I am unable to agree with the contention of the learned counsel for the applicant. That the officer or the District Magistrate hearing an appeal under section 318 is a court is put beyond doubt by reference to section 320 of the Municipalities Act, and the only question that remains for consideration is whether or not that court is Sub-ordinate to this Court within the meaning of section 115 of the Code of Civil Procedure. In the determination of this question no assistance can be had from section 3 of the Code of Civil Procedure for the simple reason that the enumeration of Sub-ordinate courts in that section is not exhaustive and there may be courts not referred to in that section that may be Sub-ordinate to this Court. It appears to me, however, that a court can be said to be Sub-ordinate to another court only if the latter court has appellate or revisional jurisdiction or power of superintendence given to it by some statutory provision over the former court, and that the mere authority to decide a reference does not necessarily make the court making a reference Sub-ordinate to the court deciding the same. Further, as by section 115 this Court is given revisional powers only with reference to cases decided by Sub-ordinate courts, that section can only have reference to courts over which this Court has a judicial and not a purely administrative power.

Neither appellate nor revisional powers have been conferred on the High Court over the court of the District Magistrate by the Municipalities Act. On the contrary it is provided by clause (2) of section 321 of that Act that the order of the appellate court under section 318 shall be final. Nor am I aware of any statutory provision conferring on this High Court power of superintendence over courts hearing appeals under section 318 of the Municipalities Act. I, therefore, hold that the decision sought to be revised by this Court is not the decision of any court Sub-ordinate to this Court and, as such, the application for revision is incompetent.

In my judgment the Bombay case relied upon by the learned counsel for the applicant has no application to the case before me. It was decided in that case that with regard to questions arising in reference to cases to be stated by the Resident at Aden for the decision of the High Court of Judicature at Bombay under section 8, Aden Courts Act (II of 1864), the Resident's court is Sub-ordinate to that High Court within the meaning of section 115 of the Code of Civil Procedure. The learned Judges who decided that case relied on the preamble to, and on section 31 of, the said Act in support of the conclusion arrived at by them. By the preamble it is provided inter alia that “it is expedient to provide for the superintendence or revision of certain of such judgments and proceedings by the High Court at Bombay”, and by section 31 the High Court at Bombay is authorised and empowered “to make and issue general rules for regulating the practice and proceedings of the court of the Resident and also to frame forms for every proceeding in the said court, etc.”. In view of these provisions the learned Judges held that the court of the Resident at Aden was a court Sub-ordinate to the High Court of Bombay within the meaning of section 115 of the Code of Civil Procedure, notwithstanding the fact that, by section 15 of the said Act it is provided that the Bombay High Court is not a court of appeal as regards the decisions by the court of the Resident at Aden.

The reasons assigned by the learned Judges of the Bombay High Court for holding that court has revisional powers over the Resident's court at Aden have no application to the case before me. Provisions analogous to the provisions contained in the Aden Courts Act are not to be found in the Municipalities Act, and, as already stated, the court of the District Magistrate under the Municipalities Act has not by any statutory provision been made Sub-ordinate to the High Court in matters decided by it under the Municipalities Act.

The mere fact that under certain circumstances the District Magistrate is authorised to make references under the Municipalities Act to this Court cannot, in my opinion, be a justification for holding that the District Magistrate is Sub-ordinate to this Court in matters coming under the Municipalities Act. A reference has been made in the Bombay case to the decision in the matter of John Thomson , in which it was observed that a reference was “a modified form of appeal”, and the learned Judges of the Bombay High Court appear to have been inclined to the view that the mere fact that a court is empowered to entertain a reference made by another court makes the court making the reference Sub-ordinate to the court deciding the same. With all respect, I am unable to agree with this view. In the absence of a definite statutory provision to the effect that the decision of the court making the reference is to be in accordance with the decision of this Court on the matter referred to it, I can discover no justification for holding that the court making the reference is Sub-ordinate to this Court. There is no such provision in the Municipalities Act. The appellate court under that Act is no doubt empowered to make a reference to the High. Court for the decision of the point on which it entertains doubts, but it is not bound to decide the point referred to this Court in accordance with the decision of this Court. After deciding the matter referred to it under that section this Court cannot enforce compliance with its decision, and even if the appellate court in deciding an appeal under section 318 decides the point referred to this Court otherwise than in accordance with its decision, this Court cannot interfere with that decision. To me there appears to be no analogy between a reference and an appeal. An appeal is preferred by an aggrieved party, whereas a reference is made not by a party but by a court. The decision of the subject matter of appeal is by the court entertaining the appeal, whereas the decision of the matter about which a reference is made is not necessarily by the court deciding the reference.

For the reasons given above I hold that the court of the District Magistrate, while deciding an appeal under section 318 of the Municipalities Act, is not Sub-ordinate to this Court and, accordingly, no revision lies to this, Court, and the preliminary objection is well founded, I dismiss this application with costs.