- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
S. Fateh Mohd. v. Mst. Ghosia Bibi
Atma Charan, J.C.
1. Heard the parties. These are two connected appeals, being civil Second Appeals Nos. 74 and 99 of 1946, by the plaintiff and the defendant respectively from the Judgment and the decree of the appellate Court below. It appears that the plaintiff filed a suit against Ghosia Bibi and S. Abdul Sakhi on the allegation that he was the owner and in possession of the property in dispute having purchased it from Mst. Hulas Kanwar w/o. Ghisulal Sogani on 16-8-1941 and that two days later Ghosia Bibi and her husband S. Abdul Sakhi clandestinely sot into possession thereof. He accordingly brought a suit for recovery of possession and mesne profits. The defendants denied the allegation that they Rot into possession of the property in dispute on 18-8-1941, and asserted that they had been in possession thereof for a long time past. The defendants thus set up a title in themselves adverse to that of the plaintiff. The trial Court decreed the suit against both the defendants. The appellate Court below, however, allowed the appeal of Ghosia Bibi and dismissed the appeal of S. Abdul Sakhi.
2. With a view to appreciating the case of the parties properly the following pedigree would toe of some help:
3. It is an admitted case of the parties that Qutbuddin and his nephew Nosherali alias Nosh Mohd. were absolute owners of the property in dispute, their share being half and half. Many transfers and alienations were effected of their properties and their details are as below:
Nosherali alias Nosh Mohd.'s share of the property
| Ex. P/2 | Registered sale-deed executed by |
|
| Qutbuddin's share of the property. |
| Ex. R/2 | Unregistered usufructuary mortgage- |
| Ex. R/2 | Rent note executed by Qutbuddin in |
| Ex R/4 | Registered mortgage-deed executed by |
| Ex. R/5 | Mortgage-deed executed by Shammi |
| Ex. R/8 | Registered mortgage-deed executed by |
|
| The loan was taken for the construction |
| Ex. P/3 | This is an auction-sale certificate in |
| Ex. P/1 | Sale-deed executed by Hulas Kanwar There is a specific stipulation therein |
4. No objection in regard to Exs. P/1, P/2 and P/3 has been taken before the Court. Ex. R/2 has been proved by the statement of S. Fateh Mohd., Ex. R/7 by that of Kesrimal and Ex. R/3 by that of S. Fateh Mohd. and Kesrimal. On Exs. R/4, R/5 and R/8 the signatures of Nosh Mohd. have been proved by S. Fateh Mohd. Objection has, however, been taken that signatures of the executants Munni Bibi, Shammi Begum and Kaniz Fatma on Exs. R/4, R/5 and R/8 have not been proved. As far as Ex. R/8 is concerned, it is a mortgage-deed executed by Kaniz Fatma and Nosh Mohd. Signatures of Nosh Mohd. have been proved by S. Fateh Mohd. Ghulam Mohd. Nabi clearly states that he put in his signatures after Kaniz Fatma had put in her thumb-impression in his presence on it. Ex. R/5 is a mortgage-deed executed by Shammi Begum and Nosh Mohd. Signatures of Nosh Mohd. have been proved by S. Fateh Mohd. This document is attested by three persons Rehmat Bibi Zenat Bibi and Fazal Hussain. S. Fateh Mohd. has clearly stated that Rehmat Bibi and Zenat Bibi are dead. The third remaining attesting witness Fazal Hussain (D. W. 2) has appeared as a witness for defendants and in his statement clearly admits the attestation of this document and also states that suit property was mortgaged with Ghisulal Sogani. He is the son of S. Abdul Sakhi's mother's sister. This document accordingly also stands proved. Ex. R/4 is attested by Zahur Mohd. and Abdul Hakim, and both of them are dead, vide the statement of S. Fateh Mohd. The signature of Abdul Hakim one of the attesting witnesses has been identified by S. Fateh Mohd. This document also thus stands proved. Apart from this S. 68. Indian Evidence Act lays down that where a document is required by law to be attested, one attesting witness if alive, should be called to prove if the execution of the document by the person executing it has been specifically denied. Here there is no denial at all by Shammi Begum, Munni Bibi and Kaniz Fatma. Moreover, both the attesting witnesses of Ex. R/4 are dead. Only one attesting witness of Ex. R/5, is alive, and he has come as D.W. 2. One of the attesting witnesses of Ex. R/8 has been called, and so the documents have been fully proved, and the requirements of S. 68, Indian Evidence Act, have been fully complied with Apart from this Exs. R/4, R/5 and R/8 are all registered documents. There are endorsements on the documents that the executants had admitted the execution before the Sub-Registrar. It has been held by the various High Courts that an endorsement by a Sub-Registrar showing that the executant presented the document for registration and acknowledged execution may be treated as sufficient proof of the execution vide - 'Ganpatrao v. Nagorao', AIR 1940 Nag 282 (A). The specific denial of execution is necessary before the document is required to be proved vide - 'Ban Jassa Kunwar v. Sahu Narain Das,: AIR 1946 All 178 (B) and - 'Bhima Singh v. Fakir Chand',: AIR 1948 Nag 155 (C). It accordingly appears to me that the documents have been fully proved, and that there is no substance in the objections raised by the defendants.
5. The next point that arises for consideration is whether the document Ex. R/2, which is unregistered can be looked into for the purpose of helping the plaintiff in defending his possession from persons claiming under the transferor. Section 53A, T.P. Act clearly lays down that when possession has been given by the transferor to the transferee under a document, which is required by law to be registered, and when the transferee has performed his part of the contract, the transferee and the person claiming under him can defend their possession against the transferor or the person claiming under him inspite of the non-registration of the document. - 'Gajadhar Gajadhar Misir v. Bechan Chamar',: AIR 1934 All 768 (D), clearly lays down that when the transfer took place before the Amending Act came into force but suit was brought after the Amending Act had come into force, the provisions of S. 53A, T.P. Act applied, and so by virtue of S. 53A the plaintiff, who is the person claiming under the transferee can successfully defend his possession against Ghosia Bibi, who is claiming under the transferor Qutbuddin.
6. The next point taken up is that S. 53A. T. P. Act, can be invoked only by the defendant and not by the plaintiff, and for this - 'Probodh Kumar v. Dantmara Tea Co. Ltd.',: AIR 1940 PC 1 (E), has been cited as an authority. The ruling does not lay down that the transferee or person claiming under him cannot take the benefit of S. 53A, T. P. Act in defending his possession against the acts of the transferor or persons claiming under him. This ruling rather lays down that the transferee can under S. 53A protect his possession against the illegal act of the transferor or person claiming under him. In - 'Ewaz Ali v. Mt. Firdous Jehan',: AIR 1944 Oudh 212 (F), this ruling and all other rulings have been fully and clearly discussed, and it has been held that the proper way to look at a case in which the transferee's right of possession has been invaded by the transferor or person claiming under him was really in essence a defence and there is nothing in S. 53A, T.P. Act, which disentitled the transferee from maintaining such a suit. Their Lordships further held that the use of the word 'defendant' in - ' : AIR 1940 PC 1 (E)', means a person who pleads S. 53A for defending his possession against the transferor. In - 'Municipal Board, Etah v. Moradhuj',: AIR 1940 All 340 (G) this - ' : AIR 1940 PC 1 (E), was fully discussed and the same view was taken. In - 'Suleman v. P. N. Patel',: AIR 1933 Bom 381 (H), it has been laid down that the plaintiff can invoke the aid of S. 53A and so the plaintiff S. Fateh Mohd. can successfully claim the benefit of S. 53A, T.P. Act.
7. Considering, therefore, the facts of the case on record of the trial Court it is clear that so long as the various mortgages are outstanding Ghosia Bibi or her husband S. Abdul Sakhi cannot be allowed to take the law in their own hands and disturb the possession of the mortgagee or the person claiming through the mortgagee. The plaintiff, in the circumstances, is certainly entitled to a decree for possession and mesne profits at Rs. 2/- p.m. against Ghosia Bibi and her husband S. Abdul Sakhi.
8. The appeal of S. Fateh Mohd. against Ghosia Bibi accordingly is allowed and the decree of the trial Court is restored with one set of costs in each of the three Courts and the appeal of S. Abdul Sakhi against S. Fateh Mohd. is dismissed with costs of the Court.
Alert