Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

The Emperor v. Jasha Bewa Accused.

Calcutta High Court
Feb 6, 1907
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

This opinion arises from a reference made by the Additional Sessions Judge of Mymensingh under section 307 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. The accused, Jasha Bawa or Bibi, was tried under section 302 of the Indian Penal Code for the murder of her husband, Baju Sheikh, by poisoning him with arsenic. The trial was conducted with a jury, which unanimously found the accused not guilty. However, the Additional Sessions Judge disagreed with the jury's verdict and referred the case to the higher court under section 307 of the Code of Criminal Procedure.

The factual background reveals that Jasha Bibi and Baju Sheikh were married about two and a half years prior. The accused sometimes lived with her father and sometimes with her husband. After a period of separation during which she sought a divorce, she was brought back to her husband's house. Shortly after her return, she served food containing arsenic to her husband during a family meal. The deceased fell ill with symptoms consistent with arsenic poisoning and died shortly thereafter. The accused confessed to the crime before local villagers and subsequently before an Honorary Magistrate. Evidence, including witness testimonies and a chemical examiner's report, was presented before the Additional Sessions Judge.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the confession made by the accused before the punchayet and the Honorary Magistrate was admissible in evidence.
  2. Whether the jury's verdict of not guilty was legally sustainable in light of the circumstantial evidence and confessions.
  3. The appropriate sentence to be imposed on the accused given the circumstances of the murder.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The confession made before the punchayet should be rejected because the punchayet was a person in authority and allegedly induced the accused to confess by suggesting that she must confess to save herself.
  • The punchayet was argued to be a police officer, which would render the confession inadmissible.
  • There was insufficient evidence to prove that the accused killed her husband with arsenic specifically, or that arsenic poisoning was the cause of death.
  • The confession made before the Honorary Magistrate should be discarded due to lack of proof of the identity of the confessor.

Court's Response to Arguments

  • The court found no evidence of inducement by the punchayet and held the confession admissible.
  • The court rejected the claim that the punchayet was a police officer, noting no ruling was cited in support.
  • The court considered the circumstantial evidence and the chemical examiner's report sufficient to establish arsenic poisoning as the cause of death.
  • The court admitted the confession before the Honorary Magistrate after additional evidence confirmed the identity of the accused as the confessor.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court undertook a detailed examination of the evidence, emphasizing the strong circumstantial case against the accused. It noted the accused's hostile feelings towards the deceased, the timing of the poisoning shortly after her return to her husband's house, and the distinct serving vessel used for the deceased's food. The symptoms exhibited by the deceased following the meal aligned with arsenic poisoning, which was confirmed by the Chemical Examiner's report.

The court carefully evaluated the admissibility of the confessions. It found the confession before the punchayet admissible, rejecting allegations of inducement. Regarding the confession before the Honorary Magistrate, the court initially faced doubts about the identity of the confessor but resolved these through additional evidence from police officers who escorted the accused to the Magistrate's court.

Rejecting the jury's unanimous verdict of not guilty, the court gave precedence to the Additional Sessions Judge's opinion, concluding that the accused had indeed committed murder by poisoning her husband with arsenic. The court also noted the procedural deficiency that the post mortem evidence was not recorded by the Deputy Magistrate but found it unnecessary to call further evidence on that point.

In sentencing, the court acknowledged the deliberate nature of the murder and the accused's admission of administering poison with knowledge of its lethality. However, considering the accused's young age of 16 years, the court refrained from imposing the death penalty and instead sentenced her to transportation for life.

Holding and Implications

Verdict set aside.

The court overruled the jury's not guilty verdict and upheld the Additional Sessions Judge's finding that the accused was guilty of murdering her husband by arsenic poisoning. The accused was sentenced to transportation for life instead of the death penalty due to her young age. This decision directly affects the parties by convicting the accused and imposing a severe sentence but does not establish any new legal precedent.

Show all summary ...

1. This is a reference by the Additional Sessions Judge of Mymensingh, under sec. 307 of the Code of Criminal Procedure.

2. The accused, Jasha Bawa or Bibi, has been tried, under sac. 302 of the Indian Penal Code, for having murdered her husband, Baju Sheikh, by poisoning him with arsenic. The additional Sessions Judge conducted the trial with the assistance of a jury. The jury have unanimously found the accused not guilty and the Additional Sessions Judge has differed from the verdict of the jury so completely as to render it in his opinion necessary to refer the case to us under sec. 307, C. Cr. P.

3. The facts of the case are simple. The deceased, Baju Sheikh, was the husband of the accused Jasha Bibi, They were married about 21\2 years ago. After the marriage Jasha Bewa sometimes lived at the house of her father Nur Mamud Sheikh, and sometime at the house of her husband. In Magh last the girl went to her father and would not return to her husband, but desired to be divorced from him. About six or seven months after, however, towards the latter end of Sraban, the father of the deceased, Sadhu Kamar, brought back the girl to his house at the request of the girl's father and the girl began to cook the food of the family as she was the only female in the house. Three or four days after her arrival she mixed arsenic with the denga tarkari cooked by her and served it to her husband when he and his father and younger brother were at their evening meal. The vessel in which the tarkari was served to her husband was different from that in which it was served to his father and his brother. After finishing his meal the deceased was washing his hands when he felt a nausea and began retching and vomitting. He suspected the girl and told the people who came to see him that he had been poisoned by his wife. A neighbour came and gave him some jalpara (i.e, charmed water), to drink and a woman applied a solution of rasqsindhu over his abdomen But these remedies-proved ineffectual and the man died at about one danda before sunset.

4. Information was given to the punchayet and the neighbours and the girl confessed her crime before them. Next morning she was sent to the thana of Sherpur and thence to Rai Radha Ballab Bahadur, the Honorary Magistrate of Sherpur, before whom she made another confession. These are, shortly, the facts of the case. Evidence as to these facts has been given before the Additional Sessions Judge by many witnesses. There is first the evidence of Khaju Sheikh, the brother of the deceased, who is a boy of 10 or 12 years of age and who is said to have been served with food cooked by the girl when he and his father and the deceased sat down to eat together. Khaju speaks about the cooking of the food and the serving of it by the accused. Then, we have the evidence of Sadhu Kamar, the father of the deceased, who says that his son Khaju went to sleep after taking his meal and so could not see what happened afterwards. This witness also speaks of the vomitting, purging and other incidents before the death of Baju. He says he had gone four times to the house of the father of the accused after Magh last and that his attempts to bring her back to his house were unsuccessful, as both the accused and her father wanted a divorce. There is next the evidence of Jani Kamar, a neighbour and first cousin of the deceased. He speaks of the accused having been brought to the house of her husband towards the latter end of Sraban and of the occurrence taking place three days after her arrival. He also states that at 2 gharis of the night he was called by Baju and that on going to Baju's house he found him vomitting; that Baju complained of cramps in the stomach, nausea, a reeling sensation and restlessness after taking his meal and that he (Baju) suspected his wife of having poisoned him. The next witness, Kadam Sarkar, says that he saw Baju on the morning of the day on which he died and again at about sunset when he was dead, and that he also saw the vomitted stuff. The last mentioned witnesses Jani and Kadam as also the witnesses Yasin Fakir, Khosh Mahomed Sarkar Punchayet and Sadir speak of the alleged confession of the accused after the death of Baju. Then, we have some formal witnesses; and, finally, we have the confession made by the accused before the Honorary Magistrate.

5. Now, the statements made by the witnesses named above constitute very strong circumstantial evidence against the accused. In the first place we have the feeling of the accused towards the deceased. Then, there is the fact that three or four days after being brought back to her husband's house, the occurrence took place and the further fact that the food served to the deceased and his father and brother was admittedly cooked by the accused and that the tarkari served to the deceased was in a different vessel from that served to his father and brother. Then there is the fact that immediately, after eating the food the deceased had symptoms of arsenic-poisoning, namely vomitting, retching and restlessness, followed by purging & c. We have also the statement of the Chemical Examiner, who says that he discovered arsenic in the viscera of the deceased sent to him by the local authorities. Lastly, there is the confession made to the pun-chayet and the villagers by the accused herself.

6. The admission of this confession has been objected to on behalf of the accused because it is said that the punchayet was a person in authority and that, according to the evidence of Sadhu Kamar, the punchayet told the accused that in order to save herself she must say what she had done. The other witnesses, however, and the punchayet himself say that the punchayet told the accused nothing of the sort. They have given detailed evidence of the confession and recited the exact words used by the punchayet and, accused; and they state that all that the punchayet said to the accused was that she should tell the truth.

7. The learned Additional Sessions Judge in addressing the jury pointed out to them that if they believed the statement of Sadhu Kamar, that the punchayet offered an inducement to the accused to canfess, then they should reject her confession, but that if, on the other hand, they did not think that there had been any inducement used, they should accept the evidence of that confession. In his letter of reference to this Court the Additional Sessions Judge has distinctly said that, in his opinion, the evidence of the witnesses and of the punchayet is to be believed and that he considered that Sadhu was not correct in what he said and therefore the confession is admissible and is proved. We are of the same opinion. We do not think that there is any ground for supposing that any inducement was offered by the punchayet to influence the accused to confess, and from the evidence of this punchayet and of the witnesses who heard what the woman said and who can tell the exact words used by her, it does not appear to us that this confession is inadmissible.

8. The pleader for the accused urges, first, that the punchayet was a person in authority, and secondly, that he was a police-officer. Now, no doubt, the punchayet was a person in authority. Still, as he did not make use of any inducement to influence the accused to admit her guilt her confession is admissible. Then, there is no reason to suppose that the punchayet is a police officer. No ruling to this effect has been cited to us.

9. There is next the confession made on the 17th August 1906 before the Honorary Magistrate. This confession is a detailed one and was made after due warning. In it the accused distinctly says that she was unwilling to live with her husband and had asked for a divorce, but that it had not been granted; and so she asked Ali, a neighbour of her father, if he could give her something which if taken would kill a man. She goes on to say that he agreed and she paid him 2 annas and that on Friday he gave her a small lump of some substance of a whitish colour. She adds that on that day her father-in-law went there and brought her home. Ali, she say had told her that the drug should be powdered and mixed with some article of food and that such food, if taken by her husband, would cause him to purge and vomit and then die. She then admits that she powdered the drug and on the night of Monday mixed it with the denga curry which she gave her husband to eat that he ate it and had purging and vomitting that very night and expired on Tuesday at about a prohur before sun-set, And she concludes by saying “do not punish me. It was Ali who told me to kill (the man).”

10. The Honorary Magistrate thinks that this confession was made voluntarily. The learned Sessions Judge, however, excluded it from the evidence and asked the jury to discard it, as there was no evidence to show the identity of the woman who made it. The Honorary Magistrate was called, but apparently all he could say was that the confession had been made by one Jasha Bewa. In these circumstances, we called for additional evidence on the point. We did not think that there was much doubt that the statement had been made by the accused Jasha Bewa, because it was headed “translation of the statement of the accused Jasha Bewa before R.B Chowdhury, Rai Bahadur, Honorary Magistrate” and the accused says in it that her father's name is Nur Mamud Sheikh and that she resides at Mouzah Sabir Char, Thana Sherpur, Zillah Mymen-singh, whereas before the Committing Magistrate she admits that her father's name is Nur Mamud Sheikh and that she lives at Harindhara, Thana Sherpur, District Mymensingh. Though there did not seem to us to be any reasonable doubt as to the confession having been made by the accused Jasha Bewa; yet in order to render it legally admissible, we called for further evidence, The Honorary Magistrate has now left the place and his evidence cannot be taken. But there is the evidence of the two police-officers who took this very woman to the Honorary Magistrate's Court and saw her placed before him. They were turned out of the room before she made her confession, but they say that there was no other woman there and that no other woman could have made the statement. They add that after Jasha Bewa had been in the room half an hour they were told to take her away. In these circumstances we have not the slightest doubt that the person who made the confession before the Honorary Magistrate was Jasha Bewa, the accused. There could not be two Jasha Bewas, daughters of the same father and residents in the same place.

11. We have, therefore, admitted this confession and taken it into consideration. We may remark that we have taken the additional evidence above-mentioned under sec. 422, C. Cr. P., which does not require that such evidence should be taken in the presence of jurors or assessors.

12. After taking all the evidence in this case into consideration we have not the slightest doubt that the verdict of the jury is incorrect and that the opinion of the Sessions Judge should prevail. The evidence shows that the accused has certainly killed her husband by poisoning him. The pleader for the accused contends that there is not sufficient evidence to show that she killed him with arsenic and that arsenic poisoning was the cause of his death. We think, however, that that point is immaterial, Jasha Bewa admits that she killed her husband by poison; and the circumstantial evidence of the confession as well as the Chemical Examiner's report show that she killed him by poison. There is every reason to think, that the poison used was arsenic. In the first place, she says in her confession that she got a whitish powder from one Ali, who told her that if she gave it to her husband it would kill him. All the symptoms from which Baju suffered his being taken ill within a very short time of his taking his meal, his purging, retching, vomitting and so forth—are signs of arsenic poisoning. Moreover, as already mentioned, the Chemical Examiner's report shows that there was arsenic in the viscera of the deceased. These circumstances point conclusively to the fact that the accused killed her husband by poisoning him with arsenic.

13. It is to be regretted that the Deputy Magistrate who committed the accused did not record the evidence of the Assistant surgeon, who made the post mortem examination. He should, we think, have done so. However, looking at the evidence as it stands, we think it is unnecessary to take further evidence on this point.

14. There now remains the question of sentence. There is no doubt that the accused has murdered her husband in a deliberate manner. She admits that she administered a whitish powder to him and she knew very well that it would kill him. She also admits that she obtained the powder from a neigh bour named Ali, who, she says, told her that if she gave it to her husband, he would die and that he, Ali, would then marry her after the nika form. In these circumstances the offence committed by the accused cannot be re garded as anything less than murder, and it was, as already pointed out, a very deliberate murder. Had the accused been of more mature age, we should have thought it our duty to pass on her the sentence of death. But, having regard to the fact that she is a mere girl of 16 years of age, we will not sentence her to the extreme penalty of the law but will direct that she be transported for life, and we accordingly do so.

15. Verdict set aside.