Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Estate Of H.E.H The Nizam v. Padaturi Malliah .

Andhra Pradesh High Court
Mar 3, 1955

1. This petition in revision under Section 12 of the Small Cause Courts Act, is directed against the judgment and decree of the District and Sessions Judge, Secunderabad, Shri Kumarayya, dated 4-12-1949, decreeing the petitioner's suit against the opposite party for recovery of Rs. 1253-2-0 I.G being a compensation for non-delivery of a consignment which was sent by plaintiff 1 P. Malliah, from Umdanagar to Hosadurga Road to himself. This consignment consisted of four barrels of castor oil weighing 64 Kachha maunds. It is common ground that this consignment was booked, and it was never delivered to the consignee.

2. There are two legal points of some importance raised by the learned advocate of the petitioner in this case.

3. The first is that a notice under Section 46 of the Hyderabad Railways Act, corresponding to Section 77 of the Indian Railways Act, was not sent to the defendant railway and, therefore, the suit is liable to be dismissed. There is a conflict of decisions on the point as to whether in case of non-delivery of goods Section 77 of the Indian Railways Act is applicable, or not. The Bombay High Court in a recent case reported in — ‘Martab Ali v. Union Of India’, AIR 1954 Bom 297 (A) has held that the word “loss” in S. 77 is applicable to the case of non-delivery, as well as to cases of negligence and wrongful detention or conversion on the part of the railway administration.

4. A similar view has been expressed in — ‘Firms Thakur Dass Manrak Khan Lal v. E.I Rly. Co.’, AIR 1926 All 686 (B); — ‘Sheo Dayal Niranjaw Lal v. G.I.P Rly. Co.’, AIR 1926 All 698 (C); — ‘E.I Rly. Co. v. Fazal Elahi’, AIR 1925 All 273 (D); — ‘G.I.P Rly. Co. v. Jitan Ram Nirmal Ram’, AIR 1923 Pat 285 (E); — ‘Dominion of India v. Hazarilal’, AIR 1949 Pat 410 (FB)(F).

5. The weight of authority is however in support of the opposite view. This question has been recently decided by the Allahabad High Court in two Full Bench cases; it has been held in — ‘Governor-General in Governor-General In Council v. Mahabir Ram’, AIR 1952 All 891 (FB)(G) by a Full Bench consisting of Waliullah, Bind Basni Pershad and Gurtu, JJ. that where a non-delivery of goods is due to loss of goods by the railway administration, or to their deterioration or destruction, then only a notice under Section 77 of the Railways Act is necessary, but where nondelivery of goods is due to any other reason then no such notice is required. The same learned Judges in another case — ‘Mutsaddilal v. Governor-General in Council, AIR 1952 All 897 (FB)(H) have again expressed the same view. Their Lordships have pointed out in that case that the word ‘loss’ occurring in S. 77 does not mean loss to the owner but loss suffered by the railway administration.

6. I think no other interpretation is possible considering the wording of S. 77 which runs as follows:

“A person shall not be entitled to a refund of an overcharge in respect of animals or goods carried by railway or to compensation for the loss, destruction, or deterioration of animals or goods delivered to be so carried unless his claim to the refund or compensation has been preferred in writing by him or on his behalf to the railway administration within six months from the date of the delivery of the animals or goods for carriage by railway.”

7. And bearing in mind the context in which the word ‘loss’ occurs.

8. There are also numerous decisions of different High Courts which support this view. A Full Bench of Punjab High Court in — ‘Babulal v. Dominion of India’, AIR 1953 Punj 184 (I) has held that where the suit is based on non-delivery of the goods, notice of claim is not necessary under S. 77. See also in this regard — ‘G.A. Jolli v. Dominion Of India’, AIR 1949 Cal 380 (J); — ‘G.G in Council v. Mohd. Badar-i-Alam’, AIR 1949 All 223 (K); — ‘G.G in Governor-General In Council v. Debi Sahai’, AIR 1946 All 198 (L); — ‘Bala Persad v. B.N.W Rly. Co.’, AIR 1927 Oudh 478 (2)(M); — ‘Nagendra Nath Sen v. B. & N.W Rly. Co.’, AIR 1928 Pat 95 (N); — ‘Haryana Cotton Mills Co. Ltd. v. B.B & C.I Rly.’, AIR 1927 Lah 471 (O).

9. This view is also supported by an obiter dicta of a Division Bench of this High Court consisting of Shripat Rao, C.J and Dr. M.S Ali Khan, J. in — ‘Mongani Ram v. Govt of India’, AIR 1953 Hyd 139 (P). I think if it was known to the plaintiff and if the plaint is so framed that the plaintiff admits and bases his claim on the fact that the Railway has lost the property, then possibly, the question of notice under S. 77 may arise; otherwise a notice is not necessary. If the word ‘loss’ refers to the loss of railway, this section cannot apply to the cases in which such loss is not alleged or admitted by the plaintiff. For the reasons stated above, I think that this contention of the learned advocate of the railway must fail. The other contention is that the plaintiff had no right to sue because according to his own admission in para. 3 of the plaint, he had sold the railway receipt to plaintiffs Nos. 2 and 3 and they in their turn sold to one Negeshappa, who did not accept the hundi and refused to honour it. He argues, therefore, that Nageshappa was the only person who was competent to sue the railway. I cannot agree.

10. The railway receipt shows that the consignee is P. Malliah plaintiff 1 himself. There does not appear any endorsement in the name of another person. What agreement was between plaintiff 1 and other persons is not a matter with which the railway authorities are concerned. It was their duty to deliver the consignment to plaintiff 1 as the sole consignee. Plaintiff 1, therefore, is clearly entitled to sue.

11. No other point was raised or arises for decision, with the result that this revision petition fails and is dismissed with costs.

R.G.D

12. Petition dismissed.