Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Muthu Karu Vena Alagappa Chettiar v. Kanakasabai Pillai

Madras High Court
Jan 10, 1918

This appeal can be disposed of with reference to only one of the grounds taken, that the Lower Appellate Court erred in its decision in favour of plaintiff's right to proceed by suit. The 1st defendant was under obligation, under Exhibit A-1, a compromise decree, to endorse certain promissory notes in plaintiff's favour and to execute a power of attorney and do other things within a fixed time. He did not comply with his obligation; and plaintiff, instead of compelling him to do so by process under O. 21, R. 32 or 34, has now sued him and the present appellants, certain trustees alleged to be in possession of his property, for damages on the ground that the notes are now time-barred and worthless.

The Lower Appellate Court has held that such a suit will lie on the strength of certain authorities of which (to mention only those in which Sect. 47 of the Civil Procedure Code of 1908 was pleaded) Saratmani Debee v. Bata Krishna(1) was decided in special circumstances and Kolintavita Mama Amma v. Kolintavita Haji Kandi(2) and Quamzal Huda v. Kumud Nath Sen Gupta(3) dealt with causes of action arising subsequently to, and independently of, the decree. Here the cause of action is not that the notes are barred, but that 1st defendant failed to comply with the decree and enable plaintiff to sue on them, before they became so, and the authorities referred to are not in point. In the absence of authority we are not prepared to accept the proposition involved in plaintiff's contention, that a judgment-debtor, who does not voluntarily satisfy a decree, commits an actionable wrong, for which the decree-holder can recover compensation by separate suit. Taking this view, we must hold that the suit is not sustainable.

We have been asked in the alternative to treat the plaint, as an execution petition and to allow plaintiff to recover damages under O. 21, R. 32. But, apart from any objections to such execution on its merits, we are not, in view of the delay, after which this relief has been claimed, and the course of the litigation, prepared to use our discretion to do so.

The result is that the appeal is allowed, the suit being dismissed with costs throughout.

C. K.Appeal allowed.