- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Rabindra Chandra Chatterjee, In Re
Structured Summary of the Opinion (Sanderson, C.J.; Woodroffe, J.; Mookerjee, J.)
Factual and Procedural Background
The Court considered a rule (originally granted by Mr. Justice Chatterjee and Justice Pearson) calling on the District Judge of Dacca to show cause why the proceedings instituted under section 14 of the Legal Practitioners Act against the petitioner should not be quashed or, alternatively, transferred to another Court. Pending the hearing, the High Court ordered a stay of further proceedings under section 14.
The District Judge of Dacca had caused a notice under section 14 to be served on the petitioner. The notice alleged three categories of misconduct:
- That on 15 June 1921 in the Court of the Subordinate Judge (Babu Pashupati Basu) the petitioner addressed that Judge offensively, refused to submit to an order regarding an insufficiently stamped plaint, and repeatedly interrupted the Judge in a grossly improper manner.
- That after the incident the petitioner called a meeting of the Bar Association, Dacca, and by statements about the Subordinate Judge induced certain pleaders to abstain from appearing in that Judge's Court, thereby depriving clients of agreed legal assistance.
- That the petitioner filed a complaint in the Deputy Magistrate's Court charging the Subordinate Judge with having committed criminal offences in the discharge of his duties.
The petitioner applied (by rule) to quash the proceedings and alternatively to have them transferred from the District Judge to another Judge. The High Court heard the matter and ultimately discharged the rule.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the proceedings instituted under section 14 of the Legal Practitioners Act should be quashed for want of jurisdiction because the alleged misconduct did not occur in the Court where proceedings were instituted.
- Whether the materials relied upon by the District Judge (including newspaper reports and confidential reports) were insufficient or improper to justify instituting proceedings under section 14.
- Whether the proceedings should be transferred from the file of the District Judge to the Additional District Judge because of a reasonable apprehension of bias or miscarriage of justice.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's (applicant's) Arguments
- The District Judge had no jurisdiction to institute proceedings under section 14 because the alleged misconduct occurred in the Subordinate Judge's Court, not in the District Judge's Court.
- The District Judge acted upon materials that were insufficient and in some respects improper — specifically, that information derived from newspaper reports (and other materials) did not constitute proper grounds to institute the proceedings.
- The case should be transferred from the District Judge to the Additional District Judge because of a reasonable apprehension that the petitioner would not obtain a fair and impartial hearing.
District Judge / Respondent's Position (as reflected in the opinion)
- The notice under section 14 referred to matters not confined to the Subordinate Judge's Court (heads 2 and 3 occurred outside that Court), and the petitioner practiced in the District Judge's Court; therefore, the District Judge had jurisdiction to institute proceedings.
- The District Judge disclosed the sources of his information; the only matters for which newspaper reports were used were the Bar Association meeting and the institution of a criminal case, both of which were not disputed facts (a resolution was passed and a complaint instituted).
- The District Judge provided explanations addressing the grounds for transfer and the petitioner had not shown a reasonable apprehension of miscarriage of justice; thus no transfer was warranted.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| In the Matter of Babu Het Ram | Section 14 empowers any Court in which a pleader practises to consider a charge made in such Court; the section does not limit consideration to the Court in which the misconduct is alleged to have been committed. | The Court relied on this interpretation to support the District Judge's jurisdiction to institute proceedings against a pleader practising in his Court even though some alleged misconduct occurred elsewhere. |
| In re Nabin Chandra Das Gupta | An example where proceedings under Section 14 were quashed because the alleged act (refusal to accept engagement) would not constitute grounds for disciplinary action under Section 13. | The Court distinguished that case: here, at least some allegations, if proved, could constitute grounds under Section 13, so the reasoning in Nabin Chandra Das Gupta did not require quashing the proceedings. |
| In the Matter of Southekal Krishna Rao | A presiding officer who becomes aware that a practitioner has been guilty of unprofessional conduct may take steps to have the matter adjudicated; the origin of the information need not be formally specified. | Used to show that Section 14 does not require that proceedings be founded upon formal allegations only and that action can be taken on information coming to the Court. |
| Randall v. Brigham (U.S. Supreme Court) | Proceedings against attorneys for malpractice or unprofessional conduct need not be founded on formal allegations; they may be instituted on various forms of information; when instituted outside open Court notice and opportunity for defense must be afforded; manner of proceeding must avoid oppression or unfairness. | The Court cited this passage to justify that proceedings may be instituted on diverse materials (including reports or information) provided adequate notice and opportunity to defend are given. |
| In the Matter of an Advocate | Action taken on information communicated to the Court (in that case by the Advocate-General in a letter) can form a proper basis for initiating proceedings. | Offered as an illustrative precedent showing that formal originating documents are not strictly necessary to initiate disciplinary proceedings. |
| In the Matter of an Advocate, a Vakil, a Pleader and a Mukhtear | Action taken by the Court on the basis of a casual statement in a deposition in subordinate court proceedings can be sufficient to initiate disciplinary proceedings. | Used as another example supporting the proposition that varied forms of information may justify initiation of enquiries under Section 14. |
| In the Matter of A.G. Garmpathi Sastri | The charge must be formulated with precision so that the legal practitioner can meet the allegations made against him. | The Court noted that in the present case the charge was not vague or indefinite and that the petitioner had supplied a detailed written statement, indicating no prejudice from lack of precision. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court's analysis proceeded through three principal lines of examination corresponding to the petitioner's three primary complaints: jurisdiction, sufficiency/propriety of materials, and transfer.
1. Jurisdiction
- Sanderson, C.J. found multiple answers to the jurisdiction argument. He observed that not all alleged misconduct occurred in the Subordinate Judge's Court; allegations under heads 2 and 3 related to conduct outside that Court. Independently, he emphasised that the District Judge had jurisdiction because the petitioner practised in the District Judge's Court and the District Judge could institute proceedings upon proper materials being laid before him.
- Woodroffe, J. agreed and examined the wording of section 14 ("charged in such Court"), concluding that the language does not limit the charge to the Court in which the alleged misconduct occurred. He cited and accepted the view of In the Matter of Babu Het Ram to the effect that section 14 empowers any Court in which a pleader practises to consider charges made in that Court.
- Mookerjee, J. provided a statutory interpretation tracing sections 12, 13 and 14: section 12 deals with suspension/dismissal upon conviction; section 13 deals with suspension/dismissal for unprofessional conduct even without conviction; section 14 authorises a Subordinate Court to send a copy of the charge to the pleader and to take the charge into consideration. He held that the section is not restricted to cases where the misconduct was committed in the Court instituting the proceedings.
2. Sufficiency and Source of Materials
- The petitioner argued that the District Judge had acted on insufficient or improper materials, including newspaper reports and confidential reports. The District Judge had, however, explained the materials he relied upon. Sanderson, C.J. accepted that the only matters for which newspaper reports were used were (a) the Bar Association meeting and (b) the institution of a criminal case; both were undisputed as to existence (a resolution and a complaint).
- Woodroffe, J. emphasised that at least one charge (offensive addressing and repeated interruption) could, if proved, be a ground for proceeding under the Act and that it was not possible at the interlocutory stage to quash proceedings. He also noted that details of information included reports from the Subordinate Judge and other reports, and there was nothing to show absence of ground for proceedings.
- Mookerjee, J. addressed the contention that the proceedings were based on materials that could not supply a legal foundation. He observed that Section 14 does not specify the nature of materials on which a court may take action; what is essential is that, if proceedings are instituted, there must ultimately be an enquiry supported by legal evidence. He cited Southekal Krishna Rao and Randall v. Brigham to show that proceedings need not always originate in formal allegations and that Courts may act on information obtained in various ways, but he also stressed that the charges must be precise enough to enable defence (citing A.G. Garmpathi Sastri). In the present case the Court found the charge sufficiently definite and the petitioner's written statement detailed.
3. Transfer
- The petitioner's application to transfer the proceedings to the Additional District Judge rested on alleged reasonable apprehension of bias. Sanderson, C.J. and Woodroffe, J. concluded that the District Judge's explanations answered the grounds for transfer and that there was no reasonable apprehension preventing a fair hearing. Mookerjee, J. concurred that neither branch of the rule (quash or transfer) could be supported.
Overarching Observations
- The Court repeatedly emphasised that its decision at this stage was confined to interlocutory questions (jurisdiction, sufficiency of materials, and transfer) and expressly declined to express any opinion on the ultimate merits of the allegations. The Court held that where at least one of the alleged acts, if proved, could amount to professional misconduct under Section 13, it was not appropriate to quash proceedings at this stage.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The High Court discharged the rule — the petition to quash the proceedings under section 14 was refused and the application to transfer the proceedings was denied.
Direct effects on the parties:
- The proceedings initiated by the District Judge under section 14 will continue; they are not quashed at this interlocutory stage.
- The request to transfer the matter from the District Judge to the Additional District Judge is refused; the District Judge will proceed unless or until some other competent order is made.
- The Court did not express any view on the merits of the allegations; it confined itself to determining that it was not possible at this stage to say that none of the allegations, if proved, would amount to professional misconduct under the Act.
Broader implications: The opinion relies on existing authorities for the propositions that (a) a Court in which a pleader practises may take action under section 14 even if some alleged misconduct occurred elsewhere and (b) disciplinary enquiries may be initiated on various forms of information provided charges are formulated with sufficient precision. The opinion does not purport to lay down a new precedent beyond application and reaffirmation of cited authorities.
Sanderson, C.J:— This was a rule granted by my learned brothers, Mr. Justice Chatterjee and Justice Pearson calling upon the District Judge of Dacca to show cause why the proceedings under section 14 of the Legal Practitioners Act against the petitioner should not be quashed or in the alternative, why the proceedings should not be transferred to some other Court or why such other order should not be passed as to this Court might seem proper. The Court made an order that in the meantime, pending the hearing of the rule, further proceedings under section 14 of the Legal Practitioners Act should be stayed.
2. It appears that the learned District Judge of Dacca caused a notice to be served upon the petitioner under section 14 of the Legal Practitioners Act. That notice referred to certain matters, which I think may be classed under three heads: With regard to the first, the allegation was that the petitioner, being a pleader of the Court, was on the 15th of June, 1921, “guilty of grossly improper conduct” in the Court of the Subordinate Judge, Babu Pashupati Basu, in that he addressed the Subordinate Judge in an offensive manner and repeatedly refused to submit to his order in regard to the admission of a plaint that was insufficiently stamped and, after the Subordinate Judge had passed his order, repeatedly interrupted him in a grossly improper and discourteous manner. The second matter, that was alleged, was that after this incident the petitioner caused a meeting to be called of the members of the Bar Association, Dacca, and that by the statements he made regarding the Subordinate Judge, Babu Pashupati Basu, induced certain pleaders of that Court to abstain from appearing in the Court of the Subordinate Judge on behalf of their clients in cases in which they had been engaged. Then the notice went on to allege that in consequence of such inducement certain pleaders wilfully and without excuse and in contravention of their agreements with the persons-who had engaged them to appear on their behalf in the Court of the Subordinate Judge, refused to appear in the Court of the Subordinate Judge and thus deprived their clients of the legal assistance they had agreed to render them: and, the third matter to which reference was made was that it was alleged that the petitioner had filed a complaint in the Court of the Deputy Magistrate, Babu B.M Ghosh, against the Subordinate Judge, Babu Pashupati Basu, charging him with having, while in the discharge of his duties as Judge committed certain criminal offences; and by reason of these matters, it was alleged that the learned pleader was guilty of grossly improper conduct and had rendered himself liable to be suspended under Section 13 of the Legal Practitioners Act. The first point, on which the learned pleader in support of the rule has relied, is that the learned District Judge who directed the service of this notice had no jurisdiction to institute these proceedings by reason of the fact that the misconduct relied upon did not take place in the learned District Judge's Court. There seem to me to be more than one answer to this argument. In the first place, the alleged misconduct on which the notice was based did not take place altogether in the Court of the learned Subordinate Judge. It is true that the matters referred to under the first head, which I have mentioned took place in the learned Subordinate Judge's Court; but the matters which are referred to under heads 2 and 3, namely, the alleged inducement to abstain from appearing in the Court of the Subordinate Judge and the alleged complaint in respect of criminal offences did not take place in the Court of the learned Subordinate Judge. Consequently it cannot be said that the whole of the alleged misconduct, upon which the notice was based, had taken place in the Court of the learned Subordinate Judge. Apart from that, in my judgment, the learned District Judge had jurisdiction to deal with all the matters which were alleged in the notice, inasmuch as the petitioner (the learned pleader) was practising in the Court of the learned District Judge and it was within his jurisdiction, upon proper materials being laid before him, to institute the proceedings in the manner, in which he did.
3. The second point on which the learned vakil relied was that the learned Judge had acted upon materials which were not sufficient and in a sense improper, in that he had stated that he had acquired some of the information upon which he relied from newspaper reports. It is clear from the learned Judge's answer to the petition that the only matters, on which information from newspaper reports was obtained were first, the proceedings at the meeting of the Bar Association and secondly, the institution of a criminal case against the learned Subordinate Judge. As regards those two matters, there is no dispute that there was a complaint in criminal proceedings laid and there is also no dispute that a resolution was passed by the members of the association to carry out a certain course of conduct. The learned Judge has informed the Court of the materials, which he had with regard to the other matters and as to how he obtained those materials, and, in my judgment, this second point affords no reason for making the rule absolute.
4. The third point which, the learned vakil urged was that this case ought to be transferred from the file of the learned District Judge to the file of the learned Additional District Judge. In this case the petitioner (the learned pleader) has set out in his petition his reasons why the case should be transferred from the learned District Judge's file. In my judgment, the allegations which have been made have been completely answered by the explanation which the learned District Judge has given and I can see no reason for any reasonable apprehension on the part of the petitioner that he will not get a fair and impartial hearing at the hands of the learned District Judge. In my judgment this rule should be discharged.
5. In discharging the rule I am expressing no opinion as to the merits of the matter. My judgment is confined to holding that it is not possible at this stage of the proceedings to say that none of the allegations, if proved, would amount to professional misconduct within the meaning of the Act.
Woodroffe, J.:— I agree. As stated in the judgment of the learned Chief Justice, the only matter before us now is whether the proceedings should be quashed or transferred and with no other question we are now concerned. It may be that the facts charged did not happen, or if they did, those facts were insufficient for proceeding against the applicant. On this I say nothing now. If it were shown that the facts charged, if proved, did not constitute grounds for proceeding under the Act, then there would be a case for quashing the proceedings as asked; but in this case there is at least one charge, namely, as regards “the addressing of the Subordinate Judge in an offensive manner” and “repeatedly interrupting him in a grossly improper and discourteous manner,” as to which, whatever may be said as regards the other charges, it is not possible to say that it may not in any case be a ground for proceeding under the Act. Therefore, it seems to me that the proceedings cannot now be quashed and that the facts must be enquired into. No doubt, as it was contended by the learned vakil for the applicant, there must be a foundation for these proceedings as for any other; but I am unable to say that there was no ground for such proceedings because details of the information, which include a report submitted by the learned Subordinate Judge himself and other reports said to have been received, have not been set out in detail. Moreover, although there may be difference as to what actually occurred in the case of the some of the facts, many others appear to be well enough known.
6. On the question of jurisdiction, it is said that section 14 of the Legal Practitioners Act says “charged in such Court”. It does not say that the charge must be made only by that Court in which the alleged misconduct has taken place. Therefore, it does not by these wordings limit the charge to the Court in which the alleged misconduct took place. Moreover, as already pointed out by the learned Chief Justice, the charge includes matters which are said to have occurred subsequent to the proceedings in the Court of Babu Pashupati Basu which are the subject of the first charge. It has been further held in the case of In the Matter of Babu Het Ram(1), that section 14 of the Legal Practitioners Act empowers any Court in which a pleader practises to consider a charge of misconduct made against him in such Court and that the section does not limit the consideration of a charge to the Court in which the misconduct is alleged to have been committed. I see no reason for dissenting from the opinion there expressed.
7. On the last point, namely, that of transfer, the grounds, upon which it has been urged, have been met in the explanation of the District Judge. I do not think that the applicant has established a case for the grant of the transfer asked for.
Mookerjee, J.:— I agree that this rule cannot be supported in either of its two branches.
8. As regards the first alternative, the contention of the petitioner that the proceedings should be quashed is based upon a two fold ground. It is argued in the first place that the proceedings mitigated by the District Judge are without jurisdiction, as the alleged incident did not take place in his Court. This position is, in my opinion, founded upon a construction of section 14 of the Legal Practitioners Act which is not borne out by its language. Section 12 authorises the suspension and dismissal of pleaders and mukhtears convicted of criminal offences, by the High Court. Section 13 then provides for the suspension and dismissal of pleaders and mukhtears guilty of unprofessional conduct even though the particular act of misconduct has not led to conviction by a Court of Justice. Section 14, thereupon, provides that “if any such pleader or mukhtear” (that is a pleader or mukhtear holding a certificate as mentioned in Section 13) “practising in any Subordinate Court or in any Revenue Office is charged in such Court or Office with taking instructions except as aforesaid (i.e, as mentioned in Section 13) or with any such misconduct as aforesaid (i.e as specified in Section 13, the presiding officer shall send him a copy of the charge and also a notice that, on a day to be therein appointed, such charge will be taken into consideration.” This section plainly authorises a Subordinate Court to institute proceedings against a pleader or mukhtear practising in that Court. It is not restricted to cases where the alleged misconduct has been committed in the Court wherein the proceedings are instituted. This was the Interpretation adopted in the case of In the Matter of Babu Het Ram, and no good reason has been assigned why we should place a narrow construction upon the section.
9. The second ground which forms the basis of the contention that the proceedings should be quashed is that they have no legal foundation. There is in my opinion no substance whatever in this argument. Our attention has been invited to the case of In re Nabin Chandra Das Gupta(2) where proceedings instituted under Section 14 were quashed on the ground that if what was alleged against the legal practitioner, namely refusal to accept engagement, was established, it would not constitute a ground for a disciplinary order under Section 13. In the case before us, such position cannot be maintained. It cannot be disputed that some at any rate of the allegations against the legal practitioner, may, if established, constitute grounds for disciplinary order under S. 13. It cannot consequently be maintained that there is no legal foundation for these proceedings.
10. It has been urged, however, that the proceedings have been instituted on materials which cannot be treated as affording a legal foundation for the initiation of an enquiry under Section 13. The contention is that as the District Judge has taken action on the basis of a confidential report by the Subordinate Judge, on another confidential report by the Additional Superintendent of Police, on report in a newspaper as to the proceeding at a meeting of the Bar Association, on the fact of institution of a criminal case by the pleader, and on certain information furnished by the ministerial officers of the Court, the proceedings must be deemed to be without legal foundation. I am not prepared to accept this contention as well-founded. Section 14 does not specify the nature of the materials upon which the court concerned may take action. It is plain, however, that if proceedings are instituted, there must be an enquiry supported by legal evidence. That this is the correct view of the scope of Section 14, is clear from the judgment of the Judicial Committee in In the Matter of Southekal Krishna Rao(3), where Sir James Hannen made the following observation: “It does not appear very clearly what led to the institution of these proceedings, but it is unnecessary to enquire into their origin, as, if it became known to an officer presiding in a Subordinate Court that one of the practitioners before that Court had been guilty of unprofessional conduct, it would be within the scope of his duties to take steps for the purpose of having that matter adjudicated upon.” This is identical with the opinion expressed by the Supreme Court of the United States in Randall v. Brigham(4), where Field, J., observed as follows:—“It is not necessary that proceedings against attorneys for malpractice or any unprofessional conduct should be founded upon formal allegations against them. Such proceedings are often instituted upon information developed in the progress of a cause; or from what the Court learns of the conduct of the attorney from its own observation. Sometimes they are moved by third parties upon affidavit; and sometimes they are taken by the Court upon its own motion. All that is requisite to their validity is that, when not taken formatters occurring in open Court, in the presence of the Judge, notice should be given to the attorney, of the charges made, and opportunity afforded him for explanation and defence. The manner in which the proceeding shall be conducted, so that it be without oppression or unfairness is a matter of judicial regulation. The authority of the Court over its attorneys and counsellors is of the highest importance. They constitute a profession essential to society. Their aid is required, not merely to represent suitors before the Courts, but in the more difficult transactions of private life. The highest interests are placed in their hands and confided to their management. The confidence which they receive and the responsibilities which they are obliged to assume, demand not only ability of a high order but the strictest integrity. The authority which the Courts hold over them, and the qualifications required for their admission, are intended to secure those qualities.” This view has been followed in practice in many cases reported in the books; amongst them two may be mentioned here. In the Matter of an Advocate(5), and In the Waiter of an Advocate, a Vakil, a Pleader and a Mukhtear(6). In the first case, action was taken on the basis of an information communicated to this Court by the Advocate-General in a letter addressed by him. In the second case, action was taken by this Court on the basis of a casual statement in the deposition of a witness in a proceeding in a Subordinate Court. What is essential, however, is that the charge must be formulated with precision so as to enable the legal practitioner concerned to meet the allegations against him: In the Matter of A.G Garmpathi Sastri(7). In the present case, the petitioner has not contended that the allegations contained in the charge are vague and indefinite. On the other hand, the eighteen paragraphs of his written statement give a very full and complete account of his version of the case. Indeed, up to the present moment, there is nothing to show that the petitioner has been in any way embarrassed by vagueness or indefiniteness in the charge against him. On these grounds, I hold that the first alternative branch of the rule cannot be supported. As regards the second alternative, it has been contended that there is a reasonable apprehension of miscarriage of justice in the mind of the petitioner. I am not able to adopt this view and I cannot overlook that the ultimate order, if any, can be passed by this Court and this Court alone on the materials supplied by the subordinate Court.
11. I hold accordingly, that the rule must be discharged.
12. Rule discharged.
Alert