- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Mathura Mohan Saha v. Nabin Chandra Dutt
This appeal arises out of a suit for the recovery of Rs. 6,249-2-0 which was paid by the Plaintiffs in order to save a putni taluq from being sold in execution of a decree for arrears of rent, under the following circumstances.
The Plaintiffs on the 5th June, 1906 purchased the putni taluq for Rs. 11,000 at a sale held in execution of a decree for arrears of rent due thereon up to Assar kist of 1312 B.S Some of the iutnidars applied to set aside the sale on the 26th June, 1906. The application was dismissed for default on the 23rd March 1907, when the sale was confirmed, but the application was subsequently revived and eventually dismissed on the 27th January 1908. While the proceedings for setting aside the sale were pending, and on the 19th March 1907, the zemindar brought a suit for arrears of rent of the last three lasts of 1312 and the whole of the year 1313 B.S against the recorded putnidars (Defendants 1 and 2 in that suit), and the Plaintiffs who had purchased the putni also were made parties to the suit as Defendants 3 to 10.
The present Plaintiffs (Defendants Nos. 3 to 10 in that suit) contended that they had not obtained possession of the auction purchased property and the zemindar was not entitled to any relief against them, nor to lay any claim over the sale proceeds.
On the 6th July 1907, the Court made a decree which, after directing that the Defendants do pay to the Plaintiffs the amount of rents, cesses, damages and costs decreed, proceeded as follows:— “That the decretal amount be at first realised by the sale at auction of the property in arrears; but if the entire amount be not realised by the sale at auction of that property, Plaintiffs shall be able to realise the amount claimed from the surplus sale proceeds of that taluqr as realised on the 6th June, 1906 by Mathura Mohun Saha and others (the present Plaintiffs) and from the Defendants Nos. 1 and 2 personally, and it is further ordered that on the confirmation of the sale the Defendants Nos. 3 to 10 shall remain liable for the amount of deficit, in proportion to their liability from the date of the sale or from the date of confirmation of the sale. But they shall not be liable in any other way. But even if the sale be not confirmed, the Defendants Nos. 1 and 2 shall remain personally liable.”
In execution of that decree the putni was put up for sale, and the Plaintiffs whose purchase at the previous sale had been by that time finally confirmed deposited the decretal amount (Rs. 6,066-1-6) and saved the putni from sale. It appears that out of the Rs. 11,000 the proceeds of the sale at which the Plaintiffs had purchased, Rs. 7,438 is still left in deposit as the surplus sale proceeds, and the Plaintiffs in the present suit which was brought against the former putnidars (both recorded and unrecorded) seek to recover the amount paid by them together with interest and costs (Rs. 6,249-2-0) from the Defendants and from the surplus sale proceeds.
The Court below held that the Plaintiffs are not entitled to recover the sum paid by them, and they have appealed to this Court.
The first question for consideration is whether the Plaintiffs were liable for the arrears of rent which were paid up by them. Now the said arrears were for a period prior to the date of the confirmation of the sale at which the Plaintiffs purchased the putni, during which the former putnidars were in possession. The Court below was of opinion that as rent is a first charge on the putni the Plaintiffs purchased it charged with the rent due in respect of it at the time of their purchase, and relying on the cases of Mahamni Dasya v. Harendra, Lal Rai(1), Peary Mohun v. Steeram, Chandra(2) and Manindra Chandra Nundy v. Jamahir Kumari(3), held that it was the Plaintiffs who were bound to satisfy the rent decree.
We are of opinion, however, that the principle laid down in those cases do not apply to the present case. The purchaser in those cases purchased the tenure at a sale held in execution of a decree, other than a decree for rent, and such a purchaser in the absence of anything to denote the contrary must be taken to have purchased it charged with the rent which might be due in respect of it at the time of his purchase. In the present case, the tenure was sold in execution of a decree for arrears of rent, and where a tenure or holding is sold in execution of a decree for its own arrears of rent it passes to the purchaser freed from all liabilities for its previous, arrears. See Faez Rahaman v. Ram Sulch Bajpai(4). See also the case of Haradhan Chattoraj v. Kartik Chandra Chattopadhya (5), in which the purchaser of the tenure purchased it with a notice that it was saddled with liability for previous arrears, and the case of Faez Rahaman v. Rum Sukh was distinguished on that ground.
We are of opinion that in the absence of anything to denote the contrary, a sale of a tenure held in execution of a decree for its own arrears of rent passes it free from liability for previous arrears. That being so, the Plaintiffs were not in fact liable for the arrears of rent for the period prior to the date of confirmation of sale at which they purchased the Putni.
The next question for consideration is, what is the effect of the decree in the second rent suit to which the Plaintiffs were parties. At the date of that decree, the sale held in execution of the previous decree (at which the Plaintiffs purchased) had not been confirmed, and proceedings for setting aside that sale were then pending.
The decree is not a well-drawn instrument. It begins apparently by imposing a joint and several liability on the two sets of Defendants (the Plaintiffs and the Defendants in the present suit). No doubt it goes on to say that the tenure shall be sold in the first instance, but it also appears to recognise a primary personal liability on the part of the Defendants in the present suit. It also leaves open the question whether on the sale of the tenure being confirmed any personal liability on the part of the Plaintiff is to arise as from the 5th June, 1906, the date of the sale (in which case the Plaintiffs would be liable for a considerable portion of the arrears covered by that suit July 1905 to March 1907), or as from the 23rd March 1907, the date of the confirmation of the sale.
The case is not free from difficulty, but in our opinion regard being had to the circumstances and especially to the circumstance that the sale was not finally confirmed when the decree was made, the decree does not preclude the Plaintiffs from succeeding in the present suit on the ground that it placed the burden of the debt due to the landlords once for all on the land. That was the ground on which the learned Subordinate Judge dismissed the suit, and no doubt there is something to be said for the conclusion at which he arrived. On the whole, however, as it appears to us, the present suit may be regarded either as a suit for contribution on the footing that the decree in the rent suit treated the Plaintiffs and the Defendants as jointly and severally liable for the arrears claimed or as a suit for the determination of an issue as to the respective liabilities of the Plaintiffs and the Defendants, an issue which was not finally decided between them in the rent suit and which may therefore be legitimately raised in such a suit as the present.
In either of these two views of the nature of the present suit, the Plaintiffs are entitled to succeed.
The Defendants Nos. 39 and 40 in execution of their mortgage decree against the Defendant No. 13 (one of the former putnidars) attached his interest in the surplus sale proceeds to the extent of Rs. 472. The Plaintiffs in this Court do not object to the payment of Rs. 472 to the said Defendants Nos. 39 and 40 out of the surplus sale proceeds in the first instance.
The Plaintiffs will accordingly get a decree for Rs. 6,249-2-0 the amount paid by them, to be realised from the surplus sale proceeds of the sale held on the 5th June 1906.
Under the circumstances, each party will bear its own costs in both Courts.
S.C.M
Appeal allowed.
Alert