Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

United Engineers And Contractors v. Secretary To Government Of Andhra Pradesh And Others

Supreme Court Of India
Jan 16, 2013
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellant entered into an agreement with the State of Andhra Pradesh in February 1980 for widening a road. Because the appellant did not commence or execute the work within the stipulated period, the contract was terminated: first, action was taken under Clause 60(b) of the Andhra Pradesh Detailed Standard Specifications on 24-9-1980, and final termination followed on 13-1-1981.

In 1983 the appellant instituted Original Suit No. 62 of 1983, claiming damages of Rs 16,51,950. The Subordinate Judge, Nizamabad, by judgment dated 12-7-1991, decreed the suit and awarded Rs 9,51,650 in damages. The respondents filed First Appeal No. — before the High Court of Andhra Pradesh under Section 96 CPC. On 19-4-2002 the High Court allowed the appeal and reversed the trial court’s decree. The present appeal before the Supreme Court challenges that High Court decision.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the High Court, sitting as the first appellate court, complied with the mandatory requirements of Order 41 Rule 31 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908.
  2. Ancillary issues noted but expressly left open by the Supreme Court for the High Court to consider afresh, namely:
    • whether the suit was maintainable in the presence of an arbitration clause in the contract; and
    • whether non-impleadment of the State of Andhra Pradesh as a party under Section 79 CPC affected the maintainability of the suit.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The High Court decided the first appeal “in a cursory manner” without adhering to Order 41 Rule 31 CPC, rendering its judgment vitiated.
  • The High Court failed to engage with the factual findings of the trial court, which had been recorded after examining the evidence.
  • The trial court’s decree should therefore be restored.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The contract contained an arbitration clause, making the suit itself not maintainable.
  • The State of Andhra Pradesh was not impleaded as a party; under Section 79 CPC the suit could not proceed in its absence.
  • The High Court correctly appreciated these aspects and justifiably reversed the trial court’s decree.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Ranjeet Mal v. Northern Railway (1977) 1 SCC 484 Non-impleadment of the State under Section 79 CPC Cited to indicate that the necessary-party objection could have been raised during trial but was not.
Collector v. Bagathi Krishna Rao Same principle as above regarding Section 79 CPC Supports the view that the objection, though available, was never pressed earlier.
H. Siddiqui (Dead) by LRs v. A. Ramalingam (2011) 4 SCC 240 Scope and mandatory nature of Order 41 Rule 31 CPC Formed the core basis for holding that the High Court’s judgment was procedurally infirm.
Sukhpal Singh v. Kalyan Singh, AIR 1963 SC 146 Requirement of reasoned findings by the first appellate court Relied upon in the extracted passage to emphasise appellate obligations.
Girijanandini Devi v. Bijendra Narain Choudhary, AIR 1967 SC 1124 Same as above Cited within the discussion on Order 41 Rule 31 compliance.
G. Amalorpavam v. R.C. Diocese of Madurai (2006) 3 SCC 224 Same principle regarding appellate duty to reassess evidence Supports the requirement that the appellate court give independent findings.
Shiv Kumar Sharma v. Santosh Kumari, AIR 2008 SC 171 Appellate court’s duty to record reasons Used to bolster the inadequacy of the High Court’s reasoning.
Gannmani Anasuya v. Parvatini Amarendra Chowdhary (2007) 10 SCC 296 Obligation of first appellate court to examine all issues Cited for the same procedural mandate.
B.V. Nagesh v. H.V. Sreenivasa Murthy (2010) 13 SCC 530 Value of a first appeal and necessity for detailed reasons Quoted to underline that the High Court must address every issue pressed by the parties.
Santosh Hazari v. Purushottam Tiwari (2001) 3 SCC 179 First appellate court’s duty to reconsider both law and fact Supports the conclusion that the High Court fell short of this duty.
Madhukar v. Sangram (2001) 4 SCC 756 Same principle as Santosh Hazari Reinforces the need for a reasoned appellate judgment.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court scrutinised the High Court’s judgment and found that it merely recited certain facts and then arrived at a conclusion without undertaking the analysis mandated by Order 41 Rule 31 CPC. Drawing heavily on the authorities listed above, the Court reiterated that a first appellate court must:

  • Formulate points for determination;
  • Independently assess the evidence on each issue; and
  • Record well-founded, convincing reasons for its findings.

Because the High Court did not adhere to these requirements, the Supreme Court held that its decision was procedurally unsustainable. The Court expressly refrained from examining substantive questions—such as the effect of the arbitration clause or non-impleadment of the State—leaving those matters open for consideration by the High Court upon remand.

Holding and Implications

HELD: The impugned judgment and decree of the High Court dated 19-4-2002 are set aside. The matter is remanded to the High Court of Andhra Pradesh for fresh disposal of the first appeal in accordance with Order 41 Rule 31 CPC.

Implications: The parties regain the opportunity to contest all factual and legal issues before the High Court. No opinion has been expressed on the merits of the suit, the arbitration clause, or the question of necessary parties. The ruling reinforces the procedural obligation of first appellate courts to deliver reasoned judgments but sets no new substantive precedent.

Show all summary ...

Dr B.S Chauhan, J.— This appeal has been preferred against the judgment and order dated 19-4-2002, by way of which the High Court of Andhra Pradesh at Hyderabad while entertaining the first appeal under Section 96 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (hereinafter referred to as “CPC”), reversed the judgment and decree dated 12-7-1991 in Original Suit No. 62 of 1983 passed by the Court of the Subordinate Judge, Nizamabad.

2. The facts and circumstances giving rise to this appeal are that: one agreement between the appellant and the State of Andhra Pradesh for widening of road was entered into in February 1980. As the work was not started and executed within stipulated time, Respondent 3 took action under Clause 60(b) of the Andhra Pradesh Detailed Standard Specifications on 24-9-1980 and the said contract was terminated by the State authorities on 13-1-1981.

3. The appellant vide Suit No. 62 of 1983 sought damages to the tune of Rs 16,51,950. The respondents contested the suit, however, the learned trial court vide judgment and decree dated 12-7-1991 decreed the suit awarding the damages to the appellant to the tune of Rs 9,51,650. Aggrieved, the respondent preferred an appeal before the High Court which has been allowed vide impugned judgment and order dated 19-4-2002. Hence, this appeal.

4. Shri L. Nageswara Rao, learned Senior Counsel appearing on behalf of the appellant, has submitted that the High Court while deciding the first appeal has proceeded with the premise that the suit for damages could have been entertained as the termination of contract was not challenged, particularly, when the appellant himself has breached the conditions of the contract and was not able to execute the work. The High Court committed an error while deciding the first appeal in a cursory manner without meeting the requirement of Order 41 Rule 31 CPC. The appeal has been decided without following the procedure prescribed for deciding the first appeal, thus, the impugned judgment and order stood vitiated. Thus, the appeal be allowed and the judgment and decree of the trial court be restored wherein findings of fact had been recorded in favour of the appellant after examining the evidence on record.

5. Per contra, Shri A.T.M Rangaramanujam, learned Senior Counsel appearing on behalf of the State, has contested the appeal contending that the agreement contained the arbitration clause, therefore, the suit instituted by the appellant itself is not maintainable; and the State of Andhra Pradesh was not impleaded as a party. Thus, in view of the provisions of Section 79 CPC, the suit could have been entertained. The High Court has rightly appreciated the facts and allowed the appeal filed by the respondents. Thus, the impugned judgment and decree do not warrant any interference and the appeal is liable to be dismissed.

6. We have considered the rival submissions made by the learned counsel for the parties and perused the records.

7. The issue of non-impleadment of a necessary party in view of the provisions of Section 79 CPC, has not been raised by the respondents at any stage of the proceedings and the suit had been filed against the officers of the State. The issue could have been raised and decided in view of the judgments of this Court in Ranjeet Mal v. Northern Railway (1977) 1 SCC 484 and Collector v. Bagathi Krishna Rao (2010) 6 SCC 427.

8. The question of maintainability of suit when the agreement contains an arbitration clause, the question does arise as to whether in such a fact situation, suit can be entertained. While filing the written statement, the respondents had raised this objection and taking note of the pleadings of the parties, the learned trial court framed Issue 1 in this respect. However, the trial court had taken note of such objections and answered the issue observing as under:

“The counsel for the defendant has conceded before this Court at the time of argument that he is not pressing on this issue. It is held that the suit is maintainable in spite of arbitration clause. Issue answered accordingly.”

9. The trial court has decided the other issues and awarded the damages to the appellant as referred to hereinabove. The impugned judgment and order makes it evident that the High Court, while deciding the first appeal just mentioned the facts, took note of the issues framed by the trial court and thus, abruptly reached the conclusion as under:

“… The plaintiff knew the specifications and it had been explained to him and he had accepted that, the date of acceptance of the agreement was of the date of handing over the site, that was 6-3-1980. The plaintiff also failed to prove that the agreement was not signed in his presence by the 2nd defendant on 6-3-1980. He had been given various notices by which he had been told that the contract would be terminated. At one stage he had been fined also with Rs 4000 but still he did not start the work and in terms of Clause 60(a) the defendants were empowered to terminate the contract. The plaintiff all along knew the site, contract had been signed by him, in spite of reminders from the defendants and even after imposition of fine on him he did not start the work. Therefore, we fail to understand how he could get a suit decreed for damages.
Since the plaintiff failed to challenge the order of termination of contract and he also failed to establish that he had not violated the conditions of the agreement, therefore, the decree could have not been passed in his favour at all. For these reasons alone the judgment and decree of the trial court cannot sustain and is accordingly set aside….”

10. This Court has considered the scope of Order 41 Rule 31 CPC in H. Siddiqui v. A. Ramalingam (2011) 4 SCC 240 and held as under:

“21. The said provisions provide guidelines for the appellate court as to how the court has to proceed and decide the case. The provisions should be read in such a way as to require that the various particulars mentioned therein should be taken into consideration. Thus, it must be evident from the judgment of the appellate court that the court has properly appreciated the facts/evidence, applied its mind and decided the case considering the material on record. It would amount to substantial compliance with the said provisions if the appellate court's judgment is based on the independent assessment of the relevant evidence on all important aspects of the matter and the findings of the appellate court are well founded and quite convincing. It is mandatory for the appellate court to independently assess the evidence of the parties and consider the relevant points which arise for adjudication and the bearing of the evidence on those points. Being the final court of fact, the first appellate court must not record mere general expression of concurrence with the trial court judgment rather it must give reasons for its decision on each point independently to that of the trial court. Thus, the entire evidence must be considered and discussed in detail. Such exercise should be done after formulating the points for consideration in terms of the said provisions and the court must proceed in adherence to the requirements of the said statutory provisions.
(Vide Sukhpal Singh v. Kalyan Singh AIR 1963 SC 146, Girijanandini Devi v. Bijendra Narain Choudhary AIR 1967 SC 1124, G. Amalorpavam v. R.C Diocese of Madurai (2006) 3 SCC 224, Shiv Kumar Sharma v. Santosh Kumari (2007) 8 SCC 600, AIR 2008 SC 171 and Gannmani Anasuya v. Parvatini Amarendra Chowdhary (2007) 10 SCC 296, AIR 2007 SC 2380.)
22. In B.V Nagesh v. H.V Sreenivasa Murthy (2010) 13 SCC 530, while dealing with the issue, this Court held as under:
‘4. The appellate court has jurisdiction to reverse or affirm the findings of the trial court. The first appeal is a valuable right of the parties and unless restricted by law, the whole case is therein open for rehearing both on questions of fact and law. The judgment of the appellate court must, therefore, reflect its conscious application of mind and record findings supported by reasons, on all the issues arising along with the contentions put forth, and pressed by the parties for decision of the appellate court. Sitting as a court of appeal, it was the duty of the High Court to deal with all the issues and the evidence led by the parties before recording its findings. The first appeal is a valuable right and the parties have a right to be heard both on questions of law and on facts and the judgment in the first appeal must address itself to all the issues of law and fact and decide it by giving reasons in support of the findings.
(Vide Santosh Hazari v. Purushottam Tiwari (2001) 3 SCC 179 and Madhukar v. Sangram (2001) 4 SCC 756)’”

Thus, it is evident that the first appellate court must decide the appeal giving adherence to the statutory provisions of Order 41 Rule 31 CPC.

11. The High Court decided the appeal without following the procedure required under Order 41 Rule 31 CPC. Therefore, without entering into the merits, the impugned judgment and order is set aside and the matter is remanded to the High Court to decide the first appeal in accordance with law. As the matter is quite old, we request the High Court to dispose of the first appeal as early as possible.

12. It is further clarified that we do not express any opinion on the issue of necessary parties and as to whether the suit could be entertained when there was an arbitration clause in the agreement. It is open for the parties to raise factual and legal issues permissible in law and in case, any application for any purpose is filed, the High Court is at liberty to decide the same in accordance with law. With these observations, the appeal stands disposed of.