- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Bansidhar Marwari v. P.W.D Bihar Opposite Party.
1. This is a reference by the Sessions Judge of Manbhum-Singhbhum under Section 438 of the Cr PC recommending that an order made by a Magistrate under Section 133 of the Cr PC and thereafter made absolute under S. 137(3) of the Code should be set aside. The defect to which the learned Sessions Judge invites attention is that after issuing the notice under S. 133 the Magistrate did not on the date fixed for hearing question the petitioner under S. 139A as to whether he denied the existence of any public right in respect of the way alleged to have been obstructed. Undoubtedly, it is the duty of the Magistrate to put this question to the person against whom the order under S. 133 was made and as pointed out in 17 P.L.T 791,1 is very easy to overlook the requirements of S. 139A which is placed not between Ss. 136 and 137 but after S. 139. In that case and in another case of this Court in A.I.R 1941 Pat. 38,2 the orders of the Magistrates were set aside and directions given to re-hear the proceedings from the stage where the second party should have been asked under S. 139A whether he denied the existence of the public right; but in the case before me it is an admitted fact that the way alleged to have been encroached on is a public way; it is a P.W.D road and this fact is not in any controversy between the parties.
2. Therefore, if the Magistrate had remembered to put the question contemplated by S. 139A the answer must necessarily have been that party did not deny the existence of a public right of way. That being so the procedure of the Magistrate in taking up forthwith the enquiry under S. 137 as to whether the public way had been encroached on or not was an irregularity not affecting the merits. That being so, in my opinion, this Court is not called on to interfere in revision. I therefore discharge the reference.
G.N/R.K
3. Reference discharged.
Alert