Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Sadayappa Asari v. Raghava Asari And Others

Madras High Court
Sep 10, 1919

1. As regards item 2 it is a vacant piece of land behind item 1, which is an ancestral family property. It was purchased by Annapuraniammal, the grand-mother of defendants 1 and 2. As laid down in Diwan Ran Bijai Bahadur Singh v. Indarpal Singh(1) by the Privy Council (see p. 873) and also in Narayana v. Krishna(2) and Narasimm Ammal v. Srinivasaragava Aiyangar(3), there is no presumption that a property standing in the name of a Hindu female, who is a member of a joint Hindu family belongs to the joint family and is not her stridhanam property. The evidence in this case is that this lady used to earn money by selling eatables and also that defendant 1, who was a carpenter by trade, used to give his earnings to her. There is nothing whatever to show that the property was brought with money belonging to the joint family. The learned Judge is wrong in assuming, in the absence of any evidence that this item must have been acquired by the joint family. He is also wrong in saying that it has been incorporated in the family property with item 1 for the circumstances of the case. We do not think that there is anything to show that there has been any such incorporation. Defendants 1 and 2 were the only members of the joint family in Madras in possession of item 1 and as heirs of their grandmother they were entitled to use and enjoy item 2 in any way they liked. We hold that the finding of the City Civil Court Judge regarding this item is wrong. As regards issue 4 the mortgage was executed by defendants 1 and 2 in favour of defendants 3 and 4. The amount borrowod was utilized mainly for the purpose of marrying the sister of defendants 1 and 2. The City Civil Court Judge holds that the mortgage is not binding on the plaintiffs, the other members of the joint family because defendants 1 and 2 claimed the property as their own and not as belonging to the joint family. In the deed of mortgage they say that the property is theirs, but at the same time they state the purpose for which the amount borrowed is required. Reliance is placed by the lower Court on a ruling of the Privy Council reported in Balwant Singh v. Rev. Rockwell Olancy(4).

2. That decision has been considered in this Court in two cases. Audimula Mudali v. Alamalammal(5) and Sabapathy Chetty v. Ponnusawmy Chetty(6), where it is pointed out that what was ruled by the Privy Council was that an elder brother could not by getting the signature of his younger brother who was a minor, give any validity to a deed of mortgage if such a deed was void and had no effect in law.

3. The Madras decisions lay down that even though a member of joint family proposes to alienate a property as his own if in fact the alienation was for a good family purpose, it would be upheld. There is also a ruling of the Privy Council reported in Bijraj Nopani v. Sreemutty Pura Sundary Dasee(7), which lays down that the alienation of a property by a person who professes to be beneficial owner of the property which is found not to be established but who in another capacity was entitled to deal with it would be upheld if he intended to convey whatever interest he had in the property at the time. In this case the plaintiffs were not living in Madras at the time of the alienation and it is possible that defendants 1 and 2 thought that they were solely entitled to the property. But at the same time it cannot be doubted that as they were de facto managers of the property they were entitled to deal with it for a proper family purpose. We must therefore hold that the finding of the learned Judge on this issue is also wrong.

4. The result is that the decree will be modified on these two points. The plaintiffs will pay the costs of defendants 1 and 2 and of defendant 3 in this and in the lower Court.

S.N/R.K

5. Decree modified.