Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Satdeo Narain v. Radhey Kuar .

Patna High Court
Aug 7, 1919
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Case Summary — Appeal from Subordinate Judge of Muzaffarpur (Execution / Limitation)

Factual and Procedural Background

On 4 July 1913 the appellant obtained a decree from the High Court at Calcutta declaring his title to possession of certain property, together with mesne profits and costs (costs amounting to approximately four to five thousand rupees). On 13 December 1913 the appellant instituted execution proceedings and attached property of the judgment-debtor to realize the costs.

The judgment-debtor applied for leave to appeal to His Majesty in Council and, in January 1914, petitioned the High Court to stay execution pending that appeal. On 27 January 1914 the High Court ordered:

“We will allow the decree appealed from to be executed upon the opposite party giving such security as the lower Court may think fit for the due performance of any order which His Majesty in Council may make.”

On 17 February (year stated as 1914 in the opinion) the Subordinate Judge fixed security at Rs. 50,000 to be furnished by the decree-holder within one month. The decree-holder was unable to furnish that security. As no security was furnished within the time allowed, the Subordinate Judge dismissed the execution proceedings on 28 March 1914 with the notation “No step-taken. Dismissed in default.” (The opinion also later refers, in the reasoning portion, to a dismissal dated 20 March 1915; both references appear in the text of the opinion.)

The decree-holder’s appeal to His Majesty in Council (which had been admitted by the High Court more than two years earlier) was dismissed for want of prosecution on 18 October 1916. On 12 April 1918 the decree-holder again applied for execution of the 4 July 1913 decree. The judgment-debtor objected that the execution application was barred by limitation, arguing more than three years had passed from the date when the last step was taken (13 December 1913). The decree-holder invoked Section 15 of the Limitation Act to exclude from computation the period between 27 January 1914 (High Court conditional order) and 18 October 1916 (dismissal of the Privy Council appeal).

The Subordinate Judge (Muzaffarpur) allowed the judgment-debtor's objection on 14 September 1918, holding that the High Court order of 27 January 1914 was not a stay of execution within the meaning of Section 15 of the Limitation Act. The present appeal challenges that order.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the High Court's order of 27 January 1914 — which allowed execution to proceed only upon the decree-holder furnishing security fixed by the lower Court — constituted a "stay of execution" within the meaning of Section 15 of the Limitation Act, thereby excluding the period between that order and the dismissal of the Privy Council appeal (18 October 1916) from the computation of the period of limitation for execution proceedings.
  2. Whether the second execution application (filed 12 April 1918) should be treated as a continuation or revival of the earlier execution proceedings, or as a new application, for purposes of limitation (the Court observed this point but found it unnecessary to decide because of its primary conclusion on Section 15).

Arguments of the Parties

Respondent (Judgment-debtor)'s Arguments

  • The High Court's order of 27 January 1914 was not a stay of execution in the technical sense but an order permitting execution to proceed subject to a condition (security to be furnished by the decree-holder).
  • The decree-holder's inability to proceed with execution arose from his own default in failing to provide the security, not from any order of the court staying execution; therefore Section 15 of the Limitation Act should not apply to exclude time.

Appellant (Decree-holder)'s Arguments

  • Whatever the formal language of the High Court order, its practical effect was to restrict and, in the circumstances, to stay execution by imposing a condition (security) which the decree-holder could not possibly fulfill.
  • The period between 27 January 1914 (conditional order) and 18 October 1916 (dismissal of the Privy Council appeal) should be excluded from limitation under Section 15 of the Limitation Act because the order effectively stayed execution.
  • The appellant relied on an unreported Calcutta High Court decision (Chidam Santya v. Shaik Pachumuddin Naik) with materially similar facts and decided in the appellant's favour, and on the earlier reported authority Gunesh Dutt Singh v. Mungree Ram Chowdhry (1873), which the appellant said supported excluding the intervening time for limitation purposes.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Chidam Santya v. Shaik Pachumuddin Naik (unreported; noted in Calcutta Weekly Notes, Vol. 17, p. cli) Authority with materially similar facts decided in favour of the decree-holder (supports treating conditional orders as effecting a stay for limitation). Cited by the appellant as supporting the proposition that the High Court's conditional order should exclude the intervening period from limitation. The Chief Justice regarded it as supportive of his view.
Gunesh Dutt Singh v. Mungree Ram Chowdhry (1873) Held that where an order stayed execution unless security was given pending an appeal to the Privy Council, the time between the conditional stay and the Privy Council decision should not be counted in computing limitation for taking execution proceedings. Both the Chief Justice and Foster, J., relied on this case as precedent for excluding the intervening period from limitation and as illustrating that a conditional security order can have the necessary effect of a stay.
Kamar-ud-din Ahmad v. Jawahir Lal (Privy Council ruling; cited from reporting) Described rule: where execution proceedings are interrupted (but not finally dismissed) and later a renewal is sought, the later application may revive the earlier one provided the interruption was not caused by the decree-holder's act or default. The Court considered this rule (quoted by counsel for the appellant) but found its applicability doubtful because, in the present case, there was a definite final dismissal of the first execution application and no application for revival had been made.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The opinion was delivered by Dawson-Miller, C.J., with a concurring judgment by Foster, J. Their reasoning can be summarized in sequential points (as presented in the opinion):

  1. Form vs. substance: Dawson-Miller, C.J. emphasized examining the real effect of the High Court's order rather than the literal form. Although the order purported to allow execution subject to security, in substance it restricted the decree-holder's existing right to proceed with execution by imposing a condition which he could not possibly fulfill.
  2. Impossible condition as effective stay: Because the decree-holder was admittedly unable to furnish the required security, the conditional permission to execute operated, in effect, as a stay — it deprived the decree-holder of his right to continue execution just as much as a formal stay would have done.
  3. Precedent support: The Chief Justice cited Gunesh Dutt Singh v. Mungree Ram Chowdhry (1873) as supporting the proposition that time between a conditional stay order and the decision on appeal should not be counted for limitation purposes. He observed a similar factual consequence in the present case and concluded the circumstances fell within the contemplation of Section 15 of the Limitation Act.
  4. Application of Section 15: On that basis Dawson-Miller, C.J. held that the period from 27 January 1914 to 18 October 1916 should be excluded from the computation of limitation. Deducting that period made the 12 April 1918 execution application timely.
  5. Continuation/revival point unnecessary: The Chief Justice noted but did not decide the separate argument that the second application should be regarded as a continuation of the earlier proceedings, because exclusion under Section 15 made that point unnecessary.
  6. Foster, J.'s analysis: Foster, J. agreed with the Chief Justice. He explored whether Section 15 is confined to direct stays or can extend to orders which indirectly and proximately operate as a stay. He examined O. 45, R. 13(2)(b) and O. 45, R. 14 of the CPC and reasoned that where the court requires security and declares that execution shall, as far as practicable, be stayed if security is not furnished, the natural and necessary consequence of requiring full security is that failure to furnish it will amount to a stay.
  7. Finality of subordinate court dismissal: Foster, J. treated the Subordinate Judge's dismissal (described in the opinion as occurring after the period allowed for furnishing security) as a final order dismissing the execution in due course of law; he rejected the suggestion that the decree-holder could immediately reopen the matter by offering security after dismissal without further process.
  8. Kamar-ud-din rule considered and questioned: Foster, J. noted the Privy Council rule cited by counsel (Kamar-ud-din Ahmad v. Jawahir Lal) about revival of interrupted execution proceedings, but found it inapplicable here because the earlier execution had been finally dismissed and no application for revival had been made; therefore limitation could only be saved under Section 15 in the circumstances of this case.

Holding and Implications

HOLDING: The appeal is allowed. The High Court's conditional order of 27 January 1914, which required the decree-holder to furnish security as a condition for proceeding with execution, operated in substance as a stay of execution within the meaning of Section 15 of the Limitation Act. Accordingly, the period between 27 January 1914 and 18 October 1916 is not to be reckoned in computing the period of limitation, and the execution application filed on 12 April 1918 is not time-barred.

The order appealed from (the Subordinate Judge's dismissal on limitation grounds) is set aside; the Subordinate Judge is directed to proceed with the execution proceedings according to law. The appeal is allowed with costs here and in the lower Court.

Implications: The direct legal consequence for the parties is that the decree-holder's 12 April 1918 application for execution survives the limitation objection and the Subordinate Judge must resume execution proceedings. The Court's reasoning treats a conditional order requiring security (which in the circumstances is impossible to perform) as amounting to a stay for the purposes of Section 15 — thereby excluding that period from the computation of limitation. The opinion does not state that it is laying down a novel broad principle beyond the application of Section 15 to the facts; it relies on earlier authorities with similar effect and applies Section 15 to the conditional-order circumstance in this case.

Prepared from the provided opinion text. No information has been added that is not present in the opinion.

Show all summary ...

Dawson-Miller, C.J:— This is an appeal from an order of the Subordinate Judge of Muzaffarpur, dated 14th September, 1918, passed in execution proceedings, wherein he allowed the judgment-debtor's objection that the appellant's application for execution of his decree was barred by limitation.

2. On 4th July, 1913 the appellant obtained a decree from the High Court at Calcutta declaring his title to possession of certain property, together with mesne profits and costs, the latter item amounting to something between four and five thousand rupees. On 13th December in the same year he instituted execution proceedings and attached certain property belonging to the judgment debtor in order to realize the amount of the costs awarded under the decree. The judgment-debtor having applied for leave to appeal to His Majesty in Council from the decree of 4th July, 1913, filed a petition in January 1914 praying the High Court to stay execution of the decree pending the decision of their Lordships, and on 27th January, 1914 the High Court on that application made the following order:

“We will allow the decree appealed from to be executed upon the opposite party giving such security as the lower Court may think fit for the due performance of any order which His Majesty in Council may make.”

3. On 17th February the lower Court fixed the security at Rs. 50,000 to be furnished by the decree-holder in one month from the date. The decree-holder, whose financial resources were admittedly insufficient for the purpose, was unable to provide the security which was a condition precedent to his right to proceed in the execution and, on 28th March, 1914, as no security had been furnished within the time allowed, the Subordinate Judge dismissed the execution proceeding, the order on that occasion being “No step-taken. Dismissed in default.” On 18th October, 1916, the judgment-debtor's appeal to His Majesty in Council, which had been admitted by the High Court at Calcutta more than two years previously, was dismissed for want of prosecution. On 12th April, 1918 the decree-holder again filed an application for execution of the decree of 4th July, 1913.

4. The judgment-debtor subsequently filed an objection in that execution proceeding contending that it was barred by the expiration of more than three years from the date when the last step was taken, viz., on 13th December, 1913. The decree-holder on the other hand contended that under the provisions of Section 15 of the Lim. Act, the period between 27th January, 1914, when the High Court made the order allowing execution to proceed subject to the decree-holder providing security, and 18th October, 1916, when the judgment-debtor's appeal to the Privy Council was dismissed for want of prosecution, should not be taken into consideration in computing the period of limitation.

5. The objection was heard on 14th September, 1918 and the Subordinate Judge was of opinion that the order of the High Court of 27th January, 1914 was not an order staying execution within the meaning of Section 15 of the Lim. Act, and held that the execution of the decree was barred by limitation.

6. It is from this order that the present appeal is brought. No reported case has been referred to us in which the application of Section 15 of the Lim. Act, to an order such as the present has been considered. It is contended on behalf of the respondent-judgment-debtor that the order is not one staying execution, but in fact an order allowing execution to proceed subject to a condition to be performed by the decree-holder, and the latter's inability to execute the decree is not due to any order of the Court staying the execution but to his own default in providing security.

7. The decree-holder appellant on the other band contends that whatever be the form of the order, it in substance restricts his right to proceed with the execution and in fact stays the execution by imposing upon him an obligation which it was impossible for him, in the circumstances, to comply with. In support of his contention we have been referred to an unreported case decided by the Calcutta High Court and mentioned in the notes portion of the Calcutta Weekly Notes, Vol. 17, at p. cli: Chidam Santya v. Shaik Pachumuddin Naik(1), in which the material facts are similar to the present case and was a decision in his favour. In my opinion the order of the High Court, whatever be the form of it, did in fact, in the circumstances of this case, stay the execution of the decree. It must be remembered that admittedly the decree-holder was not in a position to provide the Security demanded. Had be been in a position to do so and had nevertheless purposely refrained from providing the security, different considerations might arise in considering whether there was any default on his part which contributed to the non-prosecution of the execution proceedings, but such was not the case. In my opinion it is essential to look at the real effect of the order and non merely at the form. The effect is the present case was undoubtedly to stay the execution of the decree unless a condition impossible of performance were complied with by the decree-holder, and I do not think that the stay of proceedings can be attributed to his default simply because the condition imposed was beyond his power to comply with. Apart from any order, he already had the right, notwithstanding the appeal from the decree of the High Court to His Majesty in Council, to proceed with the execution and an Order in form allowing him to do that which he was otherwise entitled to do unconditionally but imposing a condition which was impossible of performance and thereby depriving him of his right, is an order depriving him of the right he otherwise would have had to continue the execution proceedings just as much as if the order had been one in form staying execution until the condition was performed and as the condition could not be performed, the effect was to stay execution altogether. This view is to some extent supported by the decision in the case of Gunesh Dutt Singh v. Mungree Ram Chowdhry(2) in 1873, where an order was made staying execution of a decree unless security was given pending an appeal from the decree to the Privy Council. It was there held that the time which elapsed between the data of the conditional stay order and the date of the decision by the Privy Council should not be counted in computing the period of limitation for taking execution proceedings. In my opinion the effect of the order in question clearly brought about the state of circumstances contemplated by Section 15 of the Lim. Act, and I hold accordingly that the time which elapsed between 27th January, 1914 and 18th October, 1916 should not be reckoned in computing the period of limitation for filing the execution petition. If that period of time be deducted, the application of 12th April, 1918 is not time barred. A further point was taken by the appellant that the second application for execution should be regarded as a continuation of the previous proceedings, but the view already expressed makes it unnecessary to consider this question. In the result the appeal is allowed with costs here and in the lower Court. The ordered appealed from is set aside and the Subordinate Judge is directed to proceed with the execution proceedings according to law.

8. Foster, J.:— I agree with the view taken by the learned Chief Justice that Section 15 of the Lim. Act, is applicable to this particular case and that the appeal should be allowed. At first I was impressed by the argument advanced on the side of the respondent that the High Court order, passed undeniably under O. 45, R. 13(2)(b) of the CPC, was in its express terms not an order of stay or injunction in the technical legal sense, but an order permitting the execution pending the judgment-debtor's appeal to His Majesty in Council, the permission being qualified only by an order that the executing Court should fix and require security. On the other side the appellant argues that (as is recognized in the first part of R. 13) he had the right then existing to proceed with his execution, and the judgment-debtor moved the High Court to restrict that right, giving as his reason the fact that the decree-holder had no property. So, he urges, the parties and the Court were in agreement that the decree-holder, who was directed to furnish security, could not do so, and the order for security would in effect be a stay of execution.

9. These being the arguments, the question is whether Section 15 of the Lim. Act, is confined to cases of direct stay or injunction or can to extended to orders which indirectly but very proximately and effectually cause a stay. I do not think an acceptance of the latter proposition will unduly strain the interpretation of the section. Looking at R. 14, O. 45, I see that the High Court is empowered to increase the security to be required from the decree-holder-respondent in the Privy Council appeal, the object manifestly being to ensure a full indemnification of the judgment-debtor appealing to His Majesty in Council. It is there provided that if the increased security be not furnished, the Court “shall as far as may be practicable, stay the further execution of the decree.” It seems to me reasonable to gather from this that if the law requires a stay in default of part of the security, stay must be the inevitable and necessary consequence of a default in respect of the whole security. In the present case the whole security was estimated and required, so the High Court's order necessarily implied a stay of execution in case of failure to furnish it.

10. So the order passed under O. 45, R. 13(2)(b), is in substance a restriction on an existing right to execute a decree; it is an inhibitory order suspending that right by an order nisi. The suspension was made absolute by the Subordinate Judge's order dismissing the execution on 20th March, 1915. In Gunesh Dutt Singh v. Mungree Ram Chowdhry it was held, that where a judgment-debtor, who has appealed to the Privy Council, obtains a rule nisi from the High Court suspending execution until security is given, and this rule is subsequently made absolute, it does not operate against the decree-holder in the matter of time, limitation not running against him until the result of the appeal is known, or the rule otherwise falls to the ground; and the Court based its decision on the necessary effect of the High Court's order. No doubt that case was governed by Act 14 of 1859 (vide S. 1, Act 9 of 1871), but I find so highly esteemed a work as Woodroffe and Ameer Ali's Commentary on the Code of Civil Procedure, quoting it as still an authority bearing upon O. 45, R. 13, of the Code. It may be argued that the Subordinate Judge's order was of no effect, and that the decree holder could, if he had the will and the means, have come into Court immediately after the order of dismissal of his execution and offered the security and demanded reopening of the execution. I do not accede to this proposition. In my opinion the High Court's order of 27th January, 1914 left the terms of the order for security to the Subordinate Judge, and the terms of such an order in usual practice include a provision as to the time within which security is to be furnished. As examples of this practice I would take the provisions for security in O. 45, R. 1, and in O. 41, R. 10, of the Code; in both cases the time fixed by the Court is an essential part of the order. A contrary opinion would involve great hardship and expense to a judgment-debtor; for he would have to remain in uncertainty and on the defencive in the execution case for an indefinite period. So I take it that the Subordinate Judge's dismissal of the execution was a final order passed in due course of law; and that order constituted in itself an absolute dismissal of the pending execution. My conclusion is that in the circumstances of this particular case the order of the High Court; and what I may call the ancillary orders of the Subordinate Judge, did in fact stay the execution proceedings within the meaning of Section 15 of the Lim. Act.

11. The learned vakil for the appellants quoted and laid stress upon the rule in the Privy Council ruling Kamar-ud-din Ahmad v. Jawahir Lal(3). The rule appears to me to be that when in an execution case certain proceedings have intervened to interrupt the course of the execution and that execution has not been finally dismissed and there has subsequently been an application to renew the execution proceedings so interrupted, the second application should be taken to effect a revival of the first application, provided that the interruption has not been caused by any act or default of the decree-holder. But here there was, as I have held, a definite final order dismissing the first application, and there was no application for revival; in fact the second application was a new application for execution in the form prescribed in O. 21, R. 11 of the CPC. I am therefore doubtful as to the applicability of this particular rule.

12. On the other hand I have, as the result of a full consideration of the facts of this particular case, arrived at the conclusion that limitation is, and in fact can only be, saved by the terms of Section 15 of the Lim. Act.

V.S/R.K

13. Appeal allowed.