Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Sadhu Charan Tewari v. Baikuntha Nath Madak

Calcutta High Court
Mar 10, 1914

1. This is an appeal from an order of remand made by the Subordinate Judge of the second Court of Midnapore. A suit had been brought for substantially the same cause of action as the present, and on 3rd April 1908, the following order was made in that suit: “That the suit be allowed to be withdrawn by the plaintiff, with liberty to bring a fresh suit on the same cause of action, if not barred, on condition of paying to defendant 1 Re. 4 as costs and Rs. 2 to defendants 2 and 3.” On 2nd April 1909 the present suit was instituted and it was successfully-contended before the Munsif that the suit was barred inasmuch as the costs mentioned in the order of 3rd April 1908 had not been paid. The result was that the Munsif dismissed the suit. Thereupon there was an appeal, and the order of remand, to which I have referred, was made. That order is based on a decision of Abdul Aziz Molla v. Ebrahim Molla . [1904] 31 Cal. 965.. It is contended before us that the order of the Subordinate Judge was erroneous. Though I agree with the result of the ruling of Abdul Aziz Molla v. Ebrahim Molla, I would base my decision in this case on somewhat different though not antagonistic reasons. The withdrawal was under S. 373 of the Code of 1882 which provides that “if at any time after the institution of the suit, the Court is satisfied on the application of the plaintiff, that the suit must fail by reason of some formal defect, or that there are sufficient grounds for permitting him to withdraw from the suit, with liberty to bring a fresh suit for the subject matter of the suit, the Court may grant such permission on such terms as to costs or otherwise as it thinks fit. If the plaintiff withdraw from the suit without such permission, he shall be liable for such costs as the Court may award and shall be precluded from bringing a fresh suit for the same matter.” Here permission was given. Therefore the last paragraph that I have read has no application, for it cannot be said that the plaintiff withdrew without such permission. He withdrew with the permission and the permission is under the section to withdraw from the suit with liberty to bring a fresh suit, that is to say, a permission with a sequel attached to it.

2. The condition of such permission in this case was the payment of costs. Until the costs were paid, the permission was not operative, and so there was no withdrawal with liberty to bring a fresh suit. The result was that until there was such withdrawal the former suit was still pending. This appears to me to be the literal meaning of the words of S. 373, which are now reproduced in effect under O. 23, and is in accordance with the view of the English authorities on a cognate provision, for, in Edginton v. Prondman . [1841] 1 Dowl. 152. it was decided that where the plaintiff instead of paying costs went on with the original suit and obtained a verdict, the Court refused to set aside the verdict. Where a plaintiff has obtained leave to withdraw upon payment of costs it is his duty to pay the costs at once, for until they are paid, there is no withdrawal with the permission of the Court.

3. In that view, when the case came before the Munsif, he was not entitled to dismiss it. All he could do was to regard S. 10 as a bar to his proceeding with the trial of the suit. In so far as he dismissed it, he exercised a power that was not vested in him, and I think the Subordinate Judge was right when, on payment of the costs, he set aside the decree of the Munsif and sent back the case in order that the Munsif should proceed with the trial; for on the payment of those costs there was the withdrawal complete under S. 373 of the Code or O. 23.

4. It appears to me important in cases of this kind to have regard to the precise terms of the section, and I think it will be well that Courts, when giving permission to withdraw with liberty to bring a fresh suit, should see that their orders are complete, and the proper order in such circumstances is one which limits the time within which the payment should be made, and which goes on to direct that on failure to pay within that time the original suit is dismissed with costs.

5. The only thing that remains for consideration is how the costs should be borne in this case. There can be no doubt that the plaintiff was in fault, so that we direct him to pay the defendants' costs before the Munsif and the Subordinate Judge. On the other hand, the defendant-appellant must pay the respondents' costs of this appeal. The costs, so far as they may be, will be set off. With these directions as to costs, we confirm the order of the Subordinate Judge and dismiss the appeal.

V.B/R.K

6. Appeal dismissed.