Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Aptar Ali v. Brojendra Kishore Roy Chowdhury

Calcutta High Court
Mar 9, 1914

Carnduff, J.:— In the suit out of which this appeal arises, the plaintiff sought to recover possession of certain land as lying within Mauza Damber, and consequently appertaining to an estate, purchased by him at a sale for arrears of revenue under S. 70, Assam Lanl and Revenue Regulation, 1886. In the Court of first instance, the contesting defendants did not dispute the plaintiff's title to Mauza Damber, but pleaded that some of the land claimed lay outside that mauza and in their Mauza Pitaboi. The plea succeeded, and the suit was partially decreed.

2. On appeal, the lower appellate Court upheld the decision of the first Court, and a second appeal was preferred by the plaintiff. The main point then urged apparently was, that the Courts below had not attached due weight to the that map, on which the plaintiff had relied, inasmuch as it was a map, the correctness of which had been affirmed after objection taken, and to which therefore as was held by the Judicial Committee in Rani Hemanta Kumari Debi v. Moharaja Jagadindra Nath Roy . [1906] 10 C.W.N 630, conclusive effect should have been attributed. Stephen and Holmwood, JJ., considered that the case should be reconsidered from this point of view, and they remanded it to the lower appellate Court, with the direction that Court should find whether the map concerned was of the character indicated, and if so, whether either party had acquired rights, not shown on the map, by adverse possession or otherwise.

3. The appeal comes before this Court again with the result of the learned District Judge's reconsideration of it. He has found that there was a boundary dispute between the two mauzas at the time when the thak map was prepared, that it was decided in favour of the proprietors of Mauza Damber by the highest authority in the district, and that therefore the map was of the same character as that dealt with in the case cited above. The correctness of this finding has been attacked by the learned counsel who has appeared for the appellant; but, without expressing a final opinion on the question whether the order which was passed on the dispute in this case, was an order comparable with the “judicial order,” which their Lordships of the Privy Council had before them in Bani Hemanta Kumari Debi's case, I think that the conclusion of the District Judge may be supported as a conclusion of fact with which we cannot interfere.

4. There was a dispute between the parties at the time, the dispute was decided between them and the decision was not contested. Whether that decision was a judicial decision and in that sense conclusive, or whether it had not, in strictness, that character, the circumstances that there was a dispute and a decision upon it, must be of great, if not overwhelming, weight in determining what was the true boundary between the two mauzas.

5. The Judge has however further held that no question of adverse possession arises, because adverse possession is not an incumbrance on the right of a recorded proprietor, and also because the plaintiff, although he was admittedly the owner of some shares in certain specified villages in the mahal sold for arrears it was not a defaulting proprietor of it, and therefore purchased free from incumbrances. I cannot affirm these views. Adverse possession has in a number of cases, see Karmi Khan v. Brojo Nath Das . [1895] 22 Cal. 244., been held to be an incumbrance, and it was so regarded in connexion with a sale under S. 70 of the regulation with which we are here concerned: see Mahomed Nasim v. Kasi Nath Ghose . [1899] 26 Cal. 194 and I am myself unable to understand how it is possible to take the plaintiff put of the scope of Prov. 3, S. 71 of the regulation, which declares that nothing in the section (which frees the property purchased from an incumbrance) shall apply when the purchaser is a recorded or unrecorded proprietor of the estate.

6. I think therefore that there must be another remand for a finding, on the evidence already on the record, on issues 3 and 17, as originally framed. The case should be remitted to us with the finding of the lower appellate Court as speedily as possible.

Richardson, J.:— I agree.

V.B/R.K

7. Case remanded.