- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Ghulam Ali v. Sagir-Ul-Nissa Bibi
Banerji and Chamier, JJ.:— This appeal arises out of a suit brought by a Muhammadan lady to recover her dower from one of the heirs of her deceased husband. She alleges that the amount of her dower was Rs. 2,100; that in lieu of the said dower her husband had put her in possession of his property that she is in possession, and that upon her husband's death she is entitled to recover three-fourths of the amount of her dower from the defendant who has inherited a three-fourths' share of her husband's property. The suit was resisted on various grounds, the main ground being that the plaintiff being in possession could not sue for her dower. This contention found favour with the Court of first instance. On appeal to the lower appellate Court the learned Judge held that there was nothing in the law be prevent the plaintiff from claiming her dower, and that although her possession might be analogous to that of a mortgagee, that analogy was not so complete as to bar her right to claim her dower. He set aside the decree of the Court of first instance, and remanded the case to that Court under section 662 of the Code of Civil Procedure. From there order of remand the present appeal has been preferred.
In our opinion the view of the learned Judge is correct; Under the Muhammadan law a woman to whom dower is due is entitled to claim it whenever the right to recover it has accrued to her. It is conceded that upon the death of her husband the dower due to the wife becomes payable. It is also conceded that even when the wife has been placed in possession of her husband's property in lieu of her dower, there is nothing in the Muhammadan law which precludes her from claiming her dower. It has no doubt, been held that if a Muhammadan woman entitled to dower has obtained possession of her husband's estate lawfully and without force or fraud in lieu of her dower, such possession cannot be disturbed by her husband's heirs until the dower-debt it discharged; but from this it does not follow that she cannot claim her dower if she chooses to do so. It has also been held in the case of Aziz-ullah Khan v. Ahmad Ali Khan that a Muhammadan widow lawfully in possession of her husband's estate in lieu, of dower occupies a position analogous to that of a mortgagee but it has never been held—and in our opinion it is not the law—that the possession of a Muhammadan woman under such circumstances is in all respects, that of a usufructuary mortgagee; We think the learned Judge has rightly observed that the analogy is not complete. If the position of the plaintiff had been that of a usufructuary mortgagee, section 67 of the Transfer of Property Act would have preloaded her from suing to recover her dower, but as she is not a usufructuary mortgagee that section has no application to her case. We have not been referred to any authority under which we could hold that a Muhammadan woman in possession of her husband's estate in lieu of dower Cannot claim her dower, though she offers to surrender possession. We think the Court below was right, and dismiss the appeal with costs.
Appeal dismissed.
Alert