Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Nandi Constructions v. The State Of Karnataka

Karnataka High Court
Nov 19, 2015

- 1 -

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU

DATED THIS THE 19TH DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2015

THE HON’BLE MR.JUSTICE VINEET SARAN

AND

THE HON’BLE MR.JUSTICE MOHAN M. SHANTANAGOUDAR

S.T.R.P.NOS.216/2015 & 242-252/2015

BETWEEN :

M/s. Nandi Constructions

TIN: 29370707569

125, 3rd Main

Jayalakshmipuram

Mysuru-570012

(by its proprietor T.N.Hemanth, 53 years)

…Petitioner

(By Sri T.N. Keshavamurthy, Adv.,)

AND :

The State of Karnataka

Represented by

The Commissioner of Commercial Taxes

Gandhinagar

Bengaluru-560009

…Respondent

(By Sri K.M. Shivayogiswamy, AGA.,)

R

- 2 -

These petitions are filed under Section 65(1) of

Karnataka Value Added Tax Act, 2003 against the

judgment and order dated 16.01.2015 passed in STA

Nos.660 to 663/2014 and STA Nos.664 to 671/2014 on the

file of the Karnataka Appellate Tribunal at Bangalore.

These petitions coming on for admission, this day,

VINEET SARAN J., made the following:-

O R D E R

These revision petitions are filed by the assessee

challenging the order of the Tribunal dated 16.1.2015

whereby the appeals of the assessee have been

dismissed.

2. The brief facts of this case are that the

assessee is a builder and civil works contractor,

carrying on the business of construction and sale of

apartments. For the relevant tax periods, the assessee

had sold some apartments, for which it had disclosed

- 3 -

the sale consideration, out of which the cost of the

land was disclosed in the returns at 45% and

consequently paid tax on the sale consideration minus

the land cost. The assessing authority did not accept

the land cost at 45%, but instead assessed it at 40%

and assessed the tax. The assessee challenged the

assessment order by filing the appeals, where it

claimed the land cost to be 50% of the sale

consideration, instead of 45% as had been claimed in

the returns.

3. The appellate authority considered the matter

on merits and, though on facts it came to the

conclusion that the land cost was over 50%, but as

the claim made in the returns filed by the assessee

was for only 45% of the sale consideration, the land

cost, for the purpose of calculation of tax, was taken

at 45% only. While passing the said order, the first

appellate authority relied on a decision of the Division

- 4 -

Bench of this Court rendered in the case of Infinite

Builders and Developers, Bangalore vs. The

Additional Commissioner of Commercial Taxes,

Zone II, Bangalore, reported in 2013(76) Kar. L.J

390. Challenging the said order, the assessee filed

appeals before the Tribunal claiming the land cost be

allowed at 50% of the sale consideration. The appeals

have been dismissed by a common reasoned order,

which is under challenge in these revision petitions.

4. We heard Sri T.N.Keshava Murthy, learned

advocate for the petitioner as well as Sri

K.M.Shivayogiswamy, learned Government Advocate

appearing for the respondent and perused the

records.

5. Although several questions of law are raised

in these petitions, learned counsel for the petitioner

has, today condensed the same and placed before us

- 5 -

only two questions of law for determination by this

Court, which are as follows:-

a) Whether the appellate Tribunal is

legally justified in holding that land

cost at 50% that is not claimed in the

returns cannot be considered in view

of the decisions of this Court in the

case of State of Karnataka vs. Centum

Industries Pvt. Ltd., and Infinite

Builders & Developers vs. Additional

CCT., Zone II, Bangalore?

b) Whether appellate Tribunal is legally

justified in confirming the land cost

allowed by the first appellate authority

at 45% of the contract receipts, even

after noticing the finding of the first

appellate authority that land cost as

per registered sale deeds and the

certificate of the Chartered Accountant

worked out to 54% of the contract

receipts, merely for the reason that

the same is not claimed in the returns

filed?